TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

Statue of praying Hitler in ex-Warsaw ghetto causes controversy

The statue by Italian artist Maurizio Cattelan, depicts Adolf Hitler praying on his knees.

The statue by Italian artist Maurizio Cattelan of Adolf Hitler praying on his knees in Warsaw, Poland.
The statue by Italian artist Maurizio Cattelan of Adolf Hitler praying on his knees in Warsaw, Poland.
Image: Czarek Sokolowski/AP/Press Association Images

A STATUE OF Adolf Hitler praying on his knees is on display in the former Warsaw Ghetto, the place where so many Jews were killed or sent to their deaths by Hitler’s regime, and it is provoking mixed reactions.

The work, entitled ‘HIM’, by Italian artist Maurizio Cattelan, has drawn many visitors since it was installed last month. It is visible only from a distance, and the artist doesn’t make explicit what Hitler is praying for, but the broader point, organizers say, is to make people reflect on the nature of evil.

In any case, some are angered by the statue’s presence in such a sensitive site.

One Jewish advocacy group, the Simon Wiesenthal Center, this week called the statue’s placement “a senseless provocation which insults the memory of the Nazis’ Jewish victims.”

“As far as the Jews were concerned, Hitler’s only ‘prayer’ was that they be wiped off the face of the earth,” the group’s Israel director, Efraim Zuroff, said in a statement.

‘Strong emotional impact’

However, many others are praising the artwork, saying it has a strong emotional impact. And organizers defend putting it on display in the former ghetto.

Fabio Cavallucci, director of the Center for Contemporary Art, which oversaw the installation, said, “There is no intention from the side of the artist or the centre to insult Jewish memory.”

“It’s an artwork that tries to speak about the situation of hidden evil everywhere,” he said.

The Warsaw ghetto was an area of the city which the Nazis sealed off after they invaded Poland. They forced Jews to live in cramped, inhuman conditions there as they awaited deportation to death camps. Many died from hunger or disease or were shot by the Germans before they could be transported to the camps.

The Hitler installation is just one object in a retrospective of Cattelan’s work titled ‘Amen’, a show that explores life, death, good and evil. The other works are on display at the centre itself, which is housed in the Ujazdowski Castle.

The Hitler representation is visible from a hole in a wooden gate across town on Prozna Street. Viewers only see the back of the small figure praying in a courtyard. Because of its small size, it appears to be a harmless schoolboy.

“Every criminal was once a tender, innocent and defenseless child,” the centre said in a commentary on the work.

Poland’s chief rabbi, Michael Schudrich, said he was consulted on the installation’s placement ahead of time and did not oppose it because he saw value in the artist’s attempt to try to raise moral questions by provoking viewers.

He said he was reassured by curators who told him there was no intention of rehabilitating Hitler but rather of showing that evil can present itself in the guise of a “sweet praying child.”

“I felt there could be educational value to it,” said Schudrich, who also wrote an introduction to the exhibition’s catalogue in which he says art can “force us to face the evil of the world.”

Many people who have seen the work have praised it.

‘It’s provocative, but it’s not offensive’

“It had a big emotional impact on me. It’s provocative, but it’s not offensive,” said Zofia Jablonska, a 30-year-old lawyer. “Having him pray in the place where he would kill people – this was the best place to put it.”

Cattelan caused controversy in Warsaw in 2000 when another gallery showed his work ‘La Nona Ora’ – or ‘The Ninth Hour’ – which depicts the late Pope John Paul II being crushed by a meteorite. That offended many in Poland, which is both deeply Catholic and was John Paul’s homeland.

Read: Bodies of suspected WW2 victims exhumed from mass grave in Croatia >

Read next:

Comments (53 Comments)

  • I understand both points. The artist is trying to portray the madness/evil/sickness by someone who is clearly mentally disturbed; who is praying for such evil and ultimately almost fully carries it out. Also the fact that most Germans were overwhelmingly pro-Nazi/Christian (half Roman Catholic/half Lutheran). The message of the art is good but I can still understand the hurt it can cause to many Jews regardless of the well intentioned point/message behind the art. I’m always disturbed how a country like Germany which was leading in science, technology, mathematics, education, etc. could carry out such savagery for a so-called “educated” “advanced” country.

    Reply
    • We are discussing the topic and thays good. Complacency regarding ultra nationslism at at a time of economic failure was what gave creedence to the Nazis in the first place. While the Holocaust is central to Jewish history and their sociology there is ab increase in neo nazism in many eastern european countries. Maybe this puts Hitler where he belongs , grovelling for mercy.

      Reply
    • I know the bad economy and WWI defeat were factors (scapegoats obviously, but the Jew hatred had to have existed before as well) it still amazes me that they exterminated 6 millions Jews. Yeah I’ve always found it ironic how much of this Neo-Nazism is on the rise in Eastern Europe (ex: Serbs) being that Hitler deemed them inferior and wanted to enslave them. Ultranationalism is anyways the main cause of genocide and persecution.

      Reply
    • Antisemitism was cultivated by the Roman church from its earliest days when they were portrayed as the Christ-killing alien enemy within.

      The fourth paragraph of the part about ‘ Strong emotional impact’ which refers to the Warsaw Ghetto has a disturbing echo in today’s Israeli treatment of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank.

      Ultra nationalism mutated from victim to victimiser in a cycle of tribal exclusion unable to transcend to full human inclusivity. Our own local islands are not immune from the collective psychosis.

      Reply
    • Technically was it not the Romans who killed Jesus?

      Reply
    • Well said, Damien.

      Reply
    • Technically it was the Jerusalem temple under Caiaphas, who resented the population hailing him(JC) as the anointed one as he, as high priest, figured he was the anointed pontiff. ‘Christ’ derives from ‘chrism’, the holy oils used for the anointing.

      He dragged a reluctant Pilate in to do the dirty.

      Buty Hitler’s real religious beliefs were a mish mash of Norse mythology and pseudo-scientific race-worship akin to modern day Zionism in its narcissistic self-hypnosis.

      Reply
  • rmcd66 30/12/12 #

    It’s interesting all right !

    Reply
  • I think that there might be a very simple explanation for this “art work”. (I’m not sure of the date of the article)
    http://moreintelligentlife.com/content/artview/against-odds

    “A few months ago one of Cattelan’s most significant sculptures, “Him” (pictured left), traded behind the scenes for $10m, a sum that few living artists of his generation can command. Smaller than life-size, “Him” is a spookily realistic depiction of Hitler kneeling in prayer.”

    If it was worth $10M in a gallery think how much it is worth now.

    Reply
  • A statue of Hitler placed anywhere could be seen as provocative or offensive. I’m honestly not sure if this is a good idea not convinced one way or the other.
    The one good thing is that it reminds us that such places existed and still do to some extent in other parts of the world.

    Reply
  • It is not unusual for evil people to delegate their Evil work to others while playing the innocent themselves thus having the best of two worlds.

    Reply
  • Liam 30/12/12 #

    There is no doubt that Christianity played a large role in Hitler’s life (influencing his social and political views), Hitler and the rest of his cohorts believed that the Jewish people where somehow responsible for Germany’s problems, this along with Christianity where enough of a reason to try to exterminate every Jewish person they could find. creating this statue is a reminder to people of that, however it could have been placed somewhere else.

    Reply
    • What is missing in your point is that Christians were persecuted by Hitler too, obviously not to the same extent as the Jewish people. Hitler tried to destroy the Lutheran churches by assimilating them into the Reichskirche which proclaimed Hitler as the new Messiah. Mein Kampf was put on the altar of these new churches. He imprisoned Lutherans who did not accept this new church. He fired Catholic news editors and civil servants. He also imprisoned priests who spoke out against him in their sermons. Granted, his attempts to suppress the Christian faith in Germany was more a political strategy than the patently systematic hatred he reserved for the Jews. However, Hitler’s persecution of the Jews was not motivated by a misplaced sense of Christian duty. Indeed, he denounced Christianity as being a religion which protects the weak.

      Reply
    • Hitler persuaded Germans with Christianity is the point. The German Christians aren’t the victims here regardless of individual Lutherans or Catholics speaking out against him and being killed because of it. He had a majority Christian-backing.

      Reply
    • Hitler did not wow people with a sense of fervour to a Christian message. You seem to be suggesting that people supported Hitler because he somehow linked his anti-Semitism to Christianity. Hitler appealed to peoples’ nationalism and offered them a way out of their socio-economic plight. So while the majority of people who supported Hitler were Christians, their religious moral compass was way down on the list of reasons to vote for Hitler.

      Reply
    • Anti-Semitism was very much alive in Germany before Hitler was even born. The Catholic Church? Martin Luther? I’m blaming the institutions and the German people not Christians in general.

      Reply
    • @Erin go bragh. your point is well made, many institutions failed, as they do still. the RC church did more than any group to foster hatred towards the Jewish community by blaming them for crucifying Jesus.

      Reply
    • I read mein kampf to try and understand what motivated that evil man to do what he did. Hitler was a christian and believed he was doing “gods work” he did not see himself as evil but rather a liberator who believed in the “natural order” of things and saw communism as a threat to that order. He was totally against communism and saw Jews as the main driving force behind the rise of communism in Germany/ Austria . This was one of the main excuses he used to target them. Although an evil man he admired and had good relations with the Roman Catholic Church and the RCC made many millions of Deutschmarks in church taxes during his reign. Of course the RCC has a history of supporting fascist regimes and being anti communist , socialist and anti democracy. Nowadays they try to distance themselves from Hitler, Mussolini and Franco and pretend that they the church were champions for human rights and never supported those fascist regimes during WWII. Thankfully there’s still plenty of evidence to show where their allegiances lay during those times .

      Reply
  • @Brian… The fact that you would put 6 million innocent men women and children forced into labour camps, starved to death, murdered on an industrial level never seen before and a guy who caused the death of thousands in a terrorist attack in the same category is truly disturbing. Solders are trained to take orders, in a hierarchy fascist system that existed in Nazi Germany where the top realm decide on the actions of a powerful nations armed forces the responsibility can only rest with them.

    Reply
  • Where does Sinn Fein and stand on this? Maybe, lets all move on? Ah lads, its all in the past? Sure werent they all at it…Stalin, Pol Pot etc?

    Reply
  • If I was a local I’d be down there with a sledgehammer at night. A crass and insensitive way for an artist to make a name for himself.

    Reply
  • Finally something appropriate for a jar of piss.

    Reply
  • john fox 30/12/12 #

    I have no problem wit his art . Its just where he placed it.

    Reply
  • rmcd66 30/12/12 #

    It’s interesting alright ?

    Reply
  • Looks more like a little boys praying not an adult ..

    Reply
  • Who would want to make a statue of Hitler??? Other than pro Nazi outfits? Hitler believed in the occult, as did all the high ranking party officials, so I doubt if Hitler or any high ranking Nazi of the time would pray, let alone kneel and pray! Ethics of this ‘artist’ has to be questioned! If the statue had been placed in a German city the artist would be arrested! It reeks of a sick self-publicity stunt.

    Reply
  • Oh no , this is so wrong . Its almost giving the power back to the evil he created . Would it not have been more fitting to have a Jewish victim praying . Just my thought …

    Reply
    • f molloy 30/12/12 #

      you’re right Fred, it would be more fitting to have a Jewish victim praying, but would it provoke the same reaction? the artist is being deliberately provocative here, as is his duty as an artist. just look at the comments on this page alone and multiply that by all the papers around the world that carry this story.

      Reply
  • As watery catholic a praying hitler is not the best idea unless it is stated he is praying to the darker forces .The comment about Germany being part catholic is interesting ,could it be possible that biblical
    Writings second part blaming Jews on Christ,s death make it easier for the Germans to accept those
    Authrosities

    Reply
    • Praying to darker forces? Makes no sense. Hitker was quite a religious man and that can’t be taken away from him. It’s a fact that nobody died at Hitlers hands during the war. He no more killed Jews than Obama killed Bin Laden. Soldiers do the killing.

      Reply
    • @Brian …. Just because he did not actually pull the triggers does not make him any less guilty of murdering millions !

      Reply
    • Gamma 30/12/12 #

      Brian has a point. Granted it was Hitler. That ordered the genocide but if he is to be held accountable for the Holocaust, doesn’t that mean that the blood of everyone killed by the US army in the last 5 years (innocents included) is squarely on Barack Obama’s hands?

      Reply
    • Seriously your going to compare Obama with HITLER? The US targets terrorists and isn’t exterminating any ethnic/religious groups. Do innocent civilians get killed intentionally? NO. I mean if cowards like the Taliban/Al Qaeda purposely attack US soldiers in places full of civilians or hide in civilian areas; civilians are bound to get hurt being in the middle of it all. It’s no accident that terrorists just happen to always attack/hide in such places. We’re the Allied forces who killed Nazi/Axis soldiers the same as the Nazis? NO.

      Reply
    • Erin, while I support Obama, he is targeting religious groups. Al Queda and the Taliban are religious extremists.

      Reply
    • Oh poor Pope Benedict, cry me a river.

      Reply
    • I couldn’t care less about the pope. I’m just correcting you.

      Reply
    • You can’t correct Erin…click on his name.

      Pure Bushman.

      Reply
    • What have you corrected me on? The American Catholic Church has filed lawsuits against the Obama Administration and a number of high figures in that business have urged “real” Catholics to vote Republican. Which religious group are you referring to then? Tolerance of intolerance is intolerant itself.

      Reply
    • Well you said that the US isn’t targeting any religious groups, when they are, because those religious groups (Al Qaeda and Taliban) are the terrorists. They’re the religious groups I am talking about.

      And what a stupid lawsuit to take out against the administration, Republicans do only one thing, and that’s destroy the country.

      Reply
    • Your upset that the US is “targeting” Al Qaeda and the Taliban? WTF? Therefore the US is targeting Muslims? HUH? The Muslim population grows every year in the United States and is the fastest growing religion. I’m not sure why you felt the need to tell me that Al Qaeda and the Taliban are “extremists”. What on earth did you think I thought they were?? Representatives of moderate Muslims? Jee thanks for such informative information.

      Reply
    • No I Amnt upset. You’re making assumptions and veering off the point I made. You said the US wasn’t targeting religious groups I corrected that and said they were. That’s all.

      Reply
    • Since the US (majority of which is Christian) also battled with the Germans, British, and Russians; they would have been “targeting” Christians by your logic. Since all three of those people’s are mainly Christian. Or does this standard only apply to certain countries/terrorist organizations? The KKK? We’re they also being “targeted” for their “Christian” religion? Please don’t answer any of these questions, thanks. I’m not looking forward to you’re brilliant response.

      Reply
    • Obama: making the murder of black & brown children cool for liberals since 2008!

      Reply
    • “Push one person of color off a subway platform, you’re a murderer. Kill hundreds with drones and you’re Commander-in-Chief.” — Ali Abunimah.

      Reply
    • Nobody has mentioned the origins of al CIAda yet.
      Saudi/US, Sunni-sectarian mercenary jihadists being globalised to balkanisie a fresh divide and conquer Great Game imperial carve up under a nominal democratic neoliberal Animal Farm.

      Interesting times, mar a deireann siad i China.

      Reply
    • Damien — Some folk don’t like hearing the plain truth!

      Reply
    • No, Petr, they have an allergy to information.

      It disturbs their complacent planning and preconcieved psychological support-frames. Thinking is hard labour to such entities.

      Reply
  • this story comes from associated press… owned by the Rothschilds…. war profiteers. including WWI & WW2.

    Reply

Add New Comment