TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

Shatter criticises Kelleher no-show for Friday Dáil debate

But the Fianna Fáil TD who had criticised the government over Friday sittings said he didn’t have to attend today’s Dáil debate and repeated his criticisms.

Alan Shatter (File photo)
Alan Shatter (File photo)
Image: Photocall Ireland

JUSTICE MINISTER ALAN Shatter has criticised Billy Kelleher after the Fianna Fáil TD did not attend a debate in the Dáil today having early criticised the process of Friday sittings.

The opposition party’s spokesperson on health told RTÉ Radio this morning that Dáil sittings on the first Friday of every month were “a meaningless, pointless episode” and criticised the government’s “window-dressing exercise” saying that no meaningful legislative business was being done.

However, Shatter hit back in the Dáil today: “We had on the airwaves this morning Deputy Kelleher of Fianna Fáil talking about this all being a sham, none of this was serious but he assured the nation that he was going to be present in the House for this important debate.

“Well, deputy (Dara) Calleary was here but he was the only representative of Fianna Fáil who was here,” Shatter said before adding: “If he [Kelleher] wants to make silly, political charges to get himself some personal headline perhaps he would do it on an issue that he intends to contribute to.”

The Minister went on to accuse Kelleher of undermining the government’s attempts to introduce reforms in Leinster House. Speaking to TheJournal.ie this evening the Cork North Central TD hit back and insisted that Dáil sittings on a Friday “are a sham”.

“He’s observant isn’t he?,” he said referring to Shatter. “I am surprised that he would reference me in particular but I’m delighted he’s so observant.”

Kelleher insisted that while he was in Leinster House today it was not for him to be present in the Dáil for a debate on an issue that did not fall within his health portfolio.

“I said I would be in Dublin. I am the spokesperson for health, it it was a justice bill. I don’t know why the Minister would expect spokespersons on other portfolios to be there.

“Friday sittings are a sham. There is no accountability by government, no vote on business on a Friday and there are very few ministers in the environment of Leinster House.

“It is a very important bill,” he said referring to proposed legislation before the Dáil today. “I was watching proceedings. Our spokespeople were represented there and I’m the spokesperson on health so it’s not for me to be present at every Dáil debate.”

He went on the criticise Shatter and his government colleagues, questioning why many of them had not been had been present “in the environment of Leinster House” on a Friday.

“Minister Shatter is accusing us of cheap politics. Well, he should look back at his role in opposition when he accused Fianna Fáil of setting up NAMA to protect builders and accused of protecting bankers. He is in government nearly a year, what has he actually done?” Kelleher added.

Earlier: Dáil sittings on a Friday are ‘a slap in the face of reform’ – Fianna Fail TD

Read next:

Comments (27 Comments)

  • Look around the place most evenings on the news…the place is half empty…and this is what we’re getting for their bloated pay packets…they should be paid on performance and attendance…

    Reply
  • Actually everyone this time I am going to stick up for a politician.. Minister shatter was in a meeting today with two ex soldiers finding solutions for a major problem serving and exer’s are going through.

    Reply
  • So Billy thinks going on the news is more important than turning up to work.

    Reply
  • Hi Billy and I are having a restful evening. He’s exhausted rushing into the Dail to clock in an then straight out to RTE

    Reply
  • they haven’t gone away you know…well maybe for a long weekend….

    Reply
  • This is totally irrelevant, but I have to say you guys at the journal seem to have a talent for getting our politicians best publicity shots ;)

    Reply
  • Billy fell to the first rule of Bull shi&&ing. The fool of a took walked in to this one.

    Reply
  • He’s full of shat

    Reply
  • DaveC 04/02/12 #

    Shatter was absolutely spot on.

    Reply
  • Yes, Kelleher was asked this morning would he be going to the Dail-almost as an aside at the end of the interview.

    He stuttered once or twice, and then replied. That was enough for me. A stuttering Fianna Failer is one without the choreographed skill or the personal discipline to pretend otherwise. In other words, a lying, craven leech.

    Reply
  • Class file photo no doubt.

    They put a time and attendance system into the Oireachtas for TDs and Senators because they had to. they had to prove they showed up to the office to get certain benefits. That’s not to say they have to go to the Dail chamber though. They could sit in the bar all day if they wanted.

    Reply
  • Begrudgy 03/02/12 #

    Nice teeth ha ha.

    Reply
  • Friday sittings are a nonsense and pure window dressing. Fine Gael promised to extend Dail sittings and have come up with this farcical voluntary powerless method so that they can say to the electorate “we have increased the number of days that the Dail sits”

    The only effective way to increase the Dail sittings is to reduce the the periods of recess. It is a nonsense under our system of constituency representation to to expect members to rush back to their constituency offices on a Friday night. Constituency work as to be done. An extra five to seven weeks of sittings would represent real and effective reform.

    Reply
    • It’s disgraceful that the Dail has to sit on Friday. I mean what would happen if normal people had to turn up to work on Friday…

      Reply
    • So when do you expect them to do their constituency work?

      Reply
    • Perhaps the same days of the week that parliamentarians in other countries do it.

      Reply
    • Exactly – Friday to Monday.

      Reply
    • What Const. work. There needs to be a major move away from the TD as a Const. worker. They are there to create and legislate for the state. Let the pot hole filling to Cllr’s. Asking a TD to sort out a medical card should be a criminal offense. I jest but only just.

      Reply
    • @ Tim: The thing is that there is no agreed definition of a good TD. Many voters (both rural and urban I hasten to add having lived in both types of constituency) continue to vote based on what a TD does for them and their local area, rather than taking account of the national situation. It’s been seen time and time again that good constituency workers but terrible parliamentarians get re-elected. The small size of the country, as well as our electoral method (which most people would be strongly against changing) mean that this phenomenon is magnified. As for the voters who rank constituency work above national issues, you and I may disagree with them but in a democracy that is their prerogative and indeed their right I’d say.

      Reply
    • Having our parliamentarians turn up for parliament more often is a good way to get them away fixing pot holes.

      Tim is dead right here. Billy Kelliher’s only hope to get FF back into power is to fix a lot of potholes cause they won’t get in on their parliamentary record.

      More Dail days – fewer pothole fixers.

      Reply
    • Tom, interesting you say thy, because I was a constituent of Kelleher’s for 5 of the last 10 years & he does nothing for his constituents, not a whit. Like the rest of his craven party he is happy to thieve the votes of Cork inner city but gives back nothing in return. Totally unsurprised he doesn’t want to bother turning up for work on Fridays, it only shows the contempt which he clearly holds for his constituents. Shame on him, no wonder Sinn Fein are wiping the floor in Knocknaheeney and Fairhill.

      Reply
  • Alan shatter is shattering and ruing the country, trying to empower everyone in the country, he is some peace of work him and all FG and LB, they should be kicked out of government, a total disgrace to all of them in the way they are corrupt and greedy and trying to undermine all the Irish people, they are nothing, the people of Ireland are better than them, what a load of gift robbing theirs and liars that ever govern this country, wasters.

    Reply
    • Alan Shatter appears to be genuinely committed to reform, give the man a chance. He is in the process of reforming the personal insolvency laws of the country to allow people crippled by debt a new start, and he is reforming the legal profession in order to make it more accessible and affordable to the rest of us. Hardly ruining the country.

      Reply

Add New Comment