TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 19 °C Tuesday 18 June, 2013

Italy: Court acquits Google executives in autism video appeal

An Italian appeals court acquitted three Google executives of having violated the privacy of an autistic Italian boy by failing to take down a video of him being bullied at school.

Image: Mark Lennihan/AP/Press Association Images

AN ITALIAN APPEALS court on Friday acquitted three Google executives of having violated the privacy of an autistic Italian boy by failing to take down a video of him being bullied at school.

The executives, none of whom are based in Italy, had received six-month suspended sentences in 2010 for failing to remove a video from the Internet showing the teenager being bullied.

“We’re very happy that the verdict has been reversed and our colleagues’ names have been cleared,” Giorgia Abeltino, policy manager for Google Italy, said in a statement.

“Of course, while we are delighted with the appeal, our thoughts continue to be with the family who have been through the ordeal,” she added.

“We are absolutely satisfied, but not surprised,” the executives’ lawyer Giulia Buongiorno said following the ruling.

“The conviction was based on nothing and acquittal is the right result,” she added.

Google “has no responsibility of control on video uploading,” Buongiorno said.

Students at a school in Turin had uploaded the mobile phone video on Google Video in 2006, where it remained for nearly two months.

The video, which showed four students taunting and hitting the boy in front of more than dozen others who did not intervene, sparked a public outcry in Italy.

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (15 Comments)

  • John F 21/12/12 #

    Some interesting points raised in the comments here! I heard a guy on the radio earlier saying the word ‘disabled’ is also offensive, I think thats a bit much in my opinion! What about disabled parking, disability allowance – should all those terms be updated? And will the new descriptors eventually become offensive?

    Reply
  • I strongly object to the word autistic being used as an adjective. Could it be changed to Italian boy with autism? Also, the word handicapped isn’t accurate. Autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder. Media have a huge role to play in influencing how society talks about children with special educational needs.

    Reply
    • Ok that’s the google guys off the hook . What about the thugs that carried out the assault . Any chance we could have them flogged senseless in public and have it uploaded on you tube .

      Reply
    • Excuse my ignorrance Michelle, But why? All that comment says to me now is I’ve to be careful talking to someone about autism with the way I word it. Can you fill me in. Thanks

      Reply
    • A child with autism is not defined by it. They have many other attributes. They are first and foremost a child but with some differences in areas such as social communication, verbal ability or theory of mind. Not all children with autism have those impairments as it is a spectrum disorder. The term handicapped is terribly outdated and seldom used by people working with children with autism or their families. I see the AP is the source of the article hence the American descriptors. The Journal need to be aware of the power of the language they use in the articles they choose to publish. Some may be offended by the terminology.

      Reply
    • Thanks for that. Honestly never knew. Just shows the likes of myself who does’t have to deal with autism how uneduacated we are.

      Reply
    • As a parent of an autistic child… I object to the use of autism as being something that a person “has”, like flu or tummy bug. Flu/bug (as with most illnesses) will go away, autism will not. It is part of the person and is integral part of their personality and their being. They don’t “have” autism, they are Autistic.

      Reply
    • Couldn’t have put it straighter than that .. Totally true ever word ..

      Reply
    • John F 21/12/12 #

      Ye! I’m not an alcoholic, I have alcoholism!

      Reply
    • I hate being called a man with Aspergers, it’s as silly as saying a man with Irishness. There’s nothing wrong with being Irish or an Aspie, it’s who I am not what I have.

      Reply
  • Autism is a difference not a disability. Do people still use the word handicapped when describing people? Lazy journalism

    Reply
  • I also would find both terms, autistic and handicapped offensive and lazy. In an age when diagnoses of autism spectrum disorders are becoming more common, and when we are striving as a society to mainstream these kids (who have huge potential) as much as possible, this kind of language only serves to pigeon hole them and isolate them from their neuro-typical peers.
    They need a clean slate, not to be defined and hence judged by a term which most people know nothing about or in some cases very little and tar all ASD children and adults with the same brush.
    This article proves that the ignorance surrounding ASDs has still to be combated for everyone’s sake.

    Reply
  • the term handicaped is seen as very offensive,, it refers back to the days when a person with a disability, may of had to beg on the street for money etc, as they would of had no other support.. this ws said to be going cap in hand and where the word handicap originated from.

    Reply

Add New Comment