TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Grangegorman whistleblower out of work as Irish Advocacy Network hit by funding shortage

Louise Bayliss was “shocked” to hear that the Irish Advocacy Network had no jobs for its trainees but CEO Colette Nolan said funding has got so tight the group is looking for ways to keep the staff it already has.

Louise Bayliss.
Louise Bayliss.
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

THE WOMAN WHO went public on the health service’s plans to hold mental health patients in a locked facility over Christmas has been let go from the Irish Advocacy Network after completing a six-month training programme.

The group’s CEO Colette Nolan has defended the move, citing funding shortages and cuts to its budget.

The IAN receives the majority of its funding from the Health Service Executive, a figure that was cut by 7.1 per cent last year.

“We have streamlined a lot of different things throughout the organisation to keep our staff this year but as far as new jobs are concerned, we will be looking at how to keep the staff we already have,” Nolan told TheJournal.ie.

The chief executive was speaking after Louise Bayliss was told there would be no extension to a trainee contract that she and another colleague were signed onto in March.

“We wanted to build up capacity so that we would have people trained up and willing to be called on to help us out,” she explained. “It meant that they would be there if we could secure funding, which we couldn’t.”

All those who completed the training will still be put forward for accreditation.

Late last year, Bayliss went public over plans to transfer mental health patients to St Brendan’s Hospital in Grangegorman and keep them in a locked unit over the Christmas period.

In January, she was informed that her six-month advocacy contract was being terminated after three months. The contract’s withdrawal sparked public outcry, and she was subsequently reinstated.

However, she told TheJournal.ie that in March, she and four colleagues were told that they were being put on training contracts. Of the three who finished the course, one already had a permanent contact and has been retained by IAN.

“We were trained for nothing,” she said. “They brought us in today for five minutes each and said, ‘Good luck, I’m sure our paths will cross one day.’”

“The ironic thing about it all is that four years ago, I was suffering from post-natal depression and going through the break-up of my marriage and I decided to go into the mental health sector. So I went back to college and I thought that by the time my daughter is ready to go to school, I’ll be ready to start a job. For four years that’s what has kept me going.

“Could they have chosen a worse day to tell me there’s no job? My daughter starts school tomorrow.”

“So I’m back to square one, looking for another job. I thought that if I played the game, then it would work out. I never thought they’d train us for six months without any job at the end of it.”

Going public

Bayliss says she still has no regrets about going public on the patients transfers before Christmas.

“I was only in the bank a few weeks ago and I met one of the patients who was transferred. I didn’t think she would recognise me, but she came up to me and she said, ‘Thanks for doing that.’”

“It has been very hard for me to go in the morning and face everyone,” she said of going back to work after the whistleblowing. “But I did it with a smile on my face. I genuinely did want to work with patients and help people, and I wanted to show that I wasn’t just a troublemaker, that I wanted to help.”

She said that she was “shocked” to see the group being told there were no jobs at the end of the training “because they had to pay for us to be trained, pay for mobile phones, pay for transport, sometimes accommodation, for somebody to train us”.

“And all for nothing.”

Changes in training

Nolan and the IAN have worked on changing their training methods after last year’s incident after taking full responsibility for what happened. The new model will include group training before any shadowing of experienced advocates takes place.

“We have the best staff in the world,” said Nolan. “We are instrumental in helping so many people in their journey to recovery. They do an incredible job and maybe it is time to get that out there, rather than the negative stuff.”

-With additional reporting by Sinéad O’Carroll

Related: Government publishes draft legislation aimed at protecting whistleblowers>

Read next:

Comments (19 Comments)

  • I just want to clarify a few things. Firstly I Believe the staff in IAN do fabulous and important work and I would love to see them getting their funding increased. Secondly, I was not hired as a trainee, I was hired as an advocate for the National Mental Health Forensic Services (Central Mental Hospital) and was learning on the job in Grangegorman while waiting for Garda clearance. After the furore in January, everyone who started at the same time as me , were compelled to sign “trainee contracts” . The organisation does not have the funds to pay people for 9 months without getting any benefit from their training, so I see this as a gross mismanagement of scarce financial resources and I do believe it was an expensive pr stunt. I have campaigned for the unfair attacks on lone parents, on DCA payments, carers and rent caps which are forcing families out of communities and schools. I make no apologies for that and will continue to do everything in my limited capacity to fight for a more equal and just society. I am not ant-government per se but against inherited privilege and it’s natural corollary of inherited disadvantage. I do believe that it is harder for certain groups of people to show dissent or argue their cases and in these austere times they seem to be the most vulnerable. I am not a bleeding heart or a goody two shoes but I passionately believe that a more just and equal society will benefit everyone and I will continue to campaign for that. I believe in structure and in fair government and a real democracy ensures all voices are equally heard and currently I don’t believe that is happening.

    I honestly wish all the staff in Irish Advocacy Network well and hope the organisation does grow and strengthen as a voice for people diagnosed with a mental illness. The staff do a very important job and I can honestly say that I am full of admiration for them all and their utmost dedication to the people they work with.

    Reply
    • In my opinion there are very few lone parents . what we have are lots of people who for one reason or another have decided to bring up a child independently of its father . your first port of call should be to the father of the child and not expect the general public to pay the costs of same

      Reply
    • Gerry — That’s already happening. An applicant cannot be awarded OFP without first having approached the father for maintenance. If the father refuses he will often be pursued through the courts but even when this is exhausted nobody can actually make him pay; often fathers will refuse to pay and the mother will eventually give up.

      As for your opinion that there are very few lone parents: What’s it based on exactly?

      Reply
    • Well done Louise. I have no doubt that you have been blacklisted though. Why else would you not be offered a post?It seems that being a good advocate is not what they want. I’m sure that some enlightened organisation will be only too pleased to gain the services of a principled, caring, intelligent and strong individual such as yourself. I would suggest that you try politics but for the fact that I think you’d be blackballed there as well. Good luck for the future and I’m certain that more than just the patients you helped admire your character….

      Reply
    • It would seem that you had your own agenda and didn’t pay heed to the very well,laid down guidelines for action that would have direct consequences on the organisation that gave you chance. But you knew better and here you area still,unwilling to realise that conformity is vital in the kind of work you do. Non conformity can lead to problems and they have clearly caught up with you.

      Reply
    • Keep up the good work Louise.
      A little prayer attached that may help from time to time.

      “I have never made but one prayer to God, a very short one: “O Lord make my enemies ridiculous.” And God granted it. ”
      Voltaire

      Reply
  • fair play to her. She spoke up about wrongdoings and was sacked. she won her case for unfair dismissal and has now been strung along. its the wrong message to send out to people that if they report bad practice they will be treated like shit. bullying of the worst order.

    Reply
  • “Punishment is now unfashionable… because it creates moral distinctions among men, which, to the democratic mind, are odious. We prefer a meaningless collective guilt to a meaningful individual responsibility.”

    Thomas Szasz, Psychiatrist and patients rights advocate who died earlier this week aged 92.

    Reply
  • Will 15/09/12 #

    The Establishment will always get you, they’re happy to bide their time.

    Reply
    • I don’t thinks so Conor the name is real and I have a Mammy and Daddy but I use the twitter account exclusively for postings on the Journal. I do that because I have had death threats and we have had our property entered by people late at night with offensive weapons found on them. What would you like me to do……put my phone number up as well? .

      Reply
  • It does raise questions aplenty about the competence of management and use of scarce funds in the health service. The phrase, “Too many chiefs and not enough indians” springs to mind.

    Reply
  • Jerry slattery, what an obnoxious comment to make. No woman chooses this life, whether you want to believe that or not. How dare you make such a vile statement. Let me make you aware of something, I never Intended to be parenting alone..but do you know what..I HAVE to. I had to get out of a horrible situation for myself and my daughter, now my ex partner has been in her life always, well takes her a couple of hours a week, never wanted more than that. July 14 th he didnt show up for her as scheduled, I had a 2 yr old waiting at the window for him. He hasn’t shown up since that day . Fast forward to. August 7 th, he stopped paying anything towards his child. I’m left not only with a toddler who is wondering where her dad is, and looking for answers, but with no contribution from him towards her care. So please don’t come out with stupid uneducated comments like ‘the first port of call to be the father of the child’ that is the first port of call for all lone parents and you will not received a payment from the state until you have tried to get maintenance from the father. My point is, my ex has vanished from my daughters life with no reason, I’m heartbroken that someone could walk away from a beautiful little girl, but I’m very aware that when my court date comes up in November my faith on maintenance will rely on the judges mood that day..so maybe if we had a proper court system in place things would be better for all…this shouldn’t be yet another attack on people parenting alone.

    Reply
  • I would think this strong minded person is not about to shy away from the limelight . I expect we will hear from her again people such as Joe Duffy and that late night guy on 4fm thrive on people like her .

    Reply
    • In more ways than one, Jerry..if Duffy, and the likes, would take a less obscene salary from the public purse there might be enough to fund twenty more staff. Throw in Pat Kenny’s and Ms Finucane sack of loot and we could open a new wing.
      No shortage of wealth..its the distribution by the deified(by the grateful beneficiaries) ‘invisible hand of the market’ that is insane(in the original meaning of insanitary/unhealthy i.e. unbalanced by rationality).
      Even our ‘national broadcaster’ has been bought(by stealth)into the corporate gluttony.

      Reply
  • mcbab 15/09/12 #

    Mick Collins is right. There is much more to this story. How about the Journal doing a bit of investigating ?

    Reply
    • Why….the girl is a troublemaker no matter where she will go. No employer wants someone as a trainee shooting from the hip when a quiet word in the right ear would have done so much more. This lady lobes and courts confrontation. End of story

      Reply

Add New Comment