TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Airlines not required to carry defibrillators

No law requiring airlines to carry the devices, which are used on heart attack victims.

Ryanair and Aer Lingus do not carry defibrillators on European flights
Ryanair and Aer Lingus do not carry defibrillators on European flights
Image: Niall Carson/PA Wire/Press Association Images

AIRLINE ARE NOT required to carry defibrillators on board planes, according to a spokesperson at the Irish Aviation Authority.

TheJournal.ie made the enquiry after a doctor wrote a letter to The Irish Times, stating that no emergency medicines such as adrenaline, morphine and aspirin are available on Ryanair flights – “but most alarmingly of all, there are no defibrillators for cardiac arrests” on board Ryanair flights.

Defibrillators work by delivering a charge of energy to a person who has suffered a heart attack. The aim is that the shock resets the heart so that it can begin beating normally again.

According to a spokesperson at the Irish Aviation Authority, airlines are not required to carry defibrillators under European law. She said that because airplanes can make emergency landings when flying over European soil, there was no requirement for them.

In response to an emailed question from TheJournal.ie, a Ryanair spokseman said:

The safety of our passengers, crew and aircraft is Ryanair’s number one priority. Ryanair meets all regulatory requirements in terms of medical assistance provided on its flights.

Aer Lingus does carry defibrillators, but only on transatlantic flights.

Varadkar outlines concerns about Aer Lingus stake sale >

Read next:

Comments (31 Comments)

  • Ryanair are probably looking for one that takes all major credit cards!!!!!

    Reply
  • Al 29/06/12 #

    Defibrillators are not used for heart attacks!

    They are used for cardiac arrests.

    Heart attack is where a coronary artery is blocked by a clot. Cardiac arrest is where the heart has stopped completely. Yes a heart attack can cause an arrest but they are by no means the same thing.

    Either way a disgrace they are not carried considering they’re in almost every sports club in the country

    Reply
    • they had one in the grounds when the Bolton player needed one… it was locked away… CPR kept him alive till ambulance crew could wire him up.

      Reply
    • They’re not much use when the heart has stopped completely, more when it is in fibrillation. In a adult this is most likely secondary to a heart attack although well publicised underlying conditions could also cause it.

      Reply
    • Al 29/06/12 #

      yes it is useless when the heart gas stopped completely but I didn’t think it was appropriate to start discussing cardiac arrest rhythms.Yes a heart attack is a major cause of an arrest but there are plenty of reasons.

      Just sick of the media misleading the public by interesting arrest nd attack wrongly

      Reply
  • Come on now, it’s 2012 and we still don’t carry AEDs on our flights? One life saved is worth the investment.

    Reply
  • It should be law that major shopping centres and other public places. I was trained to use one by the Civil defence and they are so simple to use.nnYes they are not cheap but what price would you put on a persons life?

    Reply
    • ball park figure for a waterproof (will not work under water but rain or flooding will not damage it) AED is 1400euro. we are setting up a village AED station as nearest ambulance would be 20-25 mins away.

      Reply
    • We bought one recently and it cost €1200 ex-vat, considering their purpose and what they can achieve, they are very reasonably priced.

      Can I ask a question, why have you used nn before the word yes in your sentence? I have seen this a lot on here and cannot make sense of it? Is it an abbreviation of and or is it keystroke error?

      Reply
    • Sam I Am 29/06/12 #

      I do the ‘nn’ all the time on my ipad, it happens sometimes when you try to stretch to hit the space bar.

      Reply
  • bit off topic but : There is nowhere in law that states any public building is to have one, but it is in law that its forbidden to block or tamper with any safety equipment that is place. so if your local shopping center has one they cannot block access to it with stock or equipment same goes for exits.

    Reply
  • Glad thejournal.ie was diligent enough to find out that neither major carrier has them. Otherwise it would be the usual ryanair bash-fest commencing.

    Reply
  • a heart attack is just a general term, you can only use a defib when the electrical activity in the heart becomes erratic and needs resetting (to put in easier terms!) for example in ventricular fibrillation or pulseless ventricular tachycardia, defibs are no use if the heart and all it’s electricity has stopped all together as there is nothing to work with there, so your average basic life support is needed most here, that being said, things like a defib, adrenaline (especially this!), morphine and aspirin can be life saving, a life can be lost in a matter of seconds so they really shud have the basics on board!!

    Reply
  • My airline carry them on all their 300 aircraft regardless of shorthaul or longhaul routes and all 15000 cabin crew are trained to use them from day one of their Aviation Med training which is refreshed and retested on an annual basis. nThe defibs involved are very user friendly and once the electrodes are attatched correctly they basically work themselves advising you to shock or not to shock as the case may be.nIv had to use it 3 times now in 10 years although cant describe it myself because all 3 situations happened so quickly you just launch into action mode! We saved 1 life, extended another for enough time to divert and get them professional help but unfortunately one died despite 2 hours of CPR and regular shocking by the crew but that was unique in that we were just that far away from an appropriate airfield!nnAs for Ryanair, well I’m no fan but I can understand why they don’t have them, their flights are mostly all short, all over land bar a few short over water hops and they can be down on the ground within minutes!nnI do still feel however that standards should be in place on all European airlines and airlines which operate into Europe to have defibs and enhanced medical kits like those my airline uses which arent a requirement but provided anyway!

    Reply
  • oh so the excuse is they can land in an emergency!!??!! haha yea i wanna see them land within the 8-10 min that they have doing CPR alone and have an AED and the first shock in by then!!!! that’s just a joke! however up until about 9 years back there were no AEDs outside of hospital settings, we were one of the first in the country to get them in the hotel i was in and looking back now on how quickly the rest of the country has taken to them we couldn’t have believed it would have grown so fast, i have taught the use of AEDs over the last number of years and it’s fantastic to hear back the stories of those saved and even those who may not have made it but were at least given a chance! but it’s a joke that companies like this making millions on a monthly basis wouldn’t put them on AerLingus included, it’s not only trans Atlantic flights that need them! imagine the deal they would get when purchasing so many, it would be little or nothing to these airlines, they don’t have the excuse of the cost of staff training anymore either as it’s now covered in occupational first aid which would be mandatory anyway!

    Reply
  • According to the law, the Titanic had enough lifeboats and the company only fitted enough to comply with the law. It seems very strange that one hundred years after that disaster companies are still coming out with the same verbal crap about life saving equipment!!

    Reply
  • The commonest cause of cardiac arrest is ventricular fibrillation … thus, an AED is of paramount importance, given the relatively high incidence of acute coronary syndrome (“heart attack”) in the population. The fact that not all the cardiac arrests are caused by ventricular fibrillation and therefore not “curable” by defibrillation is true, but they represent a clear minority of cases.

    In comparison to AEDs, drugs such as adrenaline and morphine are far less important. Morphine, in particular, can (often) be a useful adjunt in the treatment of acute coronary syndrome, but its use shows no reduction in mortality; on the contrary, aspirin carries a 30% reduction in mortality and is definitely very useful in such situations.

    Choices should be made according to the frequency of pathologic events occurring in the general population. Otherwise, one could say that it is important to have a cobra antivenom on board, as a cobra might escape from a hand luggage and bite a passenger during a flight!

    Reply
  • Absolutely disgraceful – passenger safety is clearly not your ‘number one priority’ Ryanair!! Why haven’t the IAA made this compulsory yet??

    Reply
    • Doug when you climb off your high horse you will notice that more than one airline flies into Ireland. its not an European requirement. thinking a bit more about it. is there room to safely lay someone down, kneel next to them shock them while ensuring no one is touching them. the reason that trans Atlantic flights carry them is more floor space?

      Reply
    • Yes of course there is room to safely defibrillate – if there’s room to perform high-quality CPR then you have room to defibrillate, if not then you find enough space on the plane to do so. And yes I did notice more than airline flies into Ireland, cheers.

      Reply
    • Doug, could you not level the same criticism at Aer Lingus’ short haul fleet or do you just want to bash Ryanair?

      Reply
    • John Mack! BA have them in short haul flights as standard. If you have to use them you move the patient onto the aisle (if you can you can leave them in the seat) and move everyone else out of the way. Floor space doesn’t matter!

      Reply
    • Absolutely right Cyril – it should be mandatory for all airlines to carry these devices, on all flights – a no-brainer really.

      Reply
  • Just wondering with the metal connectors that go across the carpets and the metal seats would you be able to use one anyway?

    Reply
  • Absolute disgrace all airlines should be carrying AED’s on all flights. n€1200 is not a large amount of money for an item that can save somebody’s life.

    Reply
  • Or try this onennhttp://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2022717/Ryanair-passenger-cardiac-arrest-treated-sandwich–CHARGED.html

    Reply
  • Ryanair have shown time and time again that profit is the most important thing to them. And before anybody comes back to me with the same old tired line of ”begrudger, Ryanair knocker, great success story” perhaps you should have a read of thisn http://www.islandconnections.eu/1000003/1000043/0/31892/daily-news-article.html

    Reply
    • John F 29/06/12 #

      What’s your opinion on Aer Lingus not carrying defibrillators on their European flights?, I don’t believe that rubbish that Ryanair prioritise profit over safety, They have one of the youngest and modern aircraft fleets in Europe and have one of the best Airline safety records in the world!

      Reply

Add New Comment