TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Irish universities fail to make Top 100 list

Neither made the Top 100 but who came out on top between TCD and UCD?

Trinity College Dublin
Trinity College Dublin
Image: atbellew via Flickr/Creative Commons

IRELAND’S UNIVERSITIES HAVE failed to break back into the Top 100 of the Times Higher Education World University Rankings.

It wasn’t all bad news for Trinity College Dublin as the school managed to climb seven places to 110, an improvement on last year’s result.

However, University College Dublin (UCD) did not fare as well as its position dropped considerably from 159th to 187th with a score of less than 48. The colleges are rated across a number of core categories, including teaching, research, knowledge transfer and international outlook.

University College Cork and NUI Galway were much further down the list, being placed in the 301 to 350 category. NUI Maynooth was in the next grouping down, while DCU and University of Limerick failed to make the Top 400.

The placings will come as a disappointment for many schools which were previously seen among the most prestigious in the world. Trinity had held onto 76th position in 2010 and had previously been regarded as one of the Top 50 universities by the system.

On top again this year, with a score of 95.5, is California Institute of Technology in the US, beating out Oxford and Stanford which share second place. Oxford jumped two spots to push Harvard back to fourth position.

The US continues to dominate the rankings, claiming 76 of the Top 200 placings, while Asian universities, especially in the Republic of Korea, Singapore, Taiwan and China, performed well.

Earlier: No major changes for Irish colleges in latest University rankings>

Read next:

Comments (49 Comments)

  • I hope this doesn’t interfere with our thriving graduate export industry.

    Reply
  • Come on people! 1) we are a tiny speck of a country on the tip of Europe. 2) country-wise we are rated 15/16 country in the world. Being just behind countries like USA, China, Germany, UK, etc. is a decent result. Especially with the oul recession an’ all. ;-) Don’t sweat the statistics!!!

    Reply
  • Our degrees are worth plenty and are well recognised abroad or 10s of thousands of irish would be getting skilled migrant visas. Work abroad expos wouldnt be snapping us up either.

    Reply
  • i bet they’d be right up there on pay, i would love to compare wages with the top 10 colleges and we’d beat them there!

    Reply
    • No, no we wouldn’t. I work beside Stanford and I can tell you for a fact, they’re making more than their UCD/TCD counterparts.

      Reply
    • I wouldn’t bet your house on that – its riskier than expecting a house sale in 2012 Ireland.
      Everyone presumes the Irish earn more than everyone else. Irish lecturers are the most productive in the world in terms of the research they put through.
      You should try putting some faith in your country some time. You might surprise yourself.

      Reply
    • Xadovan 03/10/12 #

      From the US anyway

      Top Private Universities in Faculty Salaries for Full Professors, 2011-12

      Average Salary
      1. Harvard University $198,400
      2. Columbia University $197,800
      2. University of Chicago $197,800
      4. Stanford University $195,400
      5. Princeton University $193,800
      6. New York University $182,400
      7. University of Pennsylvania $181,600
      8. Yale University $180,400
      9. Duke University $175,300
      10. California Institute of Technology $172,800
      Top Public Universities in Pay for Full Professors, 2011-12

      Average Salary
      1. New Jersey Institute of Technology $166,600
      2. University of California at Los Angeles $162,600
      3. University of California at Berkeley $154,000
      4. University of Michigan at Ann Arbor $148,800
      5. Rutgers University at Newark $146,000
      6. Rutgers University at New Brunswick $145,000
      7. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill $144,000
      8. University of Maryland at Baltimore$142,600
      9. University of Texas at Dallas $142,400
      10. Rutgers University at Camden $141,800

      http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/04/09/aaup-releases-faculty-salary-data

      Reply
    • Key words in that are “Top Private Universities”.

      Salaries in public universities are lower ($120,955), and the average across all private universities is also lower ($162,561). Source: http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/04/09/aaup-releases-faculty-salary-data

      And by God, comparing Stanford to TCD/UCD. At least we aim high!

      Reply
    • A professor is a very senior lecturer in a university. So when you say average salary for a professor it’s a bit misleading. Pay scales for Irish Universities and IT’s
      http://arrow.dit.ie/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1036&context=aaschsslarts

      Reply
  • Is anybody out there aware of the academic level of our students in comparison to these top universities?? Junior certificate papers in Ireland are Equivalent to leaving certain level in the US!!! Our society is certainly not full of alcoholic “dense people” we as a country have a strict education system based on the fact that we are quite capable, if we were to lower our standards I’m sure our universities would be right up there, however education in Ireland is not based on competition it’s Quality over quantity.

    Reply
    • How can the junior cert be the equivalent of something that does not exist? The US education system is decentralized and standardized testing for graduation is a relatively new thing and not all states use them.

      Reply
    • Are you serious Niamh? I don’t think you know much about the US educational system, where high school students can take optional AP courses – the equivalent of University courses. We need to stop comparing the worst parts of the US system to the best of ours.

      Reply
    • well for having studied in France and in Ireland I found that the academic level in Ireland is far below France. That being said most of our excellent universities in France failed to makd the top 100 which makes me think: who makss and on what criteria is made this ranking?

      Reply
    • Niamh, I wouldn’t be so critical of the American education system. I’ve met a lot of smart people over here. For years I’ve heard people say how better Irish education is but I don’t think it’s true.

      Reply
  • Aoife just FYI those ridiculous college rating systems have little to do with the academic abilities or value for education of its students. It’s all politics and money. Trust.

    Reply
  • mike 03/10/12 #

    Doesn’t surprise me. About 1 in 3 lectures I had in university had a poor grasp of the subjects they taught. If they were pushed to stray even slightly from their prepared slides they got confused.

    Reply
  • Huge difference between these results and QS rankings. You gotta question both their methods with that level of inconsistency.

    Reply
  • Taking a more positive view, relative to countries of a similar size we actually haven’t done too badly.

    These surveys are based on lots of things including research revenue and lots of areas where scale matters. This makes it tough for universities in smaller countries.

    Reply
    • Funding as well. Free fees is a great thing for equality within society, but a lot of the American universities are a lot better resourced. Irish universities do well with what they have.

      Reply
  • UL is still class!

    Reply
  • I don’t think any of Irish university students would fare well on University Challenge – majority of them wouldn’t even understand the questions. The quality of students entering university here is very low despite their 6 and 7 A1′s in Leaving Cert. The marks are hyped up and are not a fair assessment of students’ abilities. Primary and secondary schools must be made to improve their standards if our universities are ever to have a chance of getting back into the top 100.

    Reply
  • @kerry. I should have stayed in school. I like many have voted Labour, FF, FG and PDs. I am a very unintelligent person. I know.

    Reply
  • This ranking is not based on quality of education, but ranks universities facilities and PR teams more likely. Russian st. Petersburg or Polish Warsaw uni are not even in top 200 while they are in top of the all time winners for world team programming contest (acm) – just to name one…Average low skilled person in most east european countries is able to give right answer for what is 3+5×2 or is able to tell you square are of the room if they measure the walls, try that on same random group of people in some countries who are much higher up all these educational rankings.

    Reply
  • Who gives a shit. Trinity has been living on past glories for years now. Thousands of Irish out here in Oz and the US working away with 3rd level education from lessor unis. Our tradesmen are the most sought after by oversees employers. I have been away from Ireland for 10 years but I hear they are coming out of collage and working in mc donalds. Nothing wrong with it just 7 years ago it was only a job for the Poles and Asians. How we have fallen hard :-(

    Reply
  • @Frank2521: Reading the following that you posted I’d guess at a push you must be a Labour voter?

    Why are so many American teachers and lecturers here – because the wages and pensions are so high. One I spoke to said her husband could afford to give up him job as the combined income in the US was much less than her salary here.

    Reply
  • hmm did reilly go this b.a. in b.s. from one of our university’s ?

    Reply
  • Why are so many American teachers and lecturers here – because the wages and pensions are so high. One I spoke to said her husband could afford to give up him job as the combined income in the US was much less than her salary here. Also the leaving cert system has been dumbed down to suit the Labour aganda. The dumber you are and the less well educated you are the greater chance you will vote Labour. Check the history of UK and Ireland Quinn will do his utmost to reduce teachers and increase class sizes plus change the inter Cert and the leaving cert. I despair at our future prospects and the future of education in Ireland.

    Reply
  • This is an exercise in PR and nothing more !! Who funds this type of study and what are the categories colleges are assessed on! Somehow I don’t think it will be unbiased or objective !!

    Reply
  • Well done university of Cape Town. 103. Beat loads of er First world universities! Just saying like

    Reply
  • TCD ranked 110 & UCD ranked 187
    I don’t believe that our colleges are ‘bad’ it’s just that some of the top ranking US colleges are light years ahead in teaching methods, knowledge transfer and outlook. The speed at which they are advancing their methods and results is leaving our colleges standing still. It’s a resources and a mind-set issue. Time for change.

    Reply
  • These university rankings are more based on money and funding than anything else. I wouldn’t pay much heed to them.

    Reply

Add New Comment