TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 9 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Support for UK’s voting reform referendum collapses in new poll

The anti-AV side leads 58-42 – but almost a quarter of voters are undecided – as David Cameron speaks out in opposition.

Image: Oli Scarff/PA Wire

AN OPINION POLL has shown that public support for scrapping the first-past-the-post (FPTP) system used for Westminster elections has fallen, less than three weeks before the matter is put to a public vote.

Ahead of the referendum on May 5, a poll carried out by ICM and commissioned by the Guardian has shown that support for replacing the FPTP system with a modified version of proportional representation – the Alternative Vote (AV) – has fallen massively since the last similar poll in February.

The anti-AV camp now commands a lead of 16 percentage points, 58-42, compared to the last such poll which had both sides virtually neck-and-neck and with the Yes camp claiming the lead before Christmas.

When likely turnout is taken into account, the lead is adjusted to 11 points – which is also the margin of the lead when ‘don’t know’ votes are included, with 44 per cent of respondents committing to voting No and 33 per cent supporting Yes.

While 23 per cent of voters remain undecided, the overall trend in polls being carried out by other newspapers is certainly towards the anti-AV side.

Hours before the poll results were released, prime minister David Cameron reiterated his opposition to the move, saying AV would “take away” some of the power of an individual vote.

The Alternative Vote, Cameron added, would result in coalition governments becoming a more common reality – which then would make politics “less accountable”.

Cameron was joined by former Labour minister John Reid – while current Labour leader Ed Miliband was simultaneously attending a  pro-AV rally with the Liberal Democrats’ Vince Cable.

The referendum – which will be only the second referendum to take place across all of the United Kingdom – will take place alongside elections to regional assemblies in Scotland, Wales and England, and a number of council elections in England.

Voters in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are considered more likely to support the referendum, given that their local assemblies and governments are elected through systems that are slightly more complex than the FPTP method, which awards victory simply to the candidate with the highest number of votes.

Provision for the referendum was one of the Liberal Democrats’ key demands when entering coalition with Cameron’s Conservatives last year.





Read next:

Comments (7 Comments)

  • Perhaps it’s just me, but it seems that the main opposition to a change in the system comes from politicians acting in self-interest to protect seats they’ve held for years. A sort of “if it’s good enough to get me elected, it’s good enough for everyone else.”
    A lot of them know they’d have to work harder to get elected under AV and are prepared to sell it to the voters that they should vote ‘No’ to protect the legitimacy of their own vote.
    I wouldn’t be so sure of overwhelming support coming from Northern Ireland since both Unionist parties are in favour of keeping the current system. (Even though if last year’s General Election was contested under AV the UUP would have actually come away with a seat or two.)

    Reply
  • Whatever about AV, FPTP is a disaster altogether, in 1983 the SDP-Liberal alliance got 25.4% of the vote yet 3.5% of the seats, and in the 2010 election the Lib Dems got more votes than Labour yet significantly less seats.

    Reply
  • Surely AV would give more power to the one vote as it’s counted more than once, then again AV is a rubbish compromise in the face of PR-STV.

    Reply
    • I think a chief argument among its opponents is that under AV, some voters get 5/10/15 votes while others just get the one.

      Reply
    • I’m indifferent to AV but this is incorrect. The votes are counted again in each round of counting – so if you vote Labour 1 and nobody else, your vote is counted for Labour in the first round, Labour in the second round, Labour in the third round, and so on. If you vote UKIP 1, Green 2, Lib Dem 3, your vote is UKIP in the first round, then if UKIP are eliminated Green in the second round, and so on.

      Reply
  • This is wrong. ~If you vote for one party only, then your vote is NOT counted in the second round. Only SECOND choice votes are counted. then THIRD and so on. If you vote once your paper is then NOT counted. Please people get the facts not the no campaign misinformation

    Reply

Add New Comment