TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Committee says improvement needed in ICT skills among teachers

The committee report also recommended the development of a Technology Visa to enable skilled workers from abroad to fill IT skill shortages in Ireland.

Image: Leon Farrell/Photocall Ireland

A NEW REPORT from the Committee on Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation has said that there is a need to boost the level of information and communications technology (ICT) literacy among teachers.

The report found that there is a significant gap between the ICT skills which are taught in our schools and those that are required to take up job opportunities in the technology sector.

According to a 2008 inspectorate report, only 25 per cent of post-primary teachers rated themselves as having intermediate or advanced IT skills.

Commenting on the committee report, Senator Deirdre Clune said it will be “impossible to further the development of computing within schools unless we have teachers who are capable of showing their students how to engage with the creative tools of ICT”.

The report also said that inadequate resources and broadband in schools are making the implementation of ICT strategies more difficult.

While the committee recognised the decision to include the option of studying short courses in computer programming as part of a new curriculum to replace the Junior Cert the report recommends making programming and/or computer science as much a part of the curriculum as languages.

The committee report also highlighted the importance of creating an accreditation system for ICT professionals.

“The benefits of creating an accreditation system with in the Irish technology sector include providing greater clarity for those who wish to pursue careers within the ICT sector, assuring a standard for companies investing in Ireland and raising the standard of the entire industry,” said Clune.

Among the report’s other findings and recommendations was a suggestion of the development of a Technology Visa for IT professionals that would enable highly skilled workers from abroad to fill temporary skills shortages in Ireland.

The committee estimated there are around 4,500 vacancies in IT skills across the country.

Read: A review of the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) skills demand in Ireland>

Read next:

Comments (25 Comments)

  • Most people with the skills required would rather earn more in the private sector which is crying out for these skilled individuals and paying good wages to get top talent. Who can blame them?
    If you were to look for hours teaching you will be met with no job security and temporary hours for many years, no pay during holidays, pay cuts and no prospect of change in this situation anytime soon.

    Reply
  • I am a secondary school teacher who EIGHT YEARS AGO did a two year Graduate Diploma in Commercial Computing (programming, applications, database design, software engineering etc.)at night. In the years since I have forgotten most of what I learned as little is relevant. In my own time I built the school Moodle with over 300 users, given advice to staff on blogs and give IT courses to teachers in Education Centres. The problem is that IT is not an officail subject on the school curriculum. Perhaps the new Junior Cert could address this and make IT a compulsory short course. Most secondary schools have the hardware infrestructure in place.
    Many younger teachers do use IT in their teaching but many lack confidence as students are often very accomplished in computing spending so much time at their computers and gaming consoles.

    I see some people seeking to beat teachers with this issue. We cannot blame teachers if training colleges havent provided the training and the Department of Education and NCCA havent promoted certified courses in schools.

    Reply
    • As a dog with a degree in IT I have been offered jobs teaching ICT. But not in Ireland. So I’m going to gather the pups and head off soon. Teaching IT is a skill I am competent in but I can’t see the jobs appearing in Ireland anytime soon.

      Reply
    • Alien8 10/10/12 #

      I agree with your sentiment, and congratulate you on upskilling. (For those without kids, moodle is an education web framework for developing courses for teachers and students online, similar to a CRM system).

      But it is up to the teachers, their representatives, and their lobby groups to put IT as a requirement to teacher training, maybe in place of the absolutely pointless religious education training that is the core subject in Ireland’s teacher training colleges? Like, littering* – don’t expect someone else to do it for you!

      * later journal post.

      Reply
  • As a secondary school teacher I would agree that a percentage teachers have poor IT skills but to be fair most under 35s are very literate while an increasing number of older teachers are up skilling.

    Keep in mind people the philosophy of education should be about ‘teaching’ kids to learn and develop for themselves. A person with a good computer knowledge does not a good teacher make.

    Reply
  • There are lots of smart teachers doing lots of smart ICT stuff every day – check out the Google Group for the Computer Education Society of Ireland at https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/cesi-list

    Reply
  • Then why are they are cutting the ICT grants for school ?

    Reply
  • I am, for lack of a better word, the “ICT guy” in the school I work. I know enough about computers in general, and have done a number of courses about teaching through ICT. I do need to acquire more technical expertise however, as I find it’s an area that I and many other teachers fall down. To give an example, I could list hundreds of good websites to use with students or to direct students to, along with teaching strategies to maximise their use, but if the broadband in the school is down it takes me a couple of hours after school to try and sort it out. same if a computer breaks or has technical issues. After I’ve turned it off and on, I’m struggling. Perhaps, some of this basic knowledge should be taught in teacher training programs. I know the risk of the technology not working when it needs to turns a lot of teachers of trying it out.

    Reply
  • Brendan’s post is the most informed here. There’s no point in people blaming their teacher from 10/20 years ago for not being proficient in a subject that didn’t exist, with resources he didn’t have. It has been blatantly obvious to all teachers for years that a subject status was required for the area but successive governments would not invest enough money. This is what teachers are talking about when they draw attention to the percentage of our GNP spent on education compared to other OECD countries. This report is a joke because it’s ‘findings’ are manifestly obvious to all.

    BTW where did The Journal get that photograph- it must be 15 years old…

    Reply
  • thelast thing we need is jobs being outsourced . I myself own an IT company ( Two man Operation ) , and I would love to get this opportunity , but Im sure theres loads of IT Irish people who can do this job without going abroad !

    Reply
  • IT needs to be thought by IT qualified teachers. it’s not good enough that 25% think they have intermediate to advanced IT skills. don’t 90% of drivers think they are excenlent drivers.
    teachers doing short courses and being able to use Facebook doesn’t cut it when it comes to teaching IT to our kids who’s competition is the larger world and not the next school over in ballygobackwards.
    plus what is it with schools buying over expensive apple mac’s, seems fashion driven rather than requirement

    Reply
  • ICT should be a subject in the junior/leaving cert, I’d prefer to see one of my kids learn code rather than home economics or worse still religion, if you want people to be prolific at a subject bring it in to secondary school, plus there’s only so many times you can do word and excel Microsoft basically sponsor the little bit of IT in schools

    Reply
  • Barry 10/10/12 #

    IT skills amongst teachers in schools was shocking when i went to school,

    Teacher couldn’t type for crap and knew nothing about the computers yet he was our computer teacher, he used to give us stuff to type which was supposed to last us 40min but half of us would have it finished in 5min as we could type properly.

    Reply
    • The basic problem was that those with an aptitude and/or the skills for programming tended to become programmers, not teachers. Teaching wasn’t an attractive option. The stereotypical teacher wasn’t seen to be a technical person. The Irish school system favoured humanities overheard sciences. Now the Job market is very different, but there are not enough available Tesching positions to bring in People with the necessarily skills. Maybe an answer would be, for a certain percentage of positions, to not view teaching as a”job for life”, but as something other professions do for a 5-10 year period. Get the real-world skills into the classroom.

      Reply
    • I have no idea why Barry is receiving so many red thumbs – what he says is true.

      I had some great lecturers in college in IT related subjects. These were people who had worked (or still worked) in the industry and had superb experience. Whereas in school we had teachers who hadn’t worked in the industry and were similar to what Barry describes.

      Perhaps the best option would be to have individuals from the IT sector teach one day a week in schools.

      Reply
    • As teacher would say, ” When finished, use the remaining time to check back over your work Barry.”

      Reply
    • Mick 10/10/12 #

      I like your ideas Nikolas…keep them coming

      Reply
    • Z? 10/10/12 #

      @ Ryan : red thumbs = indignant permanent and pensionable teachers

      Reply
  • Serious computers on the picture, where did they get them from, back to the future? :-)

    Reply
    • Tesco’s ran a scheme “computers for school” – spend x amount and get tokens to give the school. I participated myself for a few yeaes. I don’t know how successful it actually was but I’m sure every little helped!

      Reply
  • Teachers teaching Facebook!!!! Love it

    Reply
  • They haven’t a clue. I worked in a school and every day teachers came to me saying their computer or printer didn’t work., 99 per cent of the time they never even bothered to plug them in. When they did they couldn’t use them.

    Reply

Add New Comment