TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Brian Hayes: Legislation on public pay ‘inevitable if there is no agreement’

The Junior Finance Minister said that while this was the case, government would rather not impose “some unilateral settlement”.

Thousands of frontline services staff attended a rally against pay cuts at the National Basketball arena in Tallaght yesterday.
Thousands of frontline services staff attended a rally against pay cuts at the National Basketball arena in Tallaght yesterday.
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

JUNIOR FINANCE MINISTER Brian Hayes has said that legislating with regards to public sector savings “is inevitable if there is no agreement”.

He cautioned against having to go down this route, however, saying: “We don’t want to impose some unilateral settlement if we cannot find agreement”.

Speaking to Newstalk Breakfast, Hayes said that he wasn’t surprised by yesterday’s protest by frontline staff, but said that further cuts to public sector pay required looking “under the bonnet” in order to help cut the €1 billion that government require.

While legislating for pay cuts alone would be “too simplistic”, he said that government instead hoped to deal with the “systematic problem” that existed instead and that things such as weekend overtime and premium pay could not be excluded.

Extending the talks

With Croke Park Agreement talks continuing, and with the deadline of the end of February now ‘looming’, Hayes hinted that the date could be extended.

Downplaying large scale industrial action by saying that the “great majority of public service unions were still around the table”, he said that it would be foolish to not extend the deadline, if required.

Read: ‘We have no more to give’: Over 3,000 attend Frontline services rally >

Read next:

Comments (92 Comments)

  • They don’t want to legislate because any new legislation regarding pay would prove to the populace that politician’s pay can also be subject to new legislation .

    Reply
    • They don’t want to legislate because it would bring in every single PS worker under the same cuts, including themselves.
      If frontline workers accept these proposed cuts, then those just working Monday to Friday 9 to 5 would not face any cuts at all.

      That’s why they don’t want unilateral cuts to wages. It’ll be their own wages being cut along with ours.

      Reply
    • Surely if they are that interested in their own pay they’ll exempt themselves from any legislation?

      Of course I am of the extreme view that politicians aren’t in it for the money and actually care about their country, but I know such arguments disrupt the consensus on this site.

      I am of the view that any % cut applied to the public service through this deal should also apply to politicians.

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 19/02/13 #

      And as a politician in waiting I can take what you say with a pinch of salt.

      Reply
    • “Of course I am of the extreme view that politicians aren’t in it for the money and actually care about their country”

      If they honestly cared for their Country, then they should have been the first to take a wage cut.

      If they really cared about their Country, then we wouldn’t be in this mess in the first place.

      Reply
    • @David. Are you serious? The money for them has become to good to even contemplate the country. If they were that serious, then have no public servant on over 100k a year including expenses. Encourage people to start spending money so so reduce VAT. I know there will be harsh taxes but when people start seeing its equally across the board they might not be so p@ssed off

      Reply
    • Government workers are entitled to annual wage increases, and, (in Teachers cases) about three months of vacation each year. That’s in addition to paid sick days, emergency leave days, and paid personal days.

      Not to mention every holiday is paid and off. You are supposedly paid over time if you work on the weekend (whatever happened to time and a half?)

      You know, I don’t blame the unions for these sweetheart deals.
      I blame those that sign the contracts. Union members are there to get the best deal possible. Politicians seem to not be able to say no.

      It reminds me of the screaming 5 year old in the candy aisle. Do I blame the child for asking for chocolate? or shall I blame the parent for purchasing?

      Reply
    • You’re looking fit Regonald. I see you are gone into Internet modelling. Nice nixer.

      Reply
    • Public servants are paid increments not annual pay rises its on the contract they sign before they commence employment. Increments aren’t paid every year either and it takes about 20 years to reach the top of the pay scale, as for 3 months holidays a year I get 20 annual days leave a year, remember the big hullabaloo when they wanted to standardize public service leave to 23 days a year across the board as some civil servants were getting up to 39 days well they told firefighters they wouldn’t be standardizing our leave as for emergency leave or paid personal days firefighters are not entitled to these

      Reply
    • Don’t feed regonald the troll. He actually “copy pasted” that comment from a thread a couple of days ago!

      Reply
  • sean 19/02/13 #

    Will the weasel hayes and his dail eireann natives be taking a paycut
    Will they be giving up there expenses , handsome pensions ,
    The country actually needs more frontline staff , not less ,
    What is does not need is layer upon layer of mgmt , layer upon layer of councillors , mayors county managers , not to mention 166td,s

    You want to save a billion hayes there you go start above

    every person on this island struggling to meet their bills should be right behind the frontline public servants ……………….
    We have no more to give .

    Reply
    • While I agree that politicians PAYROLL need to be cut, it distracts from the BILLIONS required to keep the overall public sector payroll afloat. It wouldn’t make a drop in the ocean by comparison.

      Reply
    • sean 19/02/13 #

      Reg , every bit helps , cut their pay , the number of advisors , the grossly overpaid layers upon layers of mgmt ,councillors , senators , top civil servants
      Blanket ban on all political expenses vouched or otherwise ,
      Cut overseas aids by 50% ……..savings with this alone would be €300m ,
      Cut the quangos , abolish the seanad, the gov jet,
      A levy on bankers bonus,s, a levy on pensions on retired politicians ,
      Childrens allowance removed from homes who,s incomes are above €100,000.

      this would be a great start , instead of the usual FG mantra of taking every last penny off the ordinary low, middle earners ,

      Reply
    • Fair point. It would be interesting to see if it makes all the savings, however.

      Reply
  • I get threatened on a fairly regular basis in my job, I see this as just another threat. I and my colleagues have never backed down in the face of any threats yet, what makes this Government think we will back down now? Let them legislate….and deal with the consequences.

    Reply
  • The great majority of unions around the table are those who represent the 9-5 Monday to Friday staff and the unions mantra is protecting core pay which is what the 9-5 staff pay is , when the government go after the night/weekend/bank holiday allowances that they are clearly intending to do, frontline staff should only offer there service 9-5 Monday to Friday, sure we’re not that important anyway and we’ve been constantly told the country is broke so we’ll do our bit and work reduced hours no more of them nasty night/weekend/bank holiday payments anymore for the people of Ireland to pay. I’m really looking forward to having St. Patrick’s day off now

    Reply
  • “deal with the “systematic problem” that existed”

    Jesus Hayes. Look in the mirror first will ya?

    Reply
  • The proverbial shit is going to hit the fan . The Countrys broke no cash for Frontline services that’s it. The final realization of Austerity is on the way.Hayes and his buddys are so deep into the LIE there is no going back and this country will be decimated by next election .Remember its only the start of 2013 .The coalition Government is good at one thing Buying Time with false promises and Making the Country worse whilst doing it.We laughed at Greece we will see who’s laughing by 2016 .The top 10% of course and no one else.Keep throwing your taxes into an Armani Pocket and expect services not in the nature of a Central Banker im sorry.

    Reply
  • That big hedge fund guy in America won’t be happy about these developements. He bought up a massive amount of Irish debt in the hope that the passive sheep we clearly appear to be the last 4yrs would continue. His continuing happiness is paramount to Brian Hayes & his cronnies. This could be the start of the fight back. I support you frontline staff.

    Reply
  • Well Brian (I don’t answer questions) Hayes bring it on. Introduce your legislation to cut frontline pay. But you have been warned if you exclude pay and pensions of other civil & public servants your legislation will end up in the Supreme Court. I hope this happens for the following reason.

    I would love to see a Barrister paid for with the Irish Citizens money stand up in a Irish Court on behalf of the Government and defend pay cuts to nurses, doctors, gardai & firemen etc, and then explain how they can exclude other working & retired civil and public servants from the same pay / pension cuts especially TD’s & Senators unvouched expenses.

    Bring it on Brian, for you will find you will have to answer to us, the Citizens of Ireland.

    Reply
  • Is Brian Hayes an economic & political illiterate?? Or is BULLYING now acceptable?? Here’s a message for u “Hayes” & ur Government cronies.. U bring this legislation in & it will be the “Rock” this country perishes on!! Frontline 24/7 workers WILL NOT be dictated to by u.. I pay ur wages!!!! U pompous, arrogant, inept excuse of a member of Dáil Éireann!! How dare u threaten us!

    Reply
  • The FG/Lab coalition have already voted against a SF motion to tackle the poitical gravy train they will protect themselves at any cost,disgracefull contempt for the irish workers and the state of our economy

    Reply
  • well ill be relying on the ould “legitimate expectation” defence that theyve trotted out as reasons not to cut politicians salaries, pensions etc if they go near my paltrg 25k

    Reply
  • it should be a straight cut across the board. i don’t know why this isn’t done. i am a civil servant and don’t see why some public servants are going to lose money and others are not. i really hate to be so cynical but could it be that a straight cut affects everyone top to bottom including the politicians. really don’t see the point in just targeting one sector and especially our hard working nurses which in my opinion are not paid enough anyway. as someone has already said why are they tinkering with stupid little things. also every pay rise that we got over the years was automatically passed onto public sector pensioners but now they’re on a higher scale to us.why weren’t they cut. it’s all a load of crap

    Reply
    • i agree – why should front line services be targetted . these are the people who are supposed to help us – directly . Much of the PS pay bill is wasted on the higher up who seemd to be untouchable – and on way higher salaries – and where i worked – much less of them were needed – but the created a superstructure that cost a lot – and in fact in many ways interfered with the front line staff .
      Of course if it is just the politicins protecting themselves and their friends – well f## them . in a way forcing them to bring in legislation shows waht a crowd of thugs they are .
      Last night I was watching a prog on TV – and the Peasants Revolt – and the poll tax of c 1380 . This led to Paeasants revolt . They dragged the chncellor from his hiding place – and beheaded him – that was 630 years ago .. Looks like the people then had more guts than the people now who say this and that about our criminal goverment but do little .
      In a way – thse talk shops serve the goverment – as we let off steam here – and hopefully we do not think that is job done . the Icelandes attcked their so called goverment with rocks . Our thugs are getting off light – too light .
      We must have an alternative to the crowd of yes men / women that inhabit the Dail.

      Reply
  • The ball is rolling now, this government does not have the balls for this fight. The majority of frontline workers now are not fighting for wages they are fighting to stay afloat. We have nothing left to lose. Bring it on….

    Reply
  • Typical ! Bring in an unjust law to try and cow down the natives ! Ha ha well that aint going to work . Were you not watching the live link to the Basketball stadium it was packed , and it was packed by the elite workers too, who usually gave in to government demands.

    Reply
  • I think Mr Brian Hayes with the threat of legislation regarding public service pay is about to open the door civil unrest which might open the eyes of the government and not mess with the gamekeeper

    Reply
  • Is he the best they can roll out?

    Reply
  • FG just don’t get it . If they want to stop Saturday/ Sunday allowance to our front line workers then the front line workers won’t work these days . Simple .

    Reply
  • Barty 19/02/13 #

    As was said yesterday Northern Ireland Fire Service . 1 Chief Fire Officer 2Assistant Chief Fire Officer’s 40 Civilian staff overseeing 2000 front line firefighters.

    We have 30 Chief Fire Officer’s 375 Assistant Chief’s 700 Civilian staff overseeing approximately 3400 front line firefighters.

    I wonder where we can make savings.

    Reply
  • 24% paycut .. 29000 cut in 2 paye household 45,000 since 2009! Unacceptable!

    Reply
  • So it’s election time then, the journal should run a poll on who would you vote for in an Easter election 2013

    Reply
    • It just goes to show there is one rule for the paye sector and one rule for government appointed heads of semi state bodies including banks,retired TDS and current TDS.Legislation can be drawn up to ignore contracts of employment for all PAYE sectors yet when it came to the obscene wages of the semi state bodies ceo’s,bank ceo’s etc etc we are told by noonan,kenny,gilmore,lenihan,cowan,the green party leadership no they have contracts of employment which we must honour…hypocrites

      Reply
  • Let them legitise then we know how much the government thinks each grade should be cut ow much they are willing give how much of a decrease they will impose on their advisors the unions have no business agreeing more cuts
    Since the government are going to impose the cut anyway

    Reply
  • Start at the top minister

    Reply
  • Well minister I guess it’s time to stop your talk and just legislate. But you should remember that the legislation that you do introduce better be fair and equitable to every single civil servant right across the board. You won’t get it so easy as to just pick away at the salaries of those who are on the coal face 24/7. Legislate wisely my friend as the highest court in the land and, in fact further afield in Europe, will scrutinise every single letter of the bill. It will most certainly be challenged if it is duly unfair to a particular minority of public sector workers.

    Reply
  • Our contracts are good to 2014.. We paid for that right with 14,000, Pay cut… Now the gloves are off and we are 75,000 strong… Legislation must be fair and equitable
    The plan- first negotiate; second industrial action; third modified wildcat action; , 4th full wildcat strike with agreement from all union members!
    I’m ready to implement this plan now!
    No way should I be paid less for non-social working hours on the new agreement!
    Another 10.6 is unacceptable!
    Junior minister your job is gone anyways.. You’re just a scapegoat from your EU Muppet leaders…
    There is so many ways to continuously improve and save money..
    We have done that but every time frontline tries to change the processes in our management systems which are cost effective and proactive the ministry of health tries erects another hospital or spends millions on relocation contracts which is just reactive!
    The 80/20% for improvement has reversed and 80/20% is being spent due to the government fiscal spending and not by frontline staff!
    There is no easy fix here but it’s not non-social working premiums!
    Again forced 2 week bulling politics for negotiations.. Unacceptable….
    This Gov has lost my vote for even trying to break my contract!

    Reply
  • All of this cuts is pure FG, where is labour in all this. FG are the PDs with a different name. God help us.

    Reply
  • This is not about Michael Collins! This is about our lives, our families, our community, our society and our constitution!

    Reply
  • Stick it to the man!

    Reply
  • Fianna Fail are going to walk into a majority in the next election.

    All they have to do is promise to borrow a few extra billion a year on top of the existing borrowings, and then they can then pay everyone what they think they deserve. simples.

    Reply
  • Michaelcollinsghost – Sure doesn’t Pat Kenny work about 10hrs a week for 600k. If you take out the ad breaks, news bulletins, sports bulletins etc, sure he must only work 7 or 8 hours in the week.

    Reply
  • socmot 19/02/13 #

    I wonder how many front line public sector workers voted for Fine Gael?
    Voting for FG is like voting for the Tories. Cuts, cuts cuts.
    Same with FF. They are right wing parties.

    What did you all expect, electing almost 100 of them?!
    Vote for a left wing party next time or this stuff will just keep on happening.

    Reply
  • Latest Updates on Croke Park Extension Talks

    Croke Park Extension Talks – News Update 9. 19.02.13
    print

    24/7 Frontline Services Alliance –

    National Rally attended by over 4,000

    Attention All INMO Members

    Dear Colleague

    As you will undoubtedly have seen, from the very significant media coverage, last night’s rally (Monday, 18th February 2013), organised by the 24/7 Frontline Services Alliance, was attended by over 4,000 members. The rally saw nurses, midwives, gardai, prison officers, and other frontline staff come together to demonstrate their outright opposition to any attack upon their existing income.

    The rally saw contributions, from each of the five organisations, together with numerous contributions, from ordinary frontline members, all of them reiterating that they simply cannot afford cuts to their pay.

    The campaign now continues with the following immediate steps:
    • nationwide lobbying, of all TDs and Senators, highlighting the total inequity, arising from the government’s current approach, and, in particular, their proposed attack upon premium pay; and

    • a joint meeting of the Executives, of each of the five organisations to agree further steps.

    Further updates will issue, with regard to the campaign, in the coming days.

    However it is now imperative that every member phone, email, or directly contact, their local TDs and Senators to tell them the 24/7 Frontline Services Alliance is determined to protect the existing income of its members.

    Public Service Pay Talks:

    The public sector pay talks continue today, Tuesday, 19th February 2013, with a further meeting in the health sector, between management and unions, including the INMO.

    Today’s meeting continued to exchange information, with regard to the expenditure in the area of premiums, but the INMO consistently reiterated its position that existing pay rates cannot be reduced.

    The talks are continuing this afternoon but no major developments are expected.

    The INMO, together with the Irish Medical Organisation (IMO), has requested, an early meeting of the full trade union team involved in the talks process. This is to allow for a detailed debate on the issues that have arisen, in the talks to date, and in particular, the management side’s continued demand for a reduction in premium pay rates and the union side’s collective response to this. It is expected this meeting will take place within the next two days.

    As always further updates will issue on an ongoing basis and please distribute this news update all around your workplace.

    Finally please lobby your local TDs/Senators starting immediately.

    Yours sincerely

    LIAM DORAN

    General Secretary

    Reply
  • How do you change your pic on this website??? Sorry for changing the subject

    Reply
  • Another back room con job strapped onto the backs of the vast majority of workers in this state who are conveniently not covered by this agreement but will yet be paying through the nose for it.

    How in the name of all that is serious, this government actually appears to believe that a 14 billion Euro a year deficit, or a 1.2 billion a month cash liability over income, can be tackled by tinkering around with a Sunday premium and a few allowances, is something you would only expect to see in a Father Ted episode.

    The reality is that a pay adjustment in the order of 10-20% is needed and our public sector workers will not agree to that no matter how it is bundled up, so impose the cuts and lets get on with it and lets stop deluding ourselves that we can solve this by taking away an allowance for a pair of boots and fiddling a bit with the Sunday overtime.

    Reply
  • There is no point in these talks continuing, the pay has to be cut and people in the private sector, 500,000 of whom took the ultimate pay cut when they lost their jobs as the public sector unions hid behind the protection afforded to them by the Croke Park Agreement, have no appetite whatsoever ever now for this talk of strikes, when the wheels have now completely fallen off the rotten & selfish deal they previously stupidly signed up to.

    The government are only messing with peoples heads by pretending that this issue can be ultimately dealt with by tinkering at the edges of Sunday pay and asking Gardai to buy their own boots. You can’t sort out a 1.2 billion a month problem by asking Gardai to buy their own boots and fiddling a bit with their Sunday pay rate, so why sit in talks with people and pretend that this is how affairs are going to be conducted?

    Reply
    • So the government needs to save €1bn. Start by getting rid of the independent consultants and special advisers. We don’t need spin doctors we need the truth and some honest politics. Paying independent law firms excessive fees to cover their incompetence is not the answer. Analyze how much is wasted on this rubbish cut it out and then see how much they have to come up with. Nothing. We wouldn’t even need to collect an unconstitutional property tax

      Reply
    • The people in the private sector that you speak about lost their jobs, manufacturing, building etc their services were no longer required and were let go.

      Gardaí, nurses, firemen, prisoner officers etc are employed to provide a service. Their role in society is still a requirement and they should be paid for their work.

      What is wrong with these people seeking security and opportunity for future earnings?

      Reply
  • The only point that public sector workers have made that is valid is that they should not be facing pay cuts when those in government are still creaming it with unvouched expenses and are still on completely unrealistic salaries.

    This country started coming under attack 4 years ago and the public sector climbed into their Croke Park bunker and pulled the drawbridge up behind them, so good luck to you guys now if you think you are getting any support from me or others in the private sector when you selfishly signed up to a corrupt & unsustainable pay deal that the rest of us got handed the bill for.

    Reply
    • For someone with a pic of Micheal collins, youre a hypocrite. He pulled up the drawbridge a few years back. No complaints from the likes of you!!

      Reply
    • It what way were we protected there, give me one example buddy just one

      Reply
    • What about the corrupt 50 billion the private sector got to get them out of a hole in the first place the 50 billion we will be paying back for 40yrs cos the private sector got a hard on in the naughties and lent too much money to let me guess oh yes their property developer friends in the what is it again oh yes I believe they are also a part of the private sector so don’t tell that copper or nurse or doctor that is trying to save your life or your kids life at 4 in the morning that they shouldn’t get paid for offering their expertise without a decent wage to live on and the sacrifice that their families make so that you can avail of their services

      Reply
    • Ha ha @ Michael Collins ghost. .. I dont think PS Really needs ur support Now go and dig urself a bunker . climb into it.. Stay there. !!!!!

      Reply
    • Croke Park 1 was a threecardtrick designed by the higher paid in the PS to preserve their pot of gold by linking them with everybody else including the lowest paid.
      Croke Park 2 is a similar trick but the other way round.
      It’s very clever. Real yes minister stuff.

      Reply
    • Where have you been living, frontline workers have had their pay cut by 14% since 2009 under the Croke Park Agreement and that does not include the loss of overtime, their hours in work have been changed so they now have no family life, their workload has increased as numbers have dropped and now after they have fulfilled their obligations the government want a further 11% before the Croke Park Agreement is completed, so please do tell me more about how their pay has been protected because you seem very knowledgeable on the subject. You might want to know what you’re talking about before you make an idiot of yourself. Oh and by the way how much has your wages been cut by since 2009 because I’m damn sure it’s nowhere near 25%!

      Reply
  • @PaulJones Paul what drugs are you on? Was your pay not protected for the last number of years? Was the whole country imagining that pay for the public sector was protected under the Croke Park Agreement? I’ve a mate who is a teacher who works a 18.5 hour week and is on a 55K a year salary, could you be any more protected than that?

    On what parallel universe does a guy who is getting paid 55K a year for putting in an 18.5 hour working week (that is when he is not on a 3 month summer holiday!), actually believe, and then try to convince other people around him, that he is in fact poorly paid? Seriously, snap out of it, and by the way, I’m not your “buddy”.

    Reply
    • Dear Michael Collins Ghost
      Just in case you haven’t quite come to terms with the real facts of the matter but I don’t know too many nurses police officers or doctors working an 18.5 hrs week most often it is a 50 60 hrs week and at times that most others are in bed sleepin I don’t think it is too much to ask we get paid a reasonable amount for the professional courtesy we have to pay to idiots like you sprouting right wing bull and smile politely and and still save your life and just in case you have forgotten this state was founded on the back of the working man who had been locked out by their employers and while the private sector slowly gets its act together those in the state system pay for your benefits cos no one in the private sector will create any jobs cos of a govt that still won’t take on the real villains in all of this

      Reply
  • @JasonBourne One thing about Michael Collins is that he knew the value of money and didn’t tolerate waste and he wouldn’t have tolerated for a second, money being wasted and píssed about all over the place like it is in this country, for the purposes of pandering to and appeasing what are probably the best paid public servants in the western world, who have deluded themselves that they are under some sort of an “attack” and that they are poorly paid. Our public sector workers are not poorly paid, that much is certain.

    Reply
    • @Ghost you’re absolutely correct we do have the best paid PS. However our beloved all knowing leaders want to hit the wrong public sectors. They want to hit the ones that do make a difference. The Gardai, paramedics, nurses, prison officers and junior doctors. There is nothing being said about the managers, executive officers etc. no they want to take it from the front line services. And you like everyone else will sit there and believe they are on enormous amounts, why because the government have said so, so it must be true

      Reply
    • Why are you even entertaining him. Proven troll. Same guys under different accounts

      Reply
  • @YouDontKnowMe This is the default cry now of our public congregation, if you don’t subscribe to the cult like “group-think” that is clearly going on within the public service, and if you genuinely believe that it is not right that people on salaries of anywhere between 40K-100K, typically people who are on incomes of 50-70K a year, should really not be complaining about their remuneration at the moment, and if you say that you genuinely have an issue with things like automatic pay increases that get rewarded to everyone, regardless of an individuals performance for a 12 month period, then you get attacked as a “troll”, or as being ignorant.

    Come back here and tell me why someone who isn’t performing in their job (and there are plenty of them in the public sector just as there are in the private sector), gets the same yearly increment as someone who is outperforming in their job? Why should someone like that have a job for life, in the case of a teacher, someone who can embed themselves in the system like that for 30 odd years, as is currently the case, can ruin & destroy the education of many children over the lifetime of their career? I’ve seen teachers in this country who should never have been let near a class room, we all have, yet the system, as operated and basically owned by the unions and by their members, has selfishly and wrongly protected these people for decades, because they have their “CID” and are untouchable.

    Reply

Add New Comment