TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

ABP Food Group “bitterly disappointed” by Coveney horsemeat statement

Also today, QK Meats apologised for not contacting the Department of Agriculture about horsemeat found at its plant last year.

Horseshoe prints
Horseshoe prints
Image: Keith Srakocic/AP/Press Association Images

AS THE HORSEMEAT scandal continues, two food companies have commented on yesterday’s report from the Minister for Agriculture, Simon Coveney.

QK Meats has stated that it never knowingly incorporated horsemeat into beef, while the ABP Food Group described itself as “bitterly disappointed” by Minister Coveney’s statement to Dáil Eireann yesterday and certain references to the company in his report.

Its statement, ABP Group said that it operates “to the very highest standards of management and governance, but the controls in the case of Silvercrest let the company down”.

The company has already apologised to its customers and stakeholders for these shortcomings. It described itself as “the victim of the wide-scale European equine fraud” and said the cost “has been considerable” but that it has acted since the emergence of this issue:

in an entirely appropriate fashion, having co-operated fully with the Minister’s Department; implemented the voluntary withdrawal of 10 million burgers from the market; suspended production at Silvercrest; as well as the other operational changes the company has already outlined. In particular, at an early point the Group disbanded the frozen division that Silvercrest reported into.

The company does welcome the acknowledgement in the report that its plant at Nenagh was not the source of the meat containing equine DNA in a bolognese product sold in the UK.

ABP Food Group said it also finds yesterday’s report regarding another Irish food company, QK Meats, “extraordinary”.

QK Meats

It emerged yesterday that QK meats tested for horse DNA in June 2012, and got positive results. Minister for Agriculture Simon Coveney said yesterday that certain practices by Silvercrest and QK Cold Stores (QK Meats) were “totally unacceptable”.

QK Meats said today that the quality and safety of its products is of the utmost importance to it, and that it “has an exemplary record in terms of food quality and safety standards”.

QK Meats said today that it has been cooperating closely with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine in its investigation into the horsemeat issue, and continues to assist the department.

QK Meats has never knowingly incorporated horsemeat into any of its beef products.

It said that in 2012, QK Meats had purchased a number of beef consignments from fully approved EU licensed suppliers in Poland. Following concern about a batch of product in June 2012, the company introduced a system of testing.

Any product that tested positive was immediately isolated and either returned to the supplier or detained in quarantine at our premises. QK Meats can categorically state that it did not introduce any product that tested positive into the food chain.
The actions we took at the time, we believed were correct, in compliance with our regulatory obligations and fully protected the public interest by ensuring the product did not enter the food chain.
We believe that we acted in good faith in dealing with the matters as they arose. The Minister has confirmed today that QK Meats has broken no laws. As events subsequently transpired however, it is now clear that our actions fell short, specifically in not contacting the Department sooner. We have apologised to the Department for this, deeply regret it and any breach of trust which it has caused given our commitment to food quality and safety.

QK Meats concluded that it has launched a full investigation into all events surrounding the issue and “will take every step possible to restore confidence in the robustness of our systems and procedures”.

Read: ‘We have a right to expect better’ – Coveney on the horsemeat saga>

Read next:

Comments (31 Comments)

  • Do they not think that the people of Ireland are disappointed with them, what they did was for GREED, they did not give a flying !!!!! about the Irish farmer or economy once they made there buck.

    Reply
    • Don’t worry about it Pat the case against these boyos is building all the time ……..it’s only a matter of time before the farmers organise what will probably be the largest class action in the history of the State …….. I have to say the I.F.A.’s total lack of intention to instigate this litigation is a very poor reflection of an organisation that is supposed to protect Farmer’s interests …….. wasn’t it 44 million that they took from farmers last year and they also were raided by the competition authority , or some such quango, over alleged price fixing !

      Reply
    • Drtmot nothing would please me more than to see farmers do exactly that , i don’t think it will ever happen though

      Reply
    • It will happen because the Lawyers will force it to happen …… farmers are the only game left in town for income ………. can the beef barons buy every solicitor in the country ?……….. maybe they can ….but then can they buy every solicitor in England? ……………. not implying they would but it’s the only way they can prevent it …………… it’s just delayed because most Farmers have never heard of Donoghue versus Stephenson ……….

      Reply
  • “Bitterly disappointed” ,they were found out.

    Reply
    • No bitterly disappointed they were stabbed in back by Simon coveney!

      Reply
    • Doesn’t matter, realising a statement like this just makes them look worse. If they wanted to get back at SC, this wasn’t the way to do it.

      Reply
    • What about QK meats? They did not work with dept of agriculture. They hid what they knew. ABP are great company that employ 8000 people and co-operated and worked with dept. all the way. They were let down by silvercrest and paid the price. Yesterday’s report was unfair to them. Coverage from RTE was biased. The journal has been very fair.

      Reply
    • I take it from your comment that either you or members of your family are employed by ABP. I am old enough to remember the Beef Tribunal and the truly appalling scandals revealed in relation to that Company. With almost criminal forbearance from the Haughey government, and any possible loss underwritten ny the Irish taxpayers. The ‘empire’ having been regained we now see the same slipshod , dishonest practices which almost destroyed the beef industry way back then. Truly, the leopard does mot change his spots.

      Reply
    • Lack of accountability was this countrys downfall, some people just never learn.

      Reply
    • Frankly there’s a reek to high heaven here, and Coveney is carefully sidestepping it, what with national interest and all, Goodman isn’t exactly a saintly figure now is he?

      Reply
    • Patricia Muldoon ABP is Silvercresr, Silvercrest is ABP

      Reply
    • @PatriciaMuldoon – Simon Coveney did exactly the right thing. This company has done untold damage to our industry’s reputation.
      It should be criminally negligent that they can try to distance themselves from their liability by saying ‘controls let them down’ as though the controls were in the hands of a 3rd party.

      Top Management cannot plead ignorance. They must know down to the smallest detail how they are attaining their profit margins. If they know anything about the price of real beef, they at least knew something was not adding up, if not it is also possible they were deliberately mixing in cheap product.

      Coveney should flatten every firm guilty of this and allow the ethical and honest people involved in the industry to compete on a fair playing field not infested by dirty crooks.

      Reply
    • ISBA 16/03/13 #

      Obviously you don’t live in the real world and are not familiar with the history!

      Reply
  • I love that they had nothing to do with it, it was ‘a European wide problem’, same way Fianna Fáil said the collapse of the Irish economy was because of the’European collapse of the markets’. Not bringing politics in this but if you screw the public and get caught just blame the ‘European’ forces and everything will be ok and that is what these companies did. Someone remind me what AIBP did before with Larry Goodman at the helm before he rebranded the same company as AIBP and the tribunal that cost taxpayers millions over the beef.

    Reply
    • And apparently Larry bought the former B.O.I. buildings on Nassau Street for 25 million from nama and as far as I can recall the bill to the taxpayer on that building id 212 million PLUS INTEREST !

      Reply
    • @dermot – the State, ie the people, should be allowed purchase such assets that are written down to such a fraction of their value rather than they be bought up by anyone when Ireland in in firesale mode.

      Why hasn’t Noonan announced a $1bln fund for Ireland to purchase no-brainer property and hold it for a decade?

      We should start a people’s property fund where everyone in the country chips in EUR100 each and we go buy up some of these properties before the media and beef barons get their dirty paws on them for a song.

      It is similar to stealing the wallet of an injured victim of a car crash.

      Reply
  • Sour grapes, nothing more.

    Reply
  • No charlie to the rescue this time.

    Reply
  • sorry they got caught more like it. the money they could have made. shame on them.

    Reply
  • First Ming, and now Goodman, painting themselves as the victim. Gimme a break!

    Reply
  • Rayven 16/03/13 #

    The controls let them down and I suppose the ABP management have some nameless faceless guy in that job where is the fraud squad for fck sake this country need to get a grip

    Reply
  • They bought the cheapest cuts of horse/cow meat they could find. Then mixed in with some real beef and sold it on as a 100% beef. The worst is they knew about and didn’t tell anyone.

    Everyone is forgetting horse meat might have bute in it, which can cause cancer in humans. But as QK meats and slivercreest made a few million who cares. Well done for tesco and anyone else dropping as suppliers.

    If I was minister for agriculture is fine than a few hundred million to pay for all the extra testing and a slap a team of inspectors in the meat factory for a year.

    Stuff your apology QK meats as for slivercrest, what did they want a medal for helping your the inspectors.

    Let’s hope the fraud squad get them in court but as we are waiting on the Anglo case to come up. I can’t see that happening soon.

    Reply
  • That’s it blame everyone else company’s like that ruin it for everyone they never checked what they were producing

    Reply
  • This has probably being going on for quite some time and like most other things in this country f##k all is going to be done about it

    Reply
  • D Moylan 16/03/13 #

    If the journal could replay goodman’s comments shortly after the story broke, it would be helpful to add context, something along the lines that the testing wasn’t helpful, that there’s horse DNA in nearly everything – now that’s a horse of a different colour, neigh?

    Reply
  • A load of “Bull” lads – to little to late enough said.

    Reply
  • Feck that it is costing these companys millions what cost can you put on a life ??

    GOD only knows how many people suffered cancer over there greed , Is there a test for Bute in humans ???

    Reply
  • Too late, horse has burgered!

    Reply

Add New Comment