This site uses cookies to improve your experience and to provide services and advertising. By continuing to browse, you agree to the use of cookies described in our Cookies Policy. You may change your settings at any time but this may impact on the functionality of the site. To learn more see our Cookies Policy.
Dublin: 8 °C Friday 22 June, 2018

Most prosecutions for failure to pay pension contributions were construction firms

In the Pension Board’s annual report, it also criticised the poor pension administration and expressed concern about low assets for defined benefit schemes.

Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

A REPORT BY The Pensions Board has said that a considerable part of its time has been spent investigating and prosecuting cases where employers in the construction industry  failed to pay contributions to a pension scheme after deducting it from employees’ wages.

The board said its work in 2012 had resulted in a significant number of prosecutions and convictions of companies, and in many cases directors, and these have continued in 2013. Chief Executive Brendan Kennedy said that the board has been investigating other offences with a view to prosecutiont as soon as possible.

In the board’s annual report, Kennedy said that the construction industry prosecutions have been the result of whistleblowers by scheme trustees and others, and the number of these alerts it now falling sharply.

“This means that the Board will be able to devote more time in 2013 to proactive supervision and we can focus our attention on other areas of non-compliance,” he said.

Defined benefit schemes

Kennedy also said that there has been no overall improvement in the position of defined benefit and defined contribution schemes, in which a lump sum is agreed upon with employers at the beginning and paid to the worker on retirement.

“The majority of such schemes have considerably less assets than are needed to meet the funding standard, and must prepare and submit a recovery plan to the Board by mid-2013″, he said.

The objective of the funding standard is to ensure that each scheme member has a reasonable chance of receiving the benefits set out in the rules of the scheme.  Without an adequate standard, there is a substantial risk that by the time that younger members retire, the scheme assets will have been exhausted in paying the benefits of those who retired before them; the longer that schemes put off meeting the standard, the greater is this risk.

Poor administration

Kennedy expressed concern at “poor administration and record keeping”, which could result in members not receiving all of the benefits to which they are entitled.

Last year the board carried out 28 on-site investigations and Kennedy said that in four cases, the standard of adminstration was so low that had remedial action not been taken, the board would have cinsidered withdrawing the registration of the administrator involved.

He said that the level of compliance is “unacceptably low” when it comes to the submission of annual scheme information by trustees.

2012 figures at a glance

  • There were 760,620 members in 661,232 occupational pension schemes
  • There was an overall decrease in membership of 7,533 in defined benefit and 6,211 in defined contribution occupational pension schemes
  • There were 206,936 Pension Retirement Savings Accounts last year with total assets of €3.46 billion
  • The board secured convictions in 15 cases with five struck out or withdrawan due to payment of arrears
  • It dealt with 38 suspected cases of deduction and non-payment of pension contributions by employers in the construction industry by the end of 2012
  • In the year ending December 2012, €1,328,341.89 was restored to the scheme for cases which the Board was actively investigating, bringing the total since April 2008 to over €7 million
  • The board was paid €66,000 in fines by 17 trustees of six schemes and subsequently passed it onto the Exchequer

Read: Survey finds the majority of people are unaware of pension tax breaks>
Read: Rich pensioners ‘should give back any handouts they don’t need’>

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article

Read next:


This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
write a comment

Leave a commentcancel