TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Poll: Would a People in Need Telethon work in 2013?

The People in Need chairman told TheJournal.ie today that plans to run another Telethon had run out of steam. But do you think it would work if one was run next year?

Michael O'Leary of Ryanair was pelted with water for the 2004 Telethon. Would he do the same again?
Michael O'Leary of Ryanair was pelted with water for the 2004 Telethon. Would he do the same again?

DO YOU REMEMBER the People in Need Telethon? The last one was held in 2007, but today its chairman said that the charity event has run its course.

In a TheJournal.ie report by Gavan Reilly today, RTÉ confirmed that there were no plans for another Telethon, while People in Need Trust chairman David Harvey said that despite a few attempts to get it off the ground again, the event ran out of steam.

The last Telethon saw thousands of fundraising events take place around the country, from static triathlons to fashion shows in circus tents, helping the event to make a profit of just under €7 million.

In the five years since that event, post-Celtic Tiger Ireland has undergone huge changes, and people have found their finances stretched. But would that stop a Telethon from working if one was run again next year?

Today, we want to know what you think:

Would another People in Need Telethon work if it was run in 2013?


Poll Results:





Tell us the reasons for your choice in the comments.

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (28 Comments)

  • We were fairly strapped for cash in the mid 80′s if i recall correctly and yet, per capita, Ireland gave one of the largest donations to Live-Aid…

    Reply
  • I think it would work if the receiving ‘people in need’ were Irish charity’s & the money was being kept to do good in our own country, I don’t think it would work if the money was going to overseas charity’s regardless of how needy they also are, charity begins at home.

    Reply
    • Regardless of how needy? Do you mean like dying?

      Reply
    • Charity begins at home may be a common idiom or phrase but I do not agree with it as it just too broad a generalization for a complex resource allocation issue. The issue you have brought into this conversation is Irish charities operating here versus in developing countries. The inherent implication of the idiom used in this context is that we should not help any other nations while we are in such economic trouble. Some people were saying this during the good times as well though as we had complaints and protests about public services during the peak of the boom and people asking to cut the aid budget then. The point I am clumsily trying to get at is that even those countries with excellent public services complain and demand more money (tax collected and / or fund raised) for services such as health and local poverty reduction. How much would be required to satisfy everyone?

      My estimate of the benefit per person helped or lives saved, or children educated using X amount of euro would be 5- 20 times more in a developing country than in Ireland. I would therefore take your statement to mean that a Irish person in need is deserving of 5 – 20 times more of a charitable donation than a person in a developing country by virtue of the fact they happen to live in Ireland.

      The state has a duty to provide for its citizens so I agree with cutting the foreign aid budget (though not with the severity) while we have to borrow so much money ourselves but I personally give most of my charitable donations to charities working in developing countries as I do not think Irish people are any more deserving of my donation than those in developing countries considering the fact my euro will go that much further there, helping more people in much worse conditions and situations.

      Reply
  • I agree with a previous poster. I live in Dublin City, and visited Cork City at the weekend. There is an absolute epidemic of homelessness and poverty in this country right now, and I’d love to help them with something, because the charities are close to breaking point, if not past it.

    But for some reason, Irish people see needy people overseas as “poor, desperate, God love them etc”. But when it comes to Irish people being needy it’s a case of “lazy feckers”, “there’s loads of jobs” etc.

    Reply
  • I think it could work if done properly and people were confident their money would be used for the right purposes.

    Reply
  • I think it would as Irish people would tend to give more money in hard times than people would expect.

    Reply
    • No some of those who are working are worse off than others who are not . No housing benefits . Back to school allowances . Medical cards etc . Working people although lucky to have a job are being fleeced through their pay packets week after week .

      Reply
  • The problem is we are all in need

    Reply
  • yes i think so it will work if the money goes straight to the irish charities and not to the chiefs pockets that run the charities

    Reply
  • I think the money just isn’t there at the moment.

    Reply
    • Is that O’Leary launching the new measuring system for Ryanair. Only head and hands can be brought into the passenger area…the rest has to go in the hold unless you pay € 5,000 excess charge…

      Reply
  • Half the country are people in need so who would get the money..

    Reply
  • Charity fatigue at this stage. So, no.

    Reply
  • So, the last Telethon in 2007 raised €7.5m…..a quick calculation on just TD’s basic salary (93k x 166) comes out at just over €15m (excluding any of the myriad of “expenses” added)…..so, if TD’s took a 50% pay cut…..it would met the same as the last Telethon (€7.5m)…and we wouldn’t have to watch the self obsessed cringeworthy RTE production……..SIMPLES!!

    Reply
  • I dint think a people in need would work at this time, not with costs rising in fuel, oil, gas, electricity, being taxed to death and having pay cuts. People are squeezed as it is. If those on €100,000 + salaries dont givea a damn, and probably wont get involved then why should the rest of the country be expected to. Havent we bailed out enough thus far.

    Reply
  • It would be an irrelevancy. There is a virtual telethon every day in this country as the government continues to pour billions of euro into zombie banks. People don’t need charity, they are entitled to fairness. Instead of another circus what’s needed is for the system to be changed.

    Reply
  • I think it would work. But the troika would want us to off load it.

    Reply
  • I heard the song on the radio today and it reminded me of the people in need telethon…woooo come on everybody!!;)

    Reply
  • The sad thing about the so called ‘people in need’ is that they are are neither the long term unemployed nor the low wage workers .

    Reply
  • Didn’t we just have a Telethon recently ??? Yeah,sure we did,there was lots of clowns on TV,people saying and doing stuff they wouldn’t normal do,and lots of money was given away.

    Oh wait,no that was the General Election!!!

    Reply
  • no

    Reply
  • I dint think a people in need would work at this time, not with costs rising in fuel, oil, gas, electricity, being taxed to death and having pay cuts. People are squeezed as it is. If those on €100,000 + salaries dont givea a damn, and probably wont get involved then why should the rest of the country be expected to. Havent we bailed out enough thus far.

    Reply

Add New Comment