TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

New laws on prostitution ‘must address trafficking problem’

A Fine Gael TD has said there are a number of shortfalls in the current laws which are being taken advantage of by traffickers.

File photo
File photo
Image: Paul Barker/PA

ANY NEW LAWS introduced around prostitution in Ireland must address the issue of trafficking, a Fine Gael TD has said.

Marcella Corcoran Kennedy said that there are a number of ‘shortfalls’ in the law which traffickers are taking advantage of in order to exploit vulnerable women.

She made the comments after Justice Minister Alan Shatter published a major consultation document on Friday evening on whether Ireland’s prostitution laws should be changed.

The business of prostitution has changed ‘immeasurably’ in recent years, the TD said, and Ireland’s legislation needs to change in order to address these changes.

“We regard ourselves as being a fair and humane society which is respectful of human rights, and yet hundreds of women who have been brought to Ireland under false pretenses are working as prostitutes here against their will,” said Corcoran Kennedy.

She said that a large number of women have been trafficked into Ireland from other countries to work as prostitutes.

The discussion document – which can be read in PDF here – will be brought before an Oireachtas committee, when members of the public and any interest groups will be able to offer their input on it.

Shatter publishes major document on whether Ireland’s prostitution laws should change >

Children subjected to prostitution in Dublin, Cork and Kilkenny – report >

Read next:

Comments (26 Comments)

  • What are the shortfalls? How many is “a large number of women”? How many “hundreds”? No-one actually knows how many prostitutes work in Ireland so where is she getting her figures from.
    “The business of prostitution has changed ‘immeasurably’ in recent years, the TD said, and Ireland’s legislation needs to change in order to address these changes.” That is why there is a consultation document being produced!

    Has this woman been in a coma for the last couple of weeks and is now frantically trying to keep up by throwing out sound-bites and off the top of her head figures.

    Reply
    • Precisely. Denise Charlton, CEO of the Immigrant Council of Ireland, an organization that plays a central role in the Turn Off The Red light campaign which is campaigning for a Sweden style Sex Purchase Act to be enacted that will criminalize the purchase of sex, claims that the prostitution industry in Ireland is worth 180 million. How does she know? Is an annual audit done of the prostitution industry in Ireland?

      We should seek truth from facts. What we shouldn’t do is follow authoritarian fact-free hunch-heavy emotionalism which suggests that there are quick fix solutions to complex problems, these quick fix solutions almost inevitably involving some sort of criminal sanction. With the numbers of Gardai being cut back under the agreement forged between the last government and the IMF/ECB/EU, it’s time to examine an intelligent harm-reduction approach to the sex work industry which involves listening to those who would be most affected by prostitution laws, the sex workers themselves.

      Reply
    • 180 million? Where did she get that from? Looking at a well known website that provides contacts and for ease of calculation lets say it costs €200 per hour for sexual services. That means that there are 900,000 hours per year worked by sex workers. Divide that by the average working week gives you 22,500 sex workers in Ireland! Even doubling the hours done by these workers gives us 11,250, still an unbelievable figure.

      Just looking at the same website 5 minutes ago and there are only 51 women offering their services in the second largest city in the country. Dublin has 265 women offering services and limerick has 42. So we can account for 358 women but where have all the rest gone? Maybe Marcella Kennedy has the answers!

      Reply
  • Paul 24/06/12 #

    I find this article very disturbing in two ways. 1. Not once has it been mentioned that young males are also forced into prostitution, the focus seems to be on women. 2. By mouthing off and talking about taking action to prevent this is not new, just the usual publicity show till something else comes up to distract the attention of the TD’s

    Reply
  • Corcoran Kennedy and the other circus clowns should wake up and smell the coffee.nLegalise, monitor, control and regulate the industry and remove the criminal element.nWords on paper in the statute book will not make the problem as it is, go away.

    Reply
  • There’s a prostitiute working out of my apartment block, if you criminalise her clients you will be prosectuting like 10 people a day. Surely driving the industry even further underground.
    Even with the current laws she is reticent to call the police when we had a problem unrelated to her occupation.
    Legaliseit, bring it out in the open and give the sex workers and the clients the social protection they need.

    Reply
    • is she any use?

      Reply
    • Legalising ‘it’ didn’t work in Amsterdam, contraversily legal prostitution made amsterdAM as the main destination for trafficking so that’s why they are reducing number of red light ‘kamers’. Unfortunately the most effective way is reducing demand by educating the men and penalysing the sex purchasers and traffickers not the victims. If u think that the majority of the customers are married and/or elite ppl, it seems this is the best way…

      Reply
    • Eleen 24/06/12 #

      That’s not true, Mustafa.

      Firstly, there are different models for dealing with prostitution. While the Holland model is definitely not a good one (it doesn’t seem to be supported by any sex-worker’s rights advocates at all), there are other models that legalise prostitution which seem to work much better. New Zealand has legalised it too, and it’s working very well for them there, it seems.

      And there is a lot of evidence that proves that penalysing those who purchase sex is just as bad as making prostitution illegal. Sweden has seen a spike in trafficking and violence against prostitutes thanks to their legislation. It’s been criticsed quite a lot actually. http://feministire.wordpress.com/2012/01/29/unaids-advisory-group-condemns-swedish-sex-purchase-ban/

      Either way, legalisation IS the way to go because making it illegal has never proved to work and only makes things worse for those who sell sex.

      Either way, it’s MUCH better than making it illegal. Plenty of stories and examples of how making prostitution illegal not only doesn’t stop prostitution but makes it much worse.

      Reply
  • “We regard ourselves as being a fair and humane society which is respectful of human rights, and yet hundreds of women who have been brought to Ireland under false pretenses are working as prostitutes here against their will,” said Corcoran Kennedy.

    Love to see some evidence of this that wasn’t imagined by Ruhama. The Guards have very different statistics that have stated that trafficking is very rare and isn’t a problem in Ireland.

    What we do have is Asylum Seekers that when caught working in a brothel claim they were trafficked so they won’t be deported.

    Reply
  • Alan Shatter has, by way of this recently launched discussion process, given everyone – not just the NGO’s – the chance to have their say on how the laws on prostittution will evolve. For far too long almost no one has actually listened to what the sex workers themselves have to say. When Ruhama visited Sweden they did not meet with any of that country’s sex workers to see how the law had impacted their lives.

    Reply
    • That does not surprise me.

      Ruhama has a consistent history of seeing sex workers as targets to be defined, not equals to be consulted.

      Even now if you challenge them, the answer is:
      “But you don’t seem to know what Ruhama actually does”

      Yes I do…Ruhama jump up and down and insistently misrepresent me and anybody like me so that they can impose their will, needs and ideology on our lives in lieu of our own. They always have, the always will.

      Everything else is just window dressing.

      Reply
  • The next time you hear someone speak of the success of the swedish model remember the articles you read here http://www.thelocal.se/tag/prostitution.
    rtunity to have their say

    Reply
  • Most of the figures you read about prostitution in Ireland are pure fantasy made up by the nuns who run organisations like Ruhama who in turn are the organisations the Irish govt, rely on for their information because they can’ be bothered to investigate the numbers for themselves. The Gardai have very different numbers when it comes to prostitution and trafficking but as with most religious run groups with their own agendas organisations like Ruhama are not ones to let the fact get in the way of a good story especially one that helps further their religious inspired agenda. The same group funnily enough doesn’t help ‘male’ prostitutes, wonder why that is?

    Reply

Add New Comment