TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 7 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Conference calls for tobacco tax hikes across Europe

A three-day international summit gets underway in Dublin this morning.

Image: ORLIN WAGNER/AP/Press Association Images

A MAJOR INTERNATIONAL conference is in Dublin today calling on European governments to impose even bigger taxes on cigarettes and other tobacco products.

Hosted by the Irish Heart Foundation and the Irish Cancer Society, the European Smoke Free Partnership is pushing for tobacco taxes to be used as the “chief weapon” in reducing smoking rates.

The TobTaxy workshop aims to gather a “powerful group of NGOs and senior public servants” to advocate for such taxes which its proponents believe will reduce the huge death toll and chronic illness caused by smoking.

International evidence proves that tobacco tax increases are the most effective method of reducing smoking rates, said Michael O’Shea, chief executive of the Irish Heart Foundation.

The charity’s own research shows that a €1 increase in tax on a 20-pack of cigarettes could result in some 30,000 people quitting smoking in Ireland. This would result in 15,000 fewer deaths, it said.

About 5,700 people die every year from smoking.

We have a crazy situation where the Department of Finance decides tax policy purely from a revenue-raising standpoint ignoring the health cost – which at €14.7 billion over the next 10 years is far less than the €23 billion associated with the cost of treating smoking related illness.

Irish Cancer Society CEO John McCormack also argued that it is crucial tobacco tax is seen primarily as a public health issue.

Our current tax-take does not pay for the healthcare costs associated with smoking yet the tobacco industry continues to make healthy profits. Only 78 per cent of the price of cigarettes goes to Government, the remaining 22 per cent is pure profit for tobacco companies. This is a situation that is unique to Ireland. In the UK, the Government takes 90 per cent of the price of cigarettes so the profit margin for the tobacco industry is smaller.

The link between tax increases and smuggling rates, which is propagated by the tobacco industry, will also be discussed throughout the summit.

Both the Irish Cancer Society and Irish Health Foundation believe the link to be tenuous – or false.

“We need to increase the tax Government places on cigarettes and if the tobacco industry seriously thinks that this will increase black market sales then they can always reduce their profit margin to keep price lower,” said McCormack.

A government order to the tobacco industry to make some contribution to the costs they impose on the Irish health service has also been suggested.

The Irish Cancer Society said a study has showed the imposition of a special rate of 25 per cent corporation tax on profits in Ireland is feasible.

Read next:

Comments (31 Comments)

  • Did a rough calculation over my years of smoking at 8.65 a pack over 7yrs and a 78% take from government just over €17000, yes I do agree a astronomical figure and one many could argue could be better spent elsewhere. However the argument that a euro increase would not increase the amount of people goin to the black market, I disagree with, many of my friends have gone that route since they we’re increased since the last budget.

    Reply
  • A one euro hike will not stop people smoking. it will lead to cigarette smuggling increasing. People will still get their fix nicotine addictive! Twenty smokes in Spain three euro. twenty here nine. . . The Eu needs to have tobacco priced the same in Europe. Six euro a pack in every country would be a start!

    Reply
  • Up 20/02/12 #

    Everything should have VAT and nothing else, all the double and triple taxes on certain items should not be allowed, whether thats tobacco, vrt, petrol/diesel etc it should not matter. If they really don’t want people to smoke then make cigarettes illegal, they have no problem making good things like Hemp illegal, why? because the hemp plant looks like the marijuana plant, Hemp doesn’t make you high for the people you think its the same as marijuana. It can be used to make paper/clothes/shoes/fuel and lots of other things not to mention the health benifits. http://www.naturalnews.com/031334_hemp_seeds_nutrition.html

    Reply
  • I wish these guys would just F.ck off.

    Reply
  • Alan.V 20/02/12 #

    How stupid are these so called experts?
    Put the prices up and people will smoke illegal tobacco where there is no regulation. Then your treating people without the profits or income from tax.

    These x-smokers and anti-smoker’s should back the hell off. How come they never tell us what the revenue figures are from smokers, bet its a hell of a lot more then what it costs to treat them.

    Reply
  • Donna 20/02/12 #

    I think that even cigarettes high taxes will not stop smokers from lighting their cigs. Interesting post. Thanks http://www.smokersworld.info/

    Reply
  • jimbo 20/02/12 #

    Damhsa Dmf lol! iwas trying out the new swipe keypad and as you can see its crap,along with my mobile browser,all fixed now
    so lets have a smoke and move on lol!

    Reply
  • jimbo 20/02/12 #

    Another week another piece of need with more hikes

    Reply
  • Well smoking is bad for you along with drinking, taking drugs, having children, being married and everything else depending on what day of the week it is… well folks we are all going to die… But it pleases me greatly that at some stage the health Nazis will one day be laying in bed dying of nothing at all :-) … How embarrassing for them!

    Reply
  • jimbo 20/02/12 #

    Another week and more news of tax hikes

    Reply
    • Showing a little OCD there Jimbo :)
      High time people quit that disgusting expensive habit anyway, I stopped nearly a yr ago and would never touch another, the smell alone helps confirm my decision now, let those that want to continue poison and degrade their health pay for it. It costs us more in the long run treating the aliments than the amount of revenue brought in from taxes.

      Reply
    • @ Damhsa You’re one of those ex-smokers, the worst kind, who ridicules those who still smoke. Its great that you quit but keep your bashing to yourself.

      Reply
    • Chris 20/02/12 #

      @Ian dont think he was “bashing” anyone? These are all facts, smoking places a massive burden on the Irish healthcare system. Why should non-smokers pay for the stupidity of others? Taxes probably barely cover the amount spent on treating people with smoking related diseases.

      The same can be said for overweight people, which is why I am I’m theory in favour of some sort of tax on sugar.

      By the way, I smoke

      Reply
    • @Chris – If someone crashes a car tomorrow and is hospitalised, are you saying it would be unfair if your a non-driver? That is want the Public Health Service is for, you can’t just pick a choose who get treated..

      Reply
    • Chris 20/02/12 #

      Dude, I think driving cars and smoking are completely different things, for on driving is actually a positive thing. Getting people from a to b and what not..smoking has no positives!!

      There are laws in place governing driving, speed etc which are enforced to minimize accidents. There are no such laws for smoking so one way of reducing the negative impact is tax

      Reply
  • Simply put if the powers that be wanted to they could make tabaco illegal. But then that would kick off the big tabaco company’s. And they would lose alot of easy tax money. I’m suprised they don’t legalise hash and triple it’s tax.

    BTW I’m off the smokes 9 months but still enjoy my nicoteen via a 98% less harmfully way that’s also much cheaper

    Reply
  • I want out of this nanny state Europe.To a place where people are free to choose their own lifestyles.

    Reply
  • Tobacco should be taxed out of existance

    Reply
  • Smokers should sign a waiver giving up such state care, that might reduce some smoking,

    Reply
  • jimbo 20/02/12 #

    @dahmsa dmf did once say I smoked?think your the one with ICS..

    Reply
    • I never implied you did, Christ…. You took 3 attempts to get this out….
      “Another week and more news of tax hikes” and I jokingly said you may have a small bit of OCD there.
      I retract it all entirely as its clearly a sore Monday round here.

      Reply

Add New Comment