TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Organ transplant scandal erupts in Germany, prompts calls for reforms

Two senior doctors have been suspended from the Leipzig University Clinic’s organ transplant centre as part of an investigation into alleged manipulation of the waiting list.

Posed by model
Posed by model
Image: Luis Louro via Shutterstock

THE HEAD OF the German doctors’ lobby and politicians today called for swift action to root out corruption following a scandal over preferential treatment for organ transplants.

The president of the German Medical Association, Frank Ulrich Montgomery, said physicians taking bribes in life-or-death cases would shatter the hard-earned faith that Germans have in them.

“Transplant doctors who still don’t understand that they are destroying their own field with cheating and manipulation should get out of the profession,” he told the daily Passauer Neue Presse.

Montgomery added that “all means available under criminal and professional law should be used” to bring corrupt doctors to justice.

His comments came after irregularities emerged at a transplant centre in the eastern city of Leipzig.

People wrongly registered as dialysis patients

The clinic said that between 2010 and 2012, 38 people were wrongly registered as dialysis patients so that they would be given a higher priority on waiting lists for a liver transplant.

It could not rule out that “money had changed hands” in exchange.

The head of the clinic as well as two senior doctors have been given a leave of absence while the institution conducts an internal probe. Public prosecutors have opened a preliminary investigation.

The affair follows revelations in 2012 that other German hospitals engaged in dubious practices with organ transplants, prompting an independent commission to launch a sweeping review.

The Leipzig cases emerged in the course of that inquiry.

The chief health policy spokesman of Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union, Jens Spahn, urged root-and-branch reform of the organ transplant system, echoing calls by other parties.

“Manipulation to get certain patients higher on waiting lists could mean a death sentence for other patients who have a more urgent need for an organ,” he told the daily Rheinische Post.

Such practices must be “decisively outlawed, punished and stopped for all time”.

- © AFP, 2012

Read: Germany sees property boom as people seek security

Read next:

Comments (9 Comments)

  • It’s always disappointing when stories like this overshadow the organ donation area of medicine as its a grossly under-subscribed service in terms of donors.

    Reply
    • Totally agree. I was so disheartned when the blood transfusion debacle broke out and instead of feeling good and proud to be a donor I felt ashamed.
      Still though organ harvesting should be on an “opt out” basis with as much respect given to the donors next of kin.

      Reply
  • Mmmmm don’t go to Germany for hol,s if you feel unwell

    Reply
  • “hard-earned faith ” pfff…don’t think so….been living here 13 years and the faith of the people here is just about all burnt out! :o(

    Reply
  • Dr.fury 03/01/13 #

    Shower of sheisses

    Reply
  • Dr.fury 03/01/13 #

    Human centipedesc?

    Reply
  • Our government is considering moving from the current opt-in system to an opt-out system. In light of this story and general human greed, I think that would be very dangerous.

    Reply
    • It should be an opt-out service; the service as it currently exists is nowhere near meeting even half of its requirements, and that’s before we take into account the fact that various illnesses would be properly treated if organ donation were more widespread. The fact though that organ donation is so poorly subscribed to means that doctors don’t even entertain the thought.
      The service here in Ireland is grossly under-subscribed, and is in need of vast rearrangement.
      I do have to say that this story is not the norm, still doesn’t take away from the fact that this is a sad occurrence in what should be a bitter-sweet experience.

      Reply
    • I agree it should be opt out. In Germany and other countries where you have multiple centres that carry out transplants it’s harder to regulate, here in Ireland we have only three hospitals that do transplants which means tighter regulations thank god and a fairer system.
      Centre hospitals in Ireland have very high donation numbers due to forward thinking intensivists/anaesthetic teams who invest time and energy into counselling families of donors more of this is needed.

      Reply

Add New Comment