TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Counties with lower incomes less likely to pay household charge

A comparison of household charge payments with CSO income data reveals a general correlation between payment and income.

Dublin, represented by John Cooper, has the highest incomes and the highest payment rate of the household charge - while Mark McHugh's Donegal is bottom in both charts.
Dublin, represented by John Cooper, has the highest incomes and the highest payment rate of the household charge - while Mark McHugh's Donegal is bottom in both charts.
Image: INPHO/Cathal Noonan

COUNTIES WHOSE RESIDENTS have a lower income show lower compliance rates with payment for the household charge.

Analysis by TheJournal.ie of data supplied by Phil Hogan last week, and CSO data on the estimated average income for residents in each county, shows that where individuals have higher incomes, payment levels for the charge have been higher.

The CSO data shows that Donegal, Monaghan and Offaly are the three counties whose residents had the lowest total incomes in 2009, the last year for which figures are available – and those same three counties also have the highest boycott rates for the household charge.

Similarly, people living in counties Dublin, Galway, Cork, Kildare, Meath and Limerick have both the highest average incomes and the highest rates of payment for the charge.

The average person in Donegal had a total income of €20,518 in 2009, with income of €17,708 after tax – the lowest in the country, coinciding with Donegal’s status as the county with the fewest eligible homes having paid the charge so far.

Of the eligible households in Monaghan, where residents had income of €18,011 after tax, only 28.1 per cent had paid the €100 charge as of last week.

There are some anomalies in the comparisons: residents of Kerry have the fourth-lowest incomes, with an average after-tax income of €18,694 – but rank 11th of 27 counties in terms of the counties where eligible households have paid the €100 charge.

Similarly Louth, which has the sixth-highest income after tax, has the fifth-lowest record of payment for the household charge, at 34.5 per cent of eligible homes.

In full: County incomes versus Household Charge payments (PDF)

Read: Ulster counties lead table of household charge boycotts

More: People from Donegal have lowest income in Ireland

Read next:

Comments (26 Comments)

  • So from the picture of a GAA match has a connection with household charges. If you win the All Ireland then that county is likely to pay the tax, but if you lose in the semi then they don’t pay.

    Reply
  • Or, to look at it another way, the more a county gets per head in social transfers (and CAP payments), the lower its rate of household charge payment.

    Here’s what each county gets from the tax pot per head annually (minus means they put money in), and their rate of household charge compliance for eligible households (data is CSO county incomes/taxes):

    Donegal €4,316.81 26.60%
    Monaghan €3,343.39 28.10%
    Offaly €2,748.87 32.20%
    Cavan €2,908.33 34.40%
    Louth €2,640.20 34.50%
    Westmeath €2,745.86 34.60%
    Roscommon €2,879.35 34.70%
    Laoighis €2,064.01 34.80%
    Carlow €3,751.96 35.50%
    Longford €4,110.88 35.90%
    South Tipperary €2,823.92 37.30%
    Wexford €3,373.53 37.30%
    Leitrim €4,051.69 37.60%
    Waterford €3,006.36 37.87%
    North Tipperary €2,974.82 38.50%
    Kerry €2,949.13 38.70%
    Clare €1,930.49 38.90%
    Mayo €3,538.05 38.90%
    Kilkenny €2,006.45 39.60%
    Meath -€829.46 39.70%
    Cork €1,510.43 39.98%
    Limerick €2,716.65 40.26%
    Galway €2,296.98 41.20%
    Sligo €2,625.94 41.20%
    Kildare -€772.04 45.10%
    Wicklow -€48.12 46.90%
    Dublin -€955.92 53.11%

    So the more a county usually gets from the tax pot, the less willing its inhabitants are to pay in.

    Reply
    • Have to say it does show up this household charge campaign for much of what it is. And as a resident of Dublin it pee’s me off that while we’re (rightly) sharing tax revenue with the rest of the country many people are not paying their fair share.

      Reply
  • So, the higher a percentage of your salary the charge us, the less likely you are to pay it. That is unsurprising, but at least it provides evidence of something we all suspected, that the main reason for not paying is not being able to afford to.

    Reply
  • Sick of this topic

    Reply
    • Me too.
      Though correct me if I’m wrong here but this whole article is actually meaningless, because the level at which household eligibility is set doesn’t vary by county – the people who have to pay are just as well off in Donegal as Dublin.

      Reply
  • So let’s see…..where people earn more money more people paid the household charge……….well I didn’t see that coming…………….I wouldn’t have figured that one out thanks——by the way it’s good to see still a good few loyal citizens holding out and not paying—- that would b the poor people then

    Reply
  • If I had paid this, I’d be looking for a redund by now, considering half the country haven’t paid…….

    Reply
  • Yes, people who are used to paying tax are used to paying tax.

    Reply
  • There’s a fair few of us Donegalians in Dublin paying the household charge :)

    Reply
  • Wudn b anythin to do with Donegal Monaghan and Offaly folk having balls and standing up to bullies? The border counties were particularly used to oppression. Now only difference it’s French and Germans.

    Reply
  • A Minister of government on the Late Late show states that the house hold charge is unfair but we must pay it.

    Residential properties of Minister of states are exempt from house hold charge so they don’t have to pay it!

    Minister Phil Hogan refusing to pay his property tax in Portugal.

    Unfair? Unjust? That’s an understatement. Pay your share of the tax and them come and ask us for it!

    Reply
    • Ministerial residential properties are not exempt tho no doubt they still wont pay

      Reply
    • @Jim – Mick is correct. Properties vested in a minister’s office are exempt, not their personal properties. For example, the Minister for Defence is the legal owner of army housing in the Curragh – those properties do not have to pay the charge. That doesn’t mean that Alan Shatter’s private home is exempt too.

      Reply
    • Perfect example of the delusions and lies of the can’t pay / won’t pay brigade.

      It has been acknowledged that the first phase of the household charge is not fair as it does not yet use the site valuation method. We will move towards a fairer version once the database is complete. In the meantime, we are paying a nominal charge.

      Residential properties of Ministers of State are not exempt.

      Phil Hogan is in a commercial dispute with the management company of the complex where his Portuguese apartment is located.

      Reply
  • Offaly aint a border town!!! And really not going to look at something with 2009 figures, sur we have no idea if this is true or not, a lot has happened in the last three years

    Reply
  • The cost of living in Donegal is cheaper than Dublin.

    Reply
  • Independence for the Pale……we’re just supporting scroungers.

    Reply
  • I noticed when I read that you didn’t include Kilkenny in your article, which is also a poor county, particularly rural kilkenny, hogan’s constituency, where only 2 thirds have not paid their charge, and fair play to all the people who didn’t pay and standing up to the bullies of Europe, no doubt alot of them will be voting no for the fiscal treaty at the end of this month.

    Reply

Add New Comment