TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Noonan rejects Moriarty recommendation on tax relief for political donations

The finance minister says lower limits on the amount individuals can donate will limit the impact that high earners can have.

The final report of the Moriarty Tribunal, published in March 2011, recommended tax reliefs on political donations in order to limit the influence of higher spenders.
The final report of the Moriarty Tribunal, published in March 2011, recommended tax reliefs on political donations in order to limit the influence of higher spenders.
Image: Eleanor Keegan/Photocall Ireland

THE MINISTER FOR FINANCE has said he has opted against following a recommendation from the Moriarty Tribunal on allowing political donations to be tax deductible.

Justice Michael Moriarty’s final report, published in March 2011, recommended that tax relief be offered on any donations to politicians or to political parties, up to a limited threshold.

This was because “major vested interests may be disproportionately capable, by means of their greater financial resources, of influencing political activity”.

Explaining his suggestion in his final report, Moriarty said the move would encourage a wider variety of people to make smaller donations and therefore “reduce the dependency of political life on funding from wealthy donors”.

The recommendation has now been dismissed by Michael Noonan, however, who believes the goal of limiting the influence of big spenders has already been achieved.

In response to written parliamentary questions from Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin, Noonan said recent changes to political donations limits meant it was illegal for individual politicians to accept any more than €1,000 from a donor in any one year, or for parties to take more than €2,500.

Under the legislation introduced last year which is better known for enforcing gender quotas in political parties, any donation of over €600 to an individual politician, or donations of over €1,500 to a political party, must be disclosed to the Standards in Public Office Commission.

“These limits, in themselves, should act to deter any attempts by wealthy individuals to influence political activity,” Noonan said,

The Moriarty Tribunal issued its final reports in March 2011, 14 years after it was established to look into the financial affairs of Charles Haughey and Michael Lowry, after reports that the two had received substantial donations from businessmen including Ben Dunne.

Poll: Would you support tax relief for political donations?


Poll Results:





Read: Nine legal staff on Moriarty Tribunal earned €33.7 million

Read next:

Comments (11 Comments)

  • terrible idea! donations given tax relief will benefit only those who donate and allow businesses to write off large amounts of money that they should be paying tax on while they lobby TDs etc. It will end with more corruption and politicians being bought up like in the US.
    They should be coming up with a proper system to fund our political parties which takes out the issue of who paid most etc. Perhaps revenue should collect any donations, run a back ground check of sorts on the person donating and then pass on the donation anonymously to the TD or party, that way its purely a donation and dodgy donations will be stopped.

    Reply
  • Another recommendation rejected or not acted upon by our Government. We could save a fortune on advisors at this rate.

    Reply
    • @Martin- It was a bad idea when it was put forward. It’s an even worse idea now. Tax relief on donations to political parties when the Government is dragging taxes in from all sorts of truly unpopular places? Not all recommendations have to be followed. This was but one by Moriarity and setting it aside was the right thing to do .

      Reply
    • @ Vincent Nolan, I agree.

      Forgive me for being cynical but controlling a major newspaper group is a better way of influencing politicians. Mr Murdoch realised that. I am sure that this reality was not lost on Mr. Denis O’Brien, who was the subject of adverse findings by the Moriarty Tribunal.

      Reply
  • All donations should be in the public domain along with all party memberships for without total transparency we can never know just how much cronyism in this country damages us.

    Reply
    • @ Noel, right on the nail!

      Reply
    • Look at all the planning decisions, granted to developers on flood plains or out in the middle of nowhere? FG/Labour had the power in local government, not just FF in the Dail and how many individuals can you get together to make a donation to one Councillor or T.D.? I am sure Developers, had many friends and employees to make enough donations just under the limit. That would add up too a tidy sum, in cash for the favours needed!

      Reply
  • Any recommendation on telling lies or responsible behaviour or honesty fair play ,things expected of people. Eh

    Reply
  • There’s no business like show business.

    Reply
  • You can see from the voting wheel that 10% are trying to control the government at the moment anyway

    Reply

Add New Comment