TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Comet Records joins list of disappearing indie record stores

Demise of Dublin store is sad news for Irish musos even as international Record Store Day approaches…

Image: William Murphy via Flickr

INDEPENDENT record shop Comet Records will close next month – but will re-emerge as a speciality online store.

Owner Brian O’Kelly says he aims to sell rare and collectible Irish releases on two websites in the near future. While those sites are being built, he is selling off his store stock for €4 or less per item in his Cope Street shop. He told Conor Pope in the Irish Times that the fate of record shops are sealed:

There is a whole generation who have never paid anything for music and I don’t know if they will ever be prepared to pay anything for music.

Comet is the latest in a long line of indie record shops that have bitten the dust in recent years. Plugd Records on Washington Street in Cork joined Synthetic Records, Vinyl Rooms and The Living Tradition all closed Leeside in the past few years. Galway lost Redlight Records, Zhivago and Mulligans while BPM Records in Wexford and Waterford closed their doors this month, saying:

It is the end of an era. The days of browsing through our music and DVD selections are not at an end. The future lies on the internet or in an aisle at your nearest multinational supermarket!

Dublin lost several independent record stores in recent times too, including Road Records and Freebird.

Richard Branson claimed last year that the last record store will close by 2020. Branson, who sold his chain of Virgin stores in 2007, told a BBC Radio 2 documentary:

Sadly the music store is something in the past. There may be one or two specialist stores that will survive for a few more years. But if you turn the clock forward ten years from now, I’d be surprised if there are any more music stores left in the world.

If you feel exercised by the closure of so many excellent indie record shops, keep an eye out for events in the upcoming Record Store Day on 16 April, an international celebration of independent record stores. Music blogger Nialler9 always gives a good rundown of the day’s live events and instore promotions: this was his round-up for last year’s celebration.

Read next:

Comments (18 Comments)

  • Record stores need to make the effort to reconnect with their audience and also connect with younger audiences by moving with the times. Unfortunately, most record stores don’t know how to do this. A great example is a record store / live venue / record label in Nashville TN called Third Man Records. They interact with customers online as well as in-store. They release limited edition items that can only be got by visiting the store. They hold one off events like instores with Conan O’Brien and are always finding ways to push the boundaries with Pop-up stores in Austin, LA and London.

    The record store isn’t dead but it is dying. Mainly because it refuses to evolve and move with the times. There is still a lot to be said for real tangiable music you can hold in your hands. You don’t get beveled, silkscreened, mirrorboard artwork with a digital download. But it’s this extra effort that big labels are refusing to put into their product.

    Road was a terrible blow to the Irish music scene as they helped out many an independent Irish band back in the day and can count some great names in Irish music as close friends… Remember Abbey Discs on Liffey St, Final Vinyl on Camden St? Sad times indeed.

    Reply
    • Third Man is a great example but you have to wonder how successful that would be if it wasn’t owned by Jack White. He already has access to a massive market of loyal fans who will buy nearly anything he puts his name to. An indie record store could not do what Jack White did for the above reason but also because his releases are almost “boutique” items that cost a lot to produce.

      Reply
  • Also didn’t Comet close before? I remember it being ‘Sentinel Records’ for a brief period of time… Borderline is still there though in Temple Bar and that little place in the lane with all the U2 stuff. Oh and Rhythm Records…

    Reply
    • Yes it did – it closed two shops (there was one on Washington Street in Cork when I lived there yonks back) in 2004. The Dublin one reopened only two years ago, so it’s a real shame.

      Reply
    • Rhythm records that sell shockingly over priced u2 ‘memorabilia’ and dodgy bootlegs to tourists?! Although I do remember going in there after the Chili Peppers played the point in 95 to get the show on bootleg tape and searching every week in the hope to find a rare Pearl Jam nugget. Now it’s a click of a button on eBay to look for them. The romanticism of collecting records and so on is rapidly dying.

      City discs who recently closed are a big big loss as well.

      Reply
  • Plugd Records in Cork hasn’t actually closed down as mentioned above, they’ve reopened in a new location as part of the Triskel Arts Centre. They shut down their original store on Washington St awhile back because of high rents.

    It’s an interesting move from a commercial space into an arts funded space, shared with other cultural groups… the other indie stores around Ireland haven’t had any such luck with their rents, so switching to an online service / setting up stalls at co-ops and gigs seems to be the best option for the little guy these days.

    Reply
  • There was another one too on Wicklow St it was a basement shop… with zeba stripes painted on the door I think…Anyone remember what that was called?

    @Nigel all very fair points, but the only format of physical music that has been on the incline in recent years has been vinyl. Due to it’s boutique nature and big interest from Indie bands. Unfortunately the last record pressing plant on the island of Ireland closed way back in the 80′s. Further increasing the cost of manufacturing that type of item…

    Reply
  • Susan – Freebird is still in business on Wicklow Street (the Secret Book & Record Store).

    Reply
    • Yeah Freebird is still around. This record store I’m thinking of was on the opposite side of the street. You had to walk downstairs to a basement. And there was a huge cardboard cut-out of elvis down there. All I can remember is the zebra stripes though… Cannot for the life of me remember the name of it.

      Reply
  • Thanks for the memories Comet, you were part of a weekly ritual in Dublin on a Saturday afternoon. Meet at Central Bank, spend an hour in Comet, buy latest PWEI 12″, order another , go to Foggy for underage drink, Charlies lunchtime gig. Staff were always helpful and clued up and the New Years Day half price sale was legendary. God bless and good luck to Brian.

    Reply
  • The basement shop in Wicklow street, i think was called Basement exchange,a friend recently told that there is only 48 record stores left open which is a shocking state of affairs, illegal and legal downloading is the death knell for the industry, and i for one am truly saddened at every “passing on” and it is surely it is only a matter of time when the last of the big stores have gone the way of the independent/second hand stores

    Reply
  • The basement shop in Wicklow Street was called Record Collector. Good for concert bootlegs and certain big-name rarities but otherwise forgettable. Best shop in Dublin was Freak Out on South William Street – lasted from about 1992 to the end of the decade.

    Reply
  • Pam P 30/03/11 #

    Is this an example of a broader problem of smaller independents shops closing due to recession and online shopping?

    Reply
  • Nice to see my photographs being put to good use.
    Many years ago I actually worked at this location when it was The International Trading Group (ITG Ltd). That particular company imported and distributed Hi-Fi equipment and gramophone records (sic). I actually went into the same business myself at a later date . While I never did develop a particular love for vinyl or CDs I am sorry to see record shops go out of business. A physical medium does have an aesthetic appeal that I miss when I download from iTunes.

    Reply
  • “A physical medium does have an aesthetic appeal that I miss when I download from iTunes”

    That and superior audio quality.

    Reply

Add New Comment