TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Mary Robinson calls for greater access to cervical cancer vaccines

Writing a blog for the British Medical Journal, the former President has called on pharmaceutical companies to lower the prices they charge for the HPV vaccine.

Image: Lee Jin-man/AP/Press Association Images

FORMER IRISH PRESIDENT Mary Robinson has called on pharmaceutical companies to lower the prices charged for cervical cancer vaccines so more girls can be immunised in low income countries.

Robinson also said that recipient governments need to co-finance the cost of vaccine programmes to ensure two million girls are immunised by 2015.

Writing a blog for the British Medical Journal, the former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, said that despite the support by the GAVI Alliance, some obstacles still remain before HPV vaccine programmes can be rolled out in developing countries.

Robinson added that although demand is high among such countries, questions remain about whether there is a satisfactory infrastructure to introduce it.

However, November’s announcement that the GAVI Alliance will support the introduction of the HPV vaccine is an important example of how we must continue to strive for equity in health, she said.

“Every two minutes a woman dies of cervical cancer,” she wrote. About 90 per cent of these deaths occur in the world’s poorest countries where screening and treatment are more expensive.

HPV causes about 70 per cent of cervical cancer cases.

Cervical cancer exacts a terrible and unjustifiable social and economic toll on women, their families and communities—a toll that will rise in coming decades if left unchecked. It is estimated that if current trends continue, as many as 430,000 women a year will die by 2030, 85 per cent of them in low and middle income countries.”

For more from Mary Robinson’s BMJ blog, follow this link>

Read next:

Comments (23 Comments)

  • A good screening program, like the one we have here, would also be necessary to combat cervical cancer. A HPV vaccine can only so much, as not all cervical cancer is caused by HPV. Education and raising awareness levels of both the disease itself and the screening/treatments available is vital.

    Reply
  • Easy just give it for free like any cancer drug should be!

    Reply
    • No drugs are free unfortunately… Drug company’s benefit the most when medicine is given for free to the populations as it brings in price fixing.. So the tax payer foots the bill

      Reply
    • Why would anyone work for years to develop any drug if they were expected to produce it for free?

      Reply
    • Morals perhaps? Charging people to stay alive is absolutely ridiculous

      Reply
    • Here in the real world, workers live on wages rather than air, and raw materials don’t fly in the door for free.

      All those lab technicians, manufacturing engineers, automation people, operators, clean room, validation people, warehouse and storage (as all these vaccines have very strict storage conditions)… and that’s just the manufacture. Add in the millions of man-hours spent developing them, running trials, getting it past the FDA. And how will the factories where these are manufactured be built?

      And how will the next lots of research for more cures and preventions be funded, if there is no income from this one?

      Curing or preventing the various cancers is a very expensive business, but at least there is some progress in some cancers. I don’t see any of our socialist paradise nations coming up with these life saving vaccines.

      Reply
    • P Wurple 21/12/11 #

      ps Fiacra, how does your GP take it when you refuse to pay. Or your chemist for that matter?

      Reply
    • I live in Derry with universal healthcare system like it should be, the south needs this.

      Reply
    • Yeah.. The pharmaceutical industry is so hard up that the US government has offered to research drugs for them and then allow them take control of the patents..
      Which is mad, because this industry spends on average twice as much on advertising and direct marketing as it does on research and development, and more than that again on settling fraud and damages cases.
      And then there’s the K Street lobbying expenses.. And it’s not like they’re short on profit either..

      If they were honest and didn’t put drugs they knew were unsafe on the market (eg Avandia, Vioxx, Bextra), didn’t engage in off label marketing (which is illegal), and refrained from commuting fraud (ghostwriting and RCT manipulation), then the cost of healthcare would probably plummet..
      But asking for honesty and ethics in big business is like asking a politician for same..

      Reply
    • Oops, commuting fraud? That should have been committing.. Typing too quick..

      Reply
    • P Wurple 21/12/11 #

      Shanti, none of those are cancer treatments, and at least one is still on the market (although controversial), so isn’t your statement libelous?

      Also, the term “pharmaceutical Industry” is about as meaningful as generalising about the software industry. There are giants, medium sized businesses, and many many startups. It is not all big business by any means.

      Reply
  • The cervical cancer vaccine is highly effective but price is a contentious issue as the institutions which put thirty years of research into developing the vaccine must recoup the billions they spent. Whilst it I easy to argue for a price reduction the issue is severely complicated when costs incurred by big pharma ,which many people see as the ‘enemy’ , are taken into the equation

    Reply
  • Fiachra, if it is morally wrong to charge you for a medicine , then the same argument could be made for food or fuel as we all need these to exist.
    Even in that great People’s Republic of North Korea where all food is rationed at starvation levels the people have to pay for it.
    In the United Kingdom where you live your Government, through it’s various Agencies refuses reimbursement for many medicines from which it’s citizens would derive clinical benefit.
    Without the extraordinary combined efforts and investments made by scientists physicians and organisations like pharmaceutical companies no advances could be made in the treatment and prevention of many many diseases.
    Even with this knowledge are you suggesting it is immoral to charge for such medicines?
    On this basis alone you can decide the levels of your own ignorance.

    Reply
    • Look im not going to pretend im an expert on this subject,im not, but i would rather have the NHS or NHS-esk systen than the HSE as it does, despite your mentioned difficulties, work.

      Reply
    • P Wurple 22/12/11 #

      Fiacra, not sure if you are aware, ireland does actually provide both free HPV vaccine and free cervical checks. Fantastic service, which makes a huge difference.

      Reply
    • And i am very pleased of that but i do not see why a universal health system cannot be implemented? Lets face it the HSE from its inception is a joke and hospital corridors are congested with trolleys, empty private hospitals in cork, overburdened hospitals in.. Well nearly everywhere but Galway would be a major one. The Healthcare system needs.a major overhaul and the current government are as of yet mearly putting plasters on an already infected wound, although i will give them time to see if they will actually implement reform.

      Reply
  • Dear PWurple I do believe you have real understanding and the ability to put morons in their place.Congatulations on your contribution.
    Unfortunately Fiachra is not alone in his ignorance or wish for someone else to pay. This concept doesn’t seem to infect other countries the way it does here.

    Reply
    • Im not at all ignorant? I believe in a universal healthcare system and i know from experience as my mum died of cervical cancer,and luckily did not have to worry about finances, how putting the issue of finance into someones fight for life/prevention of cancer i think is extremely immoral.

      Reply
  • Has Mary Robinson done any research about the reported Deaths from the HPV vaccine Gardasil?

    She could start looking up some of the reports on major TV networks/ newspapers in the US, Australia, UK etc.

    Reply
  • Check-out the newly released, award winning memoir, How I Lost My Uterus and Found My Voice: a memoir of Love, hope, and empowerment. This is one woman’s story of falling in love, battling HPV and cervical cancer, facing sexual dysfunction, confronting her conflicting feelings about motherhood, and becoming her own best advocate. Inspirational and honest, this memoir tells the emotional story of love, loss, resilience, and survival. 978-1-4620-7056-5 (SC ISBN)
    978-1-4620-7057-2 (HC ISBN)

    Reply
  • Could you just imagine the People’s Paradise of North Korea providing vaccines for influenza nevermind cervical cancer.
    No drug was ever developed by the massive Socialist systems of the Soviet Union or China.

    Reply
    • This has nothing to do with it? Im advocating a universal healthcare system similar to the NHS where people with illnesses that will kill them if untreated are given proper care and support.

      Reply

Add New Comment