TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

‘Culture of bonus as an entitlement’ behind push for banker bonus legislation, says O’Dea

Former FF minister says proposals target higher-ranking bankers and their work performance.

Image: Photocall Ireland

FIANNA FÁIL TD Willie O’Dea has cited a “culture” of bankers expecting bonuses as an entitlement “rather than something that has to be earned” as the impetus behind his proposals to curb such bonuses.

If enacted, the Credit Institutions Stabilisation Amendment Bill 2011 would apply to all bankers with annual salaries of more than €60,000 and bonuses of over €1,000. The bonuses would be delayed by five years and would not be paid out if the bank looses over €100,000 during that period.

Accepting that bonuses can be a means of incentivising workers, O’Dea told Newstalk Breakfast that bonuses can also incentivise excessive risk-taking.

The Limerick TD said that people should have to add to the profit of their company and shareholder value before getting a bonus.

He said that shareholders should know their manager’s performance and withold the bonus if that performance hadn’t reached the required level.

However, he said that he wanted to protect lower-grade staff who were getting smaller bonuses of up to €1,000: “It’s the people who are actually running the operation, making the vital business decisions that lead to the ultimate performance of the bank – they’re the people I’m trying to target.”

Questioned about the Fianna Fáil cabinet signing off a major severance payment for former FÁS director Rody Molloy, O’Dea said such texts would always be sent in to a radio show “because the Fine Gael press office or the Sinn Féin press office are working overtime”.

O’Dea said that in the present situation “where a lot of the problems we’ve had are due – by common consent – to excessive lending by the banks”, it is right to make people earn their bonus.

FF tables new laws to defer bankers’ bonuses for five years >

Read next:

Comments (23 Comments)

  • Beggars belief, Who does Willie and Micheal think they are fooling? They were Ministers for 12 years, (Willie slightly less due to Brothelgate) and done nothing to deal with a bubble created by these bankers, builders and developers, rather swanned around them in the Galway Tent.

    Reply
    • Fagan's 26/07/12 #

      They were too busy arranging a scheme to give the banks a hundred billion of tax payers money. This is just window dressing. The FF machine is falling in behind Sean Fitz and others. There are too many people in the party, at all levels, that made a lot of legal and illegal money off having the banks beholden to them. There are also too many bankers that could start talking and leave a lot of FF reps from last 30 years in serious tax and legal difficulties. The party would have more ex-TD’s in jail than in Leinster hse.

      If o’Dea started pushing this hard, made a real mission of it by some damascene conversion, then he would find the party becoming a very cold place for him.

      Reply
  • Is O’Dea the opposition spokesman for stating the bloody obvious? If so maybe he should look at legislation to tackle the culture of entitlement rampant in his own workplace.
    His non answer re Roddy Molloy says it all really.
    Would be great to know if the preferential loans given out to politicians like Big Phil and others should be declared and whether or not they are used in the calculation of bankers bonuses.
    O’Dea is like a permanent reminder of why FF must be shunned at all cost.

    Reply
    • There are thousands of interest only loans advanced to people in this country over the past twenty years and particularly on property. Sometimes these are called bullet loans. The idea is that you are anticipating a large payment in the near future such as a pension lump sum etc and you then pay off the loan in one go. Why would you call that a preferential loan.

      Reply
    • Maybe because while legally probably above board there appears to be no paperwork to show the loan to earnings assessments that most of us would have to supply.
      Far be it from me to question the loan practices of Michael Fingleton. I’m sure he allowed no preferable treatment to anyone especially politicians.
      However I do hope though that someone more qualified than me will get a chance to question him in the near future.
      http://www.independent.ie/business/irish/nationwides-soft-loan-to-hogan-3161567.html

      Reply
  • Yeah it was just the press offices making things up!! Still s good law though ! What about TDs pension and expenses?

    Reply
  • What an idiot…nobody working in the banking system earning under sixty thousand is allowed to make any decision. This proposal from Willie just shows he has too much time on his hands and wants to remind voters that he’s still here!

    Reply
    • Ha, yeah- a mid level branch manager loses his or her bonus because the bank makes a loss 4 years later….

      He’s making Sinn Fein’s various vote grabbing proposals look positively well thought out.

      Reply
  • Another example of why ff are Toxic!nI can’t believe the cheek of this fu**er?

    Reply
  • Elrat 26/07/12 #

    35 years a TD in limerick and did absolutely nothing for the city.

    Reply
  • Would Willie and Mehole stop making statements to the press, please? It gets in the way of real news. They have no credibility and every other statement sounds like they’re either disagreeing with something for the sake of it or rattling off a few suggestions dreamt up sipping a pint while staring pensively at the wide blue yonder. FF are an irrelevance at this stage. If the Irish people decide they want something other than FG/Labour I can only hope it’s not to reinstate this shower of gobdaws again. If it is, we deserve everything we get.

    Reply
  • Smiley 26/07/12 #

    Why should anyone get a bonus when they are being paid for doing a job already?

    Reply
  • Questioned about Fianna Fáil cabinet signing off for former director Rody Molloy, O’Dea said such texts would always be sent in to a radio show “because the Fine Gael press office or the Sinn Féin press office are working overtime”. Not just there’s Willy but mine too because we can’t forget the stench of the mess your lot left behind – want change to happen? Sign the new petition against the sale of state assets on http://www.sli-nios-fearr.com or petition.ie

    Reply
  • what about the culture of unvouched expenses…what about the culture of massive salaries and pensions for our politians while the country goes down the tubes…what about the culture of backhanders and sweeteners from dodgy developers…what about the culture of cronyisim and dishonesty….willie o’dea makes me want to puke. start cleaning your own house and then worry about the rest willie…all this mess has grown out of the culture of dishonest government and unless we put a stop to this Ireland as a nation will never recover

    Reply
  • Paul 26/07/12 #

    People shouldn’t have to be incentivised to do their jobs properly. A fair days pay for a fair days work. If they dont perform then fire them. There are thousands of people out there more than capable of doing their jobs who are on the dole and would happily jump at the chance to work for a fraction of the cost of these parasites.FFS its banking not performing heart surgery! Im so incredibly sick of the elites and their egregious apologising for greed in this country. Its a culture of greed Willie, not a culture of entitlement.

    Reply
  • What is he carrying in the green bag?

    Reply
  • Willie O D.

    Reply

Add New Comment