TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

Poll: If the UK quits the European Union, should Ireland follow?

Britain is revisiting its relationship with Brussels – and a poll says a third of us believe if they go, so should we.

If the English Channel becomes too wide for Britain to bear, should Ireland follow it out of the EU?
If the English Channel becomes too wide for Britain to bear, should Ireland follow it out of the EU?
Image: ALASTAIR GRANT/AP

A NEW POLL published this morning reveals that a third of Irish voters believe Ireland should end its membership of the European Union if the United Kingdom decides to quit the union.

A Red C poll commissioned by European Movement Ireland and carried out earlier this month also discovered that a quarter of Irish people would like Ireland to opt out of the euro.

Britain’s relationship with Brussels has been uneasy for the last few years – with David Cameron yesterday warning that without major democratic changes in the EU, “Europe will fall and the British people will drift toward the exit”.

Meanwhile, the terms of the Fiscal Compact – which the UK was one of only two countries to opt out of – also contain pledges to incorporate its terms into the EU’s founding treaties. This could put the country on another collision course with the EU.

So – today we’re putting the question to you, our readers. If the UK decides to leave the European Union, should we follow our biggest trading partner and bid adieu to Brussels?


Poll Results:





Read: One third think Ireland should leave the EU if the UK does

Read next:

Comments (161 Comments)

  • The Red C poll should have also asked how many people wanted to leave the EU even if the UK wanted to stay. The difference between both questions is the REAL figure being influenced by the UK leaving the EU……..

    Reply
  • Ireland needs to make her own decisions.

    If the UK leaves that should be a factor, but it shouldn’t be the only factor.

    That’s what independence means.

    Reply
  • I would be more concerned with a country like Turkey itching to join the EU rather than the brits leaving it.

    Reply
    • Could you explain that one? And they are not itching to join anymore. Very far from it.

      Reply
    • The Turkish economy is doing extremely well at the moment and joining the EU us no longer a desire of the country. They don’t want to take on the troubles Europe is facing and that’s a sensible decision

      Reply
    • That is my point exactly. The economy is growing and the EU dream fades into the memory. But then the very idea of Turkey scares people for some reason. All the people who liked the Zombie comment above, perhaps? Rest east folks the Turks aren’t coming, they’re staying right where they are.

      Reply
    • Rest easy I mean..

      Reply
    • So its ok for everyone to go on holiday to turkey But oh no dont let them into our screwed up little club. Haven’t actually heard no good reason from anyone as to why they shouldn’t be aloud. Arrangements usually go along the line of it will increase the Muslim population by about 150% (Currently about 45m, Turkey about 75m)

      Reply
    • Julie 19/01/13 #

      134 people liked that comment do them people not realise eu is seen as a drain on the Turkish economy If they joined I have great friend from turkey and they told me that they government has said they have no desire to join the eu and soon enough eu citizens will want to come to turkey and they will say no like we did to them .

      Reply
    • I think we should take back control of Ireland to Dublin. The Brits don’t like the idea of there borders being open to any country in the EU because to be honest a lot of the immigrants that come are only in to use the welfare system which is better than their countries . The Brits also want to make decisions for its own people and not be directed by Brussels . Bring on the red thumbs but think about it this is true .

      Reply
    • British, on average pay less tax than they receive on public services. Immigrants in britain on average pay more than they receive. Im sure its similar here. Stop demonising immigrants for cock ups that happenned elsewjere….i.e for every finger you point at an immigrant point 2 back at yourself.

      Reply
    • Daniel, religion is one aspect of the barrier to Turkish entry, but only a very small aspect. Major reservations are also held in terms of Turkish political corruption, humanitarian rights, taxation, corporate/industrial relations legislation, inequality, its relationship with Greece over Cyprus, free trade, agriculture, infrastructure, proximity to unstable regions in middle east (nice as buffer zone so to speak) etc.

      The scale of taking in a member state now with a population equating to 15-20% of current membership while GDP per cap is about third of EU average. Would take huge investment to bring Turkish infrastructure and agriculture to EU average, let alone laws/humanitarian rights/cultural alignment to EU social norms etc.

      Reply
  • If UK leaves EU it may indeed increase Irish competitiveness – as only English speaking country link between EU and USA. It would also mean transfer of lot more EU/African/Middle East head offices of US firms here to avoid trade restrictions which will be imposed on UK. UK firms whose main business interests are exports to EU rather then the domestic market (e.g service firms, R&D etc) may also consider transfer.

    With Ireland already in Euro and UK keeping pound cant see huge negative business consequences of not following UK actions when compared with positives, despite current trade % between both countries (If Euro zone can stabilise itself that is).

    Reply
    • You assume the EU and Uk wont have a trade agreement? Many countries have trade preference agreements with EU why wouldnt UK?

      Reply
    • censored 19/01/13 #

      You assume that members would not get preferential treatment.

      If they don’t get preferential treatment, then what is the point of membership?

      Reply
    • That would make Ireland a “Venue”, kinda shallow.

      Reply
    • Ireland with a low corp tax already is a ‘venue’ for lot of FDI, who set up and remain due to tax purposes – as long as brings jobs, innovation and productive the positives out way negatives. Even if UK and Euro have trade agreements in place e.g Iceland/Switzerland many U.S/BRIC firms ‘looking in’ would prefer a member part of the larger more powerful block. This provides them with stability and access to EU powerhouses such as Germany and much larger single market – rather then a sideline country with trade agreement which can be revoked or damaged if trade war occurs.

      If UK leaves EU, it will not want to isolate itself and duly will try to build EU wide trade agreements or stand alone agreements with countries such as Ireland. Either way could have negative but also very positive consequences for Ireland. I believe will all play out on how EU/UK economy is at that stage however. Strong EU/Euro would push UK towards maintaining membership or indeed strengthening links, weak or crumbling EU/Euro and may decide to jump sinking ship so to speak.

      Reply
  • If the UK leave the EU we might find ourselves in a unique position being linked to both markets and could act as a conduit for business.

    We could definitely use this to our advantage.

    Reply
  • Mal 19/01/13 #

    Why wait on the UK?

    Reply
    • Leave the European Union.
      Rejoin the ‘real’ union.
      Put the flags flying 365.
      Rename Queenstown and Kingstown.
      We have proved we cannot be left to run our own affairs.
      Please have us back ma’am.

      Reply
    • John, brilliant link … i saw the video before :D]
      But in all seriousness, following the failed parties like FF/FFG/Labour any more is just crazy. There are plenty of alternatives to vote for now, to finally start putting this country on the right track.
      To leave the EU, because some nut-jobs who still pray to portraits of the Queen of England, makes no sense. Prior to joining the EU, the UK accounted for over 70% of our export market. This is no longer the case. We are in a Global economy and our economic fate is no longer controlled by our nearest neighbour.
      If the UK does decide to leave the EU, then you must take a step back and look at the bigger picture in terms of opportunity for us a Nation. The UK will need Ireland to act as the gateway for its products to the rest of the European markets. We will be net beneficiaries of a UK exit, as long we we remain in-side the EU. Otherwise, we will end up back in the same position position we were in prior to 1973.

      Reply
    • @voiceofsense:

      Voice of nonsense.

      Reply
    • Exactly. The EU has too much say in our Country and we should change this. England can see the way the wind is blowing and is going to give its people the right to choose.
      I wonder if they will use the lies, intimidation and bully boy tactics our Govt used to get the result they want.

      Reply
  • 49% don’t know.. God, why are we a nation of pure gobshytes! We constantly need someone to hold our hand. We really are the thickos from the island!

    Reply
    • I don’t know how to answer that :) wondered why these people don’t just go off and think about it and then come back with their answer rather than clicking the no opinion option the second they see it.

      Reply
    • I agree Karolyn

      Reply
    • Sometimes people select don’t know if they want to see pie chart, but do not express an opinion.

      Reply
    • Paul 19/01/13 #

      They click don’t know because they haven’t heard all the arguments yet and the want to see the poll results.

      Reply
    • I’d rather be a “thicko from the island” who’s smart enough to realise that they are not yet in a position to give an educated answer than a know-it-all reactionary genius from the mainland who votes instantly

      As Socrates said “true knowledge exists in knowing that you know nothing”

      But I’m curious, would you be willing to make such derogatory statements about any other coy try based on such insignificant evidence?

      Reply
    • SeanS 19/01/13 #

      Funnily enough, I have the exact opposite view on it. I can’t understand how people can have such strong opinions on what would be a very complex situation. Of course leaving itself is a yay or nay response but how could anyone make an informed judgement as to whether it would be good or bad for us? It might be good in the short term, bad in the long, vice versa, neither. It might depend on perspective, for example it might benefit us in some industries/sectors and not so well in others. It seems to me the only logical choice is “I don’t know”, anything else is just guesswork and bias.

      Reply
    • SeanS 19/01/13 #

      Although, admittedly, some guesswork is more informed than others

      Reply
    • Well. it is only a poll on a website, it’s not like you are signing a legal document, should everyone pay a trip to the library before voting on polls? Come on

      Reply
    • SeanS 19/01/13 #

      Where did I say that? (I’m sure you’ve already done this but….) Read some of the comments on this site, not just this article alone, and you’ll see the strength some people have in their convictions. All I’m asking, is how anyone can feel so strongly about something, when in reality, they can’t possibly foresee its impact? And, in that context how can they they belittle others for differing opinions, and resort to name calling. As I said, the only logical option, at least to me, is to acknowledge that I don’t know whether we should leave the EU or not. It could work in the short term, to the detriment of the long term, vice versa, neither etc etc.

      Reply
    • JayK 19/01/13 #

      I’m not an economist and I don’t fully understand the knock-on effects of leaving the European Union. I don’t really even understand legislation we benefit from at the moment. Not to mention the EU and the EEC are separate entities, maybe we’ll remain in the EEC, like Switzerland? In that case, what do we lose and what do we hold onto? Do we have to leave the Euro if we leave the EU? Is that a good thing or a bad thing? I don’t know. I’d be surprised if anyone here really knows.

      So, maybe the “gobshyte” is the person who insists their opinion is heard when they have no clue what they are talking about. Economic policy? Tell everyone to **** off, we’re not paying for anything! Immigration? Tell them to **** off, they can’t come in! Europe? Tell them to **** off, we’re leaving!

      Maybe, if you don’t understand something, it’s best not to make rash decisions about it. Reactionary politics is definitively a bad thing.

      Reply
  • Absolutely not. Duty free shopping ftw!

    Reply
  • we wont leave but its time we started asking is the european union what the name suggests or just a mafia run union where powerful countries like germany and france use it for there self interests and bully the likes of ireland and others into bailing out banks so they don’t have to face up to the facts they messed up as much as anyone during the good times but let others take the bills,pain and austerity!

    Reply
  • Ireland is being held up as a poster boy for following the rules to get out of economic difficulty. I’m not sure if leaving is a good idea, but threatening to leave while our stock is high might get us a few things we want. The noises the British are making would add credibility to such a threat

    Reply
  • Just going to say it Mal. Why would we a small island matter a bit to the power brokers of the EU. We always were an independent voice in the world and in most cases respected over our neutrality. The EU is not neutral and just lsitening to the Berlusconi interview gives some insight into what happens and why. He said Sarkozy invaded another country which was not right to get involved in any ones internal affairs and thats why he did not get involved. He said Sarkozy went and told the french parliment that Italy was going to end up with all the oil and gas in Libya if the did not do some thing and he started bombing.These are Berlusconi’s words this is the EU we are involved in!!! So at any time for any reason the will wage war and we are expected to keep our mouths shut ?.just look at the latest incident in Algeria the Irish guy was let go first would an EU citizen passport get you out of harms way as would an Irish one? I think i would rather have an Irish one just like Tony war monger Blair has for his kids!!!! Imagine he kills kids women innocent men in Iraq and then knows the British are targets world wide but gets Irish passports for his kids to be safe on the back of our neutrality and the British kids well the can take their chances. Get out away from them all and have a good relationship with them as we should with all countries that are good to their people and maybe a trading aggrement like the old days of the EEC when it worked grand.

    Reply
    • Neutrality! Now that’s another can of worms. What is Irish neutrality? What was it ever? IMHO it was never anything other than a flag of convenience for cynical politicians to hide behind when it came time o stand up and make a moral choice. Whenever someone parrots Irish neutrality I reach for the bullshit barometer!

      Reply
    • As far as i have read the irish guy was not let go but rather escaped with a bomb tied around his neck ..

      Neutrality is a load of bs btw with the refueling of American Planes at shannon airport..

      Reply
    • Matt yes I know what your saying,thinking about shannon as an US base and all that, and army personnel in Afghanistan .But at least we are not spending millions on bombs and the like so thats a bonus. I would like a national debate on the point and our foreign relations policy it should not be left up to a few civil servants and the EU.Noam Chomkys hedgemony or survival is a must read and it shows who is the bad guys in the most part

      Reply
    • Sorry. I stopped reading when you started quoting Silvio Berlusconi, that bastion of integrity, to back up your argument. Good old Silvio. Sure you’d be mad to not just eat up whatever he says and take it as the unvarnished truth.

      Reply
    • b silivo haha I think the interview was Lance Armstrong copy he answered all questions (well the bit I saw) on all the thorny issues like his relationship with that woman….. Angela Merkel and on the war in Libya so in that context i used it to show what relly happens and why (it was the oil) he didnt give another reason for the bombing which if he chose to lie he could have had im sure. note taken i wont use him aging unless its of a sexual nature

      Reply
    • Silvio Berlusconi was quite happy to let Italian jets and airbases be used in ridding Libya of his good friend, and happy to have the same bases used in the campaigns in Iraq… so anything he says about the little hungarian frenchman has to be taken with a large measure of salt.. and how do you know Blair’s kids have Irish passports? And what exactly is neutrality – is it having the ability to shoot aircraft violating airspace out of teh sky or just the right to sit under NATO’s security umbrella, free loading as usual?

      Reply
    • @sean Tony Blair kids? very easy it was on national tv and he was asked the question to a very uncomfortable blair and I think it exited to a break then.
      In regards to nato exactly my point why are we in any way tied to them with out a national debate as with other things in Ireland its under the surface and hidden from the public.
      Berlusconi was asked the question why he didnt lead the way in Libya and he was telling it in the context of how France started it and why.

      Reply
    • censored 19/01/13 #

      Noam Chomsky gets to write books like that because he lives in the liberal west and enjoys all the freedoms and privileges that come with it. This is a good thing, but let’s stop the pretense that the west is the ultimate evil in the world. There is no such thing as neutrality, it only works if you don’t get invaded or can find somebody else to do the fighting. As Von Clausewitz said: you may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you.

      Reply
  • Yes, after spending all our money prompting up the European banking system we should leave it and not reap any of the benefits?!

    Not really an option if you have a brain, we have literally invested too much in it, the time we could/possibly should have left has passed.

    Reply
    • *propping – there really should be a 60 sec edit window on comments!

      Reply
    • Or you could read them before you post them?

      Reply
    • Tony, Tony oh my man please tell us the benefits that are coming our way!!!
      Remember lisbon two all the jobs all the good times we were told were coming ? im still waiting as is the rest of Europe. Yeah I can see it now Dell leaving Poland and all them low wage Polish behind to return to our shores because we saved Europe. Options or choices thats the point .
      And just one more we did put some money into the pot for their banks but not it all ,no the want the rest of it dont for get thats why the are agreeing to let us pay more over the next few generations. MY kids and grands will be paying for the mistakes that happened in the boom/bust that was not the peoples doing rather the banking sectors.
      so im waiting for an answer on the good times?

      Reply
    • Declan, You are leaving out the likes of Google, Facebook, Intel, Hewlett Packard, and all the multi-national pharamceutical companies that are based here, because of our relationship to the EU. They need easy access to European markets, we are an English speaking nation (whic is also a major contributing factor).
      Dell left for 2 reasons…
      1) It was primarily an assembly site, and did not require skilled workers. So why would a company like Dell pay Irish workers 10 euro an hour, when it could get the same workers in Poland for 3 euro an hour. Logical business decision.
      2) Dell was continually facing labour shortages (during the Celtic Tiger, this was a real problem for many companies). Yeah, this woulndt be a factor now, but 8 years ago, it was a real issue. Dell was approaching Prison Govenors to ask them to ask people expected to be released shortly to come straight to work at their plant in Limerick. How the hell would that business model be sustainable?
      Our economy was on steroids due to the flood of cheap credit and full employment. This was bad for sustainable growth, and drove wages up to an unsustainable noncompetitive level and it was down to bad economic planning by Governments over a 10 year period that resulted in companies like Dell leaving.
      Our wages went high, because the cost of living and buying homes went out of control, wages had to follow the cost of living. As i said already, this was down to extremely poor economic strategic planning.

      Reply
    • Cal oh i see now. sorry for being so silly i didnt know that we Irish had some thing special that the likes of Google etc could only find here. No one with brains else where in Europe then all computer illiterate else where, its not as if another country could supply them with the things the need to stay here,like a tax haven, grants, subsidy’s, a direct line to government (dinner with the pharma guys).
      Ok i see now i will rest easy now knowing all that you have pointed out!!!

      Reply
    • Declan, i am not arguing the Tax Haven piece, i agree that they should be paying their fair share of Tax. If we are outside the EU, then the Tax Haven element is fully removed, and these companies will have no vested interest in staying here. Be careful what you wish for. Outside the EU, Ireland has no vested strategic position to offer these companies.

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 19/01/13 #

      Looking forward to access to the ESM.

      Reply
    • Cal, haven’t you heard? It was all our fault. (sarcasm).

      Reply
    • Cal1 whether we stay in or out the tax haven still applies, only thing that could change it is if we do stay in and others make us change it.
      wage costs ok no argument there.
      Ireland outside the EU will have no impact as what will change? we will still be speaking english, tax haven will be still around and im sure that a trade agreement of some sort will be in place.
      The one and only reason the are here is tax haven, the import other nationalitys here with languages why could the not bring them into say France or more likely Poland?
      We have one good thing that all nations want FOOD, we have farmers hampered from producing as much as the can because of the EU.We should and will be feeding the EU from oh and supplying them with oil and gas if we get to keep it that is

      Reply
    • Well if we leave the EU we could (not saying should but it would be a possibility) default and leave our debts behind us so saying were “literally invested too much” not true. On the matter of the UK leaving if they did our two largest trading partners would be out side the EU. So that needs to be considered. One one final point if the UK does leave it will probably keep ties along the lines of Switzerland and Iceland through the European Economic Area.

      Reply
    • yeah Tony, stay with the gangsters that have robbed you blind, really it makes me so angry to read such crap comments, are you such a fool you want to stay in Europe, which by the way is ran by Merkel, who also runs Ireland
      are you such a sheeple you can’t see what is really happening
      sad case

      Reply
  • I they put their fingers in the fire why should we. We need to start making our own decisions. Stop these silly polls.

    Reply
  • We should be allowed to vote to leave the human species sooner

    Reply
  • Exactly..why wait. We’ve been shown to be a voiceless minnow throughout the banking crisis…the European banking crisis. Yet we are the ones that pretty much stopped German, French and British banks from imploding and are getting paid lip service in return. We’re too small in the whole scheme of things and rules are applied to this country that are not suitable for our size. German driven austerity has crushed this country and what we have gotten from the European experiment, we have repaid with interest with misery and pain. We shoud at least start a dbate on weather our long term future lies with this grouping of countries or with others.

    Reply
  • why is their no debate about immigration in this country? on Jan 1 2014 we open up our borders to 29mil people from Romania and Bulgaria. These are very poor countries with some people living on 200e a month.Our unemployment rate is huge with even bigger numbers for youth unemployment.In Britain the debate rages over EU membership/immigration/CAP/CFP and other issues.We need a serious,balanced debate on our membership of the EU. ALL OF THE PARTIES ARE PRO EU…

    Reply
  • Bring back the Irish punt!!!!

    Reply
  • Personally I no longer think being a member of the single currency is to Ireland’s advantage. But being a member of the EU still is (in my view). So I think we should at least be drawing up contingency plans for a return to the Punt while remaining within the Union. Such a move would be complex and difficult so we need to plan it well in advance (of course, that shower in Leinster House don’t have the good sense to draw up contingency plans for anything, so if we were ever forced into a withdrawal it’s be a disaster).

    Importantly though, none of these decisions should be influenced by what a bunch of right wing Eurosceptics in England decide to do (and it is England, not the UK, who tends to elect tories).

    Reply
  • Has Ireland ever really run its own country? Can some answer me this, did we go straight from English rule to Europe have we ever been on our own to make our own discussions without the influence of other country’s?

    Answers on a post card!!

    Reply
  • Not a hope is Cameron going to leave the EuroProject he is on record only recently saying he is determined to stay in it while in office.He is under pressure over in Britain from UKIP and others and the people are wanting out so just to defuse and by time like all politicians who are good actors really he is merely entertaining the idea for the media and public they wont be leaving or either will the Irish stuck now and too passive to do anything about it .Real World.

    Reply
  • Bring back the punt, this would draw in alot more tourists because of a lower value against the euro, this in turn would create jobs. Take back our fishing waters, this would create more jobs. Imports would become more expensive so whatever we could make instead of importing would also create more jobs.
    take back our oil fields for the Irish people…. we are better out of this economic prison in the long run.

    Reply
  • Is it the EU, or our politicians that are the problem?

    Reply
  • UK will need us even more if they leave the EU ….simples !

    Reply
  • The EU has like the “celtic tiger” run it’s course. People are paying dearly and the lenders are grabbing what they can by any means available.
    I would vote to depart alongside the UK.

    Reply
    • Mike
      Economies don’t run their course, they move in cycles and our current downturn is exaggerated because the last upturn was the most prolonged in modern history. Based on your viewpoint the Chinese economy is finished and the United States will see the Confederation breaking up!

      Reply
    • SamEire 19/01/13 #

      @Mark I think he is talking about the ‘busines cycle’- booms and bust which countries experience. the celtic tiger was was a ‘boom’ and therefore part of the business cycle.

      Reply
    • i agree with you Mike, i exactly join your comment
      pity there is no one else who think like you, all the comments are written by sheeples on too much fluoride
      sad lot

      Reply
    • censored 19/01/13 #

      The tinfoil hat brigade is out in force i see. Look to history to see what would most likely happen if the EU collapses, or if we leave.

      We shouldn’t blindly and slavishly accept EU hegemony, but nor should we shoot ourselves in the foot just because the current leaders are a bunch of eejits.

      Reply
    • @ censored “The tinfoil hat brigade” are you serious ? your acting exactly like out politicians !!

      Reply
  • The EU and especially the EMU are not good for Ireland.

    Reply
    • No I suppose the billions we got out of cohesion funds over forty years were no good to us at all.

      Reply
    • Bloody hell Jim, a few roads and bypasses built around Dublin, a few old cottages re-roofed?
      Just how long are you going to deny the fact of the billions upon billions we’ve paid back and not just through the imposition of bank debt either…do you remember that??- when the EU forced us to take on them debts..it’s still happening.
      What about the surrendering of our sugar manufacturing?..y’know where we stop producing sugar and buy it in instead?
      Financial stories aside, the EU is democratically deficient, it’s morphed from a trading agreement into a regime where the larger countries rule, only a masochist would choose to stay in a club like that.

      Reply
    • Julie 19/01/13 #

      How much of eu debt do we have yes 42% of all eu debt , 9000 for each and every one of us if that’s even an accurate figure , in comparison to 192 for all our other eu citizens, thanks Enda great negotiation skill we need someone like Pearse d over there who would not let them saddle us with 42% of all debt ! Our sovereignty is gone thanks to Enda after brave men not school boys died for it , our natural resources are being ripped from under our feet and our children’s and their children’s to come. Oh we had a few motor ways built etc aren’t we paying for them now. I will not have kids in this country , debt slaves for their whole lives thanks to Enda and his school teachers in leaving and like a lot of people i talk to we think we will never be able to return. Enough Is enough we have no voice in eu we are suffering it has to stop because it will get worse

      Reply
    • censored 19/01/13 #

      We don’t have 42% of EU debt, don’t be silly. Go and read the article again.

      We have benefited enormously from the EU. Not just a few roads and cottages, but a world class infrastructure including telco infrastructure that we were never able to afford to build for ourselves.

      Leave the EU, and do what? Go back to being England’s food producers?

      We need to grow up and realize that if we’re in a mess it’s our own fault, the people we put in leadership positions, our childish attitude towards the EU – the EU is not our sugar daddy, they can help us or cause more problems. It’s up to us to decide our destiny and the EU is just a tool.

      Reply
    • On the contrary censored, we don’t have control of our destiny, did we have a say in the bailout..the bank guarantee…the surrendering of sugar production…entry into the euro currency??
      The bailout was forced upon us, the bank guarantee was bullied and imposed on us and all to protect the banking cartels and a currency that was brought in here without mandate, debate or whether we wanted in or out.
      When we do have a say it’s gesture politics, the most recent referendum on the austerity treaty Noonan threatened a severe budget if we didn’t play like they wanted, Lisbon and Nice?…sure have a vote but if you say no we’ll be back until you say yes.
      Our politicians are accountable to no-one here and the EU technocrats are accountable to nobody whatsoever…it’s erroneous to even suggest we have self determination.

      Reply
  • No. Ireland should leave the EU, full stop. It was good while it lasted, no hard feelings, but we have to look at the future, not the past.

    Reply
  • I voted yes but not because we should “follow” anyone. It could be the only brave decision this government is ever going to make.

    Reply
  • No, Because were not British Lemmings!

    Reply
  • Leave EU no. Leave euro YES!!

    Reply
  • What are the benefits of being in this United States of Europe? It’s only an ideological fantasy dreamt up by German Civil Servants/ retired nazis to give them something else to do besides starting another War.
    nice idea ………

    Reply
    • here here, well said

      Reply
    • GODWIN’S LAW. Less than an hour after the article was written.
      It was inevitable I suppose that somebody would post the usual lazy, xenophobic reply.

      Reply
    • Actually Claire it was dreamt up by a French Politician who saw it as the only way to stop Germany going to war again – and it worked: Western Europe is in its longest continuous period of peace ever

      Reply
    • Julie 19/01/13 #

      Well said !

      Reply
    • Nice conjecture being offered here, the EU was set up to stop Germany going to war by giving them what they want and we all get awarded the nobel peace prize

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 19/01/13 #

      Goodwins law, while speaking about Germany. Ever try and suck a stick of chewing gum and not chew…..very difficult. Near impossible. Doesn’t make the comment less credible IMHO.

      Reply
    • The “United States of Europe” was actually dreamed up by Winston Churchill who advocated a European Union in a famous post-war speech in Zurich, Switzerland. His idea was a mutually dependent Europe would not go to war with itself. He has been proved right.

      So not exactly an idea by “retired Nazis” :)

      Reply
    • Agreed, I don’t think Godwin’s Law can be invoked in this case, the ECSC was the brainchild of French politician Robert Schuman, the logic being that if Germany’s economy was linked to France’s, they would never attack France again as it would be to their own ultimate detriment. I was happy with the European Union up until it went beyond the realms of economic cooperation, the lack of democracy and two fingers to smaller countries is disturbing. Ireland’s government will never vote to leave or follow the UK, to them Brussels is filled with Egyptian gods that they adore.

      Reply
    • Certainly agree,they tried taking Europe twice with devastating consequences that destroyed nations by force,and ruined economies.in some respects it’s happening again but there going down the political route to keep there economy at top off the class.sometimes you just have to stick up for yourself but we are minnows we need alliances to have any clout or say.

      Reply
    • censored 19/01/13 #

      The stuff about the Germans is just a load of nonsense. All nations look out for their own interests first, except for the Irish it seems.

      Reply
  • Ben Gunn 19/01/13 #

    Relax, the UK won’t be leaving any time soon. This whole issue has arisen because Tory backbenchers are running scared from the short term popularity of those nutjobs at UKIP. This has brought the Euro sceptics out of their boxes and they are in a sweat about losing their seats.

    It will all came down when UKIP screw up some more.

    Reply
  • The European community has its problems and one of the main ones has been the UK’ s inability to be part of and at the same time independent of the rest of Europe. I remember the time when travelling in Europe was a bitch, changing currencies all the time and loosing out each time being stuck in border controls and need customs documents all over….For those of you who don’t remember this I would say ‘THINK’, we have had no wars, a lot of cooperation and even given the situation which has been ‘ manufactured’ by big money bankers and others we still the collective economy the strongest in the world. The UK gives me a pain with its in/out debate pandering to anti European Fascists who are so sure of their racial importance and the overlord quality of England that they would destroy the rest of us and even the Scots and Welsh and sacrifice us on the alter of their Euro sceptisism.

    Reply
    • So Europe is doing no good because the UK is not part of it? Well wouldnt the sensible option be follow the UK then as as you say they are so important?
      So the UK think they are so important, that must mean that we are we do not think ourselves are?
      And we had no wars because Germany was beaten by the UK with America etc…….

      Reply
  • EU = Mordor

    Reply
  • Interesting debate , I wonder how the irish public would react to the even more savage cuts (multiples of the past few budgets) , if we were forced to stop spending the 20bn more a year than we generate if we were ‘on our own’ , just posing the question to the euro sceptics who seem kinda selective about the bad bits but ignore the realities that without our european borrowing at the moment – we would be in a much worse position.

    Reply
    • “our european borrowing”…do you mean bailout, the bailout the EU was complicit in forcing upon us?

      Imagine if you will, control of our own seas and who fishes them, the market for fish from the wild north Atlantic in land locked countries, making our own sugar again not buying it in like we were told to back a few years ago and the still open market to the EU…oh wait, Norway is poverty stricken as a result of staying outside the EU isn’t it?

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 19/01/13 #

      Being forced to pay into the ESM, billions at the drop of a hat, but sorry lads ya can’t get anything out!! We owe nothing, have paid our dues and more to the point, it was never our debt in the first place. Let German/French investors gamble in Italian banks and ask for the unsecured debt to be paid back after they lost it!! Whollop end of! Game over.

      Reply
    • @dermit , yeah there’s a banking mess alrite and of course innocent Irish that we are are not responsible for any of that , but separately the point I was making , is that to run the bleeding island costs around 15bn more than we get in every year , and without BORROWING that from Europe ( no one else will lend ) we would probably have to slash welfare , close hospitals schools etc etc and I was asking how people might respond , a rant about the banking crisis is all well and good , but our track record at trying the country on our own looks pretty crappy to be honest , the debate was about exiting Europe and its interesting debate , but your mistaken by mixing up the bank crisis with our irelands own public spending mess which is a massive problem , one that by the way would be infinitely more difficult to fix without borrowing from Europe.

      Reply
    • I take your point but why should we just concede that we’re tied to the EU because after they forced a bailout on us they are the only ones who will support us, it’s battered wife syndrome – I will abuse you, degrade you but you’ll never leave because I have it instilled in your mind that no-one else would have you, you’re here forever, the eternal victim, you can’t support yourself..you’re incapable, you’re nothing more than 4 million idiots compiled into one entity…but I love you, you’re special, here’s a tenner, go buy a hat and you can pay me back in monthly installments of 50′s.

      Reply
    • hmmm , well re Norway we dont have anything like their oil and resources to compare or be able stick two fingers up to the union , in relation to europe im not suggesting we do the battered wife role at all , im merely pointing out how easy it is to sit on the sidelines and moan about the bad things and call for to leave and do our own thing , but a cold hard look at the facts , our record at running the country and any likely impact of exiting hardly looks that appealing in any real measure , fine lets leave and tell them to f off , agree not to pay anything back and go alone , now go look at the reality instead of the bullshit , what state of play would ireland on its own we really be in ? That was the basis of my comment on the issue,

      Reply
    • Well we have plenty of resources but that’s for another debate on whether we start doing things here for the benefit of the nation or just give it away……

      RE: Norway again, I brought them up as a reaction to how no country can survive without the watchful eye of EU technocrats, I wouldn’t dare mention Iceland because we’re not them, they had balls. (Have you ever wondered how their turnaround is never mentioned these days?)

      The sad reality is that all our parties and political elite are inept cowards content to sit at the table and pretend they make a difference, we’re minnows in Europe, always were and always will be.
      We were bribed into secession and being bribed to remain their servile dog, I don’t buy into the straw man fallacy that we elect our TD’s so it’s our own fault we’re nothing but the whipping boys of the EU, it’s our own fault the country is in this mess because we voted for FF, FG or any of the other soundalike parties, it’s our fault we let them away with such ineptness sure and nothing will change unless we want it, and choosing not to question our quasi religious allegiance to a democratically void and one sided regime like the EU means we’re content to be the battered wife, by not questioning the legality and morality of the EU imposition of debt assures them that we’re only too happy to pay.

      Reply
    • Ok so we leve the eu. Now we are independent, great! Only prob is we are still being run by the same spineless morons who got us into the eu. We still have the same systems of government, personalities and advisors as before. So why in the bowels of Christ would leaving the eu make us any better off? The morons in govt will just do what they always have in the past and f#%k it all up.

      Reply
    • censored 19/01/13 #

      Exactly Mark, and their distraction tactics are working with everybody blaming the Germans/the EU/the ECB/mysterious forces instead of looking to our own house.

      Reply
    • Wow censored, you really have selected amnesia, would you like a recap on how or bank guarantee and subsequent bailout came about?
      Would you like to know more about the ECB acting beyond their remit in imposing such debt upon us and how the EU is playing us for fools by dragging a deal on a debt that was never ours in the first place?

      There’s more channels than RTE that deliver news you know…

      Reply
  • idiotic poll, with comments for the most part from complete lunatics.

    Reply
  • Stupid auto- correct, that should read:
    If they jumped off a bridge would you do that too?

    Reply
    • Lots of thumbs down here but this is by far the best comment amoungst all the gibberish.
      It would be jumping off a bridge. The UK may have he means and the knowledge to leave the EU but our politicians couldn’t find their way out of a paperbag. Leaving would be suicide – but statistics show that the Irish are increacingly using suicide as a way out. Such a shame!

      Reply
    • censored 19/01/13 #

      The UK might leave because their financial sector is so important to them (and to the Tory party, I might add) and they don’t want any regulation.

      Those are the folks who created this problem in the first place!

      Reply
  • So the people who want to follow the British can move there if they want to!

    Reply
  • We definitely have to leave the EU so we stop having things like cohesion funds being imposed on us – all the EU has done is wreck our environment forcing us to build roads we don’t need, destroying our native industries like shoemaking and car building, killing our traditional values and allowing women to work outside the home, not to mention making Ireland far to acce4ssible by foreign firm swho want to use Ireland as base to access the EU market. Far better that we leave the Union with the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, revert to using the common currency we used to have some controlover and keep reading newspapers published by the murdoch empire – not to mention hang onto Marks and Spencers, Topshop, Boots and keep following our favourite teams in the ENGLISH league…. Sasan abu

    Reply
  • I think Ireland should get in there first and be the first country to regain its sovereignty .

    Reply
  • We should at least wait until the motorway network is finished.

    Reply
  • 53-46, interesting and disappointing.

    Reply
  • Ridiculous …………. We are check-mated here. We cannot leave the E.U. We need their money. Do you really think those clowns in that chamber will even consider it. The Irish people were stupid enough to sign up to the Maastrict treaty so we can’t get up and leave. We are where we are and we gonna bend over and take it for another few years. This crap wasn’t on the table when times were good, even when we were governed by an ever bigger shower of clowns than we have now.

    Reply
  • For Britain to leave the EU surely they have to be in it in the first place don’t they?

    Reply
  • As my mother used to say if we ever did something stupid just because someone else was doing it : if by jump piped off a bridge would you do that too?

    Reply
  • Jay Finn 19/01/13 #

    Lennon had it right.
    “Imagine there’s no countries
    It isn’t hard to do”

    Reply
  • It would be a major factor considering their our biggest trading partner, but them leaving the EU, why would we need to follow?

    Reply
  • The amount of jobs that would be lost would be huge. Most of those MNCs are only here to take advantage of our low corporation tax, tax loopholes an that the fact it gives them an EU base. By leaving the EU we would only be putting more jobs at risk and actually creating new growth

    Reply
  • To put it bluntly any Irish person who doesnt want to be part of the EU is an idiot. I for one want to be part of europe and feel akin to these nations. Plus we are a small rock on the edge of the continent and we need friends. Why anyone would want to follow the UK like a sheep is beyond me. They are not the most important nation in the EU by any means.

    Reply

Add New Comment