TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

Ruairi Quinn: Michael Noonan has a tougher job than Michael Collins…

The Education Minister warns secondary school teachers that budgets are tight as the State’s first Finance Minister Collins had “more room for manouevre” than his most recent successor.

Are you right there Michael? Collins and Noonan
Are you right there Michael? Collins and Noonan
Image: PA Images and Photocall

EDUCATION MINISTER RUAIRI Quinn has been following up with yesterday’s “frank” speech to national school teachers with a similarly forthright address to a secondary school teachers’ union.

Quinn, pushing home the point that resources will continue to be tight, claimed that “Michael Collins, the State’s first Minister for Finance, had in 1922, more room for manoeuvre than Michael Noonan has today”.

He told delegates at the ASTI convention that the “challenges” facing the economy and the “further difficult measures” that the government needs to take are unavoidable. He said:

We all have to come to terms with the extent to which our reliance on EU/IMF funding means that we operate without economic sovereignty.

He said the country was “akin to being in receivership” and that it would be some time before the Government could return to making “unfettered decisions”.

In a clear statement that teachers who supervise extracurricular activities on their own time can not expect to be paid for the extra work, he said that there was a “tradition of volunteerism” among secondary teachers, and described it as “one of the strengths of the education system”.

Quinn warned that teachers who have held fixed-term contracts up to now will face “increased uncertainty for the year ahead”. He said:

We will need to redeploy teachers into positions that traditionally have been filled by teachers on fixed-term contracts in order to deliver on the commitment in relation to no redundancy for those in permanent positions or who have acquired a C.I.D. (Contract of Indefinite Duration).

The issue of reform of the Junior Certificate was also on the curriculum with Quinn claiming that the current one was not meeting the needs of students. Some of his ideas for changing the course include:

  • Reducing the number of subjects studied to Junior Cert level;
  • Not making the Junior Cert exams at the end of third year the main form of student assessment;
  • Introducing standardised tests of literacy and numeracy to ensure all students acquire these basic skills.

The changes in the Junior Certificate will not be copperfastened until the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA) delivers its report following a national consultation on reform of the cycle later this year.

Read next:

Comments (14 Comments)

  • Michael Collins didn’t piss about in mercs. He didn’t get paid anything near €120,000 for risking and ultimately giving his life for the future of the country. He didn’t claim unvouched expenses nor did he “work” only 120 days per year. He negotiated the formation of the state with a far more powerful empire at the time, while these clowns take all their orders from a group of faceless EU bureaucrats. To compare these men is a joke.

    Reply
  • Except Ruairi Quinn there’s a difference between them, Micheal C was the first Minister for Finance after our country gained its independence, Michael N the first Minister for Finance after our country lost its independence. We put up with the hardships under Collins because we were doing it for ourselves, we won’t be putting up with cuts imposed on us by an unelected Troika

    Reply
  • John 26/04/11 #

    Reminds me of Kanye West who over the years has compared himself to Elvis, Cobain, Maya Angelou, Jim Morrison, George W. Bush, the 1989 Tienanmen Square tank protester, Michael Jackson, Dr.Martin Luther King, Emmet Till and Jesus

    Reply
  • Collins was working with tough conditions, but he had low public expectation, low standards of living and a first attempt.
    Noonan has to undo years of unsustainable cost growth and personal debt accrual, while bringing a public used to having the highest standard of living in the world with him.. Not an easy task, and he won’t be helped by those who got us here..

    Reply
  • Are you living in the same Ireland as the rest of us??

    Reply
  • All the same wouldn’t your heart go out to him, fancy having your chain yanked by Mrs Merkin and Kermit at every hands turn.

    Reply
  • It’s idiotic to even compare the two. Completely different circumstances, events, background and most importantly problem. Usual ole drivel we have come to expect from labour!

    Reply
  • Gerry b 26/04/11 #

    It’s not that tough. CUT CUT CUT. It’s inevitable that these sorts will eventually take to the streets, so let’s just get it over and done with. Make REAL cuts, be tough, no talks, no deals or promises. Do what we elected you to do. Stop allowing unions influence decisions in the national interest.

    Reply
    • Gerry b 26/04/11 #

      Michael, here’s an Idea wait till June before you announce anything. They will all be on their summer hols and are less likely to attend union rallies etc, cos they won’t be able to take days off work.

      Reply
  • For anyone in The Dail to bring up comparisons to Michael Collins is stark evidence how detached from reality they are! No one in there is fit to shine his shoes! Fine Gael just keep diggin!!
    What we are leading to is: http://youtu.be/g56xhg9heT0

    Reply
  • I think he is subtly suggesting that assassination is the only way to deal with the teachers unions. At least Lloyd George and Churchill had a less self important view of themselves

    Reply

Add New Comment