TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 9 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Guess how many people have been jailed for not paying fines this year?

New figures reveal the thousands of people who have been jailed this year in Ireland for non-payment of fines.

Image: Sam Boal/Photocall Ireland

ALMOST 7,000 PEOPLE have been sent to prison so far this year for not paying fines, new figures have shown.

A total of 6,969 people had been committed to prison by the end of November for the offence, according to figures released by the Minister for Justice.

The figures are a minor increase on last year.

However the numbers confirm that there has been a dramatic surge in the last three years in the number of people being jailed for not paying fines.

There has been a 176 per cent increase in the number of people jailed for the offence since 2008, when 2,520 people were sent to jail for not paying fines.

Liam Herrick, the head of the Irish Penal Reform Trust (IPRT) which campaigns for reform of Irish penal policy, said that imprisoning people for non-payment was “redundant” and “wasteful”.

“At a time of scant resources, the redundant exercise of imprisoning people for non-payment of fines is extremely costly and wasteful in terms of Courts, Gardaí and prison resources,” said the IPRT Executive Director.

More importantly individuals are being committed to our overcrowded prisons in cases where judges have already determined that prison sentences are not appropriate.

Responding to the issue in the Dáil, Minister for Justice Alan Shatter defended the figures, saying that people in jail for fines make up a small fraction of the prison population at any one time.

On 30 November, 20 prisoners – 0.5 per cent of the total prison population – were in jail for not paying fines, Minister Shatter told the Dáil.

He also said that he intended to start a number of provisions contained in the Fines Act 2010 in the new year, such as allowing people to pay fines by instalments and substituting community service orders for fines.

“I expect that these measures, taken together, will all but eliminate the need to commit persons to prison for non-payment of fines,” Minister Shatter said.

However the failure to fully  implement the Fines Act, some 18 months after it became law, was criticised by Liam Herrick:

“The failure to follow up at administrative level to allow for the payment of fines by installment means that thousands continue to be jailed for non-payment of fines 18  months after the legislation was signed into law,” said Herrick.

The figures were revealed in a parliamentary question asked Michael Healy-Rae TD in the Dáil.

The figures also showed that the number of people jailed for not paying back debt has increased dramatically.

29 people were jailed for non-payment of civil debt up until the end of November this year – compared to just 5 people for the whole of last year.

The figures came from the Annual Reports of the Irish Prison Service.

Read more: Reports reveal issues in Irish prisons >

Read next:

Comments (39 Comments)

  • Fitzpatrick is still out and about though!

    Reply
  • How many people have been sent to prison for creating the situation where people are being convicted for not paying these fines?

    Reply
  • I would like to see the breakdown of what the fines were for.

    Reply
  • 18 TDs will be jailed in the new year for not paying the property tax!

    Reply
  • More than likely the reason for the increase is because the Gardai were told to go and collect fines where court judgements had been made against people and payment had not been made. They are left with no choice but to imprison anybody who either cannot or will not pay their fines. Our police force are slowly being turned into tax collectors because the state needs money. This is obviously counterproductive in lots of ways, they are employed to fight crime – (I know it’s an offence not to pay a fine ) but how much is collected over and above the cost of transporting and housing the non payers in our already overcrowded prisons. Our government really need to cop on and change the system rather than just waste money for the sake of getting numbers up for their statistics reports.

    Reply
    • It’s not up to the guards to collect fines and it never was, the courts imposed the fines and also the custodial sentence should fines be unpaid, saying that the guards are out collecting fines is pure bullsh1t.
      If the judges would just use common sense and use community service as a means of punishment we’d all be better off. It would take the pressure off the guards and prison service.

      Reply
    • @ Mark Ryan

      I’m not talking bullshit! I am 100% sure of my facts. Call it first hand experience.

      Reply
  • Eoin Faz 19/12/11 #

    As a rule of thumb if you are jailed for non-payment of fines you can expect to be locked up for a number of hours. About 2-4hrs for initial processing, followed by around 1hr for each €100 you owe. When released you will be left with a civil record rather than a criminal record, which does not inflict any restriction on international travel.

    Reply
  • How about one of those highly paid justice department secretaries implementing a system of garnering fines and outstanding taxes at source from bank accounts/wages/social welfare. The yanks have been doing it for years. Waste of resources sending people to prison. In and out the same day.

    Reply
  • How about deducting the fine by reducing tax credits or welfare payment….you do the crime u pay the fine!!!! But its rediculous jailing people for not paying TV license! Surely this costs the tax payer more than the cost of the fine…crazy stuff!!!

    Reply
    • Love this idea of reduced welfare and increased tax to cover it. Wouldn’t be able to do it legally though I think? Plus the bleeding hearts would be wheeling out “the vunerable”.

      Reply
  • That’s one way to kick start the construction again there going to need more prison places after we all get done for not paying household charges. Bring it on , I’d say some people are looking forward to it so that they can be sure of 3 meals a day .

    Reply
  • I know of someone recently who spent two days in Cork for a fine (no DOE) he did not have the money to pay. He turned up at his local Gardai station as requested and was then driven to Cork jail by two Gardai who to rub salt into the wounds spoke of their overtime perks courtesy of the recent visits of Obama and the Queen.

    The jail had no knowledge of this person so was he moved from cell to cell meeting several other people in the couple of days he spent there. They to were also in Jail for non payment of fines.

    I see no purpose to such a costly exercise and even the person in question said he would have preferred to have donated the same time to a community project thus giving something back rather than costing the taxpayer for a wasteful taxi ride courtesy of the Gardai.

    Reply
  • Doubt if any that 7,000 contained Political,Banking or Developer elite. Like taxes prison is for the little people.(“taxes are for the little people”quote from former American Heiress Leona Hemsly.She said that along time ago,seems to be spot on in Ireland today though.

    Reply
  • As far as Seanie fitz and the rest ,from last week DPP is still yet to direct prosecution..but I d like to see the figures on social welfare fraud, stopping these fines at source because again they know it’s all another scam,, why would you pay a fine when the prisons are so packed it’s like a rotating door in for 2 hours and out again., and the ppl who are doing this are well away this is it’s current state.. Think about this if fines were properly stopped at source be it paye or social welfare based on pps numbers maybe there would be less of burden on those who do the right thing and have a few morels still left..Whole system needs to be scrapped and revamped!!!!!!

    Reply
  • And by the looks of things with all the austerity cut backs and home tax there will be a he’ll if a lit of us in Jail next year

    Reply
  • I hav loads of unpaid fines & I’m never paying them. Let them lock me up & waste their money I don’t care!

    Reply
  • Where do the judges get the time to deal with making committal orders for minor offences? We hear every day how the courts are so backlogged that judges can’t clear their lists and are sitting extra hours just to keep us safe in our beds. Very busy gentlemen indeed.

    Reply
  • Jambbie 19/12/11 #

    Fine story

    Reply
  • I work with people from a certain area of Dublin and their friends would rather spend a short stint in jail than pay fines. It’s like a wee holiday for them where they get to see some of their mates. It’s a waste of tax money sending most people to prison, they just come out and repeat the same crimes again.

    Reply
  • Too many

    Reply

Add New Comment