TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Survey shows men drive faster but women are less confident behind the wheel

A report from AA also showed that 50 percent of male drivers have run over a pet or animal while driving.

Image: Stokkete via Shutterstock

RESULTS OF A new survey by AA Ireland shows that male drivers are more likely to drive over the speed limit and while under the influence while women are less confident in their skills behind the wheel and tend to leave car maintenance until the last minute.

The new gender analysis report compiles poll data gathered by AA Ireland online polls between 2008 and 2012.

The analysis shows men are more likely to exceed the speed limit by at least 10 per cent than women and are more than twice as likely to exceed the limit on motorways. 37 per cent of women will exceed the limit by 10 per cent in a 30kph zone while 44 per cent of men do.

Just 7 per cent of female drivers will exceed the limit by 10 per cent in a 120kph zone compared to 15 per cent of male drivers.

Screen Shot 2012-12-20 at 13.36.14

Results also show women at 71 per cent are more likely than men at 59 per cent to refrain from drinking and driving entirely. The report indicates men are also marginally more likely to take their chances and drive even if they suspect they are over the legal limit.

The report suggests that a higher percentage of men than women are likely to chance driving the morning after drinking whilst still unsure if their blood alcohol levels are back below the legal permissable limit.

Screen Shot 2012-12-20 at 13.41.56

Men and women were virtually neck in neck in terms of speaking on their mobile phones with results suggesting women are more likely to text.

Both genders are inclined to snack while driving and men are more likely to read a book in traffic while women are more inclined to brush their hair.

Collisions

Male respondents who have had a near miss or collision as a result of looking at something while driving were most likely to be distracted by an attractive female pedestrian or cyclist, according to the study. Women are most distracted by outdoor advertising and road traffic collisions as well as other cars stopped by Gardaí.

The same percentages of men and women said they had crashed in the last ten years with 78 per cent of both genders also saying they had not crashed at all in the last decade.

During winter driving hazards, women are statistically less likely to skid, have a close shave or crash with 35 per cent of men and 27 per cent of women saying they have had a near miss or collision as a result of ground frost.

Both genders had the most near misses or collisions with cyclists in 2011 and 9 per cent of women and 12 per cent of men had an incident with a pedestrian.

Screen Shot 2012-12-20 at 14.00.55

Neither genders had a high percentage of near misses or collisions as a result of reaching back to discipline a child though 15 per cent of women and 18 per cent of men have stopped on the motorway hard shoulder within the last two years to allow a child to go to the toilet.

Men are more inclined to break red lights from time to time than women with a higher percentage of men than women saying they would break a light if there was no other traffic around.

Bouts of road rage are more common among males but around half of both genders have made rude gestures at other drivers.

Screen Shot 2012-12-20 at 14.57.04

According to the results, more men than women feel they would definitely pass their driving test if they were to take it again in the morning.

Men also think they are better drivers with 30 per cent saying they were well above average compared with 18 per cent of women.  The AA Ireland study indicated that women are also more likely to neglect regular car maintenance checks than men.

Read: Fidelma Healy Eames fined €1,850 for driving without car tax>

More: 13 per cent of people have travelled with over-the-limit driver>

Read next:

Comments (42 Comments)

  • It’s the person that’s makes a safe driver! Not the gender!

    Reply
  • This survey is pointless because we’re all paying the same for insurance now anyway, regardless of who’s a safer driver.

    Reply
  • I would love to see some stats on motorway driving because Irish people havnt seem to have a clue how to drive on a motorway especially near to Dublin if you are coming from cork or somewhere like that… crusing in the right hand lane seems to cause more traffic than when people pull in after overtaking 1 or 2 cars rather than going for 10 doing 120 on your cruise control causing another 10 cars being stuck behind you happy to break the speed limit, sorry just eeks me on the road and makes me shout alot

    Reply
  • Men take more risks – which leads to more accidents and fatalities. Women are safer and slower drivers … but this annoys us men on the road ;)

    Reply
    • Men and women have about the same amount of accidents with women having more “fender benders”. Some studies have shown that women in fact have more accidents than men in total. The reason for higher premiums for men is that when they do have an accident it tends to cost a lot more due to the seriousness of it.

      Reply
  • Too much confidence is a very dangerous quality behind the wheel and probably led to a lot of accidents and fatalities.

    Reply
  • Confidence is good over confidence can kill.

    Reply
  • How many women are reading this article while driving

    Reply
  • That’s odd.
    When my wife is in the passenger seat she’s very confident and I drive much slower.

    Reply
  • Women quite obviously lied taking the survey. Only 53% state using a phone while driving and that’s less than men….!!! Drive through any town during school traffic, guaranteed to see a horrendous amount of women on the phone, all the time. !!!

    Reply
    • Ah yes. Anecdotal evidence, not in any way effected by confirmation bias. Surely the best kind.

      Reply
    • The survey is bullshit, I like to play a game while im driving of counting the amount of Male and Female speeders on the two main roads I use. I stay in the left lane on cruise control at 100km and for every ten drivers that pass by me speeding, its usually on average 7 women out of the ten speeding.

      Reply
    • Anecdotal evidence…otherwise known as seeing is believing…!!! For every male I see using their phones while driving I would easily see ten women doing the same….!!! That is absolutely no exaggeration….so the fact this survey shows the complete oppositte statistically I find that very hard to believe. Think about it….who uses a phone most in any household….a woman…!!! Stereotyping or not, it’s just fact. !!!

      Reply
    • In the last year I’d say I’ve seen two people talking on the phone, both men. Not that this is in any way a reflection of reality. Perhaps you should pay more attention to the road than what’s in the hands of other drivers?

      Reply
    • Well, in my case (anecdotally) I very rarely use the phone. In my parents house it’s my Dad that’s never off the phone. My Mum just gets the news about everyone from him.

      And right there is the problem with anecdotes. Research has repeatedly shown that we only “see” that which already supports our previously held beliefs and we ignore that which doesn’t. And the vast majority of the time we aren’t even aware we’re doing it.

      Your statement indicates to me that irrespective of what the study had found you wouldn’t believe it anyway. It went against your previously held belief so you won’t entertain it.

      Reply
    • Unfortunately Tricia Drivers using phones is a pet hate of mine, so is something I am quite observant about, to state, I only see what I want to see, you are pretty much calling me blind and bigoted, when in fact that is complete rubbish. The fact that in your household your father is the one who spends most of the time on the phone, that would certainly put him in the minority in terms of households nationally, next you will be telling me he hates missing any of his soaps and that he gets his hair done on a monthly basis at ridiculous costs. As the old joke goes, three fastest ways of communication…Television…Telephone…Tellawoman…!!! As I said pick any town nationally, sit on the main st between 8 and 9, and then 3 and 5….see how many of each sex you see on the phone while driving….going to go with a ratio of at least 5 to 1 in favour of women…guaranteed.

      Reply
    • “sit on the main st between 8 and 9, and then 3 and 5″

      So, you agree that you are cherrypicking the times of the day when there are a large number of parents (primarily women) doing the specific job of collecting children.

      Yeah, no bias there.

      Reply
    • I picked those times Tricia cause they are the times with the largest volumes of traffic….giving you a greater reading of the situation….picking times outside those times won’t give you a fair reflection now will it….!!! People go to and from work at those times too you know.

      Reply
    • Plus you will also find that due to the economic climate there are now a lot more males bring and collecting children from schools. So you might want to take those rose tinted glasses off you claimed I was wearing….seems to be a major issue for you this….any chance you have received penalty points for being caught on your phone ??? Lol.

      Reply
    • Tricia G 02/01/13 #

      Nope, no peno points for me. Clean licence for the 17 years I’ve been driving (so far anyway).

      And I think you’ll see I said “primarily” women. Believe me, I would never suggest that it’s only mothers that drop off / pick up the kids.

      And whilst most schools let out between 3 / 4pm, a large proportion of jobs (the 9am-5.30pm type) don’t so I will have to disagree with your assertion that 3-5 are the “busiest times” on the roads.

      Reply
    • In towns nationally Trisha you will find towns busiest time for traffic are the times I highlighted….as for the reasons only you can jump to the conclusions on them….be they school runs or people working, most people work 9-5, some work half days, some work three days a week….so again rose tinted glasses….but one thing is certain….busiest traffic times are those I highlighted….whether you like it or not….if it is the school run, and it is mainly women doing so, it only goes to further heighten my point….!!!

      Reply
    • Tricia G 02/01/13 #

      So now you’re only including Towns and excluding Main Roads, motorways etc.

      This is precisely my point. The Survey was wideranging, not specific to times / locations etc.

      I’m done. You have your opinion, and I know better then to think I’ll change it.

      But I will say this. I wasn’t the one saying the Survey was rubbish simply because it didn’t back up my perceptions of peoples driving habits. That was you.

      Right so, I’d better get some work done, and I WILL be on the road at about 6pm tonight. :)

      Reply
    • Playing a game while driving, well aren’t you a fine example of female drivers!

      Reply
    • Tricia G 02/01/13 #

      Vincent F – What game is that?

      Personally I think a good game of Twister whilst driving just can’t be beat!

      Reply
  • Ahhh women

    Reply
  • F1 for women!!???? No, didn’t think so…. For obvious reasons ;-)

    Reply
  • Wimminz bring me my baconz sammiches.

    Reply
  • More useless crap from Rent a Quote Conor.

    Reply
  • thats bullshit my mam is better than most drivers out there.

    Reply
  • ^^Sorry, wrong section

    Reply

Add New Comment