Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now
Wednesday 1 February 2023 Dublin: 6°C
Knee Defender/ Gadget Duck The Knee Defender - fair or no?
# upright position
This gadget prevents plane seat in front of you from reclining…
…But is it fair to use it?

FOR AIR TRAVELLERS who hate having their scarce legroom invaded by reclining seats, there is a solution that goes beyond asking fellow passengers to remain upright: forcing them to do so.

The Knee Defender is a gadget that uses two small pieces of plastic (just a bit bigger than a house key), which are clipped on to the arms holding up the tray table. If they are placed snugly against the seat back, that seat is blocked from reclining, keeping the users’ knees safe.

The little gadget was invented by Ira Goldman, a 6ft 4ins resident of Washington, DC, USA who put it on the market in 2003, according to ABC.

It has been generating controversy ever since.

In the debate between those who defend their right to recline their seats and those who think everyone should remain upright, which was re-ignited by a passionate Dan Kois at Slate on Tuesday of this week, the Knee Defender is the ultimate weapon for the upright contingent.

Except when it’s not allowed.

The gadget does not violate any FAA regulations (it can’t be used during taxi, takeoff, and landing, when the tray must be upright), but airlines have the right to forbid its use. Northwest, American, and Continental Airlines have done so, according to the Globe and Mail.

The Knee Defender is on sale via GadgetDuck, for $19.95.

Here’s a 2007 video produced by FareCompare (featuring an elf and Santa Clause) showing how it works:

via farecompareblog/Youtube

Do you think it is fair to use the gadget on a plane?

Poll Results:

No, it's not fair on the person in front (2813)
Yes, I'd use it (2316)
I don't know (1144)
I avoid flying (203)

- Alex Davies

Published with permission from
Business Insider
Your Voice
Readers Comments