TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 13 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

8 things we learned from TDs’ declarations of interests for 2012

How many deputies own property abroad? And where do those who keep their eyes on Ireland’s finances invest themselves?

Leo: Evidently not much of a tennis player.
Leo: Evidently not much of a tennis player.
Image: Julien Behal/PA Wire

OIREACHTAS AUTHORITIES have published the latest round of members’ interests disclosures for members of the Dáil.

The document – which you can read in full (as a PDF) here – is lengthy, but here are some nuggets we thought were interesting and worth sharing.

Barack Obama gave Enda Kenny a print last year

The US president gave a print worth €1,500 to Enda Kenny when the Taoiseach travelled to Washington for the St Patrick’s Day festivities. The Taoiseach donated the painting to the state, and it now hangs in Government Buildings.

An Aer Lingus takeover would be good news for Clare Daly

The Dublin North TD is a former Aer Lingus employee and built up a shareholding in the airline – but in last year’s disclosure we didn’t know how many.

In this year’s one we learn that the former Socialist TD has 17,000 shares in the airline. That’s worth nearly €21,000 at their current value – and €23,800 if the Ryanair takeover bid, at €1.40 per share, was approved.

Some care more than others about an economic recovery…

A global economic recovery would be good news for Michael Noonan, but not simply because it helps him in his job as Minister for Finance: he has personal investments which rise when the FTSE and Dow Jones indices increase. He also has a similar investment in US banks.

Shane Ross, meanwhile, has investments in US and German government bonds.

…while others are feeling the property pinch

TDs are not required to make any comment on their submissions, but Labour’s Arthur Spring opted to include a small additional statement in his annual disclosure.

Under his ‘occupational income’, Spring lists rental income received from an apartment in Harold’s Cross – which he points out was “purchased as my PDH [primary dwelling house] in 2006 and remains my only property”.

“It is now in negative equity and is currently let,” he adds. “The rental income falls short of the mortgage repayments. I therefore rent my home in Tralee.”

Sure enough, he later mentions a cottage he rents – again asserting, “I am renting due to the predicament of negative equity.”

Keeping it local…

There are two TDs whose private interests – as the proprietors of private companies – mean they have a particularly keen interest in what goes on at their local county council.

Michael Healy-Rae’s disclosure includes contracts between Kerry County Council and Healy-Rae’s filling station in Kilgarvan, which supplies fuel, and Roughty Plant Hire, which carries out maintenance work on behalf of both the council and the HSE.

Mattie McGrath also has a family-run plant hire company, which provides machinery to the county councils of his native South Tipperary and Waterford.

…and keeping it not-so-local

There are nine TDs (at least – we may have missed some) whose property interests includes land overseas.

Justice minister Alan Shatter owns four properties in Florida and two in London; former junior planning minister Willie Penrose has three properties in London, one in the Netherlands and one in Estonia.

Labour’s Dominic Hannigan has properties in London and Florence, while FG’s John Deasy has a place in Sardinia. Both FG minister Phil Hogan and backbencher Aine Collins have property in Portugal.

Junior minister Ciaran Cannon has property in France, while backbencher James Bannon has an apartment in Spain.

Independent TD Michael Lowry – whose British corporate property interests have come under the spotlight recently – lists properties in Mansfield and Wigan, the latter being of “negligible” value.

A few TDs are still on private pensions

Junior minister Dinny McGinley is on a pension for his time as teacher, while his FG colleague Joe O’Reilly has a part-pension for similar reasons.

Sinn Féin’s Michael Colreavy, in Sligo-North Leitrim, has a pension from his previous career working with the local arm of the HSE. Labour’s Brendan Ryan has a pension from his time working for Coca-Cola Bottlers, and FG’s Billy Timmins has a part-pension from his time in the army.

Both Michael Noonan and the Leas Ceann Comhairle, Michael Kitt, are entitled to teachers’ pensions but have forfeited them to the Exchequer while they remain in public office.

In addition, former FF junior minister Dara Calleary discloses his ministerial severance pay, which continued into 2012 – though neither Billy Kelleher nor Willie Penrose, who also received severance pay for former ministerial jobs, did likewise.

Leo Varadkar mustn’t be much of a tennis enthusiast

The Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport was given an honorary membership of Castleknock Tennis Club after his appointment – which he says was “graciously accepted” but not used to date.

Likewise, a membership of the Royal Irish Automobile Club, based close to Leinster House at Dawson Street, has also gone unused.

Read: 11 things we learned from last year’s Registers of Members’ Interests

Read next:

Comments (35 Comments)

  • “Michael Healy-Rae’s disclosure includes contracts between Kerry County Council and Healy-Rae’s filling station in Kilgarvan, which supplies fuel, and Roughty Plant Hire, which carries out maintenance work on behalf of both the council and the HSE. Mattie McGrath also has a family-run plant hire company, which provides machinery to the county councils of his native South Tipperary and Waterford.”

    Is this not all a bit suspect? Shouldn’t public bodies be tendering to get the best deal and not using companies because of family connections?

    Reply
  • Involvement in companies that have contracts with government departments is surely a conflict of interests.

    Reply
  • Allan shatter 4 properties in Florida nice.

    Reply
  • Lowry is some beaut….

    Negligible value? This is the field his estate agent wanted offers of 175-200k…..

    Incredible scenes,
    Adebayo

    Reply
  • I have no problem with anyone spending their wage however they see fit. But Alan shatter has 4 properties in Florida 2 in London WTF! There are rock stars with less property, no wonder he is out of touch. “Let them eat cake!” proclaims Alan from his mansion!

    Reply
  • It’s all about the accumulation of personal wealth. Seems to be the only reason to get into politics these days.

    Reply
    • Nonsense. Any of the Doctors and Lawyers in the Dáil could be earning much more in the private sector, and working less hours in the process.

      Many of the above mentioned TDs earned their wealth before they became TDs.

      Reply
    • Oh yeh, real captains of industry alright.

      How many of FG are doctor’s and lawyers? Reilly, Shatter and Lowry in fairness.

      I know there is a couple of teachers in there that are doing considerable better financially than what they trained for.

      Adebaaaaaaaaaayooooo! Woooooooow!

      Reply
    • Politics has considerably more hours, and is much more stressful than teaching. Of course you’d earn a higher salary. If teachers were determined to accumulate personal wealth, they could do grinds or work their way up to become principal. There are many different ways to accumulate personal wealth in all professions.

      I’m tired of this lazy argument that someone was a teacher before entering politics, therefore they’re useless. Some TDs would have only spent 2/3 years teaching. Is that a fair reason to instantly dismiss their capabilities?

      Reply
    • Who in their right mind would enter politics these days? I’d say a lot of good people are turned off it with the amount of baggage that comes with the job.

      Reply
    • Dave,

      I’d rather see some genuine talent in there. I have a problem with career politicians. They play the game.

      Who you ask? Stephen Donnelly is intelligent and I trust him. I believe he is there for the right reasons.

      Lets face facts, FG are in because FF made a balls of it. Kenny is T by default as far as I’m concerned.
      His own party nearly fecked him out as soon as they got a sniff of power because they know he is weak. The man is afraid of debate and that’s been proven. Tell him I said that when you see him.

      Peace out

      Reply
    • *fewer hours*

      Reply
    • Oh David still flag waving away for your blueshirt courts. This while your lot bleed this country dry and its people dry. Your lot have destroyed our economy and ripped off the public while ‘earning’ massive salaries, junkets and expenses. It’s a bloody cushy number and that’s why so many are attracted to politics and power. Especially the likes of greedy money grabbing neoliberalist incompetent right-wingers of FG and FF (must include New Labour these days). At least in fairness some of the left led individuals have taken salary and expense cuts and appear more genuine in their interest in fellow humanity.

      Reply
    • Hardly anyone is attracted into politics these days. We all sit around and talk about it a lot but very few are putting themselves forward for election. 2011 was an exceptional year, but this was after large cuts to TD salaries. During the boom when TD salaries were at their peak, we had much less putting themselves forward. This contradicts your argument that it’s a “cushy number” and that “so many” are attracted by the money.

      If it’s that cushy and easy to get into, why don’t you put yourself forward Keith?

      Reply
    • Elrat 02/03/13 #

      Think that’s FF you’re talking about!

      Reply
  • If i was in a good job and was earning good money i would invest as well i dont see anything really wrong with politicians doing this as long as they dont use their position to influence and benefit from it

    Reply
  • Has Enda Kenny forfeited his teachers’ pension? Genuine question as I never heard whether he did or not.

    Reply
  • Shane Ross’s German Bonds are loosing him money as the interest rates are so low.

    Reply
  • What a lowlife Artur Spring is. Going on with the poor mouth when he has a property portfolio of 3 or 4 premises. He is also from the wealthiest family in Tralee, claims a salary of 90k and expenses of 60k. On top of this he has his own business and has been creaming it as a councillor for years. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, he is the most useless representative Kerry have ever had in the Dail. And that’s saying something.

    Reply
  • No mention here of Michael Noonan’s pension of circa 57 or is it 75,000 euros from his last stint in government!

    Reply
    • Do any of you people actually read the content of the article, or just move straight to rabble rabble rabble..??

      From the article:
      ” Both Michael Noonan and the Leas Ceann Comhairle, Michael Kitt, are entitled to teachers’ pensions but have forfeited them to the Exchequer while they remain in public office.”

      Reply
    • Not paid anymore while he is in government

      Reply
    • Do you read questions before u start misquotin someones question?No mention here of Michael Noonan’s pension of circa 57 or is it 75,000 euros from his last stint in GOVERNMENT…not his teacher pension

      Reply
  • “Finance Minister Michael Noonan has taken a swipe at TDs who he said have holiday homes in Spain and France but are opposing property tax here”

    But the only TDs declaring foreign property are FG/Lab. Is Slaphead suggesting that others own property abroad and have not declared it? I think we should be told!

    Reply
  • A lot of TDs and Senators have property and off shore accounts that they don’t declare and I am surprised at Clare Daly and Shane Ross pretending to be for the people but stacking up their bank accounts.

    Reply
    • What’s wrong with stacking up your bank account?

      Why I’m not a fan of hers Clare Daly got her share holding from being an employee at Aer Lingus like hundreds more people working at the company (there’s probably limitations on disposing them). She earned them. Likewise there are thousands of ordinary Irish people who invested in property at home and overseas over the past decade.

      Reply
    • Nothing wrong with being paid for work

      Reply

Add New Comment