Skip to content
#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
On the Western Front at Verdun, France, in 1916.
On the Western Front at Verdun, France, in 1916.
Image: Topham Picturepoint/Press Association Images

"They died for nothing": WW1 'revisionism' criticised

The Irish Anti-War movement have criticised ‘idealised’ versions of the First World War.
Aug 6th 2014, 6:45 AM 13,510 90

THE IRISH ANTI-War Movement (IAWM) yesterday hit out at what it called a “revisionist narrative idealising the ‘good cause’ that these soldiers died for”.

Speaking at a IAWM press conference, independent TD Clare Daly said: “In our opinion, they died for nothing. This was not a noble cause. This was a struggle for markets and political power.”

We are in no way denigrating those ordinary people who died in the conflict, many of them were victims of poverty driven into the British army out of having no alternative.

The press conference was part of the launch of a booklet of essays entitled ‘World War 1: What did they die for?’ The booklet contains contributions from Steve Woods, John Molyneux, Jim Roche and Raymond Deane writing about narratives that have emerged in relation to the First World War.

Also speaking at the conference was Irish artist and anti-war activist Robert Ballagh. On the commemorations, Ballagh called for the reduction of military participation, saying:

With the commemorations that have happened so far, it seems to me that all the generals and all the military people have been polishing up their buttons and their medals. Medals that they got for killing people, let’s be pretty frank about that.

The artist went on to ask: “When did we abandon neutrality? There certainly wasn’t a debate in parliament. There wasn’t a vote in parliament. We are now so closely aligned with NATO, with all the imperial powers in Europe, we are not a neutral country anymore.”

Throughout the conference, parallels were drawn between the First World War and the ongoing conflict in Gaza. Speaking in response to a question from,  President of the Irish Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament said:

“One of the principles of the just war theory which is enshrined in international law is principle of propotionality. And that has been ignored. That has been completely ignored.”

Also speaking at the launch was former MEP Patricia McKenna and IAWM representatives Jim Roche and John Molyneux.

What do you think of the contention that the slain soldiers of World War I “died for nothing”? Do you agree?

Poll Results:

Yes (1476)
No (1001)
I don't know (208)

READ: Margaretta D’Arcy to be released from Limerick Prison

READ: Irish anti-war activists to hold meeting ahead of planned protest

Send a tip to the author

Michael Sheils McNamee


This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
write a comment

    Leave a comment

    cancel reply
    Back to top