TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 9 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

Burton calls on banks to do more for struggling mortgage holders

The Minister for Social Protection said that banks and mortgage institutions were not doing enough for people in financial difficulty.

Joan Burton
Joan Burton
Image: Photocall Ireland

THE MINISTER FOR Social Protection has called on the banks to do more to engage with mortgage holders struggling to pay off their debt.

Joan Burton was speaking amid growing calls for mortgage holders in Ireland to be offered some form of debt forgiveness.

New figures due out from the Central Bank tomorrow are expected to show that the number of people in mortgage arrears is rising by 20,000 per year, according to the Sunday Business Post.

Speaking on RTÉ’s This Week programme, Burton acknowledged that families across the country were struggling with mortgage issues and called on the banks to do more on a case-by-case basis.

She said:

I think every family in Ireland knows of some friend or family member who has a mortgage, they’ve lost their employment or they have lost, for instance, overtime or their salary has been cut and they’re finding it hard going.
If you have a lender who’s in distress and you have a bank or an institution which has lent that person money, if the bank wants to get much of their money back and the lender generally wants to try and pay back what they can pay back, the two of them have to sit down and they have to have a discussion about it, and it has to be done on a case-by-case basis.

She said that the National Asset Management Agency had been doing for developers what the banks needed to be doing for ordinary people and said that every mortgage holder who has difficulties needs to be able to approach their bank.

Since the idea was floated by the UCD economist Morgan Kelly nearly a fortnight ago, the idea of writing off mortgages for struggling homeowners has been fiercely debated.

Other economists have described the measure as being an “emergency need” however the government has sought to play down the possibility of introducing such a policy, questioning the cost and justification for it.

Burton said today she did not think “the banks and mortgage institutions are actually engaging sufficiently with people.”

However she insisted the government was already providing significant support to people in the form of €70 million that will be spent this year to help about 18,000 families in distress with their mortgages through mortgage interest supplements.

“We need banks to engage with this and the government is actually providing, through the Money Advice and Budgeting Service, through the community welfare officers, through my department, significant amounts of money,” she added in her interview with RTÉ.

Read: Writing off mortgage debt is an “emergency”>

Read: Morgan Kelly calls for debt forgiveness for struggling mortgage holders>

Read: Government seeks to play down possibility of mortgage relief scheme>

Read next:

Comments (28 Comments)

  • Of course Burton is correct in saying that the state is doing its bit, but the real cost of this Band Aid is falling squarely but unfairly back onto the taxpayer. The recapitalization of the banks provides for worst case mortgage default scenarios. Why on Earth the banks receiving state largesse are not being forced to do much more for distressed mortgages is once again an illustration of the conservative consensus at work that collapsed the economy. The proverbial dogs in the street know that mortgage distress can only worsen over the few years, barring a miracle that bestows full employment on the country, but it seems a nigh on impossible task to get the government to look three years down the road and do something radical on debt forgiveness.

    Reply
  • Yes some people did buy over their means, but not everyone some have lost jobs and are struggling to pay for modest homes
    And i think everyone who is struggling should be helped

    Reply
  • Surely as a Minister , she , The Taoiseach and his Cabinet can ORDER the banks to do this , after all , we all as Citizens own the main ones now !!!
    The usual ambiguity that we get from politicians , I’m afraid !

    Reply
  • mike 28/08/11 #

    The Banks are the why we are in the trouble. Insider trading, fiddling/fraud the books,fixing preices,deception. Need i got on?

    Reply
  • It would have been cheaper to pay off mortgages than the f@@king banks!
    At least it would put some cash back out there, as I am sure the banks had plenty of money the whole time. Lying scumbags

    Reply
  • …some fekin mess I got this country into! I’m a right aul bollix me! If you see me on the street sure give me a good kick up the hole!!!!!!! I deserve it!!!

    Reply
  • it’s neither useful for the home owner to loose their home nor is it useful for any bank to reposes. The home owner doesn’t want to be without a home and the banks are not real estate agents. They have enough bad debt crap on their books and I don’t believe they want to throw people out on the street.

    Those people who are unable to repay their mortgages are not going to be evicted if they are making a reasonable effort to pay something. I mean if they are actively engaging with the banks.

    Why is the media full of debt forgiveness rather than evictions.

    So restructuring the mortgage is 1 million times better than not engaging with the problem.

    Those who will not confront the problem and refuse to speak to the bank are on the road to be kicked out of their home.

    Be wary of the politician that jumps on the bandwagon – she knows right well the country has no money to pay off more debt. Why are labour not supplying solutions – they are the leaders after all

    Reply
  • Where exactly did she do what you said in the headline. I heard the interview and she avoided every question put to her. She just kept spouting about how great her dept was. She boasted about â

    Reply
  • Labour have shown themselves to be the farce that they are – The taxpayers worst nightmare. OK Joan keep comin back to the same well (PAYE worker) to draw the money sure it’ll never dry up. Let’s not bother sortin out state/semi state ‘spoilt’ sectors or dare we not mention the rife abuse of social welfare throughout ALL classes of Irish society.

    Reply
  • FOR SALE: BERTIE VOODOO DOLLS! Genuine Bertie Voodoo dolls made in Africa. Includes yella suit + 84,Billion needles!!!

    Reply
  • That’s what the rulers of the land have done !!!!

    Reply
  • I think the lenders themselves need to start being realistic about their mortgage books and they need to start looking at how they can begin to recoup their losses. If people can pay part of their loans they should buy back the house & start renting the property to the occupant. Then if the borrower finds themselves in a better situation financially down the line they can look at getting another mortgage. This way no-one loses their home and the bank isn’t lumbered with repossessed houses that they won’t make any money on.

    Reply
  • Yeah Joan don’t worry about the people prop up the banks

    Reply
  • There’s a lot of talk from the government about ”helping homeowners” with mortgage problems for a long time now.
    But nothing has been done.
    Our corrupt banks just keep on piling on the interest rate hikes and arrears behind the scenes.
    The NAMA developers debt mess was dealt with immediately, behind closed doors by the government/banks.
    The same government and banks who caused this mess in the first place.
    It would only take Chicken Feed to sort out these struggling homeowner’s debt problems compared to what is being foolishly squandered on the NAMA and Co. scam.

    Now the governments is making a big protracted deal out of helping out struggling homeowners.
    Trying to pitch neighbor against neighbor with the help of the media and their moral hazard campaign.
    While behind closed doors they dish up 10′s of Billions of our money to NAMA and Co,Corrupt Banks,Developers,Consultants and Themselves etc.etc.etc

    Reply
  • She would do better to start looking at debt forgiveness for Ireland as neither this country or any other that has had big bailouts are goin to be able to pay it back.

    Reply
  • Thats such a great picture of her! lol

    Reply
  • its makes both social and economic sense to keep people in their own homes, however danger of moral hazard cannot be ignored so in return for reduced payments banks should get an equity stake, or have mortgages changed to 99 year leases

    Reply
  • I never said that Daniel. What are you on about?

    I don’t want to bail anyone out, banks or people, I struggle enough on my own wages, why should I suffer other people’s problems too?

    Reply
  • Cannot stand this woman but as long as I’m not paying for other people who cant afford their morgage or especially people who bought greedily I don’t mind what they do, they can let em off scott free as far as I’m concerned, once it doesn’t affect me

    Reply
  • Where did I say that?
    I certainly don’t want to bail banks out either. But they take it from my wages, ive no choice.
    If you can afford your house you lose it. Simple. Life isn’t fair.
    I don’t want to see families thrown out of their homes, but I don’t want to pay for them either, I’m struggling enough as is, it’s not my problem and I shouldn’t be burdened further.

    Reply
  • Aidan M 28/08/11 #

    Damn website said comment failed but it worked. Hence the 2 comments.

    Reply
  • Shut up Joan you must be the only TD not on holiday . @ Stephen Kearon that is the most sense i have heard since this so called recession happened.

    Reply
  • repossess – prob lots of other typos sorry damm auto correction

    Reply

Add New Comment