#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 11°C Wednesday 25 May 2022

Police defend their handling of the Ashya King case as questions mount

A judge in Spain has detained the 5-year-old’s parents for a further 72 hours.

Brett King with Ashya
Brett King with Ashya
Image: Screengrab

POLICE IN ENGLAND have defended their handling of the Ashya King case as sympathy mounts for the 5-year-old and his family.

A Spanish judge has today extended the detention of Ashya’s parents who were arrested for taking their seriously ill son out of a hospital in England without medical consent.

Brett and Naghemeh King sparked an international manhunt after removing their son Ashya, who has a brain tumour, from hospital last week over fears that he was not receiving the right care.

The couple were detained on a European Arrest Warrant in Spain on Saturday and their son, who only recently underwent surgery and requires special feeding equipment, has been hospitalised in southern Spain.

Spain Britain Missing Boy Ashya King's parents' lawyer talks to the media outside the National Court in Madrid earlier today. Source: AP/Press Association Images

At a hearing in Madrid, the Kings refused to agree to their extradition back to Britain and were ordered to be held in custody for another 72 hours pending a decision on whether they should be granted bail.

The judge also ordered an urgent medical report into the condition of Ashya, who is being held under police guard in a hospital in Malaga and was said to be stable.

Criticism of the police

At home in Britain, the case has received widespread media attention, initially focused on concern for King’s immediate health, which police had said was threatened by his parents’ actions.

Following assurances by his family in videos posted on YouTube that he is being cared for properly, the concern has shifted to sympathy for the family’s plight — and anger at their pursuit by police.

Source: Naveed King/YouTube

Echoing remarks made on social media, King’s grandmother said the family were being “treated like criminals”, while a local British politician said the boy’s parents should be released immediately.

Prime Minister David Cameron, who lost his six-year-old disabled son Ivan in 2009, said the priority was to ensure that Ashya receives the most appropriate medical care.

His spokesman added:

Of course, I am sure that every parent wants to do the best for their child. That is probably the most human of human instincts.

‘Criminalised for caring’

Brett King, 51, wants his son to undergo proton beam therapy, an alternative to radiotherapy treatment which he was not offered under Britain’s National Health Service (NHS).

In a video filmed shortly before his arrest, King said he was threatened with a court order that could have denied him and his wife access to their son in hospital, because he kept raising concerns about his treatment.

Source: Naveed King/YouTube

“We couldn’t take it any more,” he said of his decision to remove Ashya from hospital and take him and his five siblings first to France and then to Spain.

British police issued a European warrant based around “neglect”, although it is not clear what, if anything, the Kings would be charged with on their return to Britain.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

“Ashya King’s parents have been criminalised for caring”, headlined one comment piece in The Guardian newspaper on Monday, while another in The Daily Telegraph said the family’s treatment was “an authoritarian disgrace”.


Hampshire Police, the southern English force which led the manhunt, has defended its actions and the local elected police and crime commissioner, Simon Hayes, said they had acted properly.

“I think if Hampshire Constabulary had ignored the professional medical advice and opinion, then they would have been negligent in their responsibilities to safeguard Ashya in this case and young children in general,” he told BBC radio.

Missing Ashya King Hampshire Constabulary Assistant Chief Constable Chris Shead Source: PA Wire/Press Association Images

The boy’s grandmother, Patricia King, said his parents and siblings had not been able to see him since the arrest, saying the situation was “absolutely disgraceful”.

“They (the authorities) are the ones who are cruel because they have taken poor little Ashya who is dying of a brain tumour and they won’t let the parents, my son and daughter-in-law, they won’t let them see him at all,” she told the BBC.

The hospital treating Ashya said it had offered the family access to a second opinion on his treatment and offered to help with organising treatment abroad.

- © AFP, 2014

Originally posted 17:37

Read: Police issue European arrest warrant for parents > 

Read: Parents of missing boy to appear before Spanish judge tomorrow > 

About the author:


Read next: