Skip to content
#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Image: Shutterstock/PixieMe

Car crash compensation claim thrown out as judge says evidence was "unbelievable"

The judge also said he found the man to be “guarded and defensive”.
Feb 6th 2017, 7:30 PM 48,805 45

THE MOTOR INSURANCE Bureau of Ireland will use all its investigative resources to help stamp out fraudulent insurance claims, the bureau’s chief executive David Fitzgerald said today.

The MIBI declaring war on unwarranted cases arising from suspicious accidents followed the decision by Circuit Civil Court Judge Karen Fergus to throw out a €60,000 claim by Michael Robinson, Broadlough View, Greenhill Road, Wicklow.

Robinson, a back seat passenger in a car driven by John Connors, Ocean View, Ballyguile, Wicklow, claimed his lower back had been injured when Connors’s car struck a bridge between Rathdrum and Laragh in March 2015.

After forensic collision investigator Tony Kelly told the court that Connors’s car had “been driven, rolled or manoeuvred” to its resting position after the accident, Judge Fergus dismissed the case.


She told barrister Conor Kearney, who appeared with solicitors Stephen MacKenzie and Company for the MIBI, that she did not believe Robinson’s evidence that he and two others had sat in the car “and did not talk at all” for more than half an hour until the gardaí arrived at the scene.

Judge Fergus said the accident had not happened in the manner in which the plaintiff said it had. The position of the vehicle after the accident was inconsistent with the position of the accident and the vehicle may have been moved afterwards.

“I found the plaintiff to be guarded and defensive and I find his evidence that he and others sat in complete silence in the vehicle for over half an hour to be unbelievable,” Judge Fergus said.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

Judge Fergus said that when the investigating garda had arrived he had taken photos on his own phone camera of the scene and the resting position of the vehicle.

“I wish to commend the actions of the garda for taking photos on his own camera and I wish this practice to be rolled out as a recommendation in the future,” Judge Fergus said.

She awarded the MIBI’s legal costs against Robinson.

Following the case a statement on behalf of the Chief Executive of the MIBI, David Fitzgerald, was issued by Jimmy Healy, senior vice president of Teneo Strategy.

Read: Man who filmed himself sexually assaulting pregnant girlfriend jailed>

Send a tip to the author

Ray Managh


    Back to top