TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

For Dolphin House residents, concerns over ‘inhumane’ conditions continue

For Linda Burnett-Bowdler, the ongoing problems with damp and mould at the housing complex in south Dublin have taken their toll on her and her family.

Linda Burnett-Bowdler in her ground floor flat in Dolphin House this week.
Linda Burnett-Bowdler in her ground floor flat in Dolphin House this week.
Image: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

RESIDENTS OF THE Dolphin House housing complex in south Dublin continue to live in flats blighted by damp, mould and sewage problems with a third annual report into conditions in the complex presented to Dublin City Council officials this week.

The report by the Rialto Rights in Action network showed that 92 per cent of people living there said that their children had missed school in the past year as a direct result of respiratory problems which affect 37 per cent of the children living in the 436-flat complex according to the survey.

One of these is 17-month-old Jayden Burnett-Bowdler who in the last six weeks was diagnosed with asthma and now has to be administered an inhaler on a regular basis by his mother Linda, who is also on an inhaler and has lived with her family in Dolphin House for the past eight years.

“We lived in one flat for six years where we didn’t have any damp and now we have lived in this flat for 20 months and it’s riddled with damp,” she told TheJournal.ie this week.

“My nine-year-old daughter, Charlie, would have chest infections which take a couple of weeks to clear with an antibiotic but the baby is only 17 months and he has asthma now. I would put it down to the damp.”

Together with her husband Karl, an unemployed home removals man, the couple also have a 12-year-old son, Keaton, whose health has not been greatly impacted by the conditions in her flat but that does not stop the qualified social worker worrying about the toll these living conditions are taking on her family.

05/06/2012. Kearon age12 and Jayden Burnett age1 i

Keaton, 12, and Jayden, 1, in their bedroom in the Dolphin House flat. Photo: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland.

Though the family have made their own attempts to address the problem it continues to affect their lives on daily basis. Linda said: “It has changed since we first noticed it about three months after we moved in. It’s gotten darker in the living room.

“We’ve treated the walls ourselves, we’ve used anti-damp paint, mildew sprays. We had to decorate again because we had family coming and it’s quite embarrassing having big black walls but the redecoration only lasted three weeks and then we had to do it again.

“When it’s in the bedrooms, you do kind of forget about it. But in the living room, you’d spend more time in there then you would in bed and it’s constantly there. It can be quite embarrassing, you spend a lot of time spraying air freshener just to take the smell away.”

The problems of damp are not confined to Linda’s house. Others in the vast complex housing over 900 people have significant problems with damp, mould and sewage which Dublin City Council have been taking steps to rectify in recent months.

Of the 75 flats surveyed by the Rialto Rights in Action group 72 per cent of residents in them reported having damp in their flats while 57 per cent said they had sewage ‘invasion’ whereby sewage was coming up through plug holes in their flats.

For residents the whole process of solving these problems has been too slow in their view. The same percentage who reported dampness when Rialto Rights in Action produced their first report in 2010 have reported it again in 2012 – 72 per cent.

While other numbers indicate that fewer residents are as displeased with the response from DCC than they were two years ago, the extent of the problem and getting it solved means residents affected by damp are likely to be waiting for months yet before their homes are treated.

05/06/2012. Linda Burnett Bowdler's living room in

Linda explained: “Dublin City Council did a survey and 28 flats were seen as affected so they were going to be moved out, work would be done on them and then we would move back in.

“Initially they said my flat wasn’t damp and but then a second test said it was the worst affected. So they sent us a letter in January saying that you are one of the worst affected and that work would be carried out .

“This process started, a few people were moved, their flats were done up, but they got damp again. So they had to do a new test but this hasn’t been signed off by the council yet and it’s now six months since we got the initial letter. So the council have sent the letters out prematurely and it’s still going to be a long process.

“The most frustrating part is that letter. If it hadn’t been sent out in January, it wouldn’t have been so frustrating.”

There has also been some disquiet with the lack of a response from the government. The Department of Environment, Community and Local Government was invited to attend and respond to the concerns of residents when the Rialto Rights in Action group presented their report this week but declined to do so.

In response to queries from TheJournal.ie the Department of Environment said that the management and maintenance of Dolphin House was a matter for DCC but added that it was “fully committed” to the regeneration of Dublin City housing estates, allocating €40 million to regeneration projects including for community social inclusion initiatives in Dolphin House.

25/5/2010. Dolphins House Issues

A statement said: “The Department has been in close liaison with the City Council in recent years in relation to maintenance issues and proposals for the overall redevelopment of the complex. A programme of remedial works and condition surveys has resulted from this process.

“The City Council has also prepared a draft schematic masterplan for the flat complex, which was presented to the Department last March for information purposes.

“The draft plan, which contains a number of potential options for the future redevelopment of the complex, will be subject to further design review, consultation and decision-making consideration by the City Council before a capital funding proposal is to be submitted to the Department.”

Residents like Linda have been promised by the council that there will be more developments by 1 July. At a meeting with residents this week, the assistant city manager Dick Brady, admitted to being “shocked” by the statistics on school attendance among children in the complex.

“It’s nice to know that they are moving and they are doing something but they’re just not doing it quick enough,” Linda added.

“It’s just very disheartening when they’re sending letters out and they’re not doing the work. We’re wondering how long we’re going to be affected for.”

She added: “I don’t think it’s acceptable in the year 2012 that people are living in these kind of conditions.

“We’ve moved on from a lot of stuff but clearly we haven’t moved on with the human rights of people. Sometimes you can just look at it and think this is inhumane for children to live in this.”

Read: Council flat conditions a breach of human rights, commission claims

Read next:

Comments (38 Comments)

  • Either level it and rebuild it properly this time or pick the nearest un-finished ghost estate and finish it. Hit the developer with the costs and/or jail time. This has been going on waaay too long. Can’t believe the residents haven’t taken a case to the european court of human rights seeing as they are being ignored here..

    Reply
  • Why are some of our citizens treated so badly by State agencies? Where is the accountability let alone basic human concern?

    Reply
  • How in the name of god are the residents of Dolphin house still having to deal with this crap. Its been going on too long. Its disgraceful

    Reply
  • Mia 09/06/12 #

    I couldn’t agree more it is a basic human right and they shouldn’t have to put up with this. Disgraceful in this day and age.

    Reply
  • Seen a documentary about flats like this a few years. One mother was bathing her daughter and raw sewage started coming up through the bath. How is it that we can pump billions into the black hole of Anglo yet we can’t spend relatively small amounts on basic human rights? Our society is seriously messed up.

    Reply
  • The debt of 2.1m owed by Mick Wallace would go a long way sorting this problem out. As a penance his company should go in there and sort it out for free.

    Reply
  • dave 09/06/12 #

    Well Martin if I have a problem with my house I have to call a builder or a plumber and pay for it. it won’t make the news I need to get off my hole and do it myself. A house needs to be maintained fact of life least you should do if ya get a free one is the upkeep of same what’s the problem I can’t call the state every time I have a problem.

    Reply
  • Yes I am a newly qualified social worker since 2010 which then had Jayden in 2010 so i haven’t went to work yet Jayden starts creche on monday and im am currently looking for work. This is my situation so yes i am currently unemployed not for to much longer please god. I do clean of this mould and dampand it does return so it is a bigger issue than bleach will do the job. This is the only time im justifying myself to people in any form if I could move I would. A house with a garden is ideal for the kids can i afford it at present no. what is wrong with a qualified social worker living in a tight communiy like Dolphin absoluttley nothing a degree doesnt make me better than anyone else.

    Reply
  • i lived in de apartments at bridgewater quay for a time and de damp coming up from de river bank was de issue, de apartments upstairs didn’t have it as bad as us on ground level so i feel your pain! my boy was diagnosed with asthma too and he was constantly sick while we lived there. i was not there thru the council though, i had rent allowance so we were able to move-i know its not that simple for you! and to those with their “crippling mortgages taking up 50% of their income”-my rent allowance does not cover my rent entirely, nor do de government pay my heating bills! we all live on de bread line. i count myself lucky though-lucky that i wasn’t foolish enough to sign up to a mortgage i couldn’t sustain!

    Reply
  • For too long council housing is seen as a “hand out’ when it should be a ” hand up”!! What about people struggling with mortgages forking out well over 50% of their income every month…if i have damp the bank won’t come out and fix it for free…people with mortgages have to put up, save and pay for repairs! Council tenants only pay 15% of their income too rent…what do people expect to get for this?? this sense and culture of entitlement has to stop- the country can no longer afford it!
    The person in the article is a qualified social worker…that’s a good wage!?Could well afford to buy their own place.
    Additionally, the argument that it is causing school absenteeism is not valid…the report from ballymun, where there has been regeneration and a project to increase school attendance has noted only a 3% increase in attendance.

    Reply
    • Regeneration! Really?. Its been a balls up since day one. Have you seen the quality of houses in the so called regeneration? Quite a high number are Poorly built dog boxes. Structural damage, poor quality. Half of what Ballymun was promised was not fulfilled. As a community worker in Ballymun, i see what was promised and not delivered daily.

      Reply
  • I can’t stand this point scoring “I’m worse off than them, I’ve a huge mortgage!” tripe over who has the most hardship. No body forced you to take a mortgage out. A lot of people are having an awful time of it at the moment. I’ve heard of the sewage issues there before and it sickened me, I’ve lived close to the flats in Dolphins Barn in the past and believe that instances of anti-social behaviour would drop in these area if issues like these were dealt in a timely manner, you can’t keep marginalising young families and expect there to be no repercussions.

    Reply
  • The fact that this has gone on untreated for so long is a credit to the inefficency of dcc, how long must people suffer in such conditions, if this was an African family suffering the same situation i bet by now some p.c. group would be screaming for corrective action to be taken but there again when you are Irish living in Ireland you must go to the back of the line and wait, in this case far too long,This treatment of these people is unacceptable and wrong , these are real issues with irish citizens health being affected and anything that is a health and saftey related problem esp where children are concerned should be addressed straight away.Why do we accept this level of disservice and disregard , at all levels in Irish society,

    Reply
  • Personally I think it’s to easy in this country, wheres the motivation gone!! If you don’t work and your from a Disadvantaged area they’ll just give you a house, free medical, fuel allowance, children allowance etc.. There’s no incentive to work. People don’t realise but the hard working taxpayer with mortgage are the ones on the breadline and we don’t complain, we just get on with it because it was the way we were brought up.

    Reply
    • Plenty of people would love to have a job but with 400,000 odd unemployed it’s not exactly that easy now is it? If you’d read the article you’d see the woman described was a qualified social worker and her husband an unemployed removals man – they had jobs once and now they don’t, like lots of people out there. Council accommodation isn’t necessarily filled with people who don’t want to work, wake up and smell the recession. You could lose your job one day and if you were unlucky enough to have your partner lose their job at the same time then this could be you in a few years.

      Reply
    • Yes Niall there are many people struggling, I accept that but most of them are home owners who have lost there jobs. I am very grateful for my job and never take it for granted. It gets me to this gimme gimme gimme sense of entitlement in our country. I have 3 sisters all with degrees that have emigrated (London, Canada, Boston – they don’t even have each other abroad) the easy option for them was to stay here and live off the state with the fingers crossed that maybe it will get better or go after work. This recession takes its toll on every family but people should be more responsible for themselves, stop your whinging Linda, be grateful you have a roof over your head, a state that won’t let you starve or freeze and all for nothing. At least she can see her family whenever she wants

      Reply
    • @ appleseed for a person who is a hardworking , home owner who does not complain you seem to be doing the opposite,the state has an onus to provide adequate and safe housing through its social housing plan to its citizens , if you chose to buy your house thats your business nobody forced you to do so but do not criticize those who were not in the same position as yourself with the they should be happy argument.Emmigration is not an option for all so using it as part of your case makes no sense, maybe the fact that your property has gone into negative equity irks you more the fact that some citizens of this state are entitled to proper public housing , you paid your money and made your choicenobody forced you at any time to buy, now stop whinging and let those who deserve better have a voice too

      Reply
  • Thank you Lesley when people don’t no a full story there quick to judge they can judge away now.

    Reply
  • yes i agree but until the inspections are done and they coporation decide to fund the regeneration of the flats. bleach and hot water will have to do. why sit back and let the damp worsen, i lived in the flats and thats what i did and it did prevent it.

    Reply
  • not all flats in dolphin house is like this, if the problem had of been treated wen first established it wouldn’t be at the extent it is now. bleach and hot water clears the damp and then a lick of paint.

    Reply
    • Bleach and hot water?! They need weathering details, waterproof membranes, insulation and injected DPC’s

      Reply
    • Bleach and hot water only cleans and kills the mildew for a while. It’s the condensation in the flats and lack of insulation that’s a big problem. Quickest cure is an appropriate air vent in all rooms.

      Reply
    • Yes water is great for getting rid of damp, you should patent that then go on dragons den!

      Reply
    • phyllis my flat was treated back in 2008 by dcc by putting plaster boards on the walls and im still affected by it as it has gotten alot worse and bleach and water only takes it away for while and it keeps coming back no matter wat ya use to get rid of it its still comes back this is why people want dcc to get in and do the job properly. and for people who think linda is moaning about hers she not only doing it for herself she is doing it for the hole complex human rights if people understand wat that means cause half the comments i have read i dont think people do

      Reply
    • jay you knob head shut up. anita i know what the flats are like im not saying fuk them leave them in it to rot im simply saying dcc dnt give a shit so the best thing is to is keep cleaning it until the dcc eventually do it. jim ohalran didn care not sure abt the new fella but with a bit of luck it’ll be done soon

      Reply

Add New Comment