TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 17 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Children’s rights groups concerned by child beauty pageant set for Ireland

Jorja Gudge has been criticised for her Miss Princess Ireland beauty pageant due to be held in Dublin next month but she insists the event will go ahead.

Beauty pageant contestant Madison Neill from California
Beauty pageant contestant Madison Neill from California
Image: AP Photo/Stefano Paltera

AN AMERICAN STYLE beauty pageant for young children to be held in Ireland next month has sparked concern among children’s rights groups.

The ISPCC says it would not be in support of the pageant and raised concerns about the way in which it may focus on the early sexualisation and appearance of young children.

The Barnardos children’s charity echoed these sentiments and told TheJournal.ie that such pageants were “encouraging children to mimic adult behaviour and fashion and that may lead to the early sexualisation of children.”

Jorja Gudge, from Sunderland in the UK and a former beauty queen, is hoping to run the Miss Princess Ireland 2011 contest in Dublin on 30 April.

According to the event’s Facebook page entrants will be charged a fee of €110 with anyone between the ages of 0-18 eligible to enter. They are required to send in three recent photos, their name, date of birth, and address.

The page also states that the pageant itself will feature three rounds – formal wear, outfit of choice and sports wear. Prizes will be “American style” with big pageant crowns, trophies, stashes, and some cash prizes.

In response, the ISPCC told TheJournal.ie that they would not be in favour of such an event. Policy and advocacy officer Lisa Collins said:

The way it is being described online indicates that it focuses on making children look like adults and act like adults and we would be concerned about this.

In a competition it should be about taking part not about looking right in front of a judging panel.

Gudge declined to comment when emailed by the TheJournal.ie and said that she thought the publicity was unnecessary: ”I do not feel it is necessary to enter a debate or push my views and opinions on anybody else, or to defend my own.”

Jorja Gudge (Picture: Facebook)

She defended her event in The Irish Sun today saying: “I’ve noticed that they are a massive confidence boost for children and they meet lots of new friends.”

The event was to take place at the Portmarnock Hotel in Dublin, according to the Facebook page, but this has since been removed from the page.

When pressed for comment, Gudge told TheJournal.ie in an email that the event would still be going ahead:

We have changed our venue due to the Portmarnock did not wish to be involoved (sic) in bad press.

We will be going ahead still as many people would be let down if we did not.

A source at the Portmarnock Hotel told TheJournal.ie earlier that the idea of such a contest “was a bit strange”.

Gudge held a similar event in Sunderland last November which again divided opinion, according to the Sunderland Echo.

As well as creating child beauty pageants Gudge is also the creator of a Facebook page with the title: “i hate Ben Mitchel (sic) from eastenders the specky little t**t” and encourages her friends to join saying : “nobody likes this little twerp… he is weak!”

Read next:

Comments (20 Comments)

  • I realise this may be a “confidence boost” for children, but what about the fact that only one can win?
    Who wants their child to believe that they didn’t win because they are not pretty enough?
    It is wrong to introduce children to something that is certain to cause body image issues – they will have enough time as adults to deal with those issues.
    Leave children to be children!

    Reply
  • I have four children and I am modern – open – liberal in my thinking – but these American imported dire competitions should be run out of the country.
    Its a very sad person that subjects a child to these type of shows and I wouldn’t want such sad people crossing my door to be honest.

    Reply
  • This show (in more ways than one) must not go on. Write to newspapers, ring Joe Duffy, this treats children as meat. Whatever about grown women posing, this is immoral.

    Reply
  • @ Cheryl: have you got any children?
    Singing and dancing competitions are something completely different. You are judged on skill and talent. Skills and talents are something you can work on to improve.
    Beauty competitions judge a child on what they look like.
    That is my problem with this – what gives anybody the right to judge a child on their looks?
    Every child is beautiful to someone.

    Would you be ok with some stranger telling your daughter she isn’t as pretty as another girl?

    Reply
    • I dont have children but iv grown up with the dancing world and i can say it is exactly the same.if you go to a freestyle competition you will see judges stand on the floor who judge on the look and skill and performance over all.every child has a dance costume, a walk on to the floor, make up,tan which is parents choice again,so its not just dancing they are actually judged on its over all presentation.just because it has the word beauty its doesnt mean its judged on looks its what they do on the day if they sing if they dance which ever.as i have already said every child is beautiful and yes to someone but they all still wall away with something which puts a smile on there faces if there happy well so should everyone else be.we have all played dress up once in are life.

      Reply
    • The point is – that you clear have missed thru lack of insight or something – is that when kids are playing dressup, they are playing.
      You for some ADULT reason, want to turn it into a competition so ADULTS in their trek for superiority, do so for their own selfish means.

      Go away and let kids be kids. Enough of this pure American rubbish and kop yourself on!

      Reply
  • Sadly, I would predict that the show will be a big success as the parents of the ‘Britneys’, the ‘Jordans’ and the ‘Rhiannas’ will be there in force.

    Its a funny world where you need a licence to have a dog, a fishing rod and a TV but not a child.

    Reply
  • what about the sun irelands FAMILY news paper? Open it to page 3 and its topless models.Makes me laugh how they can make this front page!!

    Reply
  • Did we really need the extra information about her Facebook activity?

    Reply
  • I AGREE WITH CHERYL LET THE KIDS HAVE THERE DAY ITS ONE DAY AFTER ALL WHAT CHILD WOULD,NT WANT TO DRESS UP AS A LITTLE PRINCESS OR PRINCE FOR THE DAY… STOP LOOKING AT THE BAD SIDE OF EVERYTHING ITS A DAY OUT FOR THE KIDS AND THERE PARENTS SO STOP HATING

    Reply
    • I must also say that i agree with Cheryl she has a valid point at one time or another didn’t we all like to play dress up as kids this event would be something that my daughter would be very interested( and this is on her birthday ) in as she is an outgoing girl who loves to make new friends and what better enviroment to do it in with like minded children and parents who obviously understand that beauty is not only on the outside but also within weather it be with a kind gesture or an infectious laugh i think that if a child is confident enough in themselves why not !!!!

      Reply
  • What about the girls doing those dance world comp..they have makeup, false tan, falsh eyelashes they have very little material on their bodies..nobody talks about that.

    Reply
  • Hmmm! The Xfactor comment raises a valuable point! How many young kids with their families sit in watch and vote? Alot of hi moral ground here! Watched Xfactor and well we see raunchy poses/ coked out Whitney and seriously underdressed and gyrating dancers! And we say these Beauty pageants will some way do harm! Eh ITV Saturday evening TV is surely as risky! You’ve been framed comeback, all is forgiven

    Reply
  • Can i also just say if you look at the photo of the little girl she has no make up she has no tan no fake hair just a lil one that performed on the day thaqt smiled and gave it her all

    Reply
  • What you guys are doing here is destroying something new.This pageant show doesnt have to be so Americanised and i dont think any of YOU have even asked that question?. No child is pressured into wearing false tan,hair,make up ect,its up to the parents at the end of the day.Yes it a competion about beauty but every child is beautiful.There are plenty of dance competions for example that wear costumes tan make up ect, has that ever been brought up?They dont walk around in there dancing outfits or make up all day every day?Know one is asking you to plaster a child head to toe.Its all about the innocence of them on the day in there little fairy dresses excited with big smiles on there faces, this is only gonna give children more convidence growing up and its something Ireland could do with.It bugs me to think how media can turn something around and make it look wrong.Americans have always been over the top about EVERYTHING its not exactly the same?Xfactor UK compare that with the American one,witch is more real out of the two?its also for boys too witch i never seen mentioned.Pray before you preach!!

    Reply
  • hey people,seems to b a very touchy subject this one.im friends with a cupla girls who are leaving comments supporting this,i have lots of respect for them as people and for their opinion,and am sure they will respect mine also :).i do not support these pageants.i agree that most of them are made to look and act like adults,albeit the parents doing i agree.i have watched and cringed as little girls strut and flirt with faces full of make up and skimpy clothes like grown women.in a world with peadophiles literally crawling out of the woodwork i could not encourage my child to act this way.i wasnt a confident child and im all for boosting self esteem in children but judging them in “beauty”pageants is in my opinion morally wrong.i understand that they may sing or dance to showcase some kinda of talent but this notion of “formal wear”and “swimwear”comparisons makes me feel physically sick,as they have no relevence to being children at all,they are adult concepts,as cheryl said,all children are beautiful..so therefore taking the “beauty” element out of this pageant,we simply have a talent contest..which iv no problem with.sports,singing,watever.and i kno that dance competition judge on the appearence presentation aswel but i think the dramatic costumes and headpeices an stuff go hand in hand to express the style of dance so therefore its necessary..i dont feel theyr being judged on beauty by doing this..can i just add that this idiot jorja gudge who has a facebook dedicated to slandering a child off a tv show,calling him weak,and makin reference to the fact he wears glasses,would lose my repect even b4 she decided to bring this tripe to ireland,im assuming that children who wear glasses need not apply to the pageant for the “beautiful”eh????if she want sto comment on that…please go ahead!!!

    Reply
    • Well said Lynn. I think it’s quite a shame that some little girls nowadays wear skimpy clothing like belly tops, have false tans and the like. These children are being sexualised at much too young an age. I agree it is usually the parents doing and they have the ultimate responsibility but these pageants provide a platform for a lot of parents who live through their children’s accomplishments. We as a society need to stop portraying such an importance on looks and stop the sexualisation of children at such a young age. Parents say ‘but these kids are so advanced these days’ No they’re not – they may be putting on makeup, wearing skimpy clothes, cursing and having sex but they are nowhere near mature enough to deal with the emotional consequences of their early sexualisation and I believe it pushes out all the other stuff like hobbies, sports, school, etc. which are far more important for their futures. Children should be playing and learning not being stressed out about how they look.

      Reply
  • Join the facebook group : People against the Georgia Gudge Little Miss Ireland beauty pageant
    http://www.facebook.com/home.php?#!/pages/People-against-the-Georgia-Gudge-Little-Miss-Ireland-beauty-pageant/160282320696031

    Reply

Add New Comment