TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Column: It’s the end of our economy – and now we need an alternative

The economic crisis has caused severe hardship for many – but it has also exposed our financial system for the sham it is, writes Rob Heyland.

Rob Heyland

GROWTH. IT’S A word rarely off the lips of our politicians and financiers. Growth is a the great panacea for all our ills. Growth is the only road out of here.

A few years ago there was no consensus among scientists regarding the damage humanity was inflicting on the planet. That is not the case now. The health and survival of the planet is under threat from growing consumption and production, and the vast majority of scientists now confirm that. Yet we persist with an economic and political system that requires constant growth.

We know that you cannot have infinite growth on a finite planet.

The Stern Report (commissioned by the British Treasury) and then the IPCC report before Copenhagen both confirmed the scale of anthropogenic destruction being visited on the Earth. Both used very similar language to indicate, among other things, that we need to reduce emissions by 80 per cent in order to level off the damage already done to our planet home.

We need to reduce our emissions to one fifth of their present levels. And yet the Chinese and Indians build a new coal-fired dirty technology power station every few days. Emissions continue to increase. We are sacrificing our world and our children’s future at the altar of the free market.

If we used less fuel it would last longer. If we used less power we’d need less power stations. But we are not encouraged to be frugal – we are bombarded with inducements to be profligate. It’s how the system works. It is how it survives. As with the shark, it has to swim forwards to breathe. It is addicted to growth.

Either capitalism dies, or we die.

Before 2008 it seemed unlikely that the BFG (Borrowing Fuelled Growthism) could be tamed. The only alternative systems available seemed to be the failed experiment of communism or the rising tide of radical Islam. Neither an easy sell to the democratic west. So more business as usual.

Then 2008 showed the BFG for what it is – a discredited pyramid scheme that has, as do all pyramid schemes, begun to run out of suckers. A temporary fix had been found by opening up more and more creative lines of credit to allow more suckers to buy in at the bottom and sustain the flow of wealth to the few at the top. But that created a sea of debt -sub-prime and all his pals – that drowned the scam and gave us Lehman’s, and Anglo, and all those other names on that roll of shame.

‘We will have to remove gambling and debt from our financial life’

And now the last gambit of Quantitative Easing has begun. It is the end game. History shows that printing money in quantity leads to massive inflation, and oftentimes, to war.

An alternative is slow to present itself. But we sort of know, don’t we, that we must find it. The world is beginning to polarise between the few who continue to profit from the demolition of the planet and the many who are feeling the stranglehold of austerity and are perhaps waking up to what we are in bed with.

It shouldn’t be too hard to wake the world up to the idea that our addiction to BFG is killing us. It shouldn’t be too hard to show the world that it doesn’t really reflect much credit on us that we are in bed with a system sustained by greed, growth, gambling, usury and debt.

But it is hard. Like divorce, however deeply we know it will be better for the children in the long run, we fear the jump into the unknown.

We will have to be strong, imaginative and very brave. We will have to remove gambling and debt from our financial life, for it is gambling and debt, and addiction to growth, that overheat our system and our world.

We will have to end hedge funds, short selling, speculation and share dealing – not a great loss. City traders don’t put food on our tables or shelter over our heads, however much they try to persuade us otherwise.

To make our change appealing, and to make a clean start, we will have to absolve all debt. We will have a government that cannot borrow but will provide services purely based on taxes levied. Business cannot borrow but will expand (if expand it must) on the basis of profits made. We will return to not-for-profit co-operative high street banks and insurance companies. We will stop measuring our quality of life against the size of our TV set. We will be self-sufficient and sustainable.

We will, because we have to.

Capitalism RIP.

Rob Heyland is an IFTA and BAFTA-winning screenwriter who has been honoured for shows including Between the Lines and Kavanagh QC.  He lives in West Cork, where he has a small farm that is nudging towards self-sufficiency. He also helps to run the Kilcoe Writer’s Retreat.

Read next:

Comments (65 Comments)

  • Human beings will only think about the immediate short term. It is wired into the species. As a result the species will die out. The planet will recover when we are gone.

    Reply
    • Too True! It’s time we remembered we are but a high functioning animal. We don’t have all the answers and we may not survive the swap from oil to ?. Frankly the planet is likely to be better off without us.

      Reply
  • I overheard a D4 blonde saying to her friend yesterday:

    “can they not just, like, print more, like, money or something?”

    So there it is. There is the solution to our problems..

    Reply
    • You’d go for a D4 girls economic outlook!

      Reply
    • Peter 27/03/12 #

      Printing more money is a daft idea as it devalues our currency and makes it worthless, leading to inflation which is a tax on everybody. It may solve the issue on surface but internally it wastes the economy and hurts the people allot more in the long term.

      Reply
    • And so like all our like problems like will be like G O N E L I K E. LOL

      Reply
    • Biddy. Don’t be too hard on the D4 blond. Maybe she heard that information while studying how the Federal Reserve in USA do it. They seem to think it’s perfectly acceptable. It fact it makes a lot of rich even richer.

      Where do ye think a lot if the money that fuelled our boom came from. It’s one big con lads. And all those up to their neck in debt have been had! There’s going to have to be debt forgiveness if only governments had the courage.

      Reply
  • Enjoyed this a lot and agree with it’s sentiment.

    Reply
  • A wonderful article and true, it must be because truth hurts and the opposition to your vision of how to avoid the current situation again are first to scold. I will start my day in better form and with the feeling of positivity that I have for a sustainable future. Now I’m off to feed my bees their syrup and to spend the day enjoying my life. A positive column and so refreshing from the current news stream where we all look to government to better our lives, Well said Rob Heyland.

    Reply
  • Ardo Ci 28/03/12 #

    Rob Heyland, I salute you. This is Titanic Earth on its maiden voyage – set for doom. But just as the ship is still there rusting away on the sea bed, the Earth will still be here after we dangerous creatures have finished with it through our systemic ineptitude and unbridled profligacy. The question is, what will it be like? I would only add it might be a good idea if more people read about “Gaia” by Prof. James Lovelock. We’re already ‘feeling the heat’.

    Reply
  • Greed in a nutshell will destroy everything but can u stand back and watch it on a portable tv when it now on a 60″ 3d hD flat screen tv .

    Reply
  • Lefty rubbish ….. How can Ireland be classed as a capitalist country when we bailed out Anglo etc. One of the main principles of capitalism is if a business isn’t working then it must naturally fail.

    Reply
    • exactly Martin, people on both sides of the economic divide seem oblivious to this point.

      Reply
    • you forgot to mention the other principles of capitalism eg exploitation of people http://www.spunk.org/texts/otherpol/critique/sp001276.txt

      Reply
    • Ireland can’t be called a capitalist country BECAUSE of the anglo bailout. That bailout was necessary to save the irish capitalist system and inevitable because of the the irish system!
      Capitalists have always few required state intervention to prosper and survive. Whether it was through opening markets through imperialist wars or sustaining large companies because they are too big to fail (due to their importance to the capitalist system).
      Capitalism was sure to die in the 70′s – it only survived through a crazy expansion of credit, Enabling workers to buy products with wages they had yet to receive.

      Reply
    • Eoin yes, it’s just part of the cycle of capitalism (i.e. belief and consolidation of the free market system) which may have been dealt a mortal blow if the banks had fallen like dominoes. The cycle I mean is expansion-deregulation-wild gambles-crash-regulation-expansion-

      Reply
    • … However, said cycle clearly cannot be sustained as it depends on ever decreasing finite resources. Especially considering the boom in huge developing countries such as BRIC. The World Bank themselves admit in their 2010 World Development Report that future production must avoid encroaching on already stressed ecosystems.

      Many people are in denial because of unconscious entrenchment in learned cultural behaviour (like being ‘righty’ or ‘lefty’, or wanting a large car because according to the general Irish society’s values you feel validated thereby. Nuf said.

      Reply
  • so pleased that the journal has published this as there are still millions who think technology will save us and this is “lefty nonsense”

    this man is speaking the truth and whether or not you or your family survives the coming transition will depend on your understanding of this concept that growth cannot continue and everything on earth including us will be sacrificed in pursuit of profit.

    here is a great animation by an irishman that explains the situation very well
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOMWzjrRiBg

    this recession is only the beginning….

    Reply
  • Absolve all debt? Nice one, it’s always good to have a bit of a laugh in the morning.

    Reply
  • While I do share the view that infinite growth is not possible the issue is it creates a form of stability. Without growth it becomes a zero sum game, if I better myself it comes at someone else’s expense. The ‘haves’ like growth because the ‘have-nots’ can achieve social mobility without costing the ‘haves’. Remove growth and the ‘haves’ will need to protect themselves, leading to oppression and a reduction in social mobility which will result in social unrest and instability. No-one will volunteer for this so the system will have to undergo a catastrophic event.

    Reply
  • “Business cannot borrow but will expand (if expand it must) on the basis of profits made.”

    This is clearly coming from someone who has never started a business.

    Reply
  • logically, capitalism makes no sense

    Reply
  • Donal, you speak much sense, but I fear you are making the error of expecting reason to be effective when used with people who are incapable of reasoning. Anyone capable of reasoning and understanding the concept of property rights knows that Capitalism is the only moral social system. Most references to ‘capitalism’ on this thread are referring to what is most certainly not Capitalism, thus proving my point. If there is subsidy or interference in the Market, be it from government or corporations then the Market is, obviously, not free, so cannot honestly be described as Capitalism. Most of the current economies, especially in europe can be more accurately described as Parasitism. Save your breath Donal, you cannot reason with the irrational!

    Reply
  • Seriously? Malthus again? What’s with this lefty obsession with declaring mankind both evil and finished?

    In 20 years, new technologies and human innovations will have made this article look like the dumb nonsense it is, and some other clown will be writing it again, claiming that capitalism is finished.

    Wrong in the 30s. Wrong in the 50s. Wrong in the 70s (oil was running out!), and wrong as hell now.

    Reply
  • IFTA and BAFTA – never heard of those economic awards. This guy is an expert in what he’s talking about right…..

    Reply
  • Capitalism is what happens when there is democracy, freedom and property rights.

    Reply
  • Link was just confused gobbledegook, and very poorly written too. I would not recommend reading such nonsense. Stick to facts and reason.

    Reply
  • Its the end of our economy?

    Yes we’re in a recession, yes there are people to blame, but it’s not the end of life as we know it. There have been recessions before, worse than this, and mankind hasn’t been wiped off the face off the earth.

    Saying we need to abolish capitalism because we’re in a recession is like saying “I’m giving up drinking” because you’re hungover. No one wrote articles like this 10 years ago and no one will be writing them in 10 years time. See you at the next recession.

    Reply
    • like I said above, no capitalism to see here, move along!

      Reply
    • Brendan,
      the difference with this recession (depression?) Is it is the result of the collapse of the only thing that had saved the system for the last 40 years – huge levels of credit!
      The only thing that can save capitalism its the same thing that saved it after the last depression – a massive destruction of capital, hopefully we can create a new system before we repeat ww2!

      Reply
    • @Eoin

      What do you mean repeat WW2?

      Yes we borrowed too much, but that doesnt mean borrowing is a bad thing. We need access to credit in order to function. If we couldnt take out mortgages we’d have to save till our mid-forties before we could move out of home, and we couldnt save in banks, they couldnt rent our money out to borrowers to they probably wouldnt exist, you’d be talking about saving hundreds of thousands in a shoe box under your bed. businesses and governments are the same, when a big opportunity arises we need access to credit, its how we manage our credit levels, you cant blame capitalism because we cant manage credit.

      Reply
  • Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha

    Reply
  • Ok, now that I’ve recovered a bit – I’ve got bad news for all you lefties in here. The economy isn’t ending quite yet, and you all need to pay up your hundred euros today. Get a move on.

    Reply
  • Been hearing failed predictions of hyperinflation for years now. No sign of it in UK or US. Let me know when its going to start, thanks.

    Reply
  • At last, some real words of wisdom! Are you listening FG and Labour? This is the kind of advisor you need to have!

    Reply

Add New Comment