TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Column: Am I worried about the budget? Of course I am.

Whatever tomorrow brings, it’s going to make a big difference to my little girl and I, writes single mother Nessa Toale.

Nessa Toale

MOST PEOPLE I know are worried about tomorrow’s budgetary announcement, especially families. I’m already living on next to nothing. Last year when the cuts came I cut my spending down to a minimum.

As a writer work can be erratic so at the moment I do rely on benefits, in particular the Lone Parent Allowance. I also rely on the children’s benefit of €140 per month. I don’t like being in this position, who would? I’m working hard to get off benefits my way. It will be a great day when I can walk into the Social Welfare office and tell them to stop my payment. However, until then, I do need it to live and this week will bring more adjustments to my life.

I am always on the look out for a suitable job but they are few and far between. Those with good prospects have such low entry level wages that I would be in a worse state than I am now. With childcare being so expensive, taxes and travel costs, some jobs just aren’t feasible for me. When Beth goes to school hopefully there will be other jobs that are more practical.

Budgeting

At the moment I spend €30 on groceries every week, my rent takes more than half my weekly social welfare allowance. There are also all the bills; electricity, gas, bins, phone, TV license, life insurance etc. At the end of the week I have €20 left over to put towards weddings, birthdays or Christmas. I would love to put this money away and let it build up for something nice for Beth but there is always something that it needs to be spent on. If Beth gets a cold and needs over-the-counter medicine that can be nearly €10 gone already, without all the rest. Yes, this week, whatever it brings is going to make a difference to me personally.

They are predicting a cut of €10 on the children’s allowance. For me this means being extra careful with my spending. Already, I only go out to a pub or club about three times a year. Thankfully, I gave up smoking four years ago. My one luxury has been my TV subscription for the many evenings I spend at home – as a single parent, there are quite a few. A few months ago I decided to cancel the subscription so I would have a little more cash every month, not much, but at least it was one less bill. They gave it to me for free for six months, for which I was very grateful, but when those six months are up it will be goodbye to good telly and hello soaps.

If the Lone Parent Allowance is also cut I will have to consider moving home. I don’t claim rent allowance. People think I’m mad not to claim it but I never wanted to be in a position of living completely off benefits and therefore decided not to claim it unless I really, badly needed it. Depending on how the Budget goes I may have to apply for it for now. So they will cut one benefit but I may have to claim another.

Forced to claim

If I don’t claim I will move to a smaller place. Moving home will be terrible. I have lived in my house for almost three years, it’s near my mother and Beth’s other grandparent’s. Beth took her first steps in the living room and I’ve spent so much time in the garden making it child friendly and pretty. I have been checking out smaller places in the lead up to the budget, little two bedroom houses with little or no garden. Not enough room for Beth’s swing set anyway. But what’s the alternative? I stay here and live a hand-to-mouth existence until an agent picks up my book or I get a regular slot in a paper. It would mean no treats for Beth, nights out, weddings, birthdays and next Christmas would be a totally different affair. I’m just glad I sorted this Christmas when I had some work.

After saying all that, I know I will survive. I don’t have debt. There are still changes I can make to ensure we can still afford little treats for Beth and me. But there are people out there that are at the bottom of the barrel, people on social welfare trying to pay rent and put food on the table, the working poor who struggle to make ends meet, spending hard earned cash on childminders, travel costs and mortgages. The changes to child benefit, social welfare payments, USC and all the rest will push many people over the poverty line. No one is safe. Let’s hope we can all pull together and help each other through these tough times.

Nessa Toale is a single mother and a writer. Her book is called, The Secret Beneath Bleeker Avenue. She also writes a blog called, Life, love and the pursuit of a crawling baby. More information can be found on her Facebook Page here.

Read next:

Comments (50 Comments)

  • I want to empathise with you. I really do. But in the first few lines you have pretty much identified your issue. “I am a writer and work is very sporadic” (or something along those lines). You want to right by your daughter and put money by for nice things as you said. But it just simply isn’t there… As your a writer. I lost my job in IT a few years ago now as the company closed down. I got a new job and was let go again 3 days before my second son was born. I wasnt having much luck but could see the way the things were going with the country. Most jobs i applied for where looking for certs etc. I only had experience. 11 years of it!! But i was being interviewed by non tech people so all they wanted was certs. I decided to do something about it and became a cisco certified engineer. Im being offered jobs every 2nd day now.

    I am also a musician. Work in this field can be as sporadic as a writer. But i know I cannot rely on getting a gig at the weekends to pay the bills or my mortgage. I chose to find something else to support my family.

    My partner has recently finished up work. She left off her own accord as she was in retail. We haven’t had a weekend off as a family in over 6 years. She will not be going back to that work. She has taken my advice and has chosen a path of IT. She is about to start studying to become an Oracle developer because there is work there and good money also.

    Why dont you do the same. You see that there is no money in writing. Why not learn a new skill and use writing as a hobby for a little more disposable cash rather than your bill/mortgage cash. This might sound harsh but the days of you or I living the dream of making a fortune from our lifelong passions went out the window when we had kids. Its not about us anymore really… Well until they turn 18 :)

    Good luck in the future and I sincerely hope it gets easier for you and Beth.

    Reply
    • Sue Sue 04/12/12 #

      So is the Dad maintaining the Beth at all? I also am a single mum, worked in a job that I had never ever though of when I was at University, at this stage it pays the mortgage and bills..My children’s dad does support them hence never had to rely on welfare as have his maintenance and my wages… Personal Responsibly seems to be missing here…

      Reply
    • Well said. You have to adapt, not sit around feeling sorry for yourself.

      Reply
    • Here are eight principles to guide you in the coming showdown over the deficit:

      ONE: HOLD YOUR GROUND. The wealthy have to pay their fair share of taxes. That’s what the next election will be all about. It’s only fair they pay more. They’re taking home record share of national income and wealth, and have lowest effective tax rate in living memory.

      TWO: NO DEAL IS BETTER THAN A BAD DEAL. You’re in a strong bargaining position. No party should sell themselves the way Labor did in 2011. Which isn’t such a bad thing.

      THREE: MAKE SINN FEIN VOTE ON EXTENDING THE TAX CUTS JUST FOR THE MIDDLE CLASS. After all the FF tax breaks expire, have SF vote on an extending the tax cut just for the middle-class. FG have refused and tried to hold those tax cuts hostage to tax cuts for the wealthy, it will show whose side FG are on. They’ll pay the price in 2016.

      FOUR: DEMAND HIGHER TAX RATES ON WEALTHY, NOT JUST LIMITS ON DEDUCTIONS. Don’t fall for Fianna Fail offers to limit some tax deductions on the wealthy. Demand we go back to higher tax rates on the wealthy and eliminate their unfair tax loopholes, so they truly start paying their fair share.

      FIVE: DON’T CUT SAFETY NETS. Don’t sacrifice Social Security, or programs for the poor. Irish depend on these safety nets and can’t afford any benefit cuts.

      SIX: DON’T CUT INVESTMENTS IN OUR FUTURE PRODUCTIVITY. Education, basic R&D, and infrastructure aren’t spending; they’re investments in our future prosperity. If the return on these investments is greater than the cost, they ought to be made, period.

      SEVEN: CUT SPENDING ON CORPORATE WELFARE. You want to cut, cut spending on the promissory note — which now exceeds 32 per cent of GDP. And cut corporate welfare — support to group companies, oil and gas, Big Pharma, big insurance and Banks.

      EIGHT: PUT JOBS BEFORE DEFICIT REDUCTION. Finally, Don’t cut the budget deficit as long as unemployment remains high. Otherwise you’ll cause the economy to contract, making the deficit even larger in proportion. That’s the austerity trap Europe has fallen into. We need to create Irish prosperity, not European austerity.

      Remember: Jobs come first. Refreshed copy.

      Reply
  • Good luck with finding a job in 2013

    Reply
  • Am I worried? .. You better believe it, I’m going to have a minutes silence before Noonan turns into the grim reaper and starts his speech!

    Reply
    • He doesn’t have to “turn into” the grim reaper! He’s already beyond that!

      In fact, for someone who’s so well paid for failing on each and every level, he always manages to show up looking like he’s a St. Vincent de Paul success story – having spent last night in a door way but now wearing a suit!!

      The hairs growing out of his nose & ears along with the shine to his suit are all a give away. It’s just a shame that he doesn’t manage to relate to the down and outs in our society that he and his sham government helped create and continue to fester.

      #Budget2013 is yet another example of why we should never again entrust our destiny to Fine Gael, Fianna Failure or Labour.

      The time is now people and the time is for change, real change. Vótáil Sinn Féin No.1 and help save what is left to save. Ireland can and will be a great nation but only if people wake up, react and vote accordingly.

      Reply
  • I would be more worried about the budget in April. That will be the budget from hell.

    Enda and Co think they are fooling us by not hitting income tax and welfare in this budget.

    Calm before the storm.

    Reply
    • General strike anyone???

      Reply
    • Bruce 05/12/12 #

      Sheepish Enda and Eamon will follow BERLIN’S way.

      Easy targets will be hit. No effort will be made to stop unvouched expenses.

      Reply
    • Why do people keep saying “Berlins Way”?? The Troika tell us we have to pay back the loans we got..understandable no? But they don’t tell us where we make the cuts that’s up to our own government. You can’t blame others for the mess our own government have got us in. Why don’t they hit the top brass for the money or the low Corporate rates we have? Blaming others is a cheap way to say we’re not accountable for our S**t government.

      Reply
  • I have no money

    Reply
  • Good luck to you

    Reply
    • Here are eight principles to guide you in the coming showdown over the deficit:

      ONE: HOLD YOUR GROUND. The wealthy have to pay their fair share of taxes. That’s what the next election will be all about. It’s only fair they pay more. They’re taking home record share of national income and wealth, and have lowest effective tax rate in living memory.

      TWO: NO DEAL IS BETTER THAN A BAD DEAL. You’re in a strong bargaining position. No party should sell themselves the way Labor did in 2011. Which isn’t such a bad thing.

      THREE: MAKE SINN FEIN VOTE ON EXTENDING THE TAX CUTS JUST FOR THE MIDDLE CLASS. After all the FF tax breaks expire, have SF vote on an extending the tax cut just for the middle-class. FG have refused and tried to hold those tax cuts hostage to tax cuts for the wealthy, it will show whose side FG are on. They’ll pay the price in 2016.

      FOUR: DEMAND HIGHER TAX RATES ON WEALTHY, NOT JUST LIMITS ON DEDUCTIONS. Don’t fall for Fianna Fail offers to limit some tax deductions on the wealthy. Demand we go back to higher tax rates on the wealthy and eliminate their unfair tax loopholes, so they truly start paying their fair share.

      FIVE: DON’T CUT SAFETY NETS. Don’t sacrifice Social Security, or programs for the poor. Irish depend on these safety nets and can’t afford any benefit cuts.

      SIX: DON’T CUT INVESTMENTS IN OUR FUTURE PRODUCTIVITY. Education, basic R&D, and infrastructure aren’t spending; they’re investments in our future prosperity. If the return on these investments is greater than the cost, they ought to be made, period.

      SEVEN: CUT SPENDING ON CORPORATE WELFARE. You want to cut, cut spending on the promissory note — which now exceeds 32 per cent of GDP. And cut corporate welfare — support to group companies, oil and gas, Big Pharma, big insurance and Banks.

      EIGHT: PUT JOBS BEFORE DEFICIT REDUCTION. Finally, Don’t cut the budget deficit as long as unemployment remains high. Otherwise you’ll cause the economy to contract, making the deficit even larger in proportion. That’s the austerity trap Europe has fallen into. We need to create Irish prosperity, not European austerity.

      Remember: Jobs come first. Refreshed copy.

      Reply
    • Timpson
      Great piece…..if you were writing it for a Secondary School classroom!

      Reply
    • Good points on sustainability but may I make a recommendation on point six education must not be cut agreed but the wages of those who run third level colleges must be cut so the problem is they will take from one to feed the other for example the head of ul is on €200k a year and is struggling how many students would that support for the college year and thus invest in our future, if we invest now we will gain the rewards at the end of the tunnel

      Reply
  • I’d love a general strike , but I’m self employed and can’t afford too :)

    Reply
  • All talk no action hopefully this budget will send people to the streets in mass.

    Reply
  • I will never ever pay a tax on my home. Never.. I paid stamp duty and that’s all they will get from me. If they offer free bin or healthcare or children education ill listen otherwise they can f-ck right off. Say no people to property tax, it’s you’re home they do not own you. Take to the streets. We get nothing in this country and already pay massive taxes, other countries gave property tax but they get something in return. We get NOTHING!

    Reply
    • Truer words were never said !! Thats exactly how it is … Taxed to the hilt and nothing back, and we have our intelligence insulted day in day out that we are actually a low tax economy.. Jesus wept. There is no comparison between what Irish families pay and the benefits received . PAYE workers are being tapped up for everything . I didnt have anyone knocking on my door from the banks to share their huge profits in the good times , but now we are expected to stump up for their appalling behavour . And that crap we hear about we “all partied” ??? What an insult . Ordinary folks never partied in Ireland …. Just struggled

      Reply
  • If we had subsidised childcare then we wouldn’t have the issue where benefits are greater than take home pay of an entry level job.
    Give women back our independence. Why would any mother let her child suffer by choosing to work for less money than the government will give her to stay at home?
    It’s a no brainer really.

    Reply
  • I just wanted to come on to say that Beth’s dad does contribute.

    Stephen Long, thanks for that and I will be checking out Oracle development.

    This article is just a snapshot of how my life is now and not what I expect it to be long term. The budget will mean changes for me but, as I said, they are not major changes. There are a lot more people that today will mean major changes in their personal life.

    After I finished college I took a job knocking on doors selling tv subscriptions so I don’t care what job I get. I’m not in this situation because I’ve turned my nose up at jobs unreasonably.

    Reply
    • @ nessa, look, they will savage you here no matter what you say gurl ! …think is that people are in pain, a lot of pain and they see others just swanning through having caused all this mess and then getting rewarded for it by golden handshakes and pensions etc whilst they get slammed with the taxes and levies that pay for it all .. they then take it out on everyone they consider is not suffering as much as they are .. ireland is a tough place to be the past 5 years and its getting tougher .. and we all know it …people are genuinely scare of 2013 … look, best of luck with everything, lovely photo of you both, God bless and dont mind the begrudgers, they are alive and well as usual, nowt we can do about that …..just remember that there are a lot of nice people about as well, they just dont shout AS LOUD as the others :) !!

      Reply
    • Best of luck Nessa! Hope it all works out and have a happy christmas :)

      Reply
  • No offence, but I don’t buy your argument.

    I absolutely believe that there are times when it would be more economical not to work than work if the wages are poor but you have to start somewhere. There are few jobs where they open the door & hand you €30k just for answering the bell. You do the entry level at €22k & you struggle through that but because you’re capable & good you move along & upwards to the next level in your career before eventually the money you’re paying in tax barely matches what you’d get in welfare. Just have to put up with being at the bottom for a while…..we can’t sustain this welfare state.

    Sidenote, I’m with everyone above. Your little girls daddy owes you €50 a week.

    Reply
  • Unfortunately there are still too many people in this country that aren’t worried. Not one bit. That includes those dishing out the pain in government.I dream of the day when justice will be served on those lapdogs and the Euro paymasters they lick the backside of. That day is getting nearer. Enough is enough

    Reply
  • And the elephant in the room is the father of your child ….

    I’m not happy paying for recreational sex for other people. This is the inevitable consequence of ‘modern lifestyles’

    If you are in touch with his parents, why is he not contributing ??

    Reply
    • Funny most dad after they separate from the mum stopped paying towards kids maintenance. It’s pointless exercise taking them to court if they earn little money.

      Reply
    • This is a serious issue – the parents are both equally responsible for their offspring. It’s time that this is enforced. I fully empathise with this lady but feel there are issues that she has avoided – for whatever reason.

      Reply
    • Sue Sue 05/12/12 #

      I had to take my ex husband to court for maintenance. It.was a horrible long drawn out process and lasted for just over 2 years, had to represent myself in the end as could not afford legal fees and was just over the limit for.legal aid. It worked out ok, but still waiting on arrears due! Personally I think men get off way too easy as women rely on the welfare state rather then go after the dads in court.

      Reply
  • Sorry. but im stopped reading after you say some entry level job wages are not worth it so you take benefits instead. There in lies the problem. Cut the benefits and uncentivse work

    Reply
    • Well, often in a situation like that, the child care costs, travel costs of getting to work etc, you can actually be worse off believe it or not!

      Reply
    • Ill feel peoples pain. i really do, but you should be better off working than on benfits.. not the other way round

      Reply
    • elbit i would urge you to write down on paper the figures of a single parent on social welfare and then a single parent working minimum wage paying taxes, childcare, travel etc and you will see right there in front of you how it isn’t possible for some people to take such jobs. its a shane because most want to work and not sit at home all day.
      the government are just making it further impossible for single parents to take jobs

      Reply
    • magsR 04/12/12 #

      Must say I completely agree with you. I lost interest too when i read that.It’s shocking that people consider themselves better off on benefits and is something that badly needs to change!!

      Reply
    • It would make a lot of sense to me to subsidise childcare more heavily. It’s something which would also make a real difference to working families struggling to make ends meet and make it easier to work if childcare doesn’t make it far less rewarding.

      Reply
    • Sarah
      What you have just stated is the need for benefits to be severely reduced. Is that what you meant?.

      Reply
    • where did i state that Mark? the point I am trying to make is that when you actually look at the facts and figures some single parents can’t afford minimum wage jobs because of childcare travel and other costs being too high meaning you would come out with less money than when you were not working so it does not make financial sense to take such jobs unfortunately. lowering benefits will not solve this so no i was defiantly not trying to state that at all. I am going on personal experience.

      Reply
    • Maybe employers need to pay more. Why has no one mentioned that angle?

      Reply
    • cormac i think employers already pay too much and that’s why we are in this mess in the first place. our minimum wage was always too high and that’s why cost of living is so high. don’t see what they can do about it now tho. if they raise minimum wage then employers will have to charge more for goods and services and many small businesses will have to close their doors. another idea would be subsidizing things such as childcare instead of giving people actual money into their hands and food stamps plus means testing children’s allowance would save the state money. I do believe many on social welfare spend the money on things such as tobacco and alcohol and giving vouchers etc will eliminate this and hopefully save money.

      Reply
    • Sarah you have an interesting angle, “Employers already pay too much”. The minimum wage is not too high and does not really contribute to the high costs of goods and services in this country. There seems to be a new cafe or restaurant opening in Dublin weekly, the too high minimum wage doesn’t seem to be putting off these small business owners. The high cost of goods & services in this country are a result of many other factors, high rent being one. Rent has dropped in Dublin for new leases on commercial premises and when these new eateries open the prices are generally lower than during our tiger years, but yet the Minimum wage remains the same.

      Reply
  • “Moving home will be terrible”. Imagine not being able to have a swing set?!

    My God.

    Reply
  • They better not touch commercial tax, the high rate of old car tax, petrol , diesel , smokes or drink.

    How do they expect me to run 2 luxury cars, smoke 20 a day and go get pissed multiple nights of the week , if they keep raising the price without taking money off those on the dole.

    Reply
  • Makes no sense….. Ha Ha, I gave suggestions of not wasting money ! I have work & lived in many places around the world, its not that bad here. I must say Irish peope do complain about so much, just remember we live in a very rich country relatively speaking. Ireland is not that expenove if you know how to shop and not so concerned in keeping up with the Jones. Just get on with things and stop buying crap, that being junk food. On top of that 33% of all food we buy is throwing into the bin ! Make sense ?????

    Reply
    • feel for you, i to am divorced from american, he does not pay child support, and wont, and they cant get him either,, i bought a house 10 years ago and put every penny into it,, i lost my job, and have my water off today as my pipes broke, as due to no heat, BUT i went to bank just back and cancelled payments on my mortgage, mort insurance and home insurance, i cant afford to own a home with all this stuff coming in taxes and charges, and no jobs coming to kerry,,,tomorrow i will buy coal and meat, and face reality i will be homeless with my daughter, yes we are worried, but we cant carry on this way anymore, phone cut off,, and dont say i am on internet, its was a gift to my daughter from my mom who passed in november, they have made things difficult to stay above board, have lied to get seats, enda, no homeowners tax,, gilmore no cuts on kids allowance, and they sit their so smug, there is many people hungry in their own homes and no one knows, st vincent de paul used to come, but with debt collectors calling i cant answer my door so we have to do without there also,,, my daughter begs me to call them so we can have more than soup and spuds, but we will now,, i am relieved in one way and disgusted with myself i lost my home,, which i thought would be my pension,, sometime,, i have 12 euro for food after all is paid, and thats even behind with my mortgage of 400 euro,, its been a real tough year, have always walked from one job into another trying to do better for myself, but i walk the streets handing in cvs, been to most businessses over 20 times, they even know me now,, thats sad,, and meet me at door and tell me they are laying off people ,, doors i went to are locked up, most businesses are closing in tralee, its sad state really, 125 shut on our main st, just want my daughter to finish her leaving this year, my son in usa, and pray she will get there, this is life in ireland, and know i am not alone

      Reply
  • jeez imagine being forced to watch soaps and having no treats for your kids?

    Reply
  • People give out about the problem out there, the budget & our gov taking money off us, we are under taxed and paid too much as it is! fact look at any like for like for like stats comparing us with other countries in Europe. How about people cut back on the shit they don’t really need. Holidays (stay at home & enjoy what your local area can offer, 8 million tourists come to Eire each year, I wonder why!) junk food (cut back on crisps & mince pies ( there’s a reason why 60% of Irish people are overweight, shop at the discounters, Aldi & Lidl, pubs (drink at home, I rather be infront of the fire than most pubs with good friends), walk or cycle to work, we don’t all live that far! stop spending so much on xmas its really is a big waste of money! Make things like food with actual ingridients & stop always buying stuff that you can’t afford, don’t need & probably won’t use, give up your gym membership & run alongthe road, eat at home & not that overpriced muck like ready meals, We have it so easy in this country etc etc. Really :-)

    Reply
    • You might be under taxed but a lot of us are not and I’d advise you to take your own advice and look at the like for like stats comparing us with other countries in Europe. While your doing that keep in mind Ireland is one of the more expensive places to live. The rest of your comments make no sense cut back on the junk food bit drink at home?????????

      Reply
  • I’m not worried at all :)

    Reply

Add New Comment