TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Willie O’Dea says Burton ‘continues to mislead’ over disability allowance cuts

Fianna Fáil TD said the Minister for Social Protection should be upfront about changes to criteria for the allowance and explain application refusals and delays.

Joan Burton, Minister for Social Protection
Joan Burton, Minister for Social Protection
Image: Niall Carson/PA Archive/Press Association Images

FIANNA FÁIL TD Willie O’Dea has said Minister Joan Burton continues to mislead people over the refusal rates for the disability allowance.

Deputy O’Dea was responding to comments by Minister Burton that there has been no change in criteria or conditions in the application process for the allowance.

Last week O’Dea requested a detailed explanation from the minister about the surge in people being rejected for the disability allowance as well as delays for up to 12 months on processing applications.

“The facts are there for all to see, three out of every five applications for disability allowance have been rejected since the start of this year,” he said.

Between January and April this year, the Department of Social Protection turned down 4,823 applications.

Burton responded to the request that there had been no change in criteria or conditions and that the department is changing computer systems with applications which would improve waiting times.

O’Dea said he found the minister’s response “totally unacceptable”.

“Minister Burton is misleading the public and treating those who are seeking the allowance with contempt,” he said.

“The stats do not lie, the refusal rate for initial applications for the disability allowance rose from 54 percent in 2010 to 61 percent of applications being refused in the first quarter of this year.”

O’Dea said this was all part of an “underhanded pattern” to refuse people their allowances and that the department was now on course to reject 15,000 applications this year.

“It is plainly obvious that something has changed here and the situation is made all the more distressing for those in desperate need of the allowance because they are not being told the truth here,” he said.

O’Dea called on the minister to be “upfront on this and reveal what has changed in her department”.

“If the criteria has changed the least people deserve is an explanation as to why they have been refused their allowances or why they are waiting 40 weeks for their applications to be processed,” he added.

Read next:

Comments (29 Comments)

  • This apparent increase in the percent of people refused payments could be explained by a possible increase in the number of applicants that are simply not entitled to disability payment. As people become more desperate they may feel that chancing their arm at an application for disability might work and sure they have nothing to lose. Therefore the assessment criteria would not of changed and the number of genuine payments would remain the same but the overall percent of successful applications would reduce.

    Reply
  • Lest he forgets Joan Bruton wouldn’t be in this position in the first place if willie’s government hadn’t destroyed the Irish economy. Maybe he could donate some of his large salary to help the less fortunate in limerick.

    Reply
  • Shall we ignore the fact that over 90% get approved on reapplication, because first time round, all the paper work is not submitted, or submitted on time!

    Reply
    • 90% ? what land of make belive do you live in !. Most have to endure up to 2 years wait while their appeal is delt with , and the results are far less than the fantasy 90% you say. civil servant are we ???

      Reply
    • Micheal 08/08/12 #

      Actually Alan, I am not a civil servant.
      And you should fact check – yes there are wait times, by the time many claims are dealt with, the paperwork is out of date, hence why many claims are rejected.
      But upon reapplication, most claims are approved. There actually has not been a shift in the qualification criteria at all!

      Reply
  • MnB 08/08/12 #

    This is the same Willie O’Dea that lied to a judge isn’t it? Class act, that chap. The moustache alone should preclude him from public office.

    Reply
  • Judging by his previous behaviour and statements O’Dea regards the truth as an optional extra.

    Reply
  • Willie O’Dea is in no position to lecture anyone about “misleading”.

    Reply
  • O’Dea and the rest of his FF cronies really need to crawl back onto the rather large hole they dug for themselves and never emerge again.

    They’re clearly unable to do the graceful or honourable thing by quietly folding their party and all retiring from politics.

    Reply
  • Willie O’Dea’s comments are nauseating. He uses the words ‘mislead’, ‘underhand’, and ‘mislead’ as if he understood their meanings. A little over a year ago it is clear these words were not part of his vocabulary.

    Reply
  • I would imagine more people are applying for disability allowance – and therefore this would explain the rise in the rejection rate.

    Reply
  • This Government have consistently gone after the least well off in society since coming to power!

    Reply
  • Willie O’Dea’s comments are nauseating. He uses the words ‘mislead’, ‘underhand’, and ‘underhand’ as if he understood their meanings. A little over a year ago it is clear these words were not part of his vocabulary.

    Reply
    • O Dea , is the walking personification of all that is wrong in Irish Politics. He is a very intelligent, shrewd, well-read man that believes in nothing but survival. He tuned on is former FF allies when it was clear the writing was on the wall. He is the ultimate survivor , still an opposition spokesman despite being in the cabinet throughout the during period when the government proved to be the most destructive in the history of the state .Couple this with his negligible contribution to Limerick as a whole and logic dictates that he would be ousted form political life , hiding in the shadows but this is Ireland and he is still walks the street followed by lackeys hopeful of a triumphant return . I suppose he did get an air corp flyover St Pat day a few years back) . He is still immensely popular because he your classic exponent of the clientalistic model whereby by he gets Johnny the new fridge, or gets the door replaced for Mary. Basically, like most of his peers he buys votes through using his influence to provide services that should be fulfilled by the a local authority .Yet he did nothing of note nothing for limerick , He will claim regeneration funding and a road here and there which of course are smoke screen for the political ineptitude of succession of Limerick politicians that have served their city so badly for so long . I love to say there is some respite in our City Council but then again our new mayor last year called a rugby Referee a c*** and a bastard because he disagreed with a decision or when he called people in county limerick “country bumpkins” and parts of the County as a“Sh*t Holes” , now it doesn’t really reflect well on our first citizen political skill considering that the city and county council will merge , im sure the bumpkins will be full confidence in” Gingers” stewardship , of course he enjoyed the full support of Jan o Sullivan , limericks own super junior minister who in fairness conducted a whirlwind review of planning irregularities amongst county councils which predictably found that they didn’t do anything wrong , My mistake I could have sworn the country was littered with estates built on flood plains and apartments blocks in rural villages . It all actually fairly depressing ,

      Reply
  • PeeedOff 08/08/12 #

    This Govt live for pure spin & lies on a daily basis. This is about the only thing they are consistent in.

    Reply
  • Moan Burton!

    Reply
  • ‘Worse than FF’ it would appear that you might need medical help.

    Reply
  • FG/LAB propaganda machine has worked again ! when you have messed up , lied and mislead the electorate “just blame the last shower” when are these going to accept responsiblity that THEY ARE IN CHARGE NOW. and with that in mind the buck stops with them.
    lying shower of c!?ts. Worse than FF by a long shot

    Reply
  • This accusation of “Misleading” from Willie O’Dea?

    The from the man who was forced to resign as Minister because he mislead the High Court.

    Has O’Dea any self awareness at all on his fantasy island?

    Reply
  • Joan needs a haircut. And she should take her hand off that static electric ball.

    Reply
  • KevMak 08/08/12 #

    http://www.kildarestreet.com/wrans/?id=2012-07-17.1668.0&s=34795%2F12#g1669.0.q

    If you follow above link it provides a written answer from Joan Burton,Minister for Social Protection, on Invalidity Pension. This falls into same bracket as the Disability Benefit issues, such as length of time taken to process;i.e. 37 weeks on average , which is never divulged on phone contact. Its up to you to guess with returned answers such as ,” I wouldn’t think it will take that long” (a year), “it depends! “, is just classical. Multiple reasons given for delays yet very poor execution of informing what real steps are being taken to speed process up. Many people also had to apply after changes to Illness Benefit caught many out after this was given a two year limit for claiming.
    There is no transition in place which would alleviate many genuine claimants fears of lengthy ,convoluted processing with the real possibility of being denied first time around because of outdated information.
    I do wonder how we stand against the rest of Europe with our ‘waiting times’ ?

    The ‘rants’ being directed at individual T.Ds/ Gov parties etc, doesn’t help those that have genuine reasons for applying for Invalidity or Disability Benefit as nothing is learned. I understand its the national sport and maybe justified but being constructive in addition to this sport would show some of understanding of the original question.

    Reply
  • Willie O’Dea has no credibility to accuse anybody of being “misleading”.

    This is after all a failed government minister, who, by his own confession “mislead” the High Court.

    There should be no place in Irish politics for the likes of him.

    http://www.indymedia.ie/attachments/nov2009/willienov1.jpg

    Reply
  • Willie O’Dea has a brass neck to accuse anybody of being “misleading”. Does he think that we have forgotten his “misleading” sworn evidence to the High Court which precipitated his ejection from cabinet?

    Reply

Add New Comment