TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Opposition sides to face off for prized Dáil accounts committee

The government will be left to decide which of Shane Ross or John McGuinness takes the Public Accounts Committee.

Shane Ross (left) and John McGuinness will go head-to-head to become the chairman of the Dáil's Public Accounts Committee.
Shane Ross (left) and John McGuinness will go head-to-head to become the chairman of the Dáil's Public Accounts Committee.
Image: Photocall Ireland

THE GOVERNMENT PARTIES will be left to decide which of two opposition TDs will be made Chairman of the Dáil’s influential Public Accounts Committee, when the committee meets for the first time today.

Parliamentary tradition usually allows the largest opposition party to hold the position, with Fianna Fáil set to nominate Kilkenny-based TD John McGuinness as chairman.

Some members of the Dáil’s technical grouping – made up of smaller parties and independents – oppose giving Fianna Fáil the position, though, and are backing Shane Ross as an alternative candidate.

If Ross’s nomination is backed by Sinn Féin’s Mary Lou McDonald, he and McGuinness will be tied two votes each – leaving the balance of power with the six Fine Gael TDs and three Labour TDs who complete the committee.

It is believed that, as of last night, no decision had been made by the government parties on which of the opposition candidates to support.

Ross is a longtime independent senator and former Fine Gael councillor, while McGuinness is better known for his vocal opposition to Brian Cowen’s performance as taoiseach and leader of Fianna Fáil.

The committee’s inaugural meeting begins at 3pm, and will also appoint a vice-chairman – a position usually taken by the government side.

Proceedings can be watched live on the Oireachtas website.

Who should be made Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee?


Poll Results:





  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (8 Comments)

  • Its comforting to see that tradition informs who gets on powerful Dáil committess instead of something arbitrary such as ability or experience.

    I mean if we started appointing people based on what they knew or could deliver as opposed to furthering political careers of small-minded moneygrubbers, who knows what state the country would be in today.

    Thank heavens for politicians who adamantly keep their heads firmly where the sun doesn’t shine.

    Reply
  • Christ putting a FF’er in charge of a Public accounts committee, having authority over spending, is like putting a Paedo. in charge of a nursery. McGuinness seems decent enough but you would have to be stark raving mad to trust a FF’er with the welfare of the state.

    Reply
  • Thanks for the clarification Gavin. The Socialist Party would not propose Shane Ross for any position as he is on the opposite end of the spectrum from them politically but as they are a minority in the Technical Group, the other members would be able to decide who got the nomination. Finian McGrath and Maureen O’Sullivan agree with the Socialist Party on some issues but there a large differences in other areas.

    Also there are not 19 TDs in the Technical Group. There are 19 small party or independent deputies but Michael Healy-Rae, Michael Lowry and Noel Grealish have not joined the Technical Group, which has only 16 members http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/breaking/2011/0308/breaking20.html

    Reply
  • once again proves we got tweedledum instead of tweedledee at the last election – FG/Lab would obviously prefer being ‘held to account’ by a party that will have no problem with their policies as they are exactly the same.

    Reply
  • Bad or badder

    Reply
  • Source of this article or is it original? When you say that the technical group is supporting Shane Ross’ nomination, how exactly are they doing this? Is it through votes on the Dail Accounts Committee and who exactly from the technical group is on the Committee? As you have written the article it sounds like the 5 ULA TDs are backing Shane Ross’ nomination. I would be surprised if this was the case and if it was not in fact only those members of the Technical Group on the Committee that are backing him, whoever they are. This is very politically important as the Technical Group is just that and does not operate as a party, or take common positions on anything. The only things it agrees on are divvying up extra speaking time in the Dail as it ranges from far left to far right (Ross). Can you clarify the above please or provide a source? Thanks

    Reply
    • @fleetingwhim – The piece is original. The 13 members of the PAC are as follows:

      Fine Gael (6)
      Paul Connaughton (FG)
      John Deasy (FG)
      Paschal Donohoe (FG)
      Simon Harris (FG)
      Eoghan Murphy (FG)
      Kieran O’Donnell (FG)

      Labour (3)
      Anne Ferris (Lab)
      Michael McCarthy (Lab)
      Derek Nolan (Lab)

      Fianna Fáil (2)
      Michael McGrath (FF)
      John McGuinness (FF)

      Sinn Féin (1)
      Mary Lou McDonald (SF)

      Others
      Shane Ross (Ind)

      It’s only these 13 who have a vote.

      Ross is the only member of the Technical Group (which has 19 members, not just the five from the ULA) but has the vocal support from the likes of other Tech Group TDs like Finian McGrath and Maureen O’Sullivan. You’re right to point out that the Technical Group doesn’t act as a single party, so in that regard I’ve made a small edit to the piece.

      As far as I’m aware the technical group was allocated a certain number of seats on each committee, in accordance with its size, and the group met – just as the larger formal parties did – to decide who should get which seat. From that point of view it is relatively safe to assume that the ULA are not opposing Ross’s nomination, given that there was no sound of them trying to stop him from taking the Tech Group’s single spot on the committee. (if they did try to take it themselves, then at least the majority of the group must have decided Ross should take the position, and therefore the majority back him.)

      In any event, Ross is expected to propose himself, and if Mary Lou McDonald is willing to second him then we’ll have our ball game.

      Hope this clarification is of benefit.

      Reply

Add New Comment