TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Over 200 children need repeat jabs after vaccination error

The HSE said the jabs may not have been prepared or administered in the correct way and have arranged “revaccination clinics” for the affected children.

File photo
File photo
Image: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

SOME 221 CHILDREN and teenagers will need repeat vaccinations after the HSE determined that childhood jabs given by one general practitioner (GP) may not have been effective due to an error in the way they were administered.

The issue came to the attention of the HSE following a query by a parent and on investigation it emerged that a number of the vaccines given at the GP’s office in the Dublin area may not have been prepared or administered in the correct way.

Families will now have to have their children vaccination for a second time against diseases like diphtheria, hepatitis B, measles, mumps, whooping cough and several others.

Manufacturers of the vaccines can only stand over their effectiveness if they have been administered in line with the terms of their licence with the Irish Medicines Board and European Medicines Agency.

The HSE said there are no known safety issues with the vaccines received previously by the children identified. However as the vaccine may not have been effective these children may not be appropriately protected from these diseases.

The HSE sought guidance from the National Immunisation Advisory Committee who advised that affected children should be offered an age appropriate revaccination schedule.

“Revaccination clinics” have been organised and the HSE is currently contacting 221 families to inform them their children should receive their jabs a second time to make sure they are fully protected.

A freephone information number has been made available and the HSE said only those who receive a letter are affected.

Read: HSE urges parents to vaccinate children after measles outbreak in Cork>

Read next:

Comments (64 Comments)

  • aisloy 28/08/12 #

    As far as I have heard the error that occurred was that the GP gave all the vaccines together in one syringe, rather than the several separate syringes. So if a child needed 3 vaccines on a day he drew them from the 3 vials into one syringe. He probably thought he was doing the child a favour not administering 3 needles but only one. However when these vaccines were licenced and tested the licence was given for the vaccine unmixed with any other vaccine and so the companies cannot stand over the vaccines effectiveness. They may be effective in that form but probably not proven so as you can imagine in this situation the powers that be have advised to revaccinate by the book. It is a human error. Not the end of the world, I doubt any of the children will be adversely effected. I’m sure this go has devoted his life to caring for patients and has saved many lives. It was not deliberate, he thought he was doing good.
    It was in a west Dublin area.

    Reply
  • I have to laugh at the outrage above. Far far more serious is the large percentage of stupid parents who will not vaccinate their children mainly because of the lies of the struck off “Doctor” Wakefield.

    Reply
    • William, FYI Dr Andrew Wakefield has been vindicated, in a study conducted by a team of doctors in Wake Forest University, NC on 275 children, a much larger study the DR Wakefields. The research these doctors undertook proved that in the gasto-intestinal tracts of those who had been diagnosed with Autism, were found to have the measle virus that could only have come from vaccination. It must be also stated the DR Wakefield never actually claimed there was a link between Autism and vaccines, but suggested there was reason for concern, he put forward the notion that the measles vaccine be given as a single dose vaccine, never once did he suggest that the vaccine should not be administered He was immediatley rounded upon by the BMJ (who recieve vast sums of money from Big Pharma in advertising and lobbying) , he was vilified in the gutter press , namely Rupert Murdochs media empire, who’s son James incidently sits on the board of Glaxo-Smith-Klyne, the British Pharmacuetical company that makes the MMR vaccine. Lastly i am far from stupid , i am a parent who refused that my children have mercury, chick embryos, bovine fluids, thimerosal, formaldahyde and countless other metals and toxins pumped into their veins

      Reply
    • @Deasun, I’m sorry but Andrew Wakefield has not been vindicated. The poster presentation (not a paper, not that there is necessarily anything wrong with that) done in 2008, (I assume you are talking about, seeing as you haven’t linked to it), firstly has never made it to any type of peer review journal, and secondly one of the authors was Andrew Wakefield himself.

      Secondly he has been struck off the medical register in the UK and isn’t licensed in the US, so he isn’t a doctor any more. Additionally the single dose vaccine he was suggesting was the one he held a patent on and which he stood to make a lot of profit off of if he could get enough FUD spread to get the normal one dropped.

      Finally, if you haven’t gotten your kids vaccinated then I can only hope your kids don’t have to pay for your stupidity, and it is stupidity because there is absolutely no real data backing up your position.

      Reply
  • What a vague article… What was the error? Storage temperature I’d guess?

    Diseases like “diphtheria, hepatitis B, measles, mumps, whooping cough and several others” Was it the entire set of vaccines they missed? Holy majoley I would be raging!

    Reply
  • I’m sorry, but given the above comments I query what people actually understand of a doctor or medical person in any field.
    clinical errors, such as incorrect admin of a vaccine or other drug can happen. it’s not the end of the world. for all we know it may be a small error like incorrect injection site for the vaccine etc. true it may be something worse but it doesn’t state that. I get that people would become worried by a statement like this stating that a vaccine for so many kids went awry, but due to the system in place, it was discovered and rectified. human errors are apart of life, and this doctor unfortunately made a mistake. but going down each others throats, and saying that all doctors or med professionals are at fault, or that it was administrators,(clearly read article wrong) will get nobody nowhere. instead of being glass half empty as to what could have been, how about we be thankful that nothing did happen??

    Reply
  • Mary 28/08/12 #

    I’m not surprised, especially if it was a public health facility, given the understaffed and under resourced conditions public health staff have to work in due to all the cuts. Absolutely does not justify what happened and I would be up in arms if it was my child but the public health service is seriously a disaster waiting to happen.

    Reply
    • Rhonda one of my grandaughters was involved and has one received a booster vaccination without tears but a big apology and a lollipop. Go back to your knitting woman.

      Reply
    • Hey Mick .
      Put your money where your mouth is , Can you verify that comment with details and follow up pictures ?? Or are you just claiming that your gtrandaughter is oneof the misfortunates ?

      Reply
    • Yeah, we all want a picture of the lollipop! What is going on here today? People asking for pictures of children accompanied by medical records! Seriously weird chat today Journal!!

      Reply
    • @ Brendan Harlowe
      No i do not want a photo graph . It is sarcasm . Mick is always on here asking for ”proof” . That is all . I am really not interested ion his family nor do I believe him . Like so many other commenters here have little time for him ..

      Reply
  • Maybe he’s the GP!

    Reply
  • honest to god !!! this country is a joke ….

    Reply
  • More INCOMPETENCE ! This makes me feel so angry … I mean how difficult is it ti follow the rules of storage……

    Reply
    • Joey 28/08/12 #

      Nowhere does it say the error was with storage. It says there was an error in how they were administered. How difficult is it to read an article?

      Why are you angry? The error has been identified and the children will be re-vaccinated. I’d understand your anger if your child hadn’t been properly covered, and then contracted diphtheria, hepatitis B, measles, mumps, whooping cough or any other disease the vaccine was designed to prevent against. Otherwise, it seems to me you are just completely ignorant as to what happened. Your righteous indignation, along with several other neurotic mothers on here, and faux outrage is pathetic.

      Reply
    • faux outrage ? You are another do as your told people who will defend incompetence no matter what ….Ah shur what harm ? Ah shur they didn’t mean it ! Ah shur t’was an accident! ah shur , ah shur , ah shur !!! and on and on and on you go , doing nothing and responsible for nothing . Ah shur some one else was / is meant to do that !!!! Go away !

      Reply
    • Eileen, in all honesty, get a grip. In any system errors will occur, after all we are all human. The important thing in designing the system is that checks are in place to identify and rectify errors, as is happening here. And from the number involved it would suggest that the system picked it up quickly enough.

      As for your ‘Ah sur’ comments, the article does not state if further action against the gp is pending, so less of the insinuations that the error is bring glossed over please

      Reply
    • Vocal outrage (Is that REALLY your handle? Ha ha )
      So by your estimation we should all wait and see ! Have a public debate or enquirey to see who , how or if there was a mistake made , and then time will have passed and no one will know what it was all about or no one will get a slap on the wrist . I am not advocating that any one should lose their job but a reprimand as to how this kind of mistake can be prevented in the future and lessons learned BEFORE it gets too serious.
      Have a nice day!

      Reply
    • Eileen, did you ever make a mistake, a serious mistake? There are 1000’s of doctors. it’s a credit to them that there are so few mistakes.

      Reply
    • Eileen, I have no doubt the Irish Medical Council will thoroughly investigate any complaint made, however, due process is required. Not to do so, in any walk of life, is just mob rule and the problem with mob rule is that invariably it comes to incorrect conclusions

      Reply
  • Quackery Jane?? Tell that to a mother who watched her child turn from a happy healthy alert little baby, into a severly brain damaged shell after receiving these injections!!
    Everybody has the right to be informed of the side effects of these vaccines. Even if the chances are slim of this happening. It happens. So please don’t insult the parents or children who have had their life’s deeply effected by theses vaccines, by saying it’s all quackery!!!

    Reply
  • Another dose of toxic chemicals all round!

    Reply
  • Hi, Michelle. Could you please state the time when this vaccination error occurred? The exact year? Thank you.

    Reply
  • So many administrators in the HSE and they can’t even get their admin right?!!

    Reply
  • Why are expensive doctors being paid for what is a nursing role anyway?

    Reply
  • Ryan'O 28/08/12 #

    Can I comment on this the mick Collins thread?! It is grossly unacceptable for this to happen in this day and age! It was a problem in the administration of the vaccine ?! Wtf ?! Even a GP can’t give a jab correctly, and if I was one of those parents I would be straight onto obese minister for health James nursing homes Oreily for this do call family practitioner to be struck off!! Thank god nothing awfu happened to the 221 children. And to Mick Collins, where do you get off telling people to get a life?! Their opinions are warranted and justified, remember free speech (FG haven’t taken that off us yet) let people speak with out bombarding them with silly little bully tactics by saying things like get a life! My nine year old grew out of that years ago.

    Reply
    • well said !!

      Reply
    • Joey 28/08/12 #

      Errors happen every single day in this country in every single healthcare setting. It is a fact of life. It being “grossly unacceptable” to you in “this day and age” will not change that. And 99% of the time, nothing “awful” happens as your melodramatic comment along with it’s litany of exclamation marks would seem to suggest.

      The Minister for Health can’t strike off a GP, only the Medical Council can do that. And I sincerely doubt a GP would be struck off for this. That along with the rest of your comment demonstrates your sheer ignorance.

      Reply
  • @John , Proff Walker-Smith who conducted the study with Dr Wakefield , and who was also struck off from practicing medicine had the initial verdict thrown out of a British high court last march , while the medical and judicial fields have yet to exonerate Dr Wakefield , it surely remains just a matter of time . Our very own Dr John O’Leary of St.James’s hospital who carried out tests 11 yrs ago duplicated the findings of Dr Wakefield and the doctors of Wake University .Is your interest not even a little aroused by the frenzy of snoozepaper articles that attacked these findings, as i said before Rupert Murdochs media empire was directly behind the attacks , and the fact that his familys interests lay in the corporate boardrooms of Glaxo and Merck are merely coincidental?. There are thousands of parents like i myself who chose not to have heavy metals, toxins, carcinogens and foreign DNA pumped into the veins of a baby just a few hours old. There are also a wealth of blogspots and dedicated websites that report on the adverse reactions to vaccines, many of which contain personal testimonies of parents who can no longer hold their children as they succumbed to the vaccines you so valiantly defend http://thinktwice.com/stories.htm

    Reply
  • Obviously none of ur children were affected Mick………

    Reply
  • This is far to serious to be ignored , this GP who did not administer the vaccine properly should have his licence suspended unto a full investigation is done, I do hope this is what happening !

    Reply
  • Mick ya,I believe u ..not …stop bullying and quiet

    Reply
  • seriously mike get off Ur soap box and get a life u silly man !!!

    Reply
    • Would you strike the Doctor off Rhonda? Or fire the Dean at the University in which he or she studied or maybe impeach the Minister for one case of human error…get a life!

      Reply
    • Rhonda
      I agree with you . Mick is a know it all and will not be out done by truth or morality . It is appalling to think that any child should be put in harms way due to the lack of oversight or care .

      Reply
    • Joey 28/08/12 #

      Unfortunately human error is and always will be present in medical care. Most of the time it’s not serious, unfortunately sometimes it is.

      The airline industry carries out an extensive analysis after each error to analyse if any changes to the system can be made. It has adopted a systems approach to identify and remedy errors. Instead of pointing fingers at pilots or other individuals when errors occur, the industry conducts a detailed investigation in which the many behind-the-scenes processes and protocols that led up to the failed flight are mapped out. Everyone from the ground crew to the air traffic controllers is encouraged to help identify and solve the problem. This approach has led to an impressive safety record and is adapted for use in healthcare.

      Eileen’s emotive and simplistic comments of “how hard is it to read instructions” ” will somebody think of the children” “they’ll only get a slap on the wrist”, etc do nothing to enhance patient safety or reduce errors.

      Reply
  • my daughter is one that has to be vaccinated again. its like a previous poster said, all injections were mixed in one dose, as to save injecting children more than once. As for the need to be vaccinated again, its going to be more traumatic for my little one getting the vaccinations again as she is three now and her new vaccination date is her first day of school.

    Reply
  • We received a letter concerning my daughter, my son who was born 16 months later was vaccinated by the same GP in the same manner and we have yet to be informed he requires revaccination. I was concerned about the side effects the first time round but I have serious concerns about my children receiving a double dose, if there are possibilities of a child being effected by one dose surely this possibility doubles. At the end of the day my children still received the first dose even if it is not effective because it was mixed.

    Also I now have the hassle of taking days of work to attend these clinics until the vaccination is complete ie tomorrow, three months time etc and this is not to mention the effect of all of this on my now 3 and 2 year old.

    My daughter is due to start school tomorrow and has to get her first vaccine afterwards because the only other clinic available to do so is for a weekend which we’re out of the country for.

    I totally recognise that this was human error and in fairness the GP administered these vaccinations with the best intentions but it has caused our family extreme concer, worry and inconvenience and will continue to do so for the next 13 months until the vaccinations are completed

    Reply
  • Paul – I would NOT accept the first day at school as the new vaccination date. The first day at school is traumatic enough for your little one! Cancel it! Are the vaccinations carried out at school, by school nurses specially trained in giving vaccinations, as they are in the UK?

    Reply
    • Marian if we could cancel it we definitely would, the revaccinations are being done at a clinic set up by the HSE, there are only two dates for these and we’re out of the country for the other date so we have no choice but to inflict this on our daughter on her first day at school :-(

      Reply
  • I am effected my children need to be revaccinated I am waiting on the HSE to ring me back as I am not living in Dublin any more

    Reply

Add New Comment