TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

Column: Everyone can make a positive contribution to the economy by shopping locally

Significant opportunity exists within the indigenous retail sector to generate local spend that would have a powerful impact on our local communities and the economy as a whole, writes Seán Kelly MEP.

Seán Kelly MEP

THE CALL TO ‘shop local’ is a well-worn mantra that has been preached extensively over the past number of years. As consumers we have been repeatedly told that we should, wherever possible, spend locally. Shopping local and buying Irish ensures the quality of our food and keeps our hard-earned euro within the country and our communities.

We know that a strong sense of goodwill exists towards the concept of ‘buying Irish’. Research released by Bord Bia in 2011 found that 85 per cent of shoppers were loyal, or conditionally loyal, towards Irish brands.

These statistics indicate that a significant opportunity exists within the indigenous retail sector to generate local spend that would have a powerful impact on our local communities and the economy as a whole. Buying just two more Irish-produced products on each shopping trip equates to a €300 million opportunity for the Irish economy according to Love Irish Food. Similarly, Guaranteed Irish tells us that a typical Irish household spends on average €16 a week on Guaranteed Irish products. By spending €4 more per week on Irish products or services shoppers have the power to create 6,000 jobs.

The horsemeat scandal and food traceability

The recent horsemeat controversy has underlined the need for greater understanding of where our food comes from. The issue has shown the effectiveness of Ireland’s food traceability standards and system in that a European wide issue was only brought to light by the Food Safety Authority of Ireland. By considering these issues, we can ensure the quality of our food and that our hard earned euro remain within the country to the benefit of the national economy.

The ripple effect of shopping locally should also not be underestimated. The Business Alliance for Local Living Economies reveals that for every €1 spent at a local business, 45 cent is reinvested locally. In contrast, for every €1 spent at a corporate chain, just 15 cent is put back into the local economy. Where does the differential go – overseas, to be reinvested into the national economy of the corporate grocery chain, rather than here in Ireland where it is needed?

It poses the question; while it is legal to export profits, is it morally acceptable? This debate has already been played out in the UK around taxation and perhaps Ireland would benefit from a similar type of debate. The retail sector is a case in point. What level of profit is being exported by the overseas owned grocery chains and why, in the age of transparency, is there very limited transparency in this sector? The Musgrave Group – which is owned and headquartered in Ireland and operates the SuperValu, Centra and Superquinn brands – publishes its profits. If we are to truly understand the impact of buying Irish we should fully understand what the international retailers do with our money, specifically whether it is reinvested in Ireland or shipped overseas to corporate HQ.

The knock-on impact of our spending

We must look for value for our spend, but also give consideration to the knock on impact of that spend. The influential Blueprint for Ireland’s Recovery report puts small to medium size enterprises (SMEs) at the frontline of economic recovery. The good news is that by being discerning with our money each of us can play a vitally important part in supporting SMEs and by extension, help to kick-start our national economy. Every euro that we spend on an indigenous product or service has a much more widespread impact than simply benefiting the immediate seller. That spend is distributed among the local producer, the delivery service provider, the shop worker, the shop cleaner and a host of other local businesses and services working together in their community. As the Business Alliance for Local Living Economies study reveals, local businesses invest three times more back into the local economy compared to corporate chains.

Quite simply when we buy Irish, our euro stays local and in Ireland – and when we buy imported brands or shop in international outlets a significant portion of our euro is immediately shipped overseas. When we shop locally in family owned firms we are making a positive contribution to our community and by extension to the nation as a whole. When spent in our communities our hard earned euro support and create new, local jobs and enable indigenous Irish businesses to in turn support our communities, charities and sports clubs. In this way each of us can add significantly to where we live and work, and can help to create vibrant, thriving villages, towns and cities.

The economic situation that we find ourselves in can often seem overwhelming, involving astronomical sums. However, every problem or challenge is overcome in small steps. Each of us can make a positive difference and a strong contribution to our recovery by simply practicing savvy shopping. By doing so, our hard-to-come-by euro will remain here at home protecting and generating Irish jobs and enriching our communities, rather than being shipped overseas for the benefit of other countries.

Seán Kelly is the Fine Gael MEP for Ireland South. He tweets at @SeanKellyMEP.

Read next:

Comments (82 Comments)

  • DMcE 22/03/13 #

    I would shop local but our local supermarket charges for parking by the hour…so you have to pay for the privilege of spending money there. And then they cry about people not shopping locally!

    Reply
    • Yeah it’s the same where I live, in Bray. Would like to do my shopping in Super Quinn and the surrounding shops but to pay for parking while doing it just isn’t on.

      Reply
    • I have a friend who shops there, if you bring your receipt from the parking in to Superquinn they will refund you the money for parking on your grocery bill.

      Reply
    • Not sure shopping in Superquinn counts as shopping locally, though I do shop in the Bray store and particularly like the friendliness of the staff – however the quality is not there at all in my opinion and they are now owned by the giant Musgraves, so truly a multi-national.

      I would love to see all our supermarkets having more quality Irish produce (eg the organic fruit and vegetables is often English even when the produce would be in season in Ireland). We need to have quality Irish products available and supermarkets committed to stocking truly local produce (eg quality produce from Wicklow in the Bray supermarkets).

      We also need to up the quality of our Irish produce. I don’t eat meat but I reluctantly buy it for my son, and I am sorry but the ‘quality of our meat’ mantra is rubbish to me – where is the good quality organic meat, rather than the typical fare of beef that, although they do get some grass, they also get fed foods you don’t want to think about that may contain chemicals and GMOs, and the cattle are routinely dosed with anti-biotics and hormones that go into the product. I cannot buy him Irish pork that does not involve supporting beautiful animals like pigs being kept locked up indoors in horrible conditions for their whole lives :-( I do not call that quality.

      Perhaps we should make more of an effort to support our local markets and only buy quality produce – that way we will get more good local quality food being made available.

      Reply
    • May I make one small correction there Michelle? There’s no hormones in our beef. They use recombinant bovine growth hormone (rBGH) in the US, it makes the cow grow bigger and produce more milk. However, this hormone is very similar to oestrogen and as such the EU have a ban on it. We pay a fine to Codex Alimentarius each year for banning it, because this means US bovine and dairy produce is not permitted for sale here.

      The antibiotics and GM feed are still a problem, but thankfully the hormones are not.

      Reply
    • Thank you ShantiOm for that correction – I am glad to hear it! I still think Ireland is thought of as a green and pleasant land with a natural farming sector and this is far from the truth. It’s about good food and quality as well as morals. (For example, if organic vegetables have been attacked by pests, they produce in response the kind of chemicals that when humans eat the plant will do stuff like attack cancer cells – not so with plants sprayed with insecticides – see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytoalexin for description of how plants react to their environment and change their chemistry.)
      It’s hard to get organic Irish produce (supermarkets often say that there is not enough supply and they can’t get it) and this seems crazy to me. I am particularly sad about the pigs :-( I can usually only find free-range bacon from The Netherlands in supermarkets…
      http://www.ciwf.ie/farminfo/farmfacts_pigs.html

      Reply
    • And there is this too: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salvestrols – shows that nature really does know best in ways we are only beginning to discover – think also about the phytonutrients that are in organic foods that are only recently being hailed for their effect on supporting the immune system and countering disease…
      Organic really is quality where health is concerned and I would love to see more Irish local organic produce available for the people that want to buy it!

      Reply
    • Agreed, and the supermarkets seem to have this inexplicable need to shrink wrap their organic foods in plastic..
      There’s nothing organic about plastic..

      Reply
  • So the plan for economic recovery is to persuade irish people to forswear foreign produce. Why did we join a common market again?

    Reply
  • I have always tried to shop local. However, since pension levies USC etc., I have lost one third of my pay so now its is pay my mortgage & shop cheaply. Typical politician talking out of his rear end, come & live in reality with the people of Ireland then tell us how & where to shop.

    Reply
    • Hear, hear.

      Particularly when you can often buy online, and often from the UK, at cheaper prices even after shipment costs.

      These are the same politicians who favour eager, cheap immigrant workers over the native population.

      Be off with you.

      Reply
    • While most of us shop cheaply, there are those who have a bit more disposable income. It makes sense to encourage those people to spend their money locally if they have it.

      Even for those that shop cheaply, when it comes down to similarly priced goods of similar quality, no harm in making its locality a third deciding factor in our purchases. Maybe that’s a rare occurrence but if everyone had that level of consciousness about the positives for the economy, we might create a few jobs along the line.

      Reply
    • My pocket dictates where I shop not my conscious. If your party ran this country with there conscious we might have a chance of getting ourselves out if this mess

      Reply
    • I shop mostly in lidl.. if I didn’t we wouldn’t be able to have decent meals on my income.

      Reply
  • Dunno about you Seanie boy but I am restricted to buying wherever is cheapest.

    Reply
  • I don’t feel guilty Sean because i’ll do whatever it takes to get the money together for your parties property tax and water charges…..

    Reply
  • dave184 22/03/13 #

    Yes we should buy local produce and services … the only issue is that people are watching every cent they have … jobs can be kept and created with the money spent …. if we don’t have the money we can’t spend it !!! ..stop taxing our way out of this mess and get people spending ….

    Reply
  • “By spending €4 more per week on Irish products or services shoppers have the power to create 6,000 jobs.”

    So if I go to the Porterhouse and have one pint of Plain Porter every week I create 6000 jobs?

    I’ll have two then.

    Reply
  • This green jersey nonsense coming from a politician that wait for it!!! Earns €250,000 every year of his term. Thats 1 million euro for his term.. And he preaches to a nation thats crippled through austerity enforced by all the major political parties..I can still hear the echoes of another MEP thieving tramp telling the nation that
    “the reason I get paid so much is that I have to keep 3 houses going ” it’s very difficult and we should try it sometime….
    These clowns in government are no better than what they replaced…… This country needs new voices and leaders…
    Look to Direct Democracy Ireland…. Thers a better way

    Reply
  • Wake up ! Unfortunately your shower have stolen all our disposable income and handed it over to the big bankers…who certainly do not shop local !

    Reply
  • Buy what you can afford no matter where the shop is if you have to shop in 3 different shops then do it to save money

    Reply
    • I agree! I buy most everything I can from a butchers and grocers close to where I work. I do find them slightly more expensive than the supermarkets but the quality is just different class. I don’t mind spending the little bit extra but I don’t have a house, kids or any other massive outgoings so I’m in a position to spend a little extra for better quality goods. However the notion of a politician trying to make someone feel guilty or obliged to shop in a more expensive location is a bit reminiscent of “let them eat cake”. When you’re living so far above the standards of the population and completely out of touch it’s simply impossible for them to understand the issues that people are suffering through.

      Reply
    • @ Ted. You are deluding yourself if you think any one in agriculture would supply a small time retailer with their best meat and veg. Here is the order:

      The best-is exported
      Next best-sold to biggest local buyers
      The dregs-small retailers

      This is why the best irish beef is to be found abroad. The stuff sold in Ireland Larry Goodman would turn his nose up at.

      Reply
    • Simon, deluded I may be but I can honestly tell you that there is a significant taste difference between what is purchased from Tesco/Aldi/Lidl et. al or from a local butchers or grocers. A lot of people may not notice the difference but I do. Also seeing as you know so much more about these supply chains are you certain that the big chains are getting their merchandise from the same suppliers because I would very much doubt it.

      Reply
  • If the UK adapted the same policy of buying locally grown food, the Irish food industry would collapse.
    More parish pump dribble!

    Reply
  • Seriously. Present some personal incentive or f…k off. We are told to seek value by shopping around in order to drive prices down, then told that our decisions should be made based on the origin of the goods. As long as government is intent on reducing my income and expendable cash I will concentrate on reducing my overheads. Other concerns be damned.

    Reply
  • Liam 22/03/13 #

    Shop local? Does he realise how expensive it is to do that? This doesn’t just apply to supermarkets, it is the case everywhere in Ireland, I seen in Xtravision the other day that two Xbox games would set me back €110 yet to buy them on amazon (new, not used) and get them posted over to Ireland would only cost €48. This country is such a rip-off.

    Reply
  • I find most Irish produced food is expensive. It’s amazing the products can get shipped here and still end up cheaper compared to Irish products.

    Reply
  • So Sean understands junior cert economics, great, now if he would advise his buddies in Europe that the reason we shop in Aldi is cause their austerity package has eroded disposable incomes we might move forward. Overpaid paperweight.

    Reply
  • Never knew Aldi or Lidl flys in its staff from abroad every morning before it opens. Wow must avoid these foreign companies in future and shop in places where they hire local staff that contribute locally to society. What was i thinking Seanie.

    Reply
  • We shop in Aldi and Tesco. Can’t afford Dunnes nor Superquinn Once every 3 months we make a trip up to Asda for cleaning products/nappies It’s so much cheaper.
    Fortunately we found a brilliant butcher and for €20 we get plenty meat to get our family going for a whole week.

    Reply
  • bollox.not when the council is going to china for seat backs and granite for brays paths..CHINA!!!

    Reply
  • With rip off prices on certain consumer products I’ll continue to buy them cheaper online thanks. They preach and inflict market neoliberalism on me and some times I happily participate ;)

    Reply
  • Not if it costs 3 times the price.

    Reply
    • Unfortunately your right. But saying that I do buy irish when I can for right price id love to be able to with each shopping trip but its tight for is all have to spend what we can afford.

      Mind you with things like pork and beef I find irish is always amazingly good quality. Compare irish pork to French for example and does not come close irish wins hands down.

      Reply
    • If I can buy products in Ireland at a competitive price I will buy here, the problem is competitive prices in Ireland are far and so very few and people have to be very selective what they buy, especially since the morons in power have taxed the Irish people into oblivion!

      Reply
  • Give us some sort of incentive to shop locally e.g. Free parking in towns and special offers

    Reply
    • ”Give us some sort of incentive to shop locally e.g”
      incentives are mainly Price , quality and service – all of which are usually lacking if one buys local /Irish . why are UK prices so much cheaper – and anyway these thug politicins rob our money – then preach to us . F## off with your hypocrisy .

      Reply
  • Three things to guide your shop, Price! Price! and Price! Oh and by the way, did I mention price.

    Reply
  • And another thing.

    Musgrave Group might be based in Ireland with published accounts. But it was also the group that orchestrated the shafting of Irish suppliers when Superquinn went into administration. It was eventually shamed into setting up a fund so that they could get 65-70% of what they were owed.

    If that’s supporting Ireland, I think I’ll take my chances with the Germans, who do at least pay Irish farmers.

    Reply
  • Why should I support local business when my wages are cut by the government every couple of years as a reward for working harder. If we are in this together then the small business should suffer the consequences of slagging off lazy public servants since the economy tanked. The consequences are a lot of workers with barely enough to live on and a massive chip on both shoulders when it comes to supporting the private sector. What ever money I have I try and spend in other countries. You can shove your green jersey, your big ask and all the rest of the bull crap used to impoverish me and my fellow workers over the last 5 years

    Reply
    • Well said!!

      Reply
    • Is that not just a bit of cutting off your nose to spite your face?
      I understand the cuts are devistating, but wherever you pay tax also contributes the recovery of that country, and you seem to not want to support the private sector, and in doing so your happy not to support tax income (through VAT paid on each item, through the job it supports in your local shop who pays taxes). If everyone (or even just every CS/PS) thought like you, we’d be a lot worse off again.
      Truely understand your position of frustration, but don’t understand why you would be active in compounding the problem.

      Reply
  • deirdre 22/03/13 #

    He is not living in the real world. Ya we would all love to shop local. If all the small shops hadnt closed down due to the recession……….

    Reply
  • Séan, did the European Commission not already bring a MEQR case against Ireland for promoting a “buy Irish” campaign? Since you are a member of the ruling party and a MEP I think you might be on this ice with your outlook.

    Reply
    • am sure Mr. Kelly probably does not know r care that most people are trying to keep paying as they go. so thanks Mr Kelly well said. now WHAT ARE WE PAYING U FOR THIS KIND NOF CRAP.

      Reply
  • random 22/03/13 #

    Give your money to the Irish bosses before the foreign bankers help themselves from your bank account.

    Reply
  • Dear Séan. As an MEP on circa 150k+ with expenses, you would do well to understand that what you are promoting is for most people a luxury. Most people would love to shop in farmers markets and buy locally produced produce. The issue is most of it is Incredibly more expensive than Lidl or Aldi which to be fair source almost all fresh produce in Ireland.

    Reply
  • It’s insulting and enraging. It’s OUR fault because we’re not shopping enough. Complete abdication of his responsibility for his contribution to the austerity that’s crippled the economy while enriching the super wealthy. Thanks, pal. We’ll be thinking of your eloquent out-of-touch prose.

    I am reminded of US President Gerald Ford’s solution to inflation at 18%: Pass out “Whip Inflation Now” buttons to the population and call for wage concessions.

    Reply
  • Good old ripoff ireland is still here i will stick to aldi save 50euro a week some weeks small supermarkets and shops only have themselves to blame

    Reply
  • Shop where its cheapest! Every little helps

    Reply
  • If have to shop in Aldi if I don’t I won’t be able to pay the local property tax so I can’t do everything them politicians want me to do

    Reply
  • Mother’s Day card shopping in Eason’s recently. A wall of imported U.K-made cards. Shunted off to the side was a small selection of Irish-made cards from which the profits would go towards an Irish charity. Why were Eason’s not promoting these cards more; making them more visible? Why is Fiacla toothpaste on the bottom shelf in Dunnes Stores while foreign brands are front and centre? Ditto for Boru vodka, Cork Dry Gin etc. in Dublin Airport. We should be helping these brands out as much as possible….

    Reply
  • Sure shop in Lidl and Aldi,there German shops.Thats what Enda wants send all the money to Germany.

    Reply
    • The concept of Value for Money doesn’t get understood by politicians, as they waste and help themselves to taxes and if there isn’t enough they increase the tax.
      Ordinary people haven’t got that luxury and look for Value.
      Sean, in his cocoon, doesn’t get that.

      Reply
  • You lost me at the photo Journal :)

    Reply
  • In Kerry the Puc Goat is tagged every year to make sure he is never made King more than once no wonder Mr. kelly went to Europe !

    Reply
  • We make a point of buying Irish if it is available, the trouble is the vast amounts of fruit and vegetables in shops are imported and not grown here,even though the quality is far better than the imported stuff,we just dont grow enough to meet demand here,both wexford strawberries and cream are the exception and for about seven months of the year its on our daily menu.

    Reply
  • Buy foreign.

    Reply
  • Irish businesses only have themselves to blame. Poor choice range and overpriced products met with bad customer service and d*ckhead store owners. But everything on the Internet an suit yourself.

    Reply
    • Barney r 23/03/13 #

      I would say they can also blame high council rates, rents, increasing gas and electricity bills, diesal bills, vat rates, quango goverment agencies, banks not lending, taxes…….

      Reply
  • That’s what George Bush said after 9/11: “Get out there and shop.”

    Reply
  • Mjhint 22/03/13 #

    I would like to remind retailers to practice what they preach as many of them avoid using local suppliers in particular for transport. We have a very high standard of transport suppliers in this countrythat need to be supported too. So we can all support one another.

    Reply

Add New Comment