TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Lawyer of Delhi gang-rape accused denies smearing victim

In a Bloomberg interview, the lawyer was quoted as saying the male companion of the murdered 23-year-old was “wholly responsible” for the incident as the unmarried couple should not have been on the streets at night.

Image: A.M. Ahad/AP/Press Association Images

The case against five Indian men charged with the gang-rape and murder of a student is set to be moved to a fast-track court Thursday after a lawyer said three of the accused would deny the charges.

The five are all due to make their second appearance before a district court in New Delhi after their first appearance on Monday was marred by chaotic scenes which led the presiding magistrate to order the court to be cleared.

A senior court officer said on Monday that the case would be transferred to a fast-track trial court during Thursday’s hearing which will take place behind closed doors, as is standard here in rape cases.

Three of the accused will be defended by the lawyer M.L. Sharma who has said his clients would plead not guilty when the case reaches the fast-track court.

The other two defendants have yet to get themselves lawyer while a sixth accused, who is 17, is to be tried in a juvenile court.

According to police, the group lured the 23-year-old woman and a male companion onto the bus in New Delhi after they had spent the evening at the cinema and were trying to go home.

They then took it in turns to rape the woman and violate her with an iron bar as well as assault her partner before throwing them off the bus.

Speaking to AFP on Thursday, Sharma said he would prove that his clients were not responsible for the attack on December 16 and he denied having tried to blame the victim.

In an interview to Bloomberg, Sharma was quoted as saying the male companion of the murdered 23-year-old was “wholly responsible” for the incident as the unmarried couple should not have been on the streets at night.

“Until today I have not seen a single incident or example of rape with a respected lady,” he told the financial news wire.

“Even an underworld don would not like to touch a girl with respect.”

However Sharma told AFP that he had not been trying to smear the victim.

“I did speak to Bloomberg but did not say anything about the victim. I only told them that women are respected in India, they are mothers, sisters, friends but tell me which country respects a prostitute.”

Asked if that meant that he regarded the victim as a prostitute, Sharma replied: “No, not at all but I have to protect my clients and prove that they did not commit this heinous crime.”

The victim died in a Singapore hospital, 13 days after the attack which triggered mass protests across India and soul-searching over the levels of violence against women.

The father of the victim, who cannot be named for legal reasons, said in a television interview that he was proud of his daughter and believed her death had served as a badly-needed wake of call.

“She has brought an awakening to society. Society cannot any longer turn a blind eye to these sorts of incidences which are happening every day,” he told Britain’s ITV network.

“We have to change ourselves. If there are no change then these horrible things won’t stop. The public have to wake up now.”

- © AFP, 2012

Read: Third Delhi gang-rape suspect to plead not guilty: lawyer

Read: Indian guru blames Delhi rape victim, sparks outrage

Read next:

Comments (30 Comments)

  • Even prostitutes should be respected. You cannot rape a prostitute if she’s unwilling. RESPECT WOMEN PLEASE!

    Reply
    • I dont hear Praveen Halappanavar shouting his mouth off about womens rights in India only thinks that Ireland has a bad record in relation to the treatment of women in general, makes you wonder why he cannot wait to run in front of the court with this case £££££££££ Indai with its caste system is one of the most racist and abusive countries in the world not only against women but many others too, let he without sin cast the first stone

      Reply
    • @buyinitaly. No doubt Praveen Halappanavar is as disgusted as the rest of us by this crime. ‘let he without sin cast the first stone’…. seriously? What sin did Praveen Halappanavar commit which now disqualifies him from complaining about the inhumane treatment of his wife? Being from India?

      Reply
    • My point is that he was very quick off the mark to condem Ireland and its attitude in relation to womens rights but as stated in his own country the caste system which has been in exsistance for many years is both unjust andracist ,

      Reply
  • Sounds to me like the lawyer was trying to smear both the victims. What’s wrong with walking home at night with a male friend. Doesn’t suggest to me she should be subjected to such abuse because she merely walked home in the dark with a male friend. These deserve life imprisonment. Absolutely disgusting carry on. And shame on that lawyer.

    Reply
  • How can you even argue with such stupidity?! That country is so messed up.

    Reply
  • Christ, what a thing to say – whatever about the legal profession in this country, that’s a new low!

    Reply
  • Wtf ?
    Seriously what wrong with them people over there ?
    Jeez this poor woman is dead because of those animals and more will die if they don’t get their act together and quit spouting out such dribble

    WAKE UP INDIA

    Reply
  • ( I am not the the same Brian others have been referring to above )

    ” Are you sure my clients are the guilty ones ” and / or ” some of the accused may be less responsible than others” are legitimate avenues for this defense lawyer to use. In fact justice demands that he do so. We all need certainty that the correct people are punished.

    However in the statements he has made he is re-violating the poor girl together with her boyfriend who is still alive to hear his harmful and distressing utterances. One hopes for a special corner of hell for this lawyer.

    Reply
  • Most normal people are outraged at what happened in India and make outlandish statements and that’s ok then you get the equally outlandish people people chastising them and that’s ok
    That’s normal but what’s not normal is what happened in India and no one normal can disagree with that

    Reply
  • Maybe in Saudi Arabia or someplace like that. Oh! Wait a minute……
    No! A life behind bars in the company of some big, frustrated baaaaad boys would be more appropriate.
    The comments coming from the defence lawyer gives a pointer as to why rape is so prevalent in India.

    Reply
  • A few points:
    - fastracking of rape cases is not a bad idea but lawyers should be barred from giving interviews to the press (as barristers are here – tho the odd solicitor might give a prepared statement);
    - prostitutes deserve not to be disrespected or violated, anywhere, anytime;
    - if that’s the best defence, they might want to consider a plea (tho reliance on any press coverage pre-trial is not a good indicator);
    - why is the same lawyer representing 3 of them, when there could be a conflict between them;
    - as horrendous as the alleged facts in this case are; they still do not justify any State responding with inhumane or degrading punishment as have been suggested;
    - how can muppets here denigrate a country of 1bn people because of one incident and court case?

    Reply
    • CABK 10/01/13 #

      Hi Conor,

      You should probably do some research on India before calling people muppets for their justified opinion. I suggest you start with this article and the accompanying link to an action aid information sheet. As well as a book called ‘walk across the sun’.

      India is abhorrent in its treatment of women and this is far from one incident and one court case. Indeed it seems that this incident and the opinions of this lawyer are reflective of general opinion of women in India. To take one excerpt from this article:

      “Two weeks before the notorious Delhi rape case, a group of influential local elders, all of them men, came together in a Haryana village to discuss what they called the most pressing issues their communities face – rape, illegal abortions and marriage laws.

      One speaker addressed what he called an “alarming” increase in rape cases. “Have you seen the suggestive ways that girls ride scooters?” he said. “There is no modesty in the way women dress or act any more.” These days the society has become very educated and the girls from this educated society have started eloping. When girls bring shame on their own parents and behave like that – who would want a girl”

      Reply
  • Oh shut up you moron!

    Reply

Add New Comment