TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Irishwoman, illegal alien for 89 years, to become US citizen

Josephine Stout only discovered her undocumented status when her daughter was murdered and she had to care for her grandchildren.

Chicago: The city where Josephine Stout settled as a toddler with her parents after they arrived on a boat from Ireland.
Chicago: The city where Josephine Stout settled as a toddler with her parents after they arrived on a boat from Ireland.
Image: AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster

THE PLIGHT OF Irish people currently living in the US without a green card is a long-running issue but one nonegenarian woman living in Chicago could hardly have believed that it would be of concern to her life.

Josephine Stout, who only knew that she had arrived in Chicago from Ireland as a small baby in the 1920s, always believed herself to be an American citizen. However, her astonishing case has been highlighted by the Chicago Tribune – the paper ran a lengthy feature on her story on Christmas Day.  In it, author Dawn Turner Trice recounts how Stout only realised that she was in citizenship limbo when her daughter was murdered and Stout became responsible for her young grandchildren.

What followed was a 12-year battle to establish that Stout was a rightful long-term resident of the USA and entitled to the supports and help needed to care for her grandchildren. She had a Social Security card from her time working at a fur company from the age of 17 until her own children were born – but as it turned out, no proof that she was actually a US citizen.

The whole odyssey is worth reading here - it traces the journey needed to establish where Josephine had come from, how she had arrived in the US and whether her parents ever even became US citizens themselves. In the course of the investigation, Josephine discovers she was born in March 1922 in a poorhouse in Limerick but her parents managed to bring her on board with them on a ship bound for Chicago 18 months after her birth, set for a new life.

There is good news for Josephine – she was finally issued with a green card in September of last year, and on 13 December this year, had her application to become a full US citizen kickstarted. She should become a citizen within a few months.

Stout’s reaction? “I just can’t see how a piece of paper will make me feel more American than I already do.”

Read next:

Comments (16 Comments)

  • same thing happened to my ex husband. American dad met Mexican mom was born in Mexico, family mived back to California when he was 7 yrs old. Went to school, served in military. We got married when he was 24. Planned a vacation, when he tried to apply for passport, the only paper he has is a Mexican birth certificate. Back then no other entity ask and look for legal papers in concern to immigration status thats why he was able to get by. Luckily he was a good standing citizen with American dad so they gave him a certificate with no prob.

    Reply
  • I would like to know why it took 12 years to get this straighten out. She shouldn’t have had to wait so long.

    Reply
    • tuigim 27/12/12 #

      Charles Withersppon:It’s because the system is broken. Since people like to blame immigrants and the poor and vulnerable instead of corporate crooks (and that suits the powers that be) it is politically dangerous for anyone who wants to fix it to make it efficient.

      Reply
  • If Romney and his tea party backers had won the race for the White House she probably would have been deported

    Reply
  • Tuigim:::you are an idiot

    Reply
  • Its a good job cranky ass trump didnt find her or is he only chasing Obama.

    Reply
  • The ones to blame are the American government ! She paid taxes for years contributed to her country and they didn’t want to give her the rights that she was untitled to I believe anyone who lives In a country and pays taxes should be given rights even here in Ireland! My aunty has been living in Canada since 1969 and only became an Canadian citizen 2 years ago whilst my late uncle became a citizen in the 70′s he worked right up to his death!!

    Reply
    • There are formalities and forms to fill, if you don’t follow these and fill the forms you won’t be considered ,
      This lady ( or more to the point her parents ) never did that .
      Now she has, end of story.

      Reply
  • I am glad they are getting it sorted. Immigration and naturalisation is never a breeze. After living here for 13 years it still took 39 months to process my application and grant my citizenship. Instead of being angry that it took so long I am just glad it was permitted.

    Reply
  • Should we be rejoicing and feeling all patriotic? Not so much. #1. Josephine was insulted here and #2. She will be asked to declare that guns and killing is OK with her ‘cos that’s the American way.

    No one is an ‘illegal alien.’ No person can be illegal. We are all born with inalienable rights. Certain acts are illegal but people are not and I wish America would catch up with a sense of decency an human rights when choosing its terms. I am sure the writer of this article has broken the law at some stage (ran a red light, drank alcohol too young…). This does not mean the writer is illegal. Please stop using this offensive term. Drop the i word.

    Now, after Sandy Hook and all the madness that went went it, will 89 year old Josephine be required to swear she is willing to take up arms to defend America as part of this process because if you want to be a citizen, America makes it darn clear with the process that it believes that pacifists are deviants? Yes, sadly.

    It’s time for change and a sense of decency, America.

    Reply
    • What an irrelevant rant,

      you claim they insulted her, well her parents should have followed the naturalisation process to make her a citizen when she first arrived, they insulted their new host country by breaking the laws.

      “no one is an illegal alien” So u are ok with unlimited movement of people?

      You think people should be able to flout the laws of a country just because they find them inconvenient?

      Reply
    • Tuigim, you are an idiot. Sincerely, you define the word. Do yourself a favour and refrain from making public comments.

      Reply
    • I Agree , that was some rant, ‘open slater do what you want?
      UNHCR estimates up to 43 million people would migrate as refugees to north America Europe or Australia right now f there were no boarder controls.
      A typical, warm- n- fuzzy irresponsible comment.

      Reply
    • Yaaaaawwwnnnnnnn.

      Reply

Add New Comment