TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Justice for Magdalenes group call for ‘dignified debate’ ahead of tonight’s motion

The motion, due to be tabled by Sinn Féin, is set to take place today and tomorrow.

File photo
File photo
Image: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

JUSTICE FOR MAGDALENES (JFM) – the survivor advocacy group – have today called for a ‘dignified debate’ in the run-up to this evening’s debate on the issue.

The motion, which is to take place during private members’ time both this evening and tomorrow, had been called last weekend by Mary Lou McDonald – the Deputy Leader of  Sinn Féin.

Responding to the call, JFM described the motion as ‘reasonable and driven by survivors’ pressing needs.’

The government should address these needs immediately and survivors can no longer be asked to wait until the publication of the Inter-Departmental Committee’s final report. Simply put, many women just don’t have that time. They need help now.

The motion has the support not only of Sinn Féin, but of 17 other Independent TDs.

Last week, JFM provided every TD and Senator with a copy of their previous submission to the committee which had been set up to investigate State involvement with the Magdalene Laundries.

Speaking in a statement, JFM said that they ‘look forward to a thorough and considerate discussion of the issue’.

The historical record will show that the Justice for Magdalenes Campaign has been supported by politicians at every level, from every political party and by a range of Independents. We hope that this wide measure of support will continue and voices from all parties register their part in the imminent debate.
Our anxiety to build consensus is driven by the understanding that if there is not a clear and strong endorsement of the motion by Dáil Éireann, the women who were held in the Magdalene Laundries will yet again receive the message that their experiences, their lives are not worthy of dignity nor respect.

Speaking earlier this week, McDonald had said that:

The treatment of the 30,000 women and girls of the Magdalene Laundries goes to the very core of what was wrong historically in Irish society.

Read: Motion on Magdalene Laundries to be moved next week >

Read next:

Comments (8 Comments)

  • Good luck to them. They put up with a lot! We, as well as they, need this debate, dignified or otherwise. Secrets can be a troublesome burden.

    Reply
  • Justice would be the confiscation of all church property and the imprisoning of those nuns and priests who colluded in imprisoning young innocent women. Send the nuncio packing back to Rome.

    Reply
  • For some of the victims it is too late and for those that are still alive it will be far too little. The least they could do is tell the truth and stop all this stone-walling.

    Reply
  • Senator Martin McAleese as Chair of the Committee established to enquire into the extent of the States involvement in the slavery of young women has asked for a few more weeks before they publish thier final Report. He said that the Committee were in receipt of new information that would add substantially to the impact and meaning of the final document.
    Senator McAleese is a highly respected member of our Society and I for one accept fully his integrity in the matter as do the overwhelming majority of the Members of Dail Eireann.
    So why has the Deputy Leader of Sinn Fein decided to jump the gun and put down a Motion now rather than wait the requested few weeks that the Senator requested.
    It seems that the selfish political posturing of Sinn Fein is about themselves rather than the victims this Report should help and any premature decisions by the Oireachtas could be to their disadvantage.
    Why not show some respect to both Senator McAleese and the victims rather than playing games.

    Reply
    • Ohhh look s/f hater paddy (narky) rogers raises his head again not by the story but only because s/f have been mentioned ….. Senator MacAleese has run with the ball on this and deserves a lot if credit but you don’t care about that paddy you just want to bash s/f as we see in any mention of them your right there monan and cryn …….. Will someone get ole paddy a lolly pop ;)

      Reply
  • The timing of this surely makes for great propaganda for those pushing the yes vote in the children’s referendum……….., at the expense of children who were failed by the state ….disgraceful

    Reply
    • These women were failed by everyone – the Church, their families and the State. Ideally, there would be oversights so that state would not continue to fail them by ignoring this kind of abuse.

      Reply
    • LarBren1 25/09/12 #

      I’m not so sure about how the Yes side could link the two. Much of the criticism about how some unmarried mothers where treated during those times relate to how pressure was put on them to give their children up for adoption. The state now wants to write into law that they have the right to take children away from ‘unsuitable’ parents. Different times, different ideas of what is best for children, but the same outcome for some.

      Reply

Add New Comment