TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Government to ratify ESM today following Supreme Court ruling

The EU’s permanent bailout fund still has to clear the hurdle of the German Constitutional Court which is expected to issue a ruling in September.

Image: Niall Carson/PA Wire/Press Association Images

THE GOVERNMENT WILL seek to formally ratify the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) Treaty today after the Supreme Court ruling yesterday which said that the treaty is not incompatible with the constitution.

The court’s seven judges yesterday refused to grant an injunction that had been sought by the independent TD Thomas Pringle who claimed the power of the European Union’s permanent bailout fund was unconstitutional.

He had been seeking to put the ESM to a referendum.

The fund, which will replace the European Financial Stability Facility next year, will now be a step closer to being formalised when Ireland deposits what is known as the instruments of ratification with the General Secretariat at the EU Council in Brussels today.

The process is a formal expression by the State of its consent to a treaty that it has earlier signed. The legislation which provides for the ESM was passed through the Dáil on 20 June.

A separate part of Pringle’s legal challenge to the ESM is seeking clarification from the European Court of Justice as to whether the treaty is compatible with EU law.

Last week the Supreme Court referred three questions to the ECJ concerning the ESM and its compatibility with existing treaties, a move which Pringle welcomed.

The German Constitutional Court is also currently considering a challenge to the ESM’s legality with opponents arguing that the bailout fund would limit the German Bundestag’s (parliament) power to say how taxpayer money is spent.

The court is expected to rule in September.

The ESM can only come into effect when it has the approval of Germany.

Read: Supreme Court rejects Thomas Pringle challenge against ESM treaty

Read: Ireland to formally ratify ESM Treaty after Supreme Court clearance

More: ECJ to rule on whether permanent Euro bailout fund is legal

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (14 Comments)

  • “Democracy is the art and science of running the circus from the monkey cage.” ~H.L. Mencken

    Reply
  • and Germany hasn’t ratified it yet…

    Reply
    • The “EU’s permanent bailout fund” also has to “clear the hurdle” of the European Court of Justice’s ruling on its legality – which may not take place until November! on.wsj.com/QpK1X3

      Reply
  • The Yes Sirs who voted for this will be delighted today….But they will be sorry for generations to come…!!!

    We will be borrowing money to put into this every year for Generations to pay for Spain, Italy, Greek etc bailouts…Non stop Austerity for us forever, or until this EU/Euro collapses, whichever happens first…!!!

    Reply
    • Peeed Off, I just can n’t make up my mind as to whether you are actually serious in your rants or whether you are just doing it for the Criac and seeing what the response might be. Well?

      Reply
    • JTHM 01/08/12 #

      They paid for us, so what’s your problem?

      Reply
    • JTHM 01/08/12 #

      Also, the portion we must pay in is tiny compared to what many EU counties have to cough up. if we take then it’s bad form not to reciprocate.

      Reply
    • PeeedOff 01/08/12 #

      @SeanNorris

      The real world hurts sometimes, just that some people want to keep kissing Edna’s & Gimmemore’s rear and seem to think that all of a sudden the sun is gonna start shining from there as well.
      So I just tell it as I see it, and as I see it, as long as this crowd of Reprobates are running the Bundestag Regional Office (Dail) in Dublin and wrecking this country with their current policies, I will continue to highlight the fact.

      Reply
    • @JTHM Ireland contributes the 2nd largest amount to the ESM per capita out of all eurozone countries – only Luxembourg contributes more per capita! http://www.efxnews.com/story/13627/germans-are-not-biggest-esm-contributors-after-all

      Reply
    • JTHM 02/08/12 #

      @ Rachel, if you’re going to be disingenuous, please be more skilled when doing so. Yes, what you’ve said about Ireland and Luxembourg is quite true. But two words standing strong in forty-foot tall letters is “per capita”. What countries in the EU have the smallest populations? There is a little known concept known as “economies of scale”. It applies in this situation. Pee’d Off is not sincere, he’s a troll on a mission to ruffle feathers. That’s not an insult, I do a very similar thing myself. But you Rachel have a blurry aim. Please don’t mention the banking debt, of course it was unfair but that is not the issue. Other EU countries contributed to our bail-out, we are ethically obliged to contribute to theirs. Fair’s fair. Compared to the staggering figures associated with our own debt, the amount we are obliged to contribute is extremely reasonable, so we can’t claim penury. Do you really want Ireland to be called the scrounges of Europe and for that title to be correct and justified. We give aid to those who aid us. We give aid to those who need it. This is not about a paranoid’s fantasy of a shadowly cabal of overlords, this is about showing solidarity to countries who are in the same boat as ourselves. If you take you must give, or would you rather live in a culture where that was ridiculed and/or dismissed out of hand?

      Reply
  • Kenny & Gilmore will do anything – just anything, just to please their masters. The patriots who died fighting for a free country must be turning in their graves.

    Reply
  • @PeedOff You do not know what your on about.Your another one of them Anti Eu Guys, Going into the eu was still the best thing Ireland has done !! #Fact

    Reply
  • Plus They Wont Be Paying for this For Generations To Come Because it’s A SET amount of Money , And your complaining When The Likes Of Germany And All The Country’s have to Pay WAY more money cause the bigger the economy/Country The more it is to use the Esm(European Stability Mechanism) And They don’t decided of our Budget Or Anything All We have to Really Do Is Get Our GDP Down to 60 % And if not they have a mechanism that Will “HELP” Us Get it Down, Which btw We Will get it down so we are grand!!

    Reply

Add New Comment