TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Humiliated, tortured or executed: The little-known story of the Irish POWs

Some 650 Irish soldiers were taken prisoner by the Japanese during WW2. They were starved, beaten, even crucified – but showed incredible bravery, writes historian Robert Widders.

Robert Widders

TWO BROTHERS, FROM Cork, lie buried at opposite ends of the Burma Railway.

The eldest, Lieutenant Richard Duke, died of a heart attack in May 1943, at Kannyu River Camp. He was only 44 years old, and not the most obvious candidate for a heart attack. But this was a common occurrence amongst Allied Prisoners Of War (POW) suffering from cardiac beri-beri. And Richard’s younger brother, Private Basil Duke, died three months later from tropical ulcers, at Sonkurai Camp.

Richard and Basil Duke died implementing the Imperial Japanese Army’s scheme to build a railway, linking Nong Pladuk in Thailand to Moulmein in Burma. Construction started in October 1942: When it was finished a year later over thirteen thousand Allied POWs, and 100,000 Asian forced labourers, were dead.

But the infamous Burma Railway was only one of the horrors facing the 650 Irish men and women, serving with the British forces, who were imprisoned by the Japanese Army in 1942. They were captured when Japan invaded British, Dutch, and American territories in the Far East. And by the time they were liberated in 1945 over 23% of the Irish POWs had died in captivity.

The Burmese end of the railway was started by POWs transported from Java and Sumatra. They travelled inside dilapidated merchant vessels. And many died from heatstroke in the unventilated cargo holds, their situation worsened by the deliberate withholding of water, food, and medical care.

The men who commenced work in Thailand were transported up from Singapore, and through Malaya, in cattle trucks. On arrival in Thailand the men had to march to their section of the railway. As the railway progressed further the journey proved longer and longer.

‘The POWs were beaten and brutalised’

Each work party usually had to construct their own camp in the jungle, and build huts made of bamboo where they slept at night. The further away from the railhead the groups were, the worse the conditions became. And the death rate from starvation and tropical diseases increased, whilst all the time the POWs were beaten and brutalised by the guards overseeing their work.

A small group of Irish and English prisoners tried to escape. In March 1943 Fusilier Timothy Kenneally, from Bishoptown, and Private Patrick Fitzgerald, from Kilmeadon, broke out of their work camp, along with Sergeant Francis Joseph Kelly, and Sergeant Edward Reay, from England.

Around two weeks later they were recaptured after being betrayed by Thais supposedly guiding them. The four soldiers were taken back to their POW camp, interrogated, tortured, and then taken away to be executed. Witnesses later saw the men being led away from camp by three Japanese officers and 32 Korean guards.

No one, except the executioners, witnessed the actual moment of death. Japanese documentation claims that the four men were shot whilst trying to escape. A more compelling account was given by another POW, Sergeant Priestman, who was one of a work detail, sent from the main camp about an hour after the execution. Sergeant Priestman did not use the words crucifixion, when he later gave evidence for a post-war war crimes tribunal. But perhaps his description speaks for itself.

In the undergrowth nearby we found three bamboo crosses, about seven feet by four feet. We also saw another bamboo cross jutting out of the ground. We uncovered it and found the dead body of a British soldier, tied to the cross with his arms outstretched.

But whilst crucifixions were uncommon, all of the POWs suffered an incarceration marked by starvation, disease, denial of medical treatment, beatings, and overwork. Survival, though, was often a lottery. Men who remained in Changi camp throughout captivity, were far more likely to survive than those sent to the Burma Railway. Yet others, who were sent to Rabaul, or Ballale, though they didn’t know it when they went, received a death sentence.

In October 1942, six hundred men from the Royal Artillery were loaded onto a former coal ship in Singapore docks. Conditions onboard were horrendous. They were crammed below in the hold, without food, water, ventilation, or any sanitary arrangements, suffering from heat exhaustion, dehydration, and dysentery. And during the voyage Japanese troops entertained themselves by pouring buckets of urine through the hatches onto the POWs below.

The gunners were destined for the Solomon Islands. But eighty-two men were disembarked en route, at Rabaul, on 6 November 1942. These included Lance Bombardier Patrick Ahern, from Fermoy, County Cork, and Lance Sergeant Patrick (Nobby) Nolan from Wexford.

‘Patrick Ahern fought back in the only way he could’

They were put to work unloading cargo from a Japanese ship. One of the gunners had a wound on his back which broke open. Regardless, he was ordered to continue carrying sacks of rice. When he objected, he was tied to a tree and tortured. The Japanese soldiers tried to make him drink urine. When he refused they beat him and poured a bucket of urine over his head. Then they stripped him, rubbed animal manure over his genitals, and left him (tied to the tree) to be tormented by hordes of tropical biting insects. The following morning he was taken away and murdered.

Patrick Ahern fought back in the only way he could, by ripping holes in the rice sacks destined for Japanese troops, whilst working in Wide Bay unloading ships. Meanwhile, malaria took its toll and ten of his mates died within the first two months. This was an unnecessary tragedy caused by the Japanese refusal to allow the POWs to use any of the ample stocks of quinine.

Then food rations, never plentiful, were cut even further. Boiled rice, augmented with a little (stolen) dried fish, was insufficient in quality or quantity to maintain life. And by the time they were liberated in 1945 only eighteen of the eighty-two men landed on Rabaul were still alive.

After the war many survivors met an early death from illnesses linked to their former captivity. Ill health dogged the remaining years of those who made it to old age. Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome left others spiralling into alcoholism, unemployment, homelessness, and in some cases suicide. And in Ireland the POWs faced the added problem of returning to a society ambivalent, and sometimes hostile, about the actions of men who had travelled abroad to serve with the British Army and fight fascism.

A full account of the fates of the 650 Irish soldiers is in The Emperor’s Irish Slaves, written by Robert Widders. Published by The History Press Ireland; available via bookshops, Amazon, or (post free) from the publishers: thehistorypress.ie.

Robert Widders is also the author of Spitting On A Soldier’s Grave, an account of the 5,000 men who deserted from the Irish Army during WW2. Most of these men joined the British armed services and fought against the Nazis.

Read next:

Comments (51 Comments)

  • There were many evils during the second world war, but Japan is right up there for sheer brutality. The Rape of Nanking was a horrific act of terrorism by Japan, one of the worst in modern history.

    Reply
  • My great-uncle John Kelly was one of these heroic men. Anyone who knew him said that when he came home he was a completely different person and became totally withdrawn. He understandably never wished to talk of his experiences, so I can only imagine the horror involved.

    Rest in peace John and all of the other men and women who suffered abuse and torture at the hands if others through the ages.

    Reply
  • Wow,fascinating story,there’s a film in that.

    Reply
  • Read the book road of bones by fergal keane. Burma was one of the roughest places on earth through ww2. The japs were a pretty brutal bunch. We should remember what people did to give us what we have today. We are doing a good job to mess it up. Lets hope white collar crime does leave a huge mark on this generation

    Reply
  • R.I.P. to one and all.

    Reply
    • Why do you hover about the site reading articles about people who passed away and write R.I.P. in every comment? You are a strange one indeed!

      Reply
    • @Jimmy Riddle

      Just opened up journal.ie this is the 3rd article that I’ve looked at. I was very confused when I saw your question to me. I go through all articles that I have an interest in first thing in the morning. This type of article I would very often go into as I know what it’s like to loose someone that I loved. It’s out of respect to the people and their relatives in an article like this that I say R.I.P. It’s like meeting someone on the street that I know than has lost a family member or friend. Does it bother you that much and do I irritate you when you see I have left a message.

      I read the articles, if they interest me, I leave a message. Simple as that. Does that answer your question?

      Reply
  • Can’t imagine the suffering, the concept that soldiers thru the centuries can be convinced that their perceived enemies are subhuman and are to be treated as such is a scary one,

    Reply
  • The bravest generation.

    Reply
  • ” And in Ireland the POWs faced the added problem of returning to a society ambivalent, and sometimes hostile, about the actions of men who had travelled abroad to serve with the British Army and fight fascism.”

    That’s you Paddy O’Reilly, Geraldine McNamara, Michael Hegarty and all the others who were mouthing off about Ranger Michael Maguire not being Irish during the week.

    http://www.thejournal.ie/irish-soldier-killed-on-army-firing-range-441320-May2012/

    Reply
    • I never questioned the dead soldier’s nationality, but neither he nor the men and women of this story were Irish soldiers.
      This is the second misleading strapline in two days, they were British soldiers who were born in Ireland. Irish soldiers implies that they were members of Óglaigh na hÉireann.

      Reply
    • By Ógalaigh na hÉireann, I sincerely hope you mean the Irish Defence Forces and not the Continuity IRA splinter-group! That aside, the men here were indeed Irish soldiers serving in the British Armed Forces. Your semantics serve no purpose than to annoy.

      Reply
    • Connor, if I wanted to annoy people I would have called them deserters (which some of them were).
      Yes I was referring to the Irish Defence Forces, which is comprised of Irish soldiers, just like the British army is comprised of British soldiers, irrespective of country of origin. I am not commenting on whether what they did was right or wrong, just that strap line was incorrect.

      Reply
    • That was a very misleading headline.

      Reply
  • Pilib my grandfather was a IRA man in the war of independence and imprisoned, I believe a family member of his went on to join the British army after fighting against them, his daughter and son were in the WRAF and British army, his other daughter married a English man who was imprisoned and tortured by the japanese in WW2. My mothers brother and his wife both served in the British army. I myself was in the FCA in the early eighties. My grandfather then went on to serve in the Irish army. His son, my father always admired the British army and England.
    Nothing is black and white but you seem to live in a one dimensional world!

    Reply
  • The Americans are not saints either.

    Reply
  • Pilib, where do I begin with your ignorance?

    Reply
  • AlMar 07/05/12 #

    Gavin: I’m speechless at this comment.

    How does your hatred, which would go so far as to seek to wipe out an innocent civilian population with nuclear weapons, differ from that of the Nazis or the Japanese? The Japanese and Nazis may have been wrong, but that doesn’t justify the use of nuclear weapons.

    The moral relativism here is extremely dangerous.

    Reply
  • Yes, people complain when someone drops an atomic bomb on a civilian population.

    Reply
  • He should go out more and the local library should be his first port of call if he can find one that hasn’t closed down..

    Reply
  • mart_n 06/05/12 #

    Necessity can compel men in the most intolerable of ways

    Reply
  • Japan has never adequately answered for the immensity of its war crimes, including rolling massacres of Chinese civilians. The railway was just one among many atrocities motivated by Japanese barbarities. Japan was excused paying a more appropriate price by the narcissist macArthur.

    Reply
  • Disgraceful comment

    Reply
  • So based on where you are born, one life is worth more than another? Comparisons don’t matter.

    Reply
  • Another blinkered comment. What about Abu Ghraib? Guantanamo? Invasion of Iraq. Pinochet in Chile,funded by US to assassinate Salvador Allende.

    When war happens, humanity fails, not just on the ‘other’ side but your own side too.

    Reply
  • This is an important addition to the literature on Ireland and Irish people during World War II by Robert Widders. Bravery and horror in almost equal amounts. When the surviving soldiers returned to Ireland they were ostracised and forbidden to work in any government post by De Valera. Another humiliation heaped on them was that because they’d gone off to fight against the Nazis and Japanese imperialism their children were seized and carted off to the Industrial Schools on the orders of De Valera! Once again, thanks Robert and the Journal for this valuable and well written article.

    Reply
  • This all happened barely a generation ago. There are many still alive today who lived through this.
    Can we believe that the Japanese and German nations which visited such cruelty on the world are completely cured of their genocidal tendencies?
    Perhaps they are, but we should still be wary of them…

    Reply
    • HaHa,that’s one hell of an ignorant & stupid comment. Living life with your blinkers on. Genocidal tendencies? Hardly, this was war. War is ugly and stuffed with injustice no matter what side your on.

      Reply
    • WS 06/05/12 #

      Nah Kieran ze Germans are taking over Europe financially now with having to invade countries. “Vote yes. Ve vill tell you how to run your finances or else!”

      Reply
    • WS 06/05/12 #

      *without*

      Reply
    • Alan. Do you think Hitler and Hirohito would have enacted a Marshall-type plan if they had won WW2? Would they hell! They would have continued to wipe out every “subhuman” race they came upon, and that probably would have included the superstitious, RC, allied-friendly Irish.

      War is ugly and stuffed with injustice, you are right. Bet you’re glad Adolf wasn’t the first European president, though. If that’s not too stupid and ignorant a comment for you.

      Reply
    • @Kieran, Adolf Hitler was Austrian and he doesnt represent the German mind today. Your accusation that Germans are a nation with Genocidal inclinations is ignorant and at the very least lazy.

      Reply
    • @Kieran: Any national or ethnic group is capable of committing acts of genocide if the circumstances are conducive to it. However, to single out Germany, Japan or any other nation in that regard is in itself an act of ethno-nationalist intolerance. Any right-minded person would not think for one-second that either German or Japanese people have inherent genocidal tendencies. Why should we be any more wary of those nations than our own? The conditions here are ripe for the emergence of a far-right party seeking to apportion blame for at least some of Ireland’s economic problems onto Eastern-European, African or Asian nationals who have settled here in the last decade or so!

      Reply
    • In the end the Japanese and Germans paid for the error of their savage ways and rightfully so,in particular with Japan why should we forgive and forget these animals who treated our own in such a vile and degrading way,what goes around comes around and evil deeds will always recieve the appropriate retribution that is justice for the poor souls who suffered such terrible torment and persecution

      Reply
  • sorry alan….different league and not even remotely comparable…

    Reply
  • It’s hard to feel sympathy for anyone who fought to maintain and expand the frontiers if the empire. In saying that, the Japanese were probably more barbaric in their conquests than the Brits, and that’s saying something.

    Reply
    • What an interesting interpretation of World War II!!! Myself and indeed every single mainstream historian seems to be under the impression that it came about as a consequence of Germany and Japan attempting to expand their territories and the defence of the world against fascism. Oh please do enlighten us as to your conclusions and any documentary evidence you have come across to suggest this. I’m sure that historians everywhere are dying to come across any factual information that you can provide.

      Reply
    • These soldiers were already stationed prior to Japan’s act of war against the empire. Stationed, as another commentator already stated, to maintain an oppressive and humiliating occupation of a native people in a foreign land. Once upon a time they did it here too would you believe… Shocker I know. What history books are you reading?

      Reply
    • Is that a reply to me? I can’t see the relevance of your reply to my comment

      Reply
    • Japanese forces invaded the Soviet Union in 1938 and entered colonies under colonial control (not something which I am an advocate of) in South East Asia thereafter. The Japanese were the aggressor in this instance, not the British or Americans. Yes, there were British troops stationed in those colonies, and no this was not a correct thing. Nevertheless, the Japanese were hardly acting as liberators of enslaved peoples willing to give national governments control in a liberal-democratic tradition. They wanted trade-routes, rich farmland and raw materials, much the same as the initial colonialists had. None of this however takes away from the fact that the Japanese operated as aggressors in this territory and not as some regional liberators which you appear to be implying.

      Reply
    • Imran you have no idea *facepalm*

      Reply
  • Lance Segeant Patrick (Nobby) Nolan from Wexford was my grand uncle. He was one of the 82 men who disembarked in Rabaul and he was one of the 18 survivors. As you can imagine, Pat was in bad shape when he was found after years in Japanese captivity and remarkably he recovered from his ordeal. He went on to have a family and lived a long life. He was a Chelsea Pensioner when he died. By coincidence, 70 years after Pat was captured and sent on a Japanese prison ship from Singapore I am now living and working myself in Singapore.
    Another small coincidence; the aunt of one of my Irish colleagues working with me here was a nurse in Singapore when the Japanese invaded. She was also captured and spent three years in the Japanese Changi prison in Singapore. She survived the horrors of Changi and continued working as a nurse in Singapore for many years after the war. She eventually retired and returned to Mayo and died an elderly woman there.
    These are just two of many stories of sacafice made by thousands of Irish during World War II.
    It’s good to remember them from time to time…..I found Robert Widders book to be a meaningful read….

    Reply
  • Years ago I was beaten, boiling water poured across my chest and humiliated for something I never done, when I reported it to the guards I was told there was no proof even though people witnessed me walk into the place and the hospital report, all because the person that done it was well connected. We have these sort of things that happen on a daily basis, and yet we will not face them. The old saying of get your house in order comes to mind.

    Reply
  • They where serving for a nation that brought genocide to this country. A nation who shot one off our greatest patriots while tied to a chair. A nation who sent an army into a packed stadium shooting at random. These “Irishmen” died for king and country. And it wasn’t Ireland.

    Reply
    • These men fought for many reasons, primarily to challenge and defeat fascism, anti-semitism and a wide range of truly reprehensible things. Then again, perhaps someone like yourself would feel more comfortable living under authoritarianism.

      Pilib, you views are truly disgusting and a stain on your character.

      Reply
    • @Pilib: That’s the ignorance that keeps Ireland down. That’s the ignorance that keeps hatred in our society.

      Reply
    • They fought to put food on the table. I’d say not too many people signed up to save the Jews and sort out Mr Hitler.

      Call a spade a spade

      Reply
    • True to a certain extent Imran, indeed many soldiers in World War II, especially those in dire circumstances did fight for monetary gain. Nevertheless, large numbers of soldiers from more secure circumstances were roused to fight in response to the situation in Europe and the threat posed by the Axis Powers to Europe and beyond. For these soldiers, there was certainly nothing personal to gain from the possibility and often the reality of being killed in action.

      Reply
    • I’m on about the Irish… What you say would be more true about the British soldiers feeling a duty to their empire

      Reply
    • Imran, there were indeed many Irish who responded to the case in Europe and not just monetary gain. It is not just limited to Protestant communities in Ireland, though undeniably many men and women from these communities did respond and there are commemorative plaques in churches throughout the country to this effect (in any case, people in these communities are as Irish as you and I). Besides this, large numbers of middle class Irish Catholics fought in World War II, not in defence of the British Empire, but to protect highly-regarded values such as democracy. I have numerous diary accounts to this effect from my own research in the area.

      Reply

Add New Comment