This site uses cookies to improve your experience and to provide services and advertising. By continuing to browse, you agree to the use of cookies described in our Cookies Policy. You may change your settings at any time but this may impact on the functionality of the site. To learn more see our Cookies Policy.
OK
Dublin: 7 °C Tuesday 10 December, 2019
Advertisement

Convicted murderer Wayne Dundon appeals his life sentence for the shooting of Roy Collins

Dundon and Killeen had been handed mandatory life sentences for the murder of the businessman.

The family of murdered businessman Roy Collins after conviction of Wayne Dundon and Nathan Killeen.
The family of murdered businessman Roy Collins after conviction of Wayne Dundon and Nathan Killeen.
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

NOTORIOUS LIMERICK CRIMINAL Wayne Dundon has opened an appeal against his conviction for the murder of innocent businessman Roy Collins in Limerick eight years ago.

Wayne Dundon (39), of Lenihan Avenue, Prospect and Nathan Killeen (27) of Hyde Road, Prospect, in Limerick had pleaded not guilty at the non-jury Special Criminal Court to the murder of Roy Collins at Coin Castle Amusements, Roxboro on 9 April 2009.

Collins, a 35-year-old father of two, who was engaged to be married, died in hospital a short time after he was shot.

The three-judge Special Criminal Court found Wayne Dundon had ordered the murder from prison and that Killeen was the getaway driver for the gunman, James Dillon.

The deceased’s father, Steve Collins, was believed to have been the intended target of the murder, due to his involvement in a previous successful prosecution against Dundon for a threat to kill.

Following a 29-day trial, Wayne Dundon and Killeen were found guilty of the murder. Justice Iseult O’Malley, presiding, spent almost two hours outlining the three-judge court’s reasons before delivering its verdict.

Accordingly, Wayne Dundon and Killeen were given mandatory life sentences.

Appeal

Opening an appeal against conviction today, Dundon’s barrister, Remy Farrell SC, said the Special Criminal Court’s judgment failed to engage in an analysis of the controversies in the case, failed to deal with specific inconsistencies in accounts given by prosecution witnesses and failed to deal with specific factual issues.

Evidence against Dundon came from witness testimony in the trial, with a number of former associates of Dundon and Killeen testifying against them. These were siblings Gareth Collins aka Keogh, Lisa Collins and April Collins – who were not members of the deceased’s family – along with Dundon’s cousins, Christopher McCarthy and Anthony ‘Noddy’ McCarthy.

Central to the defence’s case, Farrell said, was clear and explicit evidence of collusion between ‘Noddy’ McCarthy and other witnesses.

Anti Crime Protests Thousands of people took part in a protest rally in Limerick today, organised by the Collins family, against gangland crime. Source: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

But the trial court simply asserted, he said, that it had decided to rely on the uncorroborated testimony of ‘Noddy’ McCarthy without indicating how the controversies had been resolved.

He said ‘Noddy’ McCarthy measured up very poorly when one considered an Innocence Canada report on “jailhouse informers”. It was very easy to make an assertion but virtually impossible to disprove.

The approach of the Special Criminal Court on this issue was “truly startling”, he said, because it suggested that, while this was interesting, the trial court would not consider it in the absence of evidence.

The trial court seemed to think it was up to the defence to establish how the Canadian judicial system treated jailhouse informers, he said.

Farrell said an appeal court would have no difficulty quashing a decision of the Refugee Appeal’s Tribunal, for example, if that body had identified a whole series of controversies and failed to grapple with them.

Farrell said he took issue with the Special Criminal Court’s treatment of prosecution witnesses as not being accomplices in law.

Allegations

He alleged that they were chargeable persons arising out of the same set of facts. It was patent on the evidence that “each and every one of them” committed the offence of withholding information, he alleged.

He said the McCarthy and Collins families had been engaged in discussions amongst themselves about what benefits were going to be “reaped” and the trial court’s judgment was “manifestly defective” in failing to deal with any of those issues.

Farrell said the defence applied for a direction to find his client not guilty on the substantive issue as well as on the lack of a proper garda investigation. It was notable, he said, that the court never dealt with the latter application.

Counsel for the DPP, Michael O’Higgins SC, said Dundon’s lawyers had made a lot of points but most of them simply did not “stack up”.

O’Higgins said the case was brought on the basis that ‘Noddy’ McCarthy heard Wayne Dundon in a prison cell across the corridor threatening James Dillon and commanding him to do something over a phone.

Steve Collins Anti Crime Protests Sister of murdered Roy Collins, Leanne, father Stephen and mother Carmel, console each other at a protest rally in Limerick. Source: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

If that call was proved to be a direction to murder a member of the Collins family then the case came down to a “very narrow” issue – whether ‘Noddy’ McCarthy was telling the truth.

O’Higgins said the Special Criminal Court summarised the witness’ testimony in its judgment “warts and all”. Farrell was submitting, counsel said, that there was a bit missing in the middle about why the court ignored the warts.

It was simply not sustainable for Wayne Dundon to claim, when looking at the judgment, that he did not know how he found himself in this position, O’Higgins said.

He said the Special Criminal Court believed ‘Noddy’ McCarthy as it was entitled to do.

Mr O’Higgins will continue making submissions before Justice George Birmingham, Mr Justice Alan Mahon and Mr Justice John Edwards tomorrow.

Read: Wayne Dundon and Nathan Killeen given mandatory life sentences >

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

About the author:

Ruaidhrí Giblin

Read next:

COMMENTS