Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 12 °C Wednesday 23 May, 2012

British bishop convicted of denying Holocaust begins German appeal

Richard Williamson, pictured in 2009. Williamson has begun an appeal against a German conviction for denying the existence of the Holocaust.
Richard Williamson, pictured in 2009. Williamson has begun an appeal against a German conviction for denying the existence of the Holocaust.
Image: Kirsty Wigglesworth/AP

A BRITISH CATHOLIC BISHOP has begun an appeal against a conviction in a German court of denying the Holocaust, claiming he was tricked into saying the comments by a TV interviewer.

Bishop Richard Williamson, known for his traditionalist views and his opposition to the decisions of the Second Vatican Council, was convicted and fined €10,000 by a German court last year for his comments, aired on Swedish TV.

Deutsche Welle says Williamson’s defence team argued that their client did not believe the comments would have been aired in Germany, where denying the Holocaust is a criminal offence.

He was convicted last year in absentia because the clips had made their way online where they were available to a German audience.

Williamson also claims he was asked ‘leading questions’ which led him to make the comments over which he was convicted.

In the interview, Williamson denied the existence of gas chambers and said there was little evidence that the Holocaust had actually taken place.

The number of Jews killed by Germany’s Nazi regime was probably closer to 300,000, he said – lower than the commonly accepted figure of six million.



Williamson is a member of the breakaway Catholic Society of St Pius X, which cut its own ties with Catholicism in 1988.

He has previously been excommunicated from the Church because he was ordained a bishop by a Cardinal unauthorised to do so. He rejected the legitimacy of this excommunication, which was reversed by Pope Benedict two years ago.

Among his other outspoken views are the opposition of women attending university, having a career or wearing trousers. He is also a supporter of authoritarian parenting.

He has previously described Jewish people as the ‘enemies of Christ’.

Read Next:

Comments (20 Comments)

  • Thirsty Gargoyle 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    I’m not sure it’s really fair to describe him as a Catholic bishop without pointing out that the Church has barred him from exercising any episocopal roles unless he disowns his publicly-stated views on the Holocaust. That he is, in effect, suspended from any duties is, I think, something that shouldn’t be glossed over.

    Reply
    • Eddie Barrett 05/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      Wasn’t he reinstated to the Catholic Church by Pope Benedict a couple of years ago ?
      Shame on them !

    • Gavan Reilly 05/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      Thirsty – A fair point, but I chose not include it simply because the formal Church has disowned the society of which he is a part anyway, so they can’t really bar him from duty from a society they don’t control or recognise. Still, I suppose your comment means the fact is there for all to see anyway. :)

    • Thirsty Gargoyle 05/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      He wasn’t really reinstated, Eddie. His excommunication — which had been automatically incurred on ordination, rather than specifically imposed — was lifted, as were those of the other SSPX bishops. The Church is pretty clear that the SSPX ministers — whether bishops, priests, or deacons — have no legitimate ministry in the Church.

  • Thirsty Gargoyle 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    (I’m not disputing that he’s a tosser of the highest order, mind.)

    Reply
  • Spillinksuz 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    That man ‘has to’ deny the Holocaust because that is exactly what the Vatican did to the world for centuries while spreading “the word”..they butchered and made villains of non believers!
    So to recognise one atrocity means recognising their own…and in modern day world, the church have purged thousands of young boys with only the scantiest of apologies….no difference to be honest

    Reply
  • T Saddik 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    I have suspicion and may agree with the bishop that holocaust did not exist

    Reply
  • Report this comment

    Banning Holocaust Denial goes against the principles of freedom of opinion, freedom of speech and freedom of expression. You shouldn’t censor someone’s views because you disagree with them. It seems a little Voltairean, but I’m wholly with the priest on this, however disgusting and unfounded his opinions are.

    Besides, the clip was filmed in Sweden, which makes this all the more ridiculous. Next I’ll be convicted in Iran for airing my own views, which go against Sh’ia Islamic Law.

    Reply
    • Tony Stamper 05/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      Can’t disagree with that. The man’s views are distasteful and disgusting but show them to be wrong.

    • Darren O'Neill 05/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      Its not just an opinion. He is denying a historical fact. Opinions don’t count in that instance.

    • Gary O'Regan 05/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      @Darren O’Neill : I would advise you to research the word “opinion” in a dictionary. An opinion is a subjective belief. Fact does not come into the equation. People do not have to agree with “facts” when being subjective. I am sure an objective spotlight can but placed on this issue. However, in this case it appears to be “opinion”.

      Don’t get me wrong, I do support the general idea of what you are trying to convey. And questioning such events does seem pointless and of bad taste (in my opinion).

    • David Catleugh 07/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      The interview, for Swedish television, actually took place in Germany. He should have recorded it in a country that truly respects freedom of speech.

  • grass Eye 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    It’s the gas chambers that didn’t exist. And the 6million figure is speculative at best.

    Reply
  • Tony Stamper 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    Go to any Mosque in Europe and you will hear people, deny the holocaust. The imam that most European Muslims look to as the leading authority on Islam, including mosques in Ireland, has stated time and time again, that:

    “Throughout history, Allah has imposed upon the (Jews) people who would punish them for their corruption. The last punishment was carried out by Hitler. By means of all the things he did to them – even though they exaggerated this issue – he managed to put them in their place. This was divine punishment for them. Allah willing, the next time will be at the hand of the believers.”

    The Williamson figure is undeniably a bollox of the highest order but he is not the only one. The no. of Imam’s that will ever be charged for advocating a new holocaust, never mind denying the old one will always be very small. Justice should be impartial.

    Reply
  • Ed Kavanagh 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    When will it be an offence for Jews to deny the holocaust of the Palestinian people currently playing out.. The hypocrisy is sickening ..

    Reply
    • Darren O'Neill 05/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      What plant are you on Ed? If you are talking about the issue in Gaza then you need to do a bit more research. If there is any genocide going on in Gaza then it is down to Hamas. Israel have acted at all times in self defense. Israel do not want to partake in this violent and savage attack. However, unlike peaceful Ireland the people of Israel have to live the reality that rockets and missiles are or were a daily event. Over 600 rockets have been fired into Israel since the beginning of this year. Whats sickening to me is ignorance.

    • Tony Stamper 06/07/11 #
      Report this comment

      Darren. Having worked in a Kibbutz (Mishmar HaEmek) for a summer in 1996, I have to say that I came away with two distinct impressions. 1. The Israeli’s are once you get past the tough exterior quiet a lot of fun and 2. They see arabic people as sub-human, not just dislike them because of Hamas but they see them as inferior beings. No doubt the arabs hate them as well but I found it quiet disturbing that a people who have suffered so much could espouse views so freely, it was like picking peppers in 1930′s Germany. Whatever Israel is, it is not a normal western democracy as we know it. It is just the alter ego nation of Syria, Iran etc etc.

  • Alan Aversa 05/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    Bp. Williamson did not deny the Holocaust. How is it anti-Semitic to question how many people, not all of whom were Jews, died in the Holocaust and in what manner they died?

    Reply
  • Ed Kavanagh 06/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    Darren…maybe they should just give them back their country. Please don’t tell me God promised it to them first.

    Reply
  • Sheila Ginsberg 19/07/11 #
    Report this comment

    Read your Bible. Arabs have created propaganda based on lies.There never was a Palestinian nation. It is a creation of Arabs who poured into Israel after Jews returned to the Holy Land and began to develop it.Their large birthrate accounts for the large number of so called Palestinians. Jews have lived here for thousand of years. Find out how many Arabs were on the land in the laate 1800s. Very few. Should we give California to Mexico because large numbers of Mexicans have been born here? All you people who are sympathetic to Tibet should see the parallels. China came into Tibetan land and have transformed its culture. But Tibet belongs to the Tibetans as Israel belongs to the Jewish people.

    Reply

Add New Comment