TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 3 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Regulator announces €3million fines for fracking safety breaches

Companies engaged in any potential fracking will face stiff penalties including jail if they do not comply with regulations.

The Lough Allen basin is one of the areas that has been identified for potential fracking
The Lough Allen basin is one of the areas that has been identified for potential fracking
Image: dusi_bbg via Flickr

COMPANIES ENGAGED IN any potential fracking for shale gas in Ireland will face fines of up to €3million if they break safety rules, the energy regulator has announced.

Anyone involved in breaching the regulations could also face a jail sentence of up to three years.

Environmental activists have repeatedly raised concerns over the safety of fracking, which involves pumping water and chemicals into underground rock formations to force gas out.

The Commission for Energy Regulation yesterday unveiled its new Petroleum Safety Framework, which will apply to all companies extracting oil and gas in and around Ireland.

As well as fracking, the rules will also be imposed on extraction operations at the Kinsale gas field and the controversial Corrib operation, where natural gas extraction is yet to begin.

Energy firms will need a safety permit from the CER before beginning oil or gas production, or drilling new wells. Once a permit has been issued there will be “extensive CER monitoring” of the operation, the regulator said in a statement.

CER Commissioner Garrett Blaney said the new framework was “a significant milestone in providing for a robust regulatory system in petroleum safety.” He added:

The CER is confident that the new Petroleum Safety Framework provides a strong regulatory basis for a petroleum exploration and extraction industry in Ireland which is safe and is fully in accordance with best international safety practice.

The full report on the safety framework was compiled after receiving more than 130 submissions from interested parties.

Read: EPA fracking study reveals potential impact on groundwater and earthquakes>

More: Everything you ever needed to know about fracking>

Read next:

Comments (50 Comments)

  • €3 million! Chump change for these companies. Here’s €4 million, keep the change. €3 billion, now there’s a fine.

    Reply
    • They will spend more than that on PR € 3 Million = Petty Cash

      Reply
    • Paul MC 09/06/12 #

      If our groundwater is contaminated it will cost a lot more than three million to fix the problem, the loss in tourist revenue from fishermen, the damage to our ecology, the damage to Ireland’s green image and the cost of persuing the culprits will easily cost 3 or 4 times more. Typical Irish solution.
      In the 1980’s in Idaho USA an Irish owned dairy company (i think it was Avonmore) polluted miles of the little fork river, they paid hundreds of thousands to repair the damage (without complaint or fighting the case in court). The same company polluted a river in Kilkenny and fought tooth and nail to avoid the miserable few thousand fine our idiot legal system handed down.
      As a country we really are a shower of idiots when it comes to this sort of thing.

      Reply
  • “Anyone involved in breaching the regulations could also face a jail sentence of up to three years.”
    That has them quaking in the boardrooms of Wall Street and Frankfurt.
    They are going to make a mess of Lough Allen, pollute the Shannon and leave with whatever loot they can get and Rabbitte and other Ministers will be boasting that they created jobs – yeah, making the tea and cleaning up for the next 100 years.

    Reply
  • I’m sure they are shaking in their boots at the thought of those minimal fines!

    Sad to see we are allowing fracking in Ireland.

    Goodbye to our tourism industry. Hello health implications.

    Reply
  • Fracking will do nothing but harm to our environment. Shame on Ireland for allowing this.

    Reply
  • I have been following this issue very closely for months. The Irish government is NOT allowing fracking. According to Pat Rabbitte, only licensing options have been handed out so far. The government has committed to carrying out a second more detailed study as the University of Aberdeen study confirmed that a more comprehensive research is required. (Of course, those who have researched fracking know there is no safe means of extracting gas using this method, as Cornell University Professor Anthony Ingraffea and many other well-respected, independent experts have confirmed.) In fact, every single peer-reviewed scientific study proves that the entire lifecycle of shale gas development causes serious contamination to air, water, and land. It would be economic insanity for our government to hand out exploitation licences to an industry that even when regulated has contaminated thousands of communities in Canada, the US and Australia, when our agri-food sector alone is worth €24 billion a year. But then again, economic insanity would be nothing new for the Irish government.

    The government, the gas companies and the corporate-funded media have all realised that public opposition to unconventional gas exploration is stronger than they expected , hence why they now need to ramp up their PR campaign with the help of two PR agencies, pr360.ie and Weber Shandwick.

    Try all they like to sway public opinion, the fight is still strong on the ground and there are literally thousands of Irish people nationwide who will never allow fracking to go ahead, as it will harm their livelihoods – tourism, agriculture, organic farming, agri-food, etc. – sustainable multi-billion industries that will exist long after the gas men have left.

    Many regions and countries around the world have been successful in introducing bans and moratoria, so it is possible to stop fracking from going ahead. Don’t let articles like the above make you feel as if the fight has been lost, if anything it is only beginning! :)

    Reply
  • Choooon 09/06/12 #

    It will be a sad day for Ireland when fracking starts. What have we done with our dignity?

    Reply
  • Why does the govt go ahead with this ‘fracking’ even though the dangers are known. Even the name of the process doesn’t inspire confidence. Stupid, stupid, stupid.

    Reply
  • the cowboys who ran the country into the ground have found a new hobby. fracking suits them so well.

    Reply
  • It is in the earth for a reason. Leave it there

    Reply
  • This has to stop being perceived as a “Leitrim” issue. There are ten counties over the Island of IReland potentially to be affected by this process.
    The time has come for the rest of the country to wake up to the fact that the only growth industries, Agriculture/agri business and tourism , which have shown a small growth and upward trend for the last two years, will be wiped out if horizontal hydraulic fracturing goes ahead. Another HUGE issue is that the Bundoran shale layer sits atop of the Ballyshannon Limestone, an aquifer of regional importance (providing drinking water to Ballyshannon and surrounding areas), which if polluted by byproducts of the industry or chemicals, would not be able to be “fixed”, unlike our media and some of our elected representatives.

    Reply
    • Yeah they are deliberately choosing to start with Leitrim as they prob reckoned this would be the path of least resistance and good entry point. I would still like to know how they found the reserves in the first place and what methods they used, was any fracking carried out to ascertain the potential of the reserves for example?

      Reply
    • Lisa, all the reserves are potential. The carbon content in the existing cores is low. Therefore Tamboran need to take new cores. Tamboran (Mr Moorman) stated that he has full confidence in the cores he has and claimed to have tested all the Shale. Deti informed us that previous companies were interested in the Sandstone, and so only the top 30M of shale or so is cored. ..so someone not telling truth. It is possible Mr Moorman picked his shale samples from outcrops at Bundoran and Mullaghmore. Essentially bottom answer is that we won’t know until Tamboran have done an exploratory well or two in Fermanagh. In Fermanagh they have got land for exploratory sites. They have a licence to frack and drill horizontally and do multi-wells on pads. Until those results are reviewed (DETI confirm they will review independently) then we wont know if the field is a goer or not. My understanding is that special permissions other than the licence are required by Tamboran before they can even do the Exploratory wells.. although its beginning to look like some of these are mere paperwork exercises. given an announcement by Rathlin Energy who are operating under a similar licence near Ballycastle and who have said they can bore away without any further permissions.

      Reply
  • You know fracking is bad news when they need economic or national turmoil to introduce it. Cheney signed all the licences and legisalation in America in the weeks after 9/11 hoping no one would notice. Now with our backs against the wall they dangle this carrott in front of us, trouble is, its a ticking time bomb thats gonna go off in our faces.

    Reply
  • The financial implcations are horrific. Another great “oil and gas giveaway”. One of the companies circling Ireland like vultures bandys around figures which change each time they speak, or are quoted by our “captured” media.
    We will buy “our” gas back at market prices. End of story. The small companies with the loudest voices will not be drilling, one of the big boys will be actually carrying out the degrading , environmentally devastating exploitation of the countryside.
    Shell has an environmental record, (think Niger delta and the Ogoni Nine) which is shameful. All these companies pay lip service to environmental concerns whilst hoovering up the profits, and leaving communities split and bewildered, with health and fiscal issues to further add to their tribulations.
    We (North West Network against Fracking) have surveyed over 900 tourists to date: 85% would not come here (to the NorthWest and West (Clare basin also under attack) if it were to be perceived as an industrialized mining zone). We will put the final results of the survey up on http://www.frackingfreeireland.com as soon as our survey is complete, along with some hard, realistic fnancial facts and figures, which show not some pie in the sky gains (as blurbed by the gas men/wimmin) but what we stand, and generations to come, TO LOSE.

    Reply
  • 3m is loose change to these guys. Why not focus on tourism & renewable energy instead of ruining the natural beauty of the west for a quick buck?

    Reply
  • neo1 09/06/12 #

    Does anybody know how we can help to stop this…this is the last straw

    Reply
  • Lisa, the first shale basin they plan to exploit is the North West, see more details here:

    http://goodenergiesalliance.com/affected-areas/leitrim-and-sligo/current-plans/

    There are also plans to frack in the Clare Basin which covers areas of Clare, Limerick, Kerry and Cork.

    So it’s not just Leitrim, as many Irish people think! This is a national issue!

    GEAI is the official campaign group, but you can get regular updates on the campaign via the newsletters from the Fracking Free Ireland website and keep in touch via the many Facebook groups – NO FRACKING IRELAND (all caps) is the main one.

    Please share the information with your contacts and find out how you can get involved!

    Reply
    • Its not just Leitrim in any case. Its Fermanagh too. but why start there and why stop there. The shale lies under Mayo, Sligo, S Donegal, Tyrone, Monaghan, Cavan and Roscommon. There is another licence in NI covering most of Derry and a bit of Antrim. These companies always start where they feel least resistance – relatively poor areas with sparse population. Once we go down this route we won’t be able to stop. Once we’re addicted to shale gas, the government can’t turn off the tap — The Energy company knows that. So even if they do pollute, there’ll be a cover up as the govt has made a decision and now must stick to it.
      Think of it this way too, If I’m a farmer with good land over Shale and Tamboran or whoever offered me a big price to lease land, I’d probably tell them take a running jump. However if 5 years down the line, after a pollution incident and my market being closed off, they offer me one quarter the price, I’m probably willing to bite their hand off. It actually pays these frackers to pollute. 3million Euro .. when one pollution would lower all potential lease prices. There’ll be an accountant working out the bang for buck and advising as you read this.

      Reply
  • A total BAN is what the people wish and we will fight this tooth and nail to prevent our country from been destroyed see NO FRACKING IRELAND on facebook join up and have a voice in our resistance.

    Reply
  • This is a disgrace. The country side will be wrecked if they do like in the US & Canada. And the people who come in to do this work won’t care one bit. I think the people living in the areas where these sites are to be set up should keep video logs if this does start. as proof. The gov won’t care.

    Reply
  • With ireland s history in regulation and enforcement, this had me petrified!! How trained and experienced are these regulators? Will they be inspecting every single incident of fracking? … From experience in the construction industry, and from the banking sector, irish regulatory enforcement systems are a joke!!

    Reply
  • Spot on, Sonya. The idea of being able to regulate this industry is a joke anyway. Who would enforce the regulations? Are the regulators going to be on site 24/7 to ensure regulations are adhered to – because 24/7 monitoring is essential in such an industry. Of course, they’re not. Even the drilling companies themselves have admitted that they can’t monitor what happens once they begin to drill the shale horizontally, and let’s not even talk about the well casings. Leaks are inevitable. And the flowback material, containing all those naturally occurring radioactive materials? Really, we are so much better informed than they think! If they seriously think they are going to foist this upon the Irish people and drive our country into further economic ruin, they can think again! I wonder if the companies have factored in the costs associated with direct action. If they have, they’ll know it’s not worth their while fracking anywhere on this island.

    Reply
  • sounds like they’ve made their minds up to go ahead despite Minister Rabbittes assurances to the contrary..3 million will be nothing if damage is done.. 1/4 of the whole island could be affected..we sell ourselves cheap..the revenue that could be brought in over the 50 years would hardly pay 2 bondholder payments…but thats fine who caares if children become sick or our water supply is destroyed..and not neverminding turning a rural area into an industrial zone and having to live with it

    Reply
  • This Fracking is bad news. Did the Gorvernent give permission for it to happen.

    Reply
    • My thoughts exactly Richard…last time I heard Fat Pat waffling on about this he was waiting for some definitive report from the States saying absolutely no decision would be made until that report was published. Now we’re hearing about fines….this governments usual dirty, underhanded way of dealing with a sensitive issue. Why should I even be suprised.

      Reply
  • as we look forward
    to paying for the dumbing-down
    of fluoride in the water charges

    We can look back with fondness
    to a long proud age of free
    transcendental medication

    on tap

    but between us, fear not
    despair not, for our fine future
    is furnished with the highs

    of a new fracking-laced legacy
    and we’ll all have our money’s worth
    with an added dose of methane

    free chemicals, unspellable
    and a mere spark-away
    from a new water

    that burns

    Reply
  • thanks for putting the avaaz petition up Dervilla, over ten thousand signatures so far:)

    Reply
  • That’s gas.

    Reply
  • Peition in operation. Pls signn and circulate widely
    https://secure.avaaz.org/en/petition/Ban_Fracking_Ireland/

    Reply
  • Whats needed urgently is a serious and open public debate. The implications to our Tourism and food industries need to be quantified and highlighted. Has anyone even considered the impact of countless Articulated Truck and Tanker traffic on our rural roads and towns, never mind the millions of gallons of water required on a daily basis to execute this process? If ever there was a case for a Referendem this is one, after all this has the potential to be more damaging to us than any European Legistation. Fracking 2 everyone!

    Reply
  • 475,000 litres of crude oil spilled in Alberta, I wonder what trivial fine that will attract.
    http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/06/08/alberta-oil-spill-red-deer-river_n_1581008.html?ir=Canada&ref=fb&src=sp&comm_ref=false

    Reply
  • OK, so first of all giving a fine to a company that has a firm grasp on one of the worlds most lucrative resources is hardly going to send a shock wave through the industry. All that will happen here is that the companies will either blame individuals for negligence or just report incidents as unforeseeable accidents to which no one can be held accountable. Secondly, just how do you monitor the integrity of a structure that is 2 miles underground? This seems to me to be a token from government to try and display to the people of Ireland that they care, when clearly they do not as we have seen in Rossport… NO TO FRACKING..

    Reply
  • Lisa, yes there are reserves there. Contact the GEAI directly and they’ll provide you with all the information you need and more!

    Please don’t forget to sign the petition. 10,000 signatures already so that gives you an idea of how much opposition is out there: http://www.avaaz.org/en/petition/Ban_Fracking_Ireland/?cskVZab

    Reply
  • Fracking hell. This is a fracking joke.

    Reply
  • I thought that fracking was banned? What’s going on?

    Reply
    • Hi Lisa, no the councils have included a ban but it is more support than an actua;ity, it will be the government that decide and despite their reassurance to the contrary i think they made up their minds along time ago :(

      Reply
    • Thanks sonya, sorry what i meant was that I thought from the article that testing for fracking had already gone ahead, as they are talking about what penalties would be involved in the event of breaches of safety! This is crazy stuff, they haven’t even got the go ahead for fracking and they are already talking about what fines would be involved. People know that 3m is nothing these days, nothing.

      Reply
  • From the Oklahoma Fracking / Earthquake experience, if this fracking goes ahead in Leitrim / Donegal and the Clare Basin – it will create Earthquake zones from Donegal to Tralee.

    Ballina, Castlebar, Cavan, Monaghan, Longford and Roscommon towns will all be in the Earthquake zones.

    Galway City, Limerick City and Tralee will all be in the Clare Basin Earthquake zone.

    Viewers from all over the World will be watching the Rose of Tralee on TV, and the Roses could all heel over live on TV due to an Earthquake tremors caused by the drilling and Fracking in Loop Head.

    http://www.treehugger.com/energy-disasters/fracking-may-have-already-caused-50-earthquakes-oklahoma.html

    Buildings in all of those towns will probably end up with cracked foundations.

    Would the Irish State be then liable for the structural damage from the Earthquakes caused by Fracking, as the Government would have issued the fracking licences ?

    http://www.facebook.com/President.Mulqueen

    Reply
  • Does anyone know where they have already done some testing and surveying for shale gas potential? should people be monitoring areas?

    Reply
  • I’m still not sure though on what testing they have already carried out that has made them so sure there is potential here? Is there a report or anything with regards that?

    Also couldn’t they be testing in remote areas right now for all we know?

    those are the questions I can’t get answers to.

    Reply
  • Why shouldn’t we be franking? I’d sooner we availed of our natural resources than borrow for imported energy abroad. We should go nuclear, and stop placing additional financial burden on our kids.

    P.S. all for robust fines for polluters.

    Reply
    • SMcB 09/06/12 #

      You don’t see the problem… Really??? If you had any understanding of the local macro environment you would realise that there are many problems with fracking.

      Reply
    • we will have no guarentee of supply or price, we will still be buying on the open market..i presume John you do not live in the areas and will not have to live with the air pollution, water pollution, noise 24/7

      Reply

Add New Comment