TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 3 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Liquidator to be appointed to Ireland’s newest private hospital

The €90m Cork Medical Centre – which never fully opened after the VHI refused to offer cover – will enter liquidation this week.

THE COUNTRY’S NEWEST private hospital is expected to enter liquidation this week, after its operators failed to resolve an ongoing dispute with the VHI about offering coverage to its members.

Cork Medical Centre, which was due to open for full inpatient services last month, had been forced to shut and lay off its staff last month after VHI refused to offer insurance coverage to any of its customers seeking the hospital’s services.

Its operators, Sheehan Medical, had been forced to lay off the hospital’s 75 staff as a result – and is now set to appoint a liquidator to the hospital, according to the Sunday Business Post.

Its report, by Susan Mitchell, says it believes KPMG is to be appointed to liquidate the assets, after hopes of reaching a last-minute agreement with the National Treatment Purchase Fund appeared to fall through.

Though CMC had been able to reach agreements with Quinn and Aviva last year, the VHI had said there was excess capacity in other hospitals and refused to offer coverage to the hospital’s operations for its own customers.

The VHI said it had informed Sheehan Medical of that position in 2009, but a spokesman for Sheehan Medical disputed this and said the VHI had encouraged the clinic’s construction given the age of the other two private facilities in Cork.

Health minister James Reilly has cited the case of CMC’s difficulties with the VHI as an example of how the latter’s dominant market position needed to be addressed.

Read more in today’s Sunday Business Post >

Read next:

Comments (18 Comments)

  • b flynn 27/03/11 #

    CMC as a private company surely doesnt run its company expecting that it will only be viable if it is guaranteed clients paid for by the public purse? Their risk strategy needed rethinking long before now.

    Reply
  • What a waste to see this hospital go.

    Reply
  • This is just nothing short of a tragedy!

    Reply
  • This is truly appalling!

    Reply
  • This is madness. Something needs to be done with VHI, they seem to be in a world of their own.

    Reply
  • Surely if you have VHI coverage/private hospital insurance, it is your choice where you want to be treated, not VHI.
    Or does VHI operate in the same way as the managed health care funds in America, in that they decide who treats you, where you are treated & dictates right down to what prosthesis the surgeon is allowed to use during surgery. If this is the way they are heading, God help Ireland, just look at the health sector in America.

    The operators of this new hospital are rather naive too, if they left it to this late stage to start negotiating, it doesn’t matter what VHI said to them, it is what was documented that counts.

    Reply
    • The private companies already let you choose within reason. They make cost control decisions which are entirely understandable! The real tragedy is our continued use of the private system, if we all went back to the public system the rate of change would accelerate, as it is the private system is merely papering over the cracks

      Reply
    • Th operators weren’t naive in the sense that they approached Vhi back in 2007 and received verbal approval that the hospital was needed and that Vhi would cover it. Neither Vhi nor Quinn or Aviva can cover a hospital until it is built because they do not approve off-plan and to do so would be negligent. They need to see the quality of the hospital’s facilities and also the quality of the staff running it. Only then can they approve the hospital. This means people like the Sheehan’s, and their investors, have to take the risk of building the hospital first. They did so based on their previous experience at the Blackrock Clinic and Galway Clinic, which both opened without Vhi cover and were subsequently covered shortly afterwards.

      Reply
  • They sure are Jonathan, we as a family left them and saved over 200 euros a month!

    Reply
  • This almost beyond belief, €95m spent. 75 jobs created directly and because the V.H.I won’t support it, it closes the doors, this is sickening, do the powers that be just not care? More examples of things staying the same, bang on this needs a strong arm shown to it. The govt should step in here to sort this out. The V.H.I need a good ol slap for this.

    Reply
  • I don’t believe the actual liquidator has been decided yet, discussions are still underway with the top four. The main reason this hospital failed is not NTPF it was Vhi. NTPF were just part of options discussions with third parties over the last couple of weeks.

    Reply
  • It’s a pity the wheels of govt are so
    slow to be able to react. This would be another great opportunity to show active leadership but alas I think not. Instead we will see the loss of 75 jobs and the waste of €95m

    Reply
  • Excess in other hospitals? What planet do they live on?

    Reply
  • The cost is said to be 95 million euro.But the tax breaks given by
    the caring Mary Harney to Investors are huge,Somebody I know
    said the actual cost to the Investors is more like 47 million,we the
    taxpayer pay the rest.We need puplic hospitals not private

    Reply
    • No tax breaks were given to this hospital. Not a cent of public money was used. Most of the money came from abroad and this sends very bad message to foreign investors willing to risk money in Ireland.

      Reply
  • Mary harney and privtatisation tax payers money should of been put into the public system. Rewarding innovative thinking and work practices

    Reply
  • Private hospitals are a joke anyway. Their staff have no experience compared to the general hospitals (very bad) and do not care for their patients properly. I can say this from experience with the Galway Clinic where my Dad was a patient for 4 weeks. I would never step foot in one ever again.

    Reply

Add New Comment