TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

Sweden mulls law to stop kids’ phones from ‘ruining’ parents

Case where parents held liable for €6k bill run up by their children has led to plans for new consumer protection legislation.

Mobile phones: The gift to children that keeps on taking? (stock pic)
Mobile phones: The gift to children that keeps on taking? (stock pic)
Image: John Phillips/UK Press/Press Association Images

THE SWEDISH GOVERNMENT said today that it is considering introducing a law to prevent children from emptying their parents’ bank accounts in just a few clicks when playing with their smartphones.

“It isn’t okay that children can subject their parents to financial ruin with just a few clicks on their phone,” Consumer Affairs Minister Birgitta Ohlsson said in a statement.

Her comments came after her ministry received an independent committee’s report with proposals on ways to improve consumer protection on the mobile phone market.

The main author of the report, a former Supreme Court judge, recommended that in disputes where parents contest exorbitant fees which they claim were charged by their children, the law should assume that the parents are dealing in good faith.

The report also proposes that controls be strengthened to verify that the person who purchases something with a mobile phone or tablet is indeed the owner of the bank account being debited.

The report cited a case that made headlines in Sweden in April 2011, when two six- and seven-year-old brothers spent 50,000 kronor (€5,900) on berries for Smurfs in a game downloaded for free on an Apple iPad.

Their parents were not required to pay after negotiations.

- © AFP, 2012

Read next:

Comments (27 Comments)

  • I have always thought it was wrong that children could be ripped off by these “free” mobile quizzes and ringtones services that then set up a subscription service charging then every week. Ban them.

    Reply
  • That “Buy with 1 click” thing on Amazon is especially dangerous. Especially with small children running around.

    Reply
  • Greedy smurfs

    Reply
  • My daughter played the smurfs app on my phone & ran up a bill of €46 on smurf berries…learnt a lesson the hard way to disconnect my credit card from iTunes !!

    Reply
  • Here a novel idea….say no to kids. Yes its ok to say no !!!

    Reply
  • Or….maybe parents should n’t buy kids smart phone’s until they’re of the sufficient intelligence to have one.

    Reply
    • briewee 12/09/12 #

      a lot of the time its not the kids phones that run up these charges, my 3yr loves to play some apps on my phone I haven’t set up a credit card or paypal with my app market or for any app, it is the apps based at young children that have coins/bubbles that cost money the kids click it and the charges are put on your phone/credit card.
      parents need to be careful about the kind of apps that you put on your phone and if your iphone or android phone app markets are set up to charge your account, I give my son my phone as it keeps him happy when I am traveling or need to keep him accoupied for a wee bit and I know a lot of other parents that do the same, it is up to the parent to check and to lock or password protect spending

      Reply
    • I really don’t believe you two guys should be provided with any legislative support for stupid purchases made while you’re out of control on alcohol. As adults you should be held fully responsible for such moronic behaviour and even more so when your practically boasting about it on a public web site! What’s the difference between what you are describing and placing wagers on line in the privacy of your home.

      Reply
    • I really don’t believe you two guys should be provided with any legislative support for stupid purchases made while you’re out of control on alcohol. As adults you should be held fully responsible for such moronic behaviour and even more so when your practically boasting about it on a public web site! What’s the difference between what you are describing and placing wagers on line in the privacy of your home.

      Reply
  • You need to be careful. I updated some apps on the iPad last week, then gave it to my son to play. He ordered a game, cost only ?3 thank God. Restart after updating apps, you remain logged in otherwise. :)

    Reply
  • I dont agree with this legislation really.

    Its not bad parenting to distract a child with a phone. However if you have your credit cards registered for apps and add ons etc and you hand the device to children below eight with very little concept of money, dont supervise them and then complain about the charges thats a bit irresponsible.

    Pay as you go visa’s can be used if you insist on letting kids use phones unsupervised.

    I’d give the parents in this case basic finacial and parental advice but providing legislation to protect their foolishness is bizarre

    Reply
  • Children shouldn’t be playing on, let alone having their own phones in the first place. Where is the parental common sense inall of this?

    Reply
    • I cannot agree more. I have 4 kids under 8. We travel by aeroplane regularly and are always out and about. I bring a few books (remember them?) in my handbag or another separate bag. If really stuck, a few felt tipped pens and toy cars etc. for the toddler. I have a Samsung Galaxy S2 which I adore but it is completely off limits for my kids, as are Nintendos, Wiis etc. No need for them.

      Reply
    • aren’t you a fun mother

      Reply
    • Gary, they don’t miss what they never had. They love books because that’s what they have grown up with and are very active – they play sports 6 times a week. That takes a lot of effort and commitment from us. It would be easier to let them play games, but I just feel it’s the lazy option. I’m not professing to have all the answers, but kids need to be outside and active, and my opinion is that once they get a taste of electronic games, it’s hard to compete, so wait longer and get them into healthy habits first, that’s all.

      Reply
    • Yes Gary she is. it might not be as “fun” as what you imagine childhood to be but her way of entertaining kids is far better than most people’s philosophy of “sure stick the telly on, that’ll shut them up”

      Reply

Add New Comment