TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Thursday 20 June, 2013

Coveney: ‘I suspect this isn’t just one rogue trader, it’s broader than that’

Agriculture Minister Simon Coveney described the complex supply chain that led to one case of horsemeat ending up in frozen beef products in an interview this morning.

Image: Niall Carson/PA Archive/Press Association Images

AGRICULTURE MINISTER SIMON Coveney believes the horsemeat scandal that has hit a number of EU countries including Ireland is not confined to one rogue trader selling horsemeat labelled as beef.

He was speaking after the European Union health commissioner yesterday called on member states to carry out mandatory tests on beef and horsemeat products to ascertain the scale of the problem.

The tests will see 2,500 European beef products undergo mandatory DNA testing for horse content, and 1,500 imported horsemeat samples tested for the dangerous equine medicine ‘bute’.

Coveney told RTÉ’s Morning Ireland that the tests were “a start” and said that this was now an “EU-wide problem” that required an EU-wide response.

Giving one example of the scale of the problem he referred to test results in the UK where Findus lasagne and bolognaise was found to have 100 per cent horsemeat instead of beef. He explained:

“Those products were produced by a Swedish company who actually sourced processed product from a French company in Luxembourg, who sourced product through a Cypriot trader, who sourced through the Netherlands and the Netherlands actually sourced horsemeat from Romania.

“So you begin to realise that actually this is commodity cheap meat moving around the European Union and somebody in that supply chain has fraudulently sold horsemeat as beef.”

Coveney said that European ministers were “determined to get to the bottom” of the issue and added that the continent’s transnational police network, Europol, will be tasked with finding who was at fault and will ultimately try to prosecute people.

He said: “I suspect that this isn’t just one trader, one rogue trader in one country, I think that it’s broader than that.

“I think there are a number of people who have been selling horsemeat as beef and so it’s taking some time to get the bottom of it.”

The Minister said there was “genuine co-operation happening now between countries”.

He said that Polish vets had been in Ireland yesterday to examine evidence collected by the Department of Agriculture about the source of meat products produced here that contained equine DNA.

He added that he expected further EU-wide tests to be carried out in April and May.

Each test will cost roughly €400 each, and this cost will be shared by the European Commission.

More: Brussels calls for mandatory beef DNA tests across the EU

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (22 Comments)

  • There’s horsemeat in most of the supermarket chains in Europe and they want us to believe it from one source

    Reply
  • As much as I detest this so called government and their “buddy buddy” politics I have to give credit to Simon for having the balls to run with this saga.
    Our health inspectors found the problem (makes you wonder about how efficiant the rest of the eu are) and the minister has been like a dog with a bone and won’t let go.
    (you couldn’t even begin to know how much it gall’s me to give any of them credit but fair is fair and credit where it’s due”)

    Reply
  • I am sure the irish meat industry will ride this out.

    Reply
  • My only issue here is the use of the word product. Is there any meat processing plant in Ireland that purchases actual meat?

    Reply
  • When are Tesco etc paying their fines?

    Reply
  • Gave up burgers sausages . Feel great last few weeks. .no indigestion anymore. Hmmmm I wonder

    Reply
  • The potential problem of eating horse meat is Anti-inflammatory drug, Bute that may have been used in the horse (sport horses & performance horses) so there could be traces of same in the food supply.

    Phenylbutazone, often referred to as bute,[1] is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) for the short-term treatment of pain and fever in animals.

    In the United States and United Kingdom, it is no longer approved for human use, as it can cause severe adverse effects such as suppression of white blood cell production and aplastic anemia.

    Phenylbutazone should not be used in combination with antiplatelet drugs (e.g., coumadin or warfarin), as it amplifies the anticoagulant effects of these drugs; with other NSAIDs (all NSAIDs are additive); or in horses with known kidney or liver problems. Phenylbutazone displaces warfarin from plasma binding sites and toxic blood levels leading to haemorrhage can occur.

    Reply
  • The potential problem of eating horse meat is Anti-inflammatory drug, Bute that may have been used in the horse (sport horses & performance horses) so there could be traces of same in the food supply.

    Phenylbutazone, often referred to as bute,[1] is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) for the short-term treatment of pain and fever in animals.

    In the United States and United Kingdom, it is no longer approved for human use, as it can cause severe adverse effects such as suppression of white blood cell production and aplastic anemia.

    Phenylbutazone should not be used in combination with antiplatelet drugs (e.g., coumadin or warfarin), as it amplifies the anticoagulant effects of these drugs; with other NSAIDs (all NSAIDs are additive); or in horses with known kidney or liver problems. Phenylbutazone displaces warfarin from plasma binding sites and toxic blood levels leading to haemorrhage can occur.

    Reply
  • censored 15/02/13 #

    Yeah, it’s not just one rogue trader it’s a family business.

    Reply
  • Bryan N 14/02/13 #

    The mans a genius !

    Reply
  • Well talk about stating the obvious.

    Reply
  • ‘I suspect this isn’t just one rogue Minister, it’s broader than that’

    Reply
  • mattoid 14/02/13 #

    No sh1t Sherlock!

    Reply
  • Race horse is great fast food, I dont see what the problem is.

    Reply
  • There was contaminated “beef trimmings” stored across the border in August by a company under “financial pressure ” ……. in my opinion, the department have been trying to cover it up since then!
    I hope the minister’s brother’s food distribution company in the the United Kingdom don’t find that the Salami or whatever in their sandwiches don’t contain horse ! ;greencore!

    Reply
    • “Greencore foods has said that it was the supplier of Bolognese sauce containing horsemeat which was today withdrawn from sale in Asda in the UK.

      The company says the sauce was supplied by the ABP Food Group’s Nenagh plant in Co Tipperary.

      Three other Greencore products have been withdrawn by Asda as a precautionary measure.

      The firm, run by Patrick Coveney, the brother of the Agriculture Minister, said it is complying with suppliers and testers to get to the bottom of the contamination.”

      Reply
  • No s**t Sherlock!! Of course its more than one for gods sake. Talk about stating the obvious?

    Reply
  • it’s very simple …. tons of cattle slaughtered versus tons of cattle sold ! ….for everything else there’s …….. I shall refer to the minister’s own word above “suspect” …or should that be plural !
    on an aside ; How do you spell Filial …fillial ……fillyall ?

    Reply
  • Who is the biggest rogue trader of them all ?. Did the people of Ireland get what they voted for in the last election ? They voted for a new government and ended up with a shower of lying cowboys. Now the cowboys are looking for their horses.

    Reply
  • I hope your comment is meant to be ironic, cause I laughed. Ride it out. Horse meat. Geddit?

    Reply

Add New Comment