TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 7 °C Tuesday 18 June, 2013

Cut in elderly alarm scheme criticised as “penny-wise and pound-foolish”

Age Action said that a cut in the Seniors Alert Scheme “is a bad decision” with “terrible timing”, given recent attacks on elderly people.

Image: Shutterstock

A GOVERNMENT CUT in funding for an alert scheme for elderly people has been criticised as “penny-wise and pound-foolish”.

The cuts apply to the Seniors Alert Scheme, run by the Department of the Environment, which the department told TheJournal.ie “encourages and assists the community’s support for older people by means of a community-based grant scheme to enable older people over 65 years of age, without sufficient means, to continue to live securely in their home with confidence, independence and peace of mind”.

The scheme is administered by local community and voluntary groups with the support of the department.

Reductions

The department said that due to the overall reduction in the amount of funding available for 2013, the changes in the Seniors Alert Scheme, “although regrettable are one of a number of measures which are necessary”.

It should be noted that the reduction will not impact on those persons who have already availed of the scheme.
The funding for 2013 is being targeted at those with the greatest need – elderly people over 65 years of age, without sufficient means, and living alone.

The operation of the scheme will be closely monitored and kept under review during the year and should further funding become available, the situation will be re-visited. The Minister is going to work closely with the relevant groups to minimise the effect of the cost reduction.

Over the last three years the scheme has been funded to the amount of €8.3m, which has enabled 23,686 beneficiaries over that period. This year’s budget is €1.150m.

Under the changes:

  • Funding will only be available to qualified persons over 65 who are living alone
  • Funding will be available for the purchase and installation of personal monitored alarms to a maximum of €230 per alarm
  • Grants to community and voluntary groups will still be available up to €30,000 per annum.

Reaction

Eamon Timmins of Age Action told TheJournal.ie that the cut took them by surprise, as it “wasn’t specifically namechecked in the Budget”. He believes that if 26 people were to go into a nursing home as a result of this cut because they could no longer live at home, this would cost the State around €1.3million a year.

“I think there is a general consensus this is penny-wise and pound-foolish,” he said of the decision. “It is shortsighted.” He said there are contradictions that exist within government, which is currently finalising the national positive ageing strategy.

Timmins said that at the same time as this cut is being made, rural garda stations are being cut, as are community garda. “These are the supports which are particularly helpful to keep people at home,” said Timmons. “It’s very hard to put a value on peace of mind.”

“The timing is terrible with recent attacks,” he added, noting that a 96-year-old woman who was attacked in Co Donegal used a panic button to contact the gardaí after the incident.

It’s really, really frustrating to see things cut in this way. We are hoping this can be reversed. This scheme has already been cut year after year.

Timmons said that the changes mean that couples living together, or siblings living together, do not qualify for the grant, even if both are frail and would need such an alarm.

Age Action will be seeking a meeting with the Department of the Environment and will also be lobbying for a change to this decision.

He said the situation “will come to a head come April, May or June when money runs out.” “Pressure is going to build on this one – it is a bad decision,” said Timmons.

Read: 96-year-old woman attacked in aggravated burglary in Donegal>

Read: Nearly half of Irish adults worry about elderly relatives during winter – survey>

Read next:

Comments (34 Comments)

  • Oh well who cares if some poor pensioner falls and is left helpless on the ground for hours or even days. As long as enough money is diverted to pay for the establishment to maintain the extravagant lifestyles that they are accustomed to, everything will be ok…right?

    Reply
  • Greedy Government :/

    Reply
  • Is there no end to this governments greed and stupidity .

    Reply
  • Another mean spirited and sick act by this depraved govt. The erosion of rural Garda stations, the near total elimination of the Fair Deal scheme for the elderly along with disgusting acts like this make the elderly feel more vulnerable and alone than ever. Cheers Enda.

    Reply
  • Why don’t those gangsters in Government give up their allowances to fund this scheme for the elderly who deserve every assistance in their retirement … Shame , shame on you for your treatment of our elderly ..

    Reply
  • Sigh…..so….two top of my head examples of waste…mariane Finnucane ( nothing personal ) but we pay her over 500 000 euro for about an hour of weekend radio , John Delaney , earns over 300 000 euro (and some might wish if he just did an hour of radio every weekend ), so there’s 800k in two quick examples , it would be SO easy if the will was there to save money and not touch things like alarm systems for elderly , vulnerable people who have lived through their lives and must be incredulous at the mean spirited attitude of our government towards them , shameful.

    Reply
  • Where is our caring Senators, I can’t believe they are staying quiet on this situation.

    Reply
  • Some poor elderly person will die alone and afraid because of this horrible cut. The pendant scheme is a lifesaver in so many cases and it gives security and a level of peace of mind and connection for elderly living alone. It is a disgrace that elderly people who paid taxes and served their country are treated like this. This government is as self serving and ruthless as my other before it. Fine Gael and Labour are cowardly spoof merchants and as false as can be, I am glad I am not elderly living alone in a rural area with no Gardai, I pity the elderly and shudder to think how it will be in my twilight years, perhaps we will be ruled by Germany or the troika then.

    Reply
  • This really makes me sick, out of all the cuts this has to be one of the worst. The very people who have worked all their lives to build up this country and now in their later years we cant even look after them so they can feel safe and secure in their own homes. Great move enda and co… Fckn morans.

    Reply
  • I know of a an elderly man that lives near my house .he doesn’t have to worry about any of this nonsense of cutbacks because he has 24 hour security 7 days a week 365 days of the year paid for by you the taxpayer. the reason he happens to be a member of the elite in this country an ex politician .he resigned as toiseach in the 70′s and for some reason still has this security outside his house .liam Cosgrove is his name and all ex toiseach have the same security as far as I know.i have emailed alan shatter who passed in onto the garda commissioner who passed it onto the local superintendent.who replied to me today .He informed me that garda security was based on risk assessment and that it was none of my business. maybe he could risk assess all the elderly living alone and supply them with 24 hr security or maybe we could supply a panic alarm for this house and with the money saved everyone could have a panic alarm

    Reply
  • That alarm’s the only reason my grandmother still has her independence. Shame on the cowards in the government.

    Reply
  • With this cut People will be going into nursing home under the fair deal and who then are the winners Yes The politicians after all they get them to sign away 25% of their property on application and with a couple taking up a place hey they get 50% of same property
    Fine Gael and Labour are a disgrace and are proven liars 5 point plan in 12 months yea right and closure of Gardai Stations Post offices A+E’s etc etc etc
    Last person out do not turn out the lights or lock the doors

    Reply
  • I wonder how many alarms could have been purchased and installed at the cost of the new fleet of government vehicles.

    Reply
  • Meanwhile Brendan Howlin in his makey-uppy ministry utterly fails to make any credible savings in public sector allowances.

    Reply
  • Keep on hearing Kenny blathering on the Irish people making “sacrifices”. Seems to me the only citizens required to make “sacrifices” are the ordinary citizens of Ireland and he and his political colleagues are untouched.

    Reply
  • More now that ever the Elderly need these Panic Buttons. With the. cut in Garda Numbers. I think it is a mean thing to to do. Surely it will not brake the bank to keep theses panic buttons for the elderly. They will be old one day themselves. They have taken enough already .

    Reply
  • Is the cuts for this life saving device to pay for the 50+ audi’s the TD’s are getting and the nick nack gifts all ministers get during this EU Presidency

    Reply
  • What has this Government got against our elderly ?when they retire they won’t have to worry about alarms or pension cuts or how they will heat their houses or pay their electricity bill or keep in touch with their family or friends by phone or visit them by bus or rail. THEY WILL ALL HAVE HUGE PENSIONS. SHAME ON ALL OF YOU.

    Reply
  • Why does North Korea come to mind when I see our mighty masters attending flag raising ceremonies or bending the knee to the jackbooted ones, while the population as a whole struggles to make sense of a society that targets the old, the sick and the least well off. But I forgot, twas the last crowds fault.

    Reply
  • This is so wrong

    Reply
  • This lot are taking the p…s at this stage..a horrible ,underhanded, sneaky cut that hits our most vulnerable to save a miserable couple of million..they ought to be ashamed…and I don’t care who you support but I can’t believe that anyone could support this type of heartless politics…

    Reply
  • jack ass Harry can see a lot of people in agreement of your idea,

    Reply
  • You’d swear just because your old you have some rights to this sort of thing. If you are one of the elderly who worked diligently and economized, surely your pension will cover any loss and if not, why don’t you have a pension? If you were a scrounger and a sponge on the states resources for your entire life, then this move hasn’t come quick enough.

    Reply
    • Schnucs 10/01/13 #

      I hope you remember this comment when you are old and vulnerable!!!! It’s not just about being old and entitled its about a society protecting, or not, in this case, the vulnerable and it’s about paying taxes all your working life, possibly never getting any financial assistance and then being completely screwed when you can’t fight back and have very little! It’s just mean and nasty and completely shameful.

      Reply

Add New Comment